Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-17147/13 AI generated

2-05-17147/13 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-17147/13
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-17147/13 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

            !    " # $ %%!!& &" & %  !'&(&!%& %      )*+&,- %.//0*  

   .1/)122  

  ** # **3**3**(**+!"

!"+-!", !& ! &-!&$!% !"+%$!&!"*         

#&(4**3&! $(+$&$+ "

""

""3 !  "!5%$ /16/.37///%  !"($4**3**3**3**!&$!% &! $(&,**3 &! $(+$&$+ ""!8,,  -("& $ 9  ! $3!  "::"% .37/// &!" !"&!"! $ % % +% "!!& $3!  " ,".3702/) $ % +% ""$&! $(!"! %8 $&! !" %,! !  !"("&5%&%**   

    .0* "- %.//0*     ; $$&!!<61603<673<.3<06/10663  ! "!!"!4 ;"" #  %$,"*           !"# %(,8 !"** !"("&  " %$!**8 #!- %)=// +

!" ": & !!$   **3**3**(**!&$!% &! $(** ! !*          ""!!& 5&%&+8 -&! "$ 5&%%"!  &-!&%%  #   "%&6/5&+( !% %"&!"!!&5&%%$ %& ""&" ,&", !&!"3 $, ""& %(&, +

& ,>>$, !&%  ""!!&

. +% %""&"+ !"&#&, !&!"*  $ %      ** %-

!" !  #  $  % ! &# !" !  6.==*

!"3 !&% %#! !&%%&% !+&%, #,$& " !&$((" !&$ !"("&+%$!&!*,!,(!&%- ** %&% & 5&# ** !"($ +%$+$

!"" ( !&% !+ $ & " ! &-!&$!% %"3 !&!" & %5$-!&$!% %!!&%%& !* #&(5(**- &%**% "" .//6!"% #" % ! ,(%& &%,* &%%&%&#  !"("&!" &  %&

!" "$  &%    +!" &# !" !!&*"," $+"&%&!% !"&%&&""&5& "&%&3& %& !"($

!"" +-!"$* !"+%"?<1%&7/, %8$&8 #! #: &+!"3 &!8 #!% %!&""&,!( +%$-(8&!"$!(+%(8$, !&%&&-!&$!% !"+%$!&!",+%$!&!!&* &%"$ %!&% 5%- #&( +-!"$

!"  # !&%%&%& !+$ &%, # "& !&$ & " !&$ !"("&&-!&$!% !"+%$!&!"($

!"+%$!:%&**    &  

(% ! +!"!&! &  " !" !"($ #  ( %& +$3 &"  ! %& ! 5 $$ ,!&# (", # 8$& ,&&"%!!& +8"," # "#!", # ,"&(% $ #&(%&3 !&!"    " "! +

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

!""(!&%%&% !+"&%," !"$ #&#"!"* !", !&" "&#& %$,"$*

#&( 8!"- &&%"$# # : "%!  " &$- !&%%& !(%# +&, &! ""$ A " % !  !(%! $*&%%&!" "%&&+%" 5$- #&(  # ! &! ""$ 8 #!% & + "& $ %%(#&+#* !"+%"8%8 #!!&$!&?<1%&6=6%#6 &!&,& !"!" "&#& %&,"$ (!&&& "%&&&!&,& !", !&&!,# !"3+8 - !"!!&$(8$&!&,&"#!", !"

#% (% 5!" %&5 # !8%, , !"* #&(  && #  &! ", !"  "+% !&%" 8$$

!""#!", !"3 $ !"($& %&!&$!

 "& $*

#&(5%-

!""#!"$**3"#!", !&!" &&%$, !& %"8!"**3**3** (**

!"%" #!&%"!+!"&%,!"+%(*       '   (    &!" !"&!"!&+,!&  !&%"%&% !&%**+&,$3 &!&& !&$!&<0/ %#  !&%"  !""$:%%5 $,,%&% !"%!"*; %3   ! #  %$-3

6 +&,"&%  !"! %&% !&%& %5!&%& &%!&,& %& $, &*; %  %5!&  &,% ** 5$ ! $+ &$ $&&%!&,&%& $, !& !3!

!%& !"%"! % %& $&!&$!&< %8 &%!&%8 #!""%&$ $  +% "!!&%"!"! % "& "*  $  +% "!!+%$- (% !+,!&!3&"**3 &! -">>%(!-5% 3% ! ! !- &%"!  %&% !& ** :%%5 $, !& !  %5!& !%"  **3  5

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

!"%&3 B  &!""$

!"!"  $  % !  "% .03 , %%&!" C %- ****  (% %" +%$$  "% . .2*/*.//03 &" !+ -  , !

!"!" +88$$ #6)//// ***+%$$3&"!+ -+ $%!%!"

!"",::3&" ,::# !"!$$ #!"**"#! C

!"!"*,!

