Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-23328/3 AI generated

2-06-23328/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-23328/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

$'. &'! ! #. ,. +..+. ,. &$$ +..+. *  +  @ 8    +0.-

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-23328/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: $'. &'! ! #. ,. +..+. ,. &$$ +..+. *  +  @ 8    +0.-

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

















 

 

 !







"#$%!&'!





%

%($ 

 

  





)*%+,-$** !$$

   



   

   '.

*"* + ! /0'.%0!( 121 &$%. 

+..+.)23&$%.+#,0. ,.&

      

 

 4$. $.&(!&'  .%%52

'/.%!.%.%(+.&.$!.(.%!

4.%($66  . 2 -!, 1 3 .%%52 & 

*"*45

 

   



.$.&,% !

  

 !

 



" #$% 

 & '&()



*% % +,-./,4&,

!'  %.( &!!&7,,%( 7& &$%.  %. % .5

 .      ++0+.1/

4&, !'  &,( . &7,,%( &, &$%.  +..&7,,%( % .5

 .





-2+,.1, 4&!! !'  &'&( &,&7,,%( %. &$%.  +..&7,,%( %. % .5

 







  

 

  3$

)  



 & 

 

"   *   

 



    

   

$ 4

    

 





   



 +0.-. (  !/&2&!. , +! !2,..  !

,. !&2 . .%. !( ,0!+  /0'! *  +0.- . ( 0 !,  ,0!+

/0'! ,! 2 &!. '. + ,  # ,. /!'! . &  +0. , .%(

.,  !(&# ,!!+...&!...&.&! &.$+ !7%(,.*

+0.-. (  !&#  ., ,.  1/#+&! ! .%!(

&' !*0!((&%#   !( .+..&' !,% !81*











!)53)6.&6!37

.  !('./!-',0. &  '&!&+#/0'.%0!!,,1*1

&$%.+..+.()*32&&&!1*31&$%.%.%/!-. (,% !&!!( !

,% !. +'*

.+(!&' 0,..(/(*)*1**.. !,./.%!4/.%52,.!

! '&   %! 4.5*

  .%(!( 2 $. $.&( 912 %.% &  0,..( *)*1**

-.. 6%.#$,&!,77./.%!477./.%52,.! .%(!(

,77 &  ,-.. 6%.4(5 : 



:  )32 + +4(5  &(4.(5

4.5*

 +  /.%! .  ' &  $+( %$* 19)13312 1)12

1)9&&&!!,,1234&, !' %.(&'&&7,,%(7&&$%.

+..&7,,%(% .5&$%.4.15* .+(!. ,..!%& +0121

4&, !' %.(&!!&7,,%(7&&$%.%.% .5&$%.2,.%&#+' &%.

!, *

 % &' !+#. ,% !  %!( &  +0%0!(2 ,. +.  +.., 

!, $+  %(. #.%(+ #' +0%+!.&+.($.,.&4.5*

 % $+ %!( +..+.    +.., $+ ,& #' /#+ #$%+  /#+  &!%.

'. . ,. &!!/#+%. ****   % %!( +..+. ! 3 /#+*  

+..+.+0 '  %  )23 4&, !'  &,( . &7,,%( &, &$%. 

+..&7,,%(% .5&$%.*..+.$+ ,.%!&+0 !(&!!/.&&!/#+

  /.&&!  /#+* ..+. $+ !; 23<=/#+ >  121 &$%. ? 329

&$%.=/#+2329&$%.>3/#+?)23&$%.*



@ 8    %%- +0!( 0.! %0!( $'. &'! ! #. ,.  

$.&&!,.*  +  +00.!(! 4@5 8    % /.% /.%!/ 

#. ,.&&'! !.&*@8)&'  !-&'! ! #. + + /.%!+0.

(!* @ 8  #  -2   &'! ! $.&&!,.% % +0!'   !%+ &'! !

