Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-7359/5 AI generated

2-05-7359/5 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-7359/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

.          $  !      "   #!    $$ $$%   " 3     "  1  1"  1  0   3    ("  0 8   0" 00 "  $       "       " 03 $ 3$  03   #$      3  $       "  "   <          "03 "3    % $     " "   0  10     "    /     "    3  " "     "  "  1"    8   #    1 01 $ " "$ 1 " "  # 0  $ 3 " 0 $3  $ 01   "         $  01    "   "      ("    " 3  $    50     "     ;"$     "$  3          "   "             /+ =     "          "        !  !$$%12221  #1    "$ 3  "  "  " =       % " *          "   "   $$         $

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-7359/5 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja: .          $  !      "   #!    $$ $$%   " 3     "  1  1"  1  0   3    ("  0 8   0" 00 "  $       "       " 03 $ 3$  03   #$      3  $       "  "   <          "03 "3    % $     " "   0  10     "    /     "    3  " "     "  "  1"    8   #    1 01 $ " "$ 1 " "  # 0  $ 3 " 0 $3  $ 01   "         $  01    "   "      ("    " 3  $    50     "     ;"$     "$  3          "   "             /+ =     "          "        !  !$$%12221  #1    "$ 3  "  "  " =       % " *          "   "   $$         $

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                              

        ! "!              !         # $   % $ & '()*!*  "* % $  " $ & +**)+,*-*)* "

## ! #$ &   .*/*

$%&'(&)*

+, - #!!,

., /0#    1!2       #

     1  3 ! # 3 ! 4      ,

, /0#       

##!2 #    5 1! 3 !4     ,  6#  !# !   

   7 1# !

#3 ! 4    8  ,

   ##   / " *     #  ! 5,++,.55  ## +,55

%9&)%:")&% $9 

  #  0    1    "  0        2 

   03  $     3 " $ 44"             

 % $    / 

 5

    " .* /* 6" 0"& $ 7   1  1" #$    % $          $  3    $ "        $$ % $   "  33  $        $ "         $$       33    1        33  33  3   "   " $     #    $    $ " $  0  $   $    #$         $        "   $     % $     $  $              #   "     $  $  01 1  8    $   8  3$ 1  8%   "01 $ " 1")+/6)+2 1 $3  7 $  9.+ 0    )+ /     0   $         $     ""  0 " 6 : 7       " 1   $        50 1  $ 0  "  0 $   $   

     +  $ 01 1 )+/ 8   '   $ " 0 

 "0"  "3 0       9.+ :  #   6" 0"&;" "7#$   " "(" 0 ;-    ("  $    "03 $  "      ;"  0 ; --   $    "          <       "03  "3    /  )+   $  1" $      8      " "" % $    1" " $   $   $  0     1"   "

   1  3 "  1 " " % $  1"   1   /"== 8      

         #$ 

     #$  $   & $   19.+> 0  8"

 1    #$   "$3 " 3"& )*!*'( 1"0" 1   /)+6  3$ 2  )+73$  "$ "  1" $   $  1"    " $   1 ""  3)  !

'(  $      $      1    8  " + " 

 "   100     0  $     "    "     03    3"  1             $      #$        $      $  0 1 " " $  $  1"   $   1 $  3   $  0    " 1"  "  0     1  ? 1 " "   0 $    3$  " $  1"   + 0 $  "1 ""$   "3 $ "  " $ " "10 " )*!*'( /)+ $ ;  "1 "$    $   1 "/1 ""  0 " 0 10 0;;  $ 1 " "  0 10   "0  0"  "3$     $  1   "  1 ";"

 "0" " 1 "" 3    $      0;"01 $ " " #$  0 0 10 $ " 1""1 " "        % $      1"   @ /  )+   8   $    1" .* /*    1   1    1   1"    $ ; $  " 1   1"" % $   "      )+ /   0" $  3 1"     $  $   03 0 "  3 "0  1" 9 .+  : "  0    1"      +  '()*!* "   " $ )+, -  )     "$ 1    3 "   1"  " 

 % $     " 1 "  0  0  " 1 " "   "   

"$ )+/0 $   "   " 0    3  #$ 0" "A+= 1 1 ;""  3 1  " $          1  " $  0 3$  " "  1"    " $ 01    " 1"  0 ; 1;        A+=@ 0   1  " $ 1  " $   1"

