Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-03-774/6 AI generated

2-03-774/6 · Harju Maakohus Kentmanni kohtumaja

Case Number 2-03-774/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

                                   !" # "  "  "  "    $%$&&# " " " " '( '( '( '()( )( )( )(*   *   *   *  +, +, +, +,     -   +-                        !         , , , ,  '(  )( (./"(0..' (./"(0..' (./"(0..' (./"(0..'                                    ! "  ! "  ! "  ! " $#

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-774/6 · Harju Maakohus Kentmanni kohtumaja:                                    !" # "  "  "  "    $%$&&# " " " " '( '( '( '()( )( )( )(*   *   *   *  +, +, +, +,     -   +-                        !         , , , ,  '(  )( (./"(0..' (./"(0..' (./"(0..' (./"(0..'                                    ! "  ! "  ! "  ! " $#

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

�  �  �  � 

2-03-774/92

K O H T U M Ä Ä R U S E E S T I V A B A R I I G I N I M E L

                                   !" # "  "  "  "    $%$&&# " " " " '( '( '( '()( )( )( )(*   *   *   *  +, +, +, +,     -   +-                        !         , , , ,  '(  )( (./"(0..' (./"(0..' (./"(0..' (./"(0..'                                    ! "  ! "  ! "  ! " $#

#

#

# %   %   %   %  '&"  %!( )  !*" ! &"  %!( )  !*" ! &"  %!( )  !*" ! &"  %!( )  !*" ! +           , , , ,-." "   // 

-." "   // 

-." "   // 

-." "   // 

/1 ( /*" !) ( 1" ! 1! 3  4 /1 ( /*" !) ( 1" ! 1! 3  4 /1 ( /*" !) ( 1" ! 1! 3  4 /1 ( /*" !) ( 1" ! 1! 3  4 56 56 56 56  !)   !)   !)   !) 1   7)  /  )  )  /  )  )  /  )  )  /  ) 8#

#

#

# 9 9:93  *" !"  93  *" !"  93  *" !"  93  *" !" ;, , , ,1) (  % /  "  /8 ( /*"  3" ) (  % /  "  /8 ( /*"  3" ) (  % /  "  /8 ( /*"  3" ) (  % /  "  /8 ( /*"  3"<)  3*"  4 )  3*"  4 )  3*"  4 )  3*"  4 = , = , = , = , > // 

?!@"

 A3  *"  " > // 

?!@"

 A3  *"  " > // 

?!@"

 A3  *"  " > // 

?!@"

 A3  *"  ", ,) 1 ! 3 " , ,) 1 ! 3 " , ,) 1 ! 3 " , ,) 1 ! 3 ":/     /     /     /    <, , , , , , , , > //

*

" % / 00  > //

*

" % / 00  > //

*

" % / 00  > //

*

" % / 00  9  9  9  9  = , = , = , = , = , = , = , = , -./( 

( " /! -./( 

( " /! -./( 

( " /! -./( 

( " /!B3 /  3 /  3 /  3 / B9*" C/D(3  "   (3  ( "   9*" C/D(3  "   (3  ( "   9*" C/D(3  "   (3  ( "   9*" C/D(3  "   (3  ( "  '#

#

#

# E"  

9F) @ "  

9F) @ "  

9F) @ "  

9F) @D#

#

#

#

 " /*!" !  " /*!" !  " /*!" !  " /*!" ! , , , , = , G, = , G, = , G, = , G, -./( 

( " /! -./( 

( " /! -./( 

( " /! -./( 

( " /!H3 /I!  3 /I!  3 /I!  3 /I! J9*" D/K(3 9*" D/K(3 9*" D/K(3 9*" D/K(3  " 3 (3  ( "   " 3 (3  ( "   " 3 (3  ( "   " 3 (3  ( "  LM M M M;"  

91) @ "  

91) @ "  

91) @ "  

91) @<     "   "   "   " /*!" ! , /*!" ! , /*!" ! , /*!" ! , = , N, = , N, = , N, = , N, I "  ! / I "  ! / I "  ! / I "  ! /O9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( " P971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "  *#

#

#

# R"   "   "   "  

9) @ 9) @ 9) @ 9) @?#

#

#

# $!" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , = , SI, = , SI, = , SI, = , SI, I "  ! / I "  ! / I "  ! / I "  ! /O9A(3 9A(3 9A(3 9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( " P971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "  *#

#

#

# R"  

9) @ "  

9) @ "  

9) @ "  

9) @?#

#

#

# $!" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , = , T, = , T, = , T, = , T, I "  ! / I "  ! / I "  ! / I "  ! /O9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( "  9A(3  "   (3  ( " *"  2 ( " P971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  971"   "  </<Q6 /(

 "   ( "

 !  (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "   (3  " 3 (3  ( "  *#

#

#

# R"  

9) "  

9) "  

9) "  

