Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-23343/3 AI generated

2-06-23343/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-23343/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

  9 /$ % . '. $'!( !(   !%- '  ' .%( +' 0$,. !(

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-23343/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: !(

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

















 

 

 !







"#$%!&'!





%

%($ 

 

  





)*%+,-$** !$$

   



   

   '. * * + ! /0'.%0!( ))12 &$%. 

+..+.31&$%.%0!(

      

 

 4$. $.&(!&'  .%%51

' /.%!.% .%( +.&.$ ! % "!$

4.%($66  . 1 -!,  2 .%%51 & 

* *45

 

   



.$.&,% !

  

 !

 



" #$% 

  !  &'(



$)% % "+,+-

4&& !' 7'&(7'&&7,,%(&,&$%.&,&7,,%(+..% .5

 ,

      ./0,0 47& !'  &'&( &!!&7,,%( %. &$%. 

%.&7,,%( 7& % .5

 ,



 0 .-1,1/ 4%. !'  &'&( +..&7,,%(

. &$%.. &7,,%(&!!% .5

 





  

 

  2$

(  





 

"   )   

 



    

   

$ 3

    

 





   



 +0.-. (  !/&1&!. , +! !1,..  !

,. !&1 . .%. !( ,0!+  /0'! *  +0.- . ( 0 !,  ,0!+

/0'! ,! 1 &!. '. + ,  # ,. /!'! . &  +0. , .%(

.,  !(&# ,!!+...&!...&.&! &.$+ !7%(,.*

+0.-. (  !&#  ., ,.  /#+&! ! .%!(







&' !*0!((&%#   !( .+..&' !,% !8*



!(42(5,65!27

.  !('./!-',0. &  '&!&+#/0'.%0!!,,))12

&$%.  +..+.( 31 &$%.1 &&&! 32919 &$%. %.% /!- . (

,% !&!!( !,% !. +'*

.+(!&' 0,..(/(2**.. !,./.%!4/.%51,.!

!  ' &   %!  4. 5*   .%(!( 1   %.% &  0,..(

*2* -.. 6%. #$,&! ,77./.%! 477./.%51 ,. !  

.%(!(  ,77 &  ,-.. 6%. &. 1 + +  &(  4. 5*

-.. 6%. '.%%  #' !( !- 77./.%! &'(( $-.&$(..(.# .(*

 % 77./.%! &  7 :%!(*   ,-.. 6%.  %!( . *

 + /.%!. '& $+(%$*2))9)&&&!

!,,))12&$%.4.5* .+(!. ,..!%& +0))12

&$%.1 ,. % &#+ ' &%. !, *  % &' !+#. ,% !  %!(

&  +0%0!(1 ,. +.  +..,  !,  $+    %(. #.%(+ #' 

+0%+!.&+.($.,.&4.5*

%$+ %!(+..+.  +..,$+,& #' /#+#$%+ /#+ &!%.

'. . ,. &!!/#+%. 2*3** ..+. $+ ,. % !& +0 !( &!!

/.&&!  /#+    /.&&!  /#+*   +..+.+0 ' 

.. !,./.%!  !%+ &'! ! #. ,  # ,.  %  ))1 &$%.*   %

%!( +..+. ! 92 /#+* ..+. $+ !; 12<=/#+ > 219 &$%. ? 19

&$%.=/#+1 19 &$%. > 92 /#+ ?  ))1 &$%.* ..+.+0 77./.%! 

!%+ &'! ! #. ,  # ,.  % 2213 &$%.* ..+. $+ ! $+ %$;

;

@       *9*** &!%. **2 * +..+.,##$ )<   4/#+&

+..+.,##$&%)=?12<5133&$%.;1&$%.=23/#+?1&$%.

/#+A

@      ** * &!%. 2*3*** +..+.,##$ )12 <  1 4/#+&

+..+.,##$&%)12=?12<51)&$%.;41)&$%.=/#+?&$%.

/#+5A

..+.$+ !$+%$;2))9);

@      **** &!%. **2 * +..+.,##$ )<   4/#+&

+..+.,##$&%)=?12<519&$%.;19&$%.=22/#+?1&$%.

