Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-13692/1 AI generated

2-05-13692/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-13692/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

''# 7'&  ! 2#'7'1% %)!%*( ! #'+ "2' '""' $ +1% $$ 1 '#". )2 *%%'$ " $ +1" $$ ' %". %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' =   !'1% " # ! 2#!%' %!' @1."' '#*!%6 %'#  !%%( )61+ )%. "2.'.( *11'  % " !'.!'! !6%'!%%. 1@ '".%. '#*!%6 %'# )2 *11'  % '#*!% '  1.%$ "%. #! '!%%. )212#!11' "2.'1' %1'& !''#  1.. " $ +1 $$ @1.!% '#*!%6 %'#( *11'! "  !%% 1%'! $9$9$$ + *! <  +2!%*!' +! ' 1". *??.".$ <  =  1#  1!'1 %1'& "2.'1' !''# 1%'! $ +1% $$  1.. %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!'! '#*!'  % !6%'!%%.$

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-13692/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja: )2 *%%'$ " $ +1" $$ ' %". %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' =   !'1% " # ! 2#!%' %!' @1."' '#*!%6 %'#  !%%( )61+ )%. "2.'.( *11'  % " !'.!'! !6%'!%%. 1@ '".%. '#*!%6 %'# )2 *11'  % '#*!% '  1.%$ "%. #! '!%%. )212#!11' "2.'1' %1'& !''#  1.. " $ +1 $$ @1.!% '#*!%6 %'#( *11'! "  !%% 1%'! $9$9$$ + *! <  +2!%*!' +! ' 1". *??.".$ <  =  1#  1!'1 %1'& "2.'1' !''# 1%'! $ +1% $$  1.. %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!'! '#*!'  % !6%'!%%.$

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





       

   !   ! "#        $%&' $( )( )  %*+                         #'+, $ $ -!., ///0 '1 %, ///- #'+ "2!%+, ".' 31*&'# -!., ///-

!%+, $4$5 $ -!., ///0 '1 %, ///-

!%+ '!".+, $ $ -!., ///0 .'!!, ///- !"    #"  $$$( )1  %!%"# $     #'+, $ $ #'+ "2!%+, ".' 31*&'#

!%+, $ $

!%+ '!".+, $ $   " " 36'1 %   &  ' "   (  )  (     

 *+(  )   ) (        *           '*,     -

      .     

 %%!!' 7'1' " 2#! '!%. 7'11%!"'&!  "#"" %1'  76') +!1 )%'!  %%!!' *'"'%1!!1!%'1' 6%%'%*'%*!'!%$    

 %1' $$$ '!%%. #)1.!'  !'1% ! !%+ #'+1% +1 )21+.'  !'1% !1 , 5 8$9$9$  :( 1'" %#!*!*!' %6 %+# $9$9$0 5 $8$9$   "( 1'" %#!*!*!' %6 %+# $9$9$$ "!7"# )1%!  !'1%  : "   "$ !%+ ' 1' 1'" %6'11% "" *!%.$ ;11%. 1!'1 + + "..'! < = 9 1#  + = 8 1#  + ( 71& #'+ )61+ *2!% !%+1% #'+ !! )21# !!   " +  %1. !!   4#12)  > " + 2#!& 1.  "5(  8  "$

  

* $8$$  %1' '!%%. )!%!'! !%+ # ' %""!% + ).1'& !'11' )!%( ", 5 !%+ ".! #'+1' 11+. %'* !1 71)'1( .   % ' !".( " "''. 11+. 1. #'+1' )+1. +%!'1% ""# % !' 1&! $ +" 127! "''. 11+. !%+1' %#!%.0 5 #'+1 7.& !'.!1 1! "2'%' '!%*!'!( " 7'%'"!".' '!%*!' %6 %'# " '#". ""# "2'%' '!%*!'! *??.1!%. %6 %'# '""!%*!% ' 1' %%1'%.$



 #)1.!' 1!.'! 1'). 7'%'"!"' !%+ ' 1' )'* !".$  %1. 71& !%+ +6%% #'+ ".$

  

 %!%"#1 +6 #'+ * "2'%' +.'$ !%+ '!".+ +6 )!%!'! %.. )!%)6.'%' +.' ""# 71&  1.. '#*!%$

    

" !%+ "  %1' '!%". #1' '#*!' )!%)6%'( !! %1'&  %1 2#'7'1% ". @!*! )!%!'1'( ! # " '#". )2 *%%'$

 # " '#".( !! ' 7'  ! )+1! %)!%. )2*1 "2.' 1'*!1$

#)1.!' '!%*!' +1 ' %". 212#!!'.!'( %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' +  )!) '1!' '2#!' !'.!' '".*!' !'.!' 4< 5 =  1#  +6# %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!'! ""# )212#!!'.!'! '#*!'  % !6%'!%%%  1.%!'  '""' $ +1%  %'". '#*% "2'%'1'$

''# 7'&  ! 2#'7'1% %)!%*( ! #'+ "2' '""' $ +1% $$ 1 '#". )2 *%%'$ " $ +1" $$ ' %". %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' =   !'1% " # ! 2#!%' %!' @1."' '#*!%6 %'#  !%%( )61+ )%. "2.'.( *11'  % " !'.!'! !6%'!%%. 1@ '".%. '#*!%6 %'# )2 *11'  % '#*!% '  1.%$ "%. #! '!%%. )212#!11' "2.'1' %1'& !''#  1.. " $ +1 $$ @1.!% '#*!%6 %'#( *11'! "  !%% 1%'! $9$9$$ + *! <  +2!%*!' +! ' 1". *??.".$ <  =  1#  1!'1 %1'& "2.'1' !''# 1%'! $ +1% $$  1.. %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!'! '#*!'  % !6%'!%%.$