#. ,  # ,.% +0. ,. &'% #. ,.% ' #. ,. +..+. ,.%* @ 8    / 

%%-+0!(0.!&'! !$.&&!,.&$$%0!(&'! ! #. ,. *

/.%!+0 .& &'! !,& '+ + .  !($+ $'*/.%!

'! , !& .& %   %!  &! ,. 7( .%.,!( 4 .%.,!(A . 35*

.%.,! /!%& .***&' &'! !&  #. ,/.%! 2 + + /!%& .***

!,0.  %! $+.(+ +  .%.,! 6.&$. !($+(! &$$*

. & $+(($.$,*($.,!! !,. .& ' 

+. %!(*  +  .%.,!  /!%& . **3*    &'! ! &  ., +0.,!

+. ,' ,%.,2($.2&% & 6%.+0. . $&+... .(,!! !,. &

!!  %(,  . ,.* %+  !%+  !- !( &  + +  .%.,! 

/!%& . *1* $+( %!&* $+  ,. ,.% + +  .%.,!  /!%& . 3** .

+- %!(..&.&   !,.&'! ! *

@8/&' +0.-+0!(2&!.+0%.&%&'! ! $.&&!%!(2%0!(

$'. &'! ! #. ,. +..+. ,. &$$ +..+. *  +  @ 8    +0.-

+0!(%0!(+0%.&! $'.&'! ! #. ,.+..+. ,.&$$+..+. 2$+ 

&'! !.%0! +&,!! !,. &!%.&' #. ,.%.*..+.,##$& &@

891#   !(.% $.,##$2,..%(!-)< *#' !(@83#   !(

(./. ..+! /0'.,0   //..( ' %.% &  .%.,!  /!%& . 3** &&&!

+..+. ,##$ 23 < /#+ #'   !,  !,, * .%.,!  /!%& . 3*9*

&'  &,& ! !&!,,&!,.'*







%+ #' !(+0%-& '12314&!! !' &'&(&,&7,,%(

%. &$%.  +..&7,,%( %. % .5 &$%.2 ,.  /0'.%0! 4'.'.%(5 ,(! -

121 4&, !'  %.( &!!&7,,%( 7& &$%.  %. % .5 &$%. %.% +..+.

)234&, !' &,(. &7,,%(&,&$%.+..&7,,%(% .5&$%.*

.+..&' !,% !(! .&!4 58)&' . -,% %!(&'!

,% !&!!( !,% !. +'&' ! !+0.,% ! 0/ +,##$!*

 +  8&' &%%-'.,% !&!!(/2&&'!& !

' .* ,! . !- '7+. ( +.&!( &' !+#.( &!!(2 ,.& % & ,% !. 

.%( %0!  &!!(%.%,% !. 0.(!&!!(*

% !&!!( $'.  &.%(&,##$,.  +0.- %0!(  '%(%!( .,  ,

&' !  '%(. .(!+ &!!( /$/$ .%  ! !  /#+ &!  

&!!(  ! &'  ' !( '%(. 0! !,.  4  8 )1  5* ...&' !

.+..&.!,. **   '%(. &'  .+.. %$  +0.- &!!

(&!,%(.&  ,!!'! (&!,% 2 ,.  %#' !- .%( !  !( 0.!-.  

!,.&'! !*

 &'! ! !( .%( /  !  !( 0.!-.   ) /$ % . '. $'!( !(

  !%- '  ' .%( +' 0,. !( /.%! 2 ,.( 0%(- '

&.%%. !&.$.4.5*

.+..&' !,% !(! .&!4 58/ 1#' !(  -'2 %%0!

&.$.&!,% ,.%.%./+.&!&#-.+ ,. &' !. !%.*

8)9&' .  &677....&!+ !'. ,!&'#$.!$..(..

..&!+ ! ,!&'#$.*

.%($66

 .



%

*)*

!%!(

$...0.+!

!,,

3

&$%.