9) 2323@ @ @ @?#

#

#

# $!" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , !" /*!" ! , = , U, = , U, = , U, = , U, V ( " &"   V ( " &"   V ( " &"   V ( " &"  $WYX WYX WYX WYX;Z[\ ]^ _!` [ ^ aYbbc Z[\ ]^ _!` [ ^ aYbbc Z[\ ]^ _!` [ ^ aYbbc Z[\ ]^ _!` [ ^ aYbbc " /! 8) 2!2 %  " /! 8) 2!2 %  " /! 8) 2!2 %  " /! 8) 2!2 % *#

#

#

# $ " /!" ! ,  " /!" ! ,  " /!" ! ,  " /!" ! , = , d, = , d, = , d, = , d, -./  /  A%    %!(3/7 // 

?%! /3%I3I  " !  / 00 

 I I) ! !  -./  /  A%    %!(3/7 // 

?%! /3%I3I  " !  / 00 

 I I) ! !  -./  /  A%    %!(3/7 // 

?%! /3%I3I  " !  / 00 

 I I) ! !  -./  /  A%    %!(3/7 // 

?%! /3%I3I  " !  / 00 

 I I) ! !  "  A!  

M/! 8  " //



"  

" ! 

*  1" 3"

"I/

, "  A!  

M/! 8  " //



"  

" ! 

*  1" 3"

"I/

, "  A!  

M/! 8  " //



"  

" ! 

*  1" 3"

"I/

, "  A!  

M/! 8  " //



"  

" ! 

*  1" 3"

"I/

,

�  �  �  � 

2-03-774/92

= , e, = , e, = , e, = , e, f /@" "  



g / f /@" "  



g / f /@" "  



g / f /@" "  



g /h/ / / /$   C //  //  //  // 6#

#

#

# C&

$! ?) 7!  

/! // 

% "   M " &

$! ?) 7!  

/! // 

% "   M " &

$! ?) 7!  

/! // 

% "   M " &

$! ?) 7!  

/! // 

% "   M " /

, /

, /

, /

, = , i, = , i, = , i, = , i, #

#

#

#

/  @$/*7 "  

$!@" ! 

/  @$/*7 "  

$!@" ! 

/  @$/*7 "  

$!@" ! 

/  @$/*7 "  

$!@" ! 

jM M M M+ !! 7%!( 7!( %  6 3

!! 7%!( 7!( %  6 3

!! 7%!( 7!( %  6 3

!! 7%!( 7!( %  6 3 /1   3 !" //"  /1   3 !" //"  /1   3 !" //"  /1   3 !" //" 1%" "  

"  Y !6k = T %" "  

"  Y !6k = T %" "  

"  Y !6k = T %" "  

"  Y !6k = T?lllm ( //" , lllm ( //" , lllm ( //" , lllm ( //" ,"   ! A38* 3@ "   ! A38* 3@ "   ! A38* 3@ "   ! A38* 3@ #

#

#

# 7"  )

*   "  )

*   "  )

*   "  )

*  j   $!( %I   !( %I   !( %I   !( %I   / /

*( / /

*( / /

*( / /

*(n, , , , G, G, G, G,- - - -.1@ " // 1@ " // 1@ " // 1@ " //I

"  

" ! 

1*"   "  

"  

" ! 

1*"   "  

"  

" ! 

1*"   "  

"  

" ! 

1*"   " 8"  8"  8"  8" %3(3  " 3" (



3" //  " %3(3  " 3" (



3" //  " %3(3  " 3" (



3" //  " %3(3  " 3" (



3" //  " 3"  

3"  

3"  

3"  , , , , N, N, N, N,-Y1* " //

/   1) 2!2 %*  ? " !, -Y1* " //

/   1) 2!2 %*  ? " !, -Y1* " //

/   1) 2!2 %*  ? " !, -Y1* " //

/   1) 2!2 %*  ? " !, SI, SI, SI, SI, > / > / > / > //

 " "  !% L/*L   " ( ) !  2! !/

%  / 00 

   9 o!  

 n/ /

 " "  !% L/*L   " ( ) !  2! !/

%  / 00 

   9 o!  

 n/ /

 " "  !% L/*L   " ( ) !  2! !/

%  / 00 

   9 o!  

 n/ /

 " "  !% L/*L   " ( ) !  2! !/

%  / 00 

   9 o!  

 n/   +!@"

    +!@"

    +!@"

    +!@"

 p)  ! o"  1*  " //

M "/

' 3 " "1"   " C%I3(3  " !" )  ! o"  1*  " //

M "/

' 3 " "1"   " C%I3(3  " !" )  ! o"  1*  " //

M "/

' 3 " "1"   " C%I3(3  " !" )  ! o"  1*  " //

M "/

' 3 " "1"   " C%I3(3  " !" (3 

!" // ?! / M&"  %I3( 8

"  

"  

, (3 

!" // ?! / M&"  %I3( 8

"  

"  

, (3 

!" // ?! / M&"  %I3( 8

"  

"  

, (3 

!" // ?! / M&"  %I3( 8

"  

"  