/#+5A

@      ** * &!%. 2*3*** +..+.,##$ )12 <  1 4/#+&

+..+.,##$& % )12= ? 12<5 19 &$%.; 419 &$%. =  /#+ ? 1

&$%./#+5A

%& +..+.+0'3147& !' &'&(&!!&7,,%(%.

&$%.%.&7,,%(% .5&$%.*

0!(0.!.&/0'%(!

B 8 3   %%- +0!( 0.! %0!( $'. &'! ! #. ,.  

$.&&!,.*  +  +00.!(! 4B5 8 3   % /.% /.%!/ 

#. ,.&&'! !.&*B89&'  !-&'! ! #. + + /.%!+0.

(!*B8#  -1 &'! !$.&&!,.%%+0!'   !%+&'! !

#. , # ,.%+0.,. &'% #. ,.%' #. ,.+..+. ,.%*B8/

%%- +0!( 0.! &'! ! $.&&!,. &$$ %0!( &'! ! #. ,. *

/.%!+0 .& &'! !,& '+ + .  !($+ $'*/.%!

'! , !& & %   %!  &! ,. 7( .%.,!( 4 .%.,!(A . 25*

.%.,!  /!%& . *** &'  &'! ! &  #. , /.%! 1   + +  /!%& .







*** !, 0.  %!  $+.( + +  .%.,!  6.&$. !( $+(! 

&$$*  .  &  $+( ($.   $,* ($. ,!! !,.  . 

&  '  +. %!(*  +  .%.,!  /!%& . **2*    &'! ! & 

., +0.,! +. , '  , %.,1 ($.1 &% & 6%. +0. . 

$&+... .(,!! !,. &!! %(, . ,.*%+  !%+  !-!(

&  + +  .%.,!  /!%& . ** $+( %!&* $+  ,. ,.% + + 

.%.,! /!%& .2**.+- %!(..&.&   !,.&'! ! *B8

 /  &'  +0.- +0!(1 &!. +0%.& % &'! !  $.&&!%!(1 %0!( $'.

&'! ! #. ,. +..+. ,. &$$ +..+. *  +  B 8    +0.-

+0!( %0!( +0%.&!  $'. &'! ! #. ,. +..+. ,. &$$ +..+. 1

$+  &'! ! .%0! +& ,!! !,.  &!%. &' #. ,.%.* ..+. ,##$&

 &B8)#   !(.% $.,##$1,..%(!-9< *#' !(B8

2 #   !( (./. ..+! /0'.,0   //..( ' %.% &  .%.,!  /!%& .

2** &&&! +..+. ,##$ 12 < /#+ #'   !,  !,, * .%.,! 

/!%& . 2*)* &'   & ,& ! !& !,, &!,. '* %+ 

#' !( +0%- &  '  32919 4%. !'  &'&( +..&7,,%( . 

&$%.  . &7,,%( &!! % .5 &$%.1 ,.  /0'.%0! 4'.'.%(5 ,(! - 

))124&& !' 7'&(7'&&7,,%(&,&$%.&,&7,,%(+..% .5

&$%. %.% +..+.  31 47& !'  &'&( &!!&7,,%( %. &$%. 

%.&7,,%( 7& % .5 &$%.* .+..&' !,% ! (! .&! 4 5 8 9  

&'  . -  ,% %!( &'! ,% !&!!(  ! ,% !.  +'

&' ! !+0.,% ! 0/ +,##$!* +  8&' &%%-

'.,% ! &!!( /1 & &'!&  ! ' .* ,! . !- '7+. ( +.&!(

&' !+#.( &!!(1 ,.& % & ,% !.  .%(   %0!   &!!( %.%

,% !. 0.(!&!!(*% !&!!($'. &.%(&,##$,. +0.-%0!(

'%(%!(., ,&' ! '%(..(!+&!!(/$/$ .% !!

/#+&! &!!( !&'  ' !('%(.0! !,. 4 89

5*...&' ! .+..&.!,.** '%(.&'  .+..%$

 +0.- &!!(&!,%(.&  ,!!'! (&!,% 1 ,.  %#' !- .%( !  !(

0.!-.  !,.&'! !* &'! ! !(.%(/ !  !(0.!-.

  9 /$ % . '. $'!( !(   !%- '  ' .%( +' 0$,. !(

/.%! 1 ,.( 0%(- ' &.%%. !&.$. 4. 5* .+..&' !,% ! (! .&! 4

(/.(. 5 8    /   #' !(  - '1   % %0!  &.$.&!