" 1 "

  1"  "1 ">  1"     )+/  1  " $  $  " "+ "3  1"  1 " "    1" 0   % $  0    " )+/  1"   1 " 1  A+ =  3         1     " +    $  3 "$  1"   "1 ""

  " 1"1  " .* /*   #$  1 ")+ /6)+2 1 $3  78 3  $   : "  0     0  9B         #$           $  : " 

 @  #$   "   +- "  "  :  $   $ 0$ 

0   " " "     #$    $  "0   

 "  "(" " 9.+ 0        $   $     " 9 .+ 0          : " 0   $  

 "0    "01 $       0 1"0  $  $ 1 " "   "      "3         " "     $    "   0  1 3   #$        @          8  $  8    @8  #$        1   $         $  :  

33    8    % $      $  0     $33 "   "3$  ;" "    "" $  0 $3  "  / 

       ) "  @@ @@@8@ 50 (" 0 $   "  "$  "  0$ 00  3" "0 "  $ 0 0  :     $  "   #$   "  " "   3 03 8@

44"  "0  ) 3    $   "  3  $ /  3       $ )+2  "  "$  1" 3$    0 

  +  )+2 0  1   "  " "$    "  $  0 3  " )+ 2  $  $  00" ("  0         "   $  3   "  )+ 2    3 , $  " "3$ 0" "044 "   $ 0     3        #$    )+ 2  0 044 " " 1 )+ 2    0  1     "  " " $    "  $ 03 "  % $  10  $  9 .+ 0  1 $    " 9 .+  : "       0     ; 0 0   $  0     $  0    3   $3    0 "    $3  "1  #$  3" 0  10           01 $ " "     $   "   " 3$ 10 10     "" $ 0 $3  "     3 0 10 "0$ 0  10 03 $   $ 1"3  $  9.+0      $  ("        " 1   0  10  $  0 3  $ 10 3 " "0 8     0 $   $ 1  1" $ 0 0   1 0  10   "  0  3  $  10  /  (" 0 @$ 1"0 3  $  8  ? 10 9.+0 

3  $ 100   )+/1  1"  $   "     " 3  $   "  "   $  " 100      " "   "  "       $  " " # " $  " "

3 1      #$   " :     :  3 "   ;     #$  1 0  3  $   " #$  ;;""  :          9.+0  "  " "  " #$  

    0     $  60      $  

 0  $ "     0 87   " :  0 3  $  $    $   $  ,   0  10   

3      $  :              :  33  6 " "  ";;  7  :     ;   $    $  3 1 10 0 

3    #  $  10  0  

3    

 0  3  $    $   :     "       $      :   

  $  $  :  " " 

$  : 3$  

   ;             0  1  "     /:  ;  "  00   100    +     $  1 

1"   " $ 0  $  "0    0 8 $ @ #$ :   " "" $      $    1 ":    

  8 #$     " 1    "   3        " 1   /" =     =  $      3  "  "  1  1"  1  0   3    ;      0   0" ("  0  8   $     "      " 03 $ 3$  03    #$      " 3  $       "      <         "03 "3    % $    ""  0 10     "   # 0 10 "  "("  33 < 03    $     " 0 " 1  33   < 03 /     "   3  " "      " $   8    % $    1 01 $ " "$ 1   $  $3 "0  0 "$1         % $          " 1 $  3    " " "" $      "1 "     ""1 " "$  $ $33  1$ "           #      0  $     33  " 3  $   "$ " "                       #  "  " $    $ " $        " $  ""  "1 """  01 $ " " $   " 

        

  !" #  !"$#  %  &%'!

 / 8   $   1".*/*  1   1  1   1"  $ ;$ "1   1"" # 0  $ 3 "  1"   $ ;  6/ 7$ 1  " $ 6)*!*'(700$    1   1 6$ 7  (! !() *+!

#!  "!  ! ! ! !    !   ,    !

% () &#

#!  " !  # !

 !  " # #

 !  # !  

!

 % #

  !  " !

 $ " "!  "   !  % () *-  !