!"!,"$,&"&% #&(** !,$ !"%.2D,"%$!,!"5 $%#.63 *  !(8$$!, !&%&3&" ,5, !! !8%, , !"" !"+ !!(% !"%&-5 $$ !&$3&"**!&% !%&3(" "$ + ,&$ !&5&& +!"3!,"  5$+$ ** + "&% "% #!# ! "&$  &, 1 #&( **   .0*/=*.//0  " !"#  5" %% !""%*605* !"(&! $(+ $&3&"!,$&5%"&+ &%!,%%!&%%&,!(8!"$  ""!!&  +!""&#&% !&%&*!(%&% !"$"%=2%%  #  ""!!)*/0*./// 3 ! +$"  ** 5&%%"!  &-!& %!&% %-     " /**=== "!! ** # ! **(**+!"

!"+-!", !& !*! %#& # &! ""$!,%8 #!% %%!&% ?<7/%#(.%!&%3 $ !"($& %&!,$***(**- &%% ""$ +% "!!&&& !& !!  (0*/0*.//).7.@*01  !&%""%)   " "!!&# /*/2*.//63 "!! (8!"! /=*/*.//6*   " !  (8$$ ** ( ** ":"&$ ** ( **3 &!  &!%&+! "! +

%!(! !"("& !*,"   !"( !"$%&% &**3 &$&! $-&,**   !5&-%% !& !"! +

% %%&&# , 5%"," +&& +!!!+%("$"3&"**!&%&"!"&  !&%"5 !"&%,,&,%"**3 &!&%! ,&""$,(! ,!,  ! %5!&%5!& &* #&( 5( ** ( "&, 5&& #*&%& ** !, % ! $ !"($ + $%!%!&!"&%,!" $"% $! ==.*!"%"#! &%,* #&(!&%&"!3&"" !&%-! !"("&% ,(( &%, "%%* &&#  5%"& + &% "&#&, !" &%,8 #!%  ! "&#3 , $ &#%&& -&%,!&$!<* ;&% %"& %$  "%%!"  %$$!(% &$, !&%?!""& $( #  %$," (", &% 58 (&$"$*  "+

$&?<)%#1%&& %&+!"%!"!!&#*<  !&%" &#%&& - &%,  !", !&!" "& $ ! "& $ &%,!&$!3 ? < ) %#   !&%"

 !"&!"-!(8 #!!(8 #!&$3!& !- #   ""!!&!3, %%&#(&"   " /**==="!!,","(5&%%"!  &-! %$,"*  ! +8"" ! !( ($&    "  "! +

%" ,  .12@===3 ! &&%+

$"$  ""!!&,"&(% $!+$*

  ""!!/**==="! +! .12@===

 %%   #   " "!! )*/0*.///  $ ,&"%!&$  "8&$ $ ! +

 ",&&"%!&&$!" !<.2.%#.,8 !"&!*  !%& -3&"  %$, !&%&"%&-8%8 #!!&$!&3! +

%!&$!" 9%$!&$!&(  +!+ &% !&8 #!&&$!& &$, !&&$!&<23, %%&%8 &  !&%"&& *(% " .//. "& "$ "& # !- 5!" *(% " .//. ": !"$ +8  %&5 # : &5%!&%" %85&"$: !&! & " +!!&$!&!!"&!""$ !*: !", !&(%85&", !&%!"&! "&!  %$" !& "& # "&#&, !& (% & " $ !&$!"*%"&! /*/2*==. & " $ &%,!&$!&  < . %8 &   !&%" &%,! &"& -(& " !  &%,* < .7 %# 6  !&%"&%, "!" !", !&%  %$" !&&%, :: %&5 #"&#%&& + $!""& $ /*/0*==7*?3!9( +!+ &% !&8 #!&&$!& &$, !&&$!&<. %8 &  !&%"&&*(% ".//.!8%, "$ &!"+!%&5 #"&%&  %$" !&%"&!*(% !" .//."! +

%!&$!" :%$!!&$!&! #+8%8 #!!&$!&!!"&!"""*8%8 #!!&$!< 6" "(":: %&5 # % &:%&!:"%&, &(<1!6." "(":: %&5 # % !& :%&!:"%&, !& " "($3  , %%& %8 &   !&%"  "%&-  :%&!:"%&, !&!" "& !&%& 5%& "&"$ + &,%" %, $&""&*?<6.)%#1  !&%"&%, :: %&5 #:%&!:"%&, !& !

$&%:%&!:"%&, !&+,(?<6.)%8 &)  !&%" &!%&+5# + %8 #&"&!1 !"&!""$8&"&%&, ""&+!"+:%&!:"%&, &": &*

#&("&&! $(5%""%0/*/2*.//) !""$( !"("&%&" " (#!$&"$8& &-!&$!%  +%$!& %85&", !& !  ," 0.  $ ! !+

!"  " &  +!" !&$!& 8&"&%&  :: %&5 # :%&!:"%&, !& ! &  +,  &# ! ! !!* #&(  5%$

!" +-!"$ 6/*(% ! .//) 3 8&  +%(!""$  ./*/2*.//) !** !&$!&! "$$ %,& % !&&""&"&", !&" "(!&,&% !"("&%&"$&# %"/5&+* &%"$$!(%$&%5$- #  %$, !& !!&$!% %!*  # $ %%!  "   8 #&4* %%!@  " @