Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-15510/2 AI generated

2-05-15510/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-15510/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-15510/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

          !"#  

!"$% &% %''!$# #( ($% ''      ))*)  

     

   "+%, &#$ #!-.%'/0($-%#(/.(# !$(%!-.%'( #12, &#$"+% #!-.%'/0($-%#(/.(#)          +(23 

!#$23,    

    4))*))&'%  !"$%#$+%'     ,"%..(#564*1644'+)2 #60)16'+)16* '+)16*'+) %7)))) ("$%& 2 #677*16 781616*7*77  "'.. "+%2'/0($. #!-.##&'( !$(%!-.%'(12$$ !$(%!-.

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

   : ##. !'- :--(.  #  ) %%+% /( '!($ #(  /($( !"#('$ $%.($ #1 % !#$2 $#; /.(  0(& 2!! #' '"(.% 2/#$-%#(#$ 2+-%#('$3 #2 ".#-%%#$((%-%  &( 784(#$%="%#0+#1&%%$(-;(8>*>*1#('+%$.$#%&%%'#% $#$&.#2';%&$-%# '.)      

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

!#$2 ,   /#$# #!-.% '/0($-%#(+ 2 (#%$# !"$'( &#$"+% #!-.% '/0($-%#( #1  !$(%!-.% !!# #$-%( (% !'( &/%-'% ) !#$2 #!!&%; %#( !$(%!-.%$ #$.1 $(-'( '; #-#-2##&$(%( !$(%!-.2 !$#$;( #!'( #(.( !$(%!-.%$(:"%( #$-%()((+ !#$20'; #!-. '/0($.#(''%#('$1($ !$(%!-.2 # !#$2'(2$- #;"+(2'(&'2$(-!#"#)     !   +(2 %2'% #&#$#(#(%/#$ #!-.%'/0($-%#(+ !#$20!!'$0 $.&%%#%'1  !#$20!'( (#!'(&2% #$. -;+% !$(%!-.%$#) !#$2('; $(+('% '$ ;% # 2(#  . &''#)  ="( !$(%!-.% !#$%# !#$2  -;(#  #$$ $+#%2!#(. !+(+::%'(..) +(2!'%"+%(#%$.(#!!$#(#1($ !$(%!-.% -::+%$(('#;$!-!#-::+%#$#(''%#(#--"1($(.'(%#( !$(!#$1#(#$"+(2' -. ('-%#0%. (% !'()  #0($&-#(#$ $'((&'$  #.& "  ((#$ 0!'( &/%-'%  # (.'( ('-% !#$) ((+ "+(2 0'; #!-. '/0($. $(- 0!!'$ #!!&%$. &%%#%'1($ !$(%!-.2 #$''(2$- #; !#$2!#&'2"#) 

!#$2&#$"+%#"+(2 (#%$#&#$&%$(."+%'(1-%''( !"#('$"+(2&%$('#$%#$ !#$2'(($$(0(  #!-.%'/0($-%#( #&%%#%'#)!)"+(2&//.;!--/$$('%#( !# !#$2'( &)  &'%  -::  (-0 -%#(') #%'+#(# "+%# !'% #!-.% '/0($-%#( &%%#% #&'% (-0 -%() !#$2(#%$#&#$"+%20'# #!-.'/0($.&%%#%'1($ !$(%!-. 2; $''( 2 $ - #; "+(2 !# &'2 "#) !$(%!-.% &$#( # !

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

#!-.% '/0($-%#$ 2 #(''( &/%-'% ( &%%#( (% # #(.  #/'$&##( #(''(#$1 # %-($$.$!%-%+#$#.&"#--"'. #"+(2$(('-%#0%-($#(-%#(') 

!"$%#$+%' "+(2 0'# "+% "'.. 2 '/0($. #!-. #(''%#('$ ($ !$(%!-. 2 # $''( 2 $ - #; !#$2'( $(- !# &'2) ' (% !'( $(%#$ ('-%#0%. 2  % !$(%!-. 2; !#$2'( #%%# (% !'( $' &/%-'%  #.. " ((#$  $ ('-%#0%. -($#(.) ! %.0 .(# !#'$$#%!!%'2$''(!';$.'(1($&'2- #$ !#$2!#1#-$%$!($;$(.$:$)#$"+%2$$"'.-$) 

!"$%#$+%' !#$2 0'# &#$"+% 2$$ "'.-$ 2 '/0($. #!-. &%%#%'1 ($ !$(%!-. 2 # $''( 2 $ - #; &'2 "+(2'( $(- !#) $. -2# !  # !$(%!-.%$1-%''(#$: # ';$''(2$(%(!"+(2+ #!-.%#) (-'( '& !$(%!-. ! &% (1 ($ #(' ('.1  $' ! 0(( ;% # 2  # $%# #&. '#$) '-#)") !$(%!-.%.&2&.(-!$%2"+(2+0!'(&/%-'% :"(#-2#('.)           !  "   "      !    "   # #& : # !$(%!-.%$(#$1 ';  *977 -)!)  <'( 2 4977 -)!) , ?'( $')7> ) (+(-%#$!$!'%#( !$(%+1 #!  @@ 2(#% $') ) #$&'$564*'+) #!-% '!/%+#%+'2'/. #!-.%'/0($-%#$)5 644'+)2+% % #!-% .(%#&$ ! '(0($ #!-.%#!'(&#22+-%#(&%%#% #"$(#1!$##$; !"#"+(2/.(' #2+.#% #!-% (&"('('!#.(#1.#% :"('(&)-%$-('( #!-% '(10(#(%'( !"#$#(- #$$(%#$('( #!-% ('(&'2 (.( !#. "#1 &/% -:: #%  &'% ' &) #!-% (&"('%#(' (-0 -%#(' %+ #..  " 2+. #!-% ( &"(' &#$&'$ (.( !# ##('() +(2    ! (#%$. !"$'("+% #!-.%'/0($-%#( #&%%#%'1($ !$(%!-.2;$''(2$- #; $(%#('( #!-% '( &'2 $(- !# "#) !#$2  ,  &#$"+%# "+(2  ! (#%$. !"$'(&#$"+% #!-.%'/0($-%#( #&%%#%'1($ !$(%!-.2 #$''(2$- #; &'2 !#"#)((+-/'(-. #!-% .#!!&%&. !$(%!-.%$(.'(2! /# - #- &'2 $(%#( #!-%  !# "#) !!'(. ! (#%$. !"$'(  ;( # %.-%#$((#$( =  "%.( $%1 -%''( !"#('$ !$(%!-.% $&$#  #(%#+ )>)*)) ! 74 !!% $')7 1 47 87 ) !!'(. /#$&. 1 ($ !$(%!-.% &$# (#!'(&'2'!74 !!%)

!"# '.(#0!!'$("&%#%.'(%;1($ #!-.$'(;'/0($."+(20!!'$0 $.&%%#%' #)!) !$(%!-.2$$"+(2 <'(2 !"#$.$(.&'2- #- !#$2!#"#) +(2 !#&$#!*977#)!)8A()* !!%2 !#$2!#&$#!4977#)!) A() !!%) +(2 !#:.%.>>#$'1!$@@&/%-($14A$@@&/%-( !$#( 0!$#($) (-  % (#( # #%##($'(  # ! $@@&/%-($#0(#%!) +(2 ('; &%.'#'#('0%'0% %#$%.2-.('-%#0%.$'(%!'() -!#-::-%#('(%

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

!"$%