, T T T TI, , , , > //

 > //

 > //

 > //

:/ / / /: I!  I!  I!  I! ;53( )  f   /  ;53( )  f   /  ;53( )  f   /  ;53( )  f   /  " "   /  " 0:0 / " "   /  " 0:0 / " "   /  " 0:0 / " "   /  " 0:0 /* ( /*" !n)  ( /*" !n)  ( /*" !n)  ( /*" !n)                     D)  3*"  8    , )  3*"  8    , )  3*"  8    , )  3*"  8    , U U U UI, , , , f

   !  ! I  !1" ! *  3) (    q6 f Rr f

   !  ! I  !1" ! *  3) (    q6 f Rr f

   !  ! I  !1" ! *  3) (    q6 f Rr f

   !  ! I  !1" ! *  3) (    q6 f Rr8SING*) ( "/ //

*

  "  SING*) ( "/ //

*

  "  SING*) ( "/ //

*

  "  SING*) ( "/ //

*

  "  > // > // > // > // "R/;  < 3" 3) 3

K)  / ; // o

!%"  3  "R/;  < 3" 3) 3

K)  / ; // o

!%"  3  "R/;  < 3" 3) 3

K)  / ; // o

!%"  3  "R/;  < 3" 3) 3

K)  / ; // o

!%"  3 < 3" %" "   ) L(  3" %" "   ) L(  3" %" "   ) L(  3" %" "   ) L(s    !     !     !     ! /1 ( /*" !3" +   !*"  /1 ( /*" !3" +   !*"  /1 ( /*" !3" +   !*"  /1 ( /*" !3" +   !*"  t " 3 "

3? 

t " 3 "

3? 

t " 3 "

3? 

t " 3 "

3?  3) (     3) (     3) (     3) (     983q f KrCSNGD!" 3  91"  

q f KrCSNGD!" 3  91"  

q f KrCSNGD!" 3  91"  

q f KrCSNGD!" 3  91"  

/!  R    ! n   !1"  / L //  /1 ( /*"  3" t%  3@LI!  !) ! $ " ! /!  R    ! n   !1"  / L //  /1 ( /*"  3" t%  3@LI!  !) ! $ " ! /!  R    ! n   !1"  / L //  /1 ( /*"  3" t%  3@LI!  !) ! $ " ! /!  R    ! n   !1"  / L //  /1 ( /*"  3" t%  3@LI!  !) ! $ " ! uu!(3  / !! I! "  3 /  ) 1%  A% "  ! * 3 ! ! !!** "

!  uu!(3  / !! I! "  3 /  ) 1%  A% "  ! * 3 ! ! !!** "

!  uu!(3  / !! I! "  3 /  ) 1%  A% "  ! * 3 ! ! !!** "

!  uu!(3  / !! I! "  3 /  ) 1%  A% "  ! * 3 ! ! !!** "

!  &

&

&

&

,-Y"C*    </v ! I  ! : "  D //@1" ! :   v% ,-Y"C*    </v ! I  ! : "  D //@1" ! :   v% ,-Y"C*    </v ! I  ! : "  D //@1" ! :   v% ,-Y"C*    </v ! I  ! : "  D //@1" ! :   v% " /1 ( /*"  3" 9$/ " /1 ( /*"  3" 9$/ " /1 ( /*"  3" 9$/ " /1 ( /*"  3" 9$/    !1" ! w!!*?!

( "   " ! " )  ( /       ! ?  3) ( )

? 7    !    !1" ! w!!*?!

( "   " ! " )  ( /       ! ?  3) ( )

? 7    !    !1" ! w!!*?!

( "   " ! " )  ( /       ! ?  3) ( )

? 7    !    !1" ! w!!*?!

( "   " ! " )  ( /       ! ?  3) ( )

? 7    !    !1" !  / /    9 " !    Y " 

 1

" 3"  " ,    !1" !  / /    9 " !    Y " 

 1

" 3"  " ,    !1" !  / /    9 " !    Y " 

 1

" 3"  " ,    !1" !  / /    9 " !    Y " 

 1

" 3"  " , > //

v/ /  " "  !I9C  /1 ( /*"  <%3 !@xI  F%!@I   )    !



, ,  ,  ,  ,    ,   ,   ,   ,    - +  ,            , "    % -

          , +                  -+ ,,  ,, -+ ,,  ,, -+ ,,  ,, -+ ,,  ,,     ,, -,    , ,    +-, -,  , - - +-, - +-   -   1, ,     , ,  +- +    , 1, ,  -  ,  2 " ( 3 #%  4 +, -,     , ,

++-, -  +" (3#54-#+-        -,  +, -       " " ( 3 #%  +-   -    +-, + , - ,  , +-   ,  ,  ,   -   

  +-    +    - , 

�  �  �  � 

2-03-774/92

,     ,           ," (3$,#54-# #%4 #% #%% -   ,  +-,          � 7yz8{| }~ � 7yz8{| }~ � 7yz8{| }~ � 7yz8{| }~ �y€ z| ‚!ƒ �y€ z| ‚!ƒ �y€ z| ‚!ƒ �y€ z| ‚!ƒ