'%(!,.%. $.!,. $+(!$+ )) ,#$&.( +.. %!,-$.& 9)9

%.%. !& *...0.+!&!,. &% $.-$...0.+!+0 4852*'*

&'!4835*

&.%%. -.  !((&!,% .(&/. 0.! *

#' !(7 (! %.%!'.%(!(@8( 322)22/(

22 8( 22922)92122

21122)2)12228( /232

/!- '; 5 '.+(! $'!((A 5 ,0.  &   ' &!& +# /0'.%0!

4'.'.%(5 !,,  121 4&, !'  %.( &!!&7,,%( 7& &$%.  %. % .5

&$%.2 +..+.( !,,  )23 4&, !'  &,( . &7,,%( &, &$%. 

+..&7,,%( % .5 &$%.2 &&&!  1231 4&!! !'  &'&( &,&7,,%( %.

&$%.+..&7,,%(%.% .5&$%.A5. (,% !&!!( !,% !. 

+'*  ,% !&!!( '.+(! . ,. .! %; $...0.+ 3 4&&(

+..&7,,%( &$%.   % .5 &$%.  0.!-.&!!(  2) 47& !'  7&(

&!!&7,,%(7&&$%.&'&&7,,%(. % .5&$%.*



 3) !

 .&' !+ %!(= *92=*



 ! !

'! ! +!%!( .+.., $.(.-2 &#++0.-  !

'.$'!((*

 8 1)   #  -2   &'! +0.- '  ! +0. ,  ! '.

 ! $'!(( '.+(! ,#$. !(  !( 0.!.&!  /0'%( !(

! !2&!.& 2&&'!%,##$%!(+ ,. #' 2. #'  + %!(2

..&!.'. .,  .& &# +#.$...+0.&!. .,  .&# +.&! *!'!

 &'.  !(6& ..(+#. (& / ,&+0 !&*





+0.-%.,  !(  !. (&'.+(!4 81)5*  !

+0.- 81)0.&%.,  !(!'! '&' !. !%. /.(, 4 81)5*



 +# &'!'.+(!. !(, $.(1*9***2&'! (

&   '. &.$.&!  + ,  /#+ &! '. &# ,.    = * 9=*

 %,% !(&!,% / .! !/ &#  .,  !(..&.&! 3*9*= **

=*  .&' ! #'  + %!(*B#$.&!  !-!(''..  !(

6& ..( +#. ( &  /  ,&+0 !&*   %   !( '. + ,  # ,.

#$( *

'!!-.!&'2 '%0.!.&! /0'%(%!(,'.+(!,#$. !(

%0!(,.  81)!&!!!-'.  !$'!(,.*



/!-. (,% !&!!( !,% !. +'*



8 21&' '.,% !&!!(&%%-/2&&'!& !

' .*

"2 & &'!&  ! ' .2 '7+. - . / ,!! '! &' !,% ! 0 !

&&.%!(+.&!(&' !+#.(&!!(* ' !+#.(&!!(2,.'7+.  & !%%. 2&

$+ !('7+. ., ##%!( CC !+0.,!!/7.+. !&! 2'7+.  &/

,(! ,! !2%!'7+.  & !%%. &!!(* '!+0.-# &!!(

#..&! +0.. / %(.&%(2&!.+ /&!!(+#,0. ,.%/ 2&

&'!& ! ' .2& ,!' ##$,. -0.%+0.-,0. .&*



 +   8 )     . -  ,% %!( &'! ,% !&!!(  !

,% !.  +' &' ! ! +0. ,% !  0/ + ,##$!*  #$,.%

,% +&' !'%(..  &&!%.&% !(,% !&!!( !*% !&!!(

 ! %#- &'!  2 ,..( ,% !&!!( &. ,% !.   /- &%(,*

(! &$$ ,##$- &'! &.%(& ,% !&!!( /$/$ .%  !

,% !. +'*

 (! !.%( !- ,&'! .!&'2   &  /- &%(, ' ,% !

&!!( !,$...,% !(&!,% .(&#  ., ,.&!!(*







*

%($ 

&' !%.&