!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' 4 !;5 = > 1#   !'1% 2#! "2. %'!'1% !1% %' %'#'*!% )2 !'11'!% .*!% 4"2'5 '#& !'.!'! !6%'!%%. %6 %+ 4'#*!%6 %'#5 +!1$ 36!% "2.' '#*!% )2&  !%%. ! ''1.. *  !%!%' %6%*!'!%$

!; = > 1#  1!'1 " %' "#!% %1'"') "2.' '#*!%6 %'# 1* !%%$

" # " '!%%.  %!!' $ +" $$( !! ' 1' 1*' !%"' '#*!%6 %'#( *! ' %'!%% <  1!'1 1%'! $+1 $$ %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' +2!%*!'# *??.". +  %1 71' 72 +!%  1.. '#*!%$

212#!!'.!'( %!)1!'.!% @1.! !'.!' +  )!) '1!' '2#!' !'.!' '".*!' !'.!' =   !'1%  1.%!' !+11' )2 %*"#1'( *! " %'". )2 %' %. '""' $8$$$( !+1 %'*!' )2 %*"# %'#'*!' +1 ' %". !'.!%$ * !'.!' =  !6%'!%&( '% )21! %'1'( *! " %'". '""' $8$$$(  1.%!' '""' 6'!1') !'.!' +2!%*!% ' %". !'.!%$

''# 1& "%. ).1!'!  1.*!'1' )21! %'  1'"! %' %'*!' +1 ' %". %!)1.'!$

!)1.'! = 8 1#   !'1% ""& 1'"1'7"# +6# @! 71 41'"%+5 %'!'1' 71'1' 41'"+1'5 *".!!' 47'%)!'!!' 1.!'!!'5   )2 1#%""!%'# 7%1'%. !+.( 1'"+ #  !%& 1'"%+1' !* !   )2 )2.!' #!' !* 1 + !* )1%''.# !+ %#!%*$ * 7# ) 12'   !'1% 1'"1'7"# 1'%!' !21*%!   @1'".*!' **'".!%$

! = 8 1#   !'1% %1'&  !%!'. %6% "2'%' !'1 )!1 + ".1!*66%. %6 %+!



 )!%)1% !'.!' )2 1'7"# !6%'%'1'$ A ! = 8>  !'1% ' 1'  !%!' %6%*!'!% @ '71"' ''1.*"' 1&%.( )61+ )%. !'.!'# '%%'"6 %. + .$

.1!% ' 1'( '% $ $ " +1! 11+.'! $8$9$$$ %""!%".( '% ! $ $ )21#   " " $9$9$$ + 8$9$9$$ %""!%".( '% ! $ $   .11% " $9$9$$ .1!% ' 1'( '% 6'!1') +" !%+ *"#'. !!. #'+1' *!". ' 1'$  %1' '!%%. 11+.'# 1'&  ! %2'".%!( '% !%+ ! #'+1%   '!% "   .11%$ 31'. ' ).1'( '% )1%!!   .11 ! %'! %1'& )'!%.   "$

! = 8 1#   !'1% " 1'"+1 2#! 1'"1'7"#% ).1!%. !'11'  %!' 76!%(  % %2'".&( '% %   )2 !+ 1'"%+1% %'#'11% @1.!' ' !". )2 ! )6!'*! #!'!(  1'7"#! %6 '".%.$ '11' !6%%'  !'1% "  %!' %2'".*!'  !%! !%+1$ !%+ 71' '!%".  %1' %2'".'.( '% 11+. 1'!. 1". +%!'. )2 '% 11+. 1'!. 1". +%%. % %'% 71%' ) '1 !21*%. 1'"1'7"## 1 2#!1' %#+6#$

" $$$$ ' %". %!)1 %*'"'%1!' !'.!% =   !'1% +  1%'! $$$$ ' %* ". %!)1 %*'"'%1!' !'.!% =  1#  !6%'!%&( '% 7'& *& 71 %2'".* "'. !+1!.( *11'1' %#"'). %'* "2.'. + )!%)6%'.$

6 %.'! ''1%.!% 1'&  !( '% # " 72 +'".%.( !'!% !%+ * 1'"1'7"#! %1'"')%  !%!% %6%". ' 1'$ ''# %1'& !%+1% #'+ !! )61+ *2!%   " )21#"')!' %%'!$

    

!)1 %*'"'%1!' !'.!% + %6%'*'"'%1!' !'.!% '".*!' !'.!' 4 ! +  5 =   !'1% '""' 6'!1') !'.!' +2!%*!% 1!%%. *'"'%1!' 7 1  1.%!' *'"'%1!1.' +%*!'1' + "'".' ".1!*66*!'1' !'" ' %". %!)1 %*'"'%1!' !'.!%! !6%'!%%%$ " $$$$ ' %". ! =  1# +6# *2!%&  ! 71' %%1!'1( '11' !! " %!! %' %.( %'!'1% 71'1% !'11' 71' !! )61+ )+1. +

72 +'".%.  %1.$

" $$$$ ' %". ! =  1#  +6# *2!%&  ! 71' %%1!'1( '11' !! " %!! %' %.( %'!'1% 71'1% !'11' 71' !! )61+ )+1. + 72 +'".%.  %1. + ! =  1#  1!'1 2#!&1 " )! 7%!'"% #  1.%. !!%$ "  ! #  1.&( !! " 72 +'".%. !%+1% )61+ *2!% #'+ !! %!%. #12) %%'! > " + 2#!&1.' %%'! 1'&  ! " 72 +'".%. )61+ *2!% )'!%.'! %!)1!+ * % + ''!%  "( !'' "   %1!.   "$

 %"

! "#