,% ,. %.% . / +.&!&  #-.+ ,.  &' !. !%.*  8 9)  

&'  .  & 677.. ..&!+ !'. ,!&'#$.!$..(....&!+ !

,!&'#$.*.%($66 .%3*9* !%!($...0.+!!,,2&$%.

'%(!,.%. $.!,.   $+(!$+   993   ,#$&.(   +.. %!,-$.&

)9)%.%. !& * &.%%. -.  !((&!,% .(&/. 

0.! *

#' !(7 (! %.%!'.%(!(B8( 2131911/(

11 8( 11)119)1113

1119191118( /121

/!-';5'.+(!$'!((A5,0. &  '&!&+#/0'.%0!

4'.'.%(5 !,,  ))12 4&& !'  7'&( 7'&&7,,%( &, &$%. 

&,&7,,%( +.. % .5 &$%.1 +..+.( !,,  31 47& !'  &'&(

&!!&7,,%(%.&$%.%.&7,,%(7&% .5&$%.1&&&!329194%. !' 

&'&(+..&7,,%(. &$%.. &7,,%(&!!% .5&$%.A

5 . ( ,% !&!!(  ! ,% !.  +'*  ,% !&!!( '.

+(!. ,..!%;$...0.+2&$%.0.!-.&!!(3213&$%.*









 2( !

 .&' !+ %!(= *)1=*



 ! !

'!  ! +!%!( .+.. , $.( .-1   &#+  +0.-

 !'.$'!((*

 8 9   #  -1   &'! +0.- '  ! +0. ,  ! '.

 !$'!(('.+(!,#$. !(!(0.!.&! /0'%( !(

! !1 &!. & 1 & &'! % ,##$%!( + ,. #' 1 .  #'  

+ %!(1 .. &!. '. .,  . &  &#  +#.$... +0. &!.  .,  . &# 

+.&! *!'! &'.  !(6& ..(+#. (& / ,&+0 !&*

 +0.- %.,  !(  ! . ( & '.+(! 4  8 9  5*

 ! +0.-  8 9 0.&  %.,  !( !'! ' &' !. !%.  /.(, 

4 895*

  +#  &'! '.+(!   . !( , $.( *)***1

&'! (&  '.&.$.&! + ,/#+&!'.&# ,.  = *

)=*  %,% !(&!,% / .! !/ &#  .,  !((.%(,.&

2*)* = ** =*   .  &' ! #'   + %!(* C#$.&!  !- !(

' '. .  !( 6& ..( +#. ( &  /  ,&+0 !&*   %   !(

'.+ , # ,. #$( *

'!!-.!&'1 '%0.!.&! /0'%(%!(,'.+(!,#$. !(

%0!(,.  89!&!!!-'.  !$'!(,.*



/!-. (,% !&!!( !,% !. +'*

8 1&' '.,% !&!!(&%%-/1&&'!& !

' .*"1&&'!& ! ' .1'7+. - ./,!!'!&' !,% !

0 ! &&.%!( +.&!( &' !+#.( &!!(* ' !+#.( &!!(1 ,. '7+.  &

!%%. 1&$+ !('7+. ., ##%!( :: !+0.,!!/7.+. !&! 1

'7+.  & / ,( !   , ! !1 %! '7+.  & !%%. &!!(*

'!+0.-# &!!( #..&! +0.. / %(.&%(1&!.+ /&!!(

+#,0. ,.%/ 1&&'!& ! ' .1& ,!' ##$,. -0.%

+0.-,0. .&*



 +  89. -,% %!(&'!,% !&!!( !

,% !.  +' &' ! ! +0. ,% !  0/ + ,##$!*  #$,.%

,% + &' ! '%(. .  & &! %. &% !( ,% !&!!(  !* % !

&!!(  ! %#- &'!  1 ,..( ,% !&!!( &. ,% !.   /-

&%(,*(!&$$,##$-&'!&.%(&,% !&!!(/$/$ .% !

,% !. +'*

 (! !.%(!-,&'!.!&'1 & /-&%(,',% !

&!!( !,$...,% !(&!,% .(&#  ., ,.&!!(*





*

%($ 

&' !%.&