!  "  !  " , ! "!   !! # $   *& !+$ " !"  %  "A+3  1  " $ 1  1 "    1   $  1   1"   3  "1 1 $  1    "  3    1  " $ 1 1"  " "1  " $ 6    (" 07$   $ " "  1  " $  3"#3   $ 0 $ 0   "

 0  3 "  1  " $  1   " 1"  A+   "3"=  3  1  " $ =    =1   3"1  " $  1"$    " 1"   =  "  "1 1 3 " 1 1  "  1  1    1     3"1 "  1  " $  $ 1    "   1  " $   " 3" 1  " $  A+=   1    "1 3"   $    1  " $ 1  $ $3 "  "1  $" " $ A+="$  "1  3  " " 1     1 " "    

    % $    "1 "" 1"   $ $     &

1" 0  58)'67$ )+/ 8 6 7   "" 1   (" 06* "*7  3 03 8@

44"  "0 # 0  "1 "  $  1" "/)+ "$  3  0 1   1 " "0 +  $  $   "

1" '()*!*0(" 00"   -%(! "   

  

  "  $"!#

 !   % (! !# ,  " !         %" !      %"  ,  " ! !$      "  !  # ! %" #   %

 

 &       $!  "  $$$"  $ #   

 &+     ,

  $%   #$    1 " $    0"   "  $  $  /  6)+ 2  1 $3  7  1"8    0  86 7

 @ '   $ " 0 

 "0 0"    "3 0          9.+  :          ("  ("   "  $    0  $   $    1 "    " $  ""  "  $   "  0        (" " (" 80 ;687 "$  " 0 8  $   "   " 1        9.+   "    "      0  8 6-- 0 ) "  "7? 8  $     "  " 03  $  3$   03    /3  $       "    "  <03     0 1"0  $ 1 " "   "          " 3    $      "         0  1 3 #$  1  : "  0  6   87 $     0  9B     #$        6 7  $  : " 

@   #$   "  +- "  "  :  $   0  0"  "     #$        1   $      $  :  

33      6 7   @    6  7 % $     "   "  1 "  " @@@@@8@"   "" ("  -- 0 60 7 0"   $  "  +       "1  8    $ 01 " " $  1 $  ""  ."    1$ 3"  $ 01 " " 0 $ 0$  3$  "  $      $ "    3   $  $  " ;  " 0"     #     "  0 $  $  $  0 0 06(" --07 / ! % $ 0  "0 

3  $  1 "3  $ 0  3  $   60 05  "3 "0  1087+   " 0 (" ---0$ -C0 % $ 10 $ 0 (" 0 ; 0 $   0    $3        "  " 6("  0 7 #   1 $  3     0   " 0  10      ("  0  0  $  ("  0   0  10    "  3 "0  ";" (" 0

3 " "   $      #$      $  1" 3  $   0      $  ("     "1  0 10  $  0  3  $ 10   " "    "100  67 " " "      $  " "     ("  0"  $        $  1  1"  $ 0 0  10 10  " 0 3  $ 10  (" 083 9.+0 10  (" 0  "   $   "   $     "# $    "  :        $    $    " 3 "  

  ;    #$ 10 3  $ ";;"" :        9.+0  "  #$  

     $       "   :    0  3  $  44"   $ 6 1087# $ 10 3  $   0 

3  $    :  $ 0 ;  /:   " D 0$  " "6@7 /:  ; " 100  % $ 1  1" $   "    (" 0"8$ @  %(  #$   "1   3      

 

  .  0        "   $$ #   !          $!! $#$  % 

.  0 .          !  "   % ."  "$

    % 

.          $  !      "   #!    $$ $$%   " 3     "  1  1"  1  0   3    ("  0 8   0" 00 "  $       "       " 03 $ 3$  03   #$      3  $       "  "   <          "03 "3    % $     " "   0  10     "    /     "    3  " "     "  "  1"    8   #    1 01 $ " "$ 1 " "  # 0  $ 3 " 0 $3  $ 01   "         $  01    "   "      ("    " 3  $    50     "     ;"$     "$  3          "   "             /+ =     "          "        !  !$$%12221  #1    "$ 3  "  "  " =       % " *          "   "   $$         $

   %   " $  #1 

$    "/+ =    !  

    #   # 

   

$ "" "!"  %       "  = 0

 #  #!      

  $ " "  " !"    " 

  !     " !   "$  " %    +    $  3$  1 $     1       $  $ 0 " $  " 1   8@        #  &