Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-3238/6 AI generated

2-06-3238/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-3238/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

4, !&2 , ,%, !( 4/!.  +/'! )  ./,* , ( / !4  4/!. +/'!

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-3238/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: 4, !&2 , ,%, !( 4/!.  +/'! )  ./,* , ( / !4  4/!. +/'!

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

















 

 

 !







"#$%!&'!





%

%($ 

 

  





)& *$)) !$$

   



   

 %+%&',-)). !./)0&$%,%/!(

      

 

 %+%&1$, $,&(2!&' ,,., ,%%32

' ,%( 4 !!,% 1+ ,($ ,,., 

,%%32& -))1

 

   



,$,&4% !

  

 !

 



" #$% 

&  '!(





%

)1&'& !' 5&(

&4&544%(&43

 )+  





  

 

  &$

'!(

  





 

"   (   

 



    

   

$     

 





   



  ./,* , (  ! + &2 &!, 4 .! !2 4, ,  !

4, !&2 , ,%, !( 4/!.  +/'! )  ./,* , ( / !4  4/!. +/'!

4! 2&!,',. 4 # 4,+!'!,& ./, 4,%( ,4  !(&# 4!!

.,,,&!,,,&,&! &,$. !5%(4,)

./,*, (  !&#  ,4 4,  6+#.&! ! ,%!(&' !)

/!((&%#   !( ,.,,&' !4% !76)













!',&'-./-!&0

,  !(',.(!  *'&  ./)0&$%,.#4/, 4, &/,,

4% !&!!(1'$,,,/,.88&$%,3& &%(# 4, )

,.(!&' /4, , %+%&2 %,,,% ,1(+,(,9,,,%3

-)) 1(+,(,9 & 3 .' ))))  #$4&!&$(, &! 4, +,%

1(+,(,9+,%324,&' ./,4(,,,%& &$(,,(,,4,, ,!44

)  , &$%,2  +,%! ! .#  !( &$(,, &$(, ' !( ',%! 

&$(, $,4,&) !  !(&$(,,(,,4,,(, &'! !&  !4,,,%!,% $,

. . +,%!,,,%!',%%&,$1,3: )

 &'! !. . +,%! !45&&$(&!!4&+#.24,&

+,%!&' ,&!!8)&!!+#.2,% $,&!  !(&$(,,(,,4,,(,   4

&!  !( &$(,,(,,4,, , +5,4& !!$! !442 4,&  +,%! &'  ,

) ,&$%,&!!)

  ,&$(,, &$(, ',%!,(;26 ,&$%,.##$ !) !  !(&$(,,(,

,4,,(,  # , &  4&+#. ,% $, !4   +5,4&  4 ) 

$,&&!& +,%!+!%& ,)6))

))))/4, ,, %+%&,,,%!.'#$4&!&$(,&! 4,

+,%!  , %,,,% ,/,! &'! ! 5./ 4,+,%1,8324,

+)&' %(,,,,%+,%!  !%.(,,,%!/,!(&'! !(5

, %+%&1(+,(,9'3)

 .,  &   )8)6)) &,$,&!  1, 3  +,%!  !%. 

./%.! %/!(,./%.! !4, ',4 6+#.&!+%,4  !(

&,$,&!   &# 4, )  .,  &   5' , ! 2   ./%.!

!4 # 4,5 *'+,%!5)  , !%!(+,%!  !%. 

./%.! 24, / !5 '+,%!5)

,!))))4(! *& +,%!  !%../%.!'&&&!

20  , &$%,2 4,  +/', ./%.! % ;26  , &$%,2 ,% $,

./%.!;26 ,&$%,++ $'.82 ,&$%,1,63)

 ,',, 4,+#.,!.* ' ,&! '%/!(,( #, %!()



<78#  *2  ,.,,/,!(&'! !( &,.( ',%!  2(!#   !(

5%(4!    4!!(  ,4,%!  2 4, (! * ,.,,/,!   &'! ! 

&&,4,24! ,/,!.    !( )

=7#  *2 +,%%+,%!+  #, 4,&&'! !,&)

= 7 06   &'  &!, &'! !  !* . .  (! ./, +,%! !(

,% $,2 % ,% $,4##$& +  &!+ !$+ &+% +/',$>,%% $,4,

+$ ,%,(&'( ..,,4%,% $,4##$%%, )%!$,)!!, 2&!,

(!./,+,%!, %#' !( ,, ,)

= 7 #  *2   &'! !$,&&!4,%%./!'   !%.&'! ! #, 4 

# 4,%./,4, &'% #, 4,%2'! #, 4,.,,., 4,%)

= 7    +!%& ,(   6 &'  &!, ./%,& % &'! !  $,&&!%!(2 ./,*

./!(%/!(&'! ! #, 4, 2 %(+,%! ./,?(+,%5)

=7#  *2 ./!(./,*&'! !$,&&!4,&$$&! ($(,./,

&&/,&,(!  !%.,(/,!&, .'%(,(24,(*5' &! (2&!,

(! ./,+,%! , !% ,, ,)

=7&!,./%,&$,&!*$'4&4,&'! ! 2./,*./!(%/!(

#, 4, )

 % %/!  &,$,&! 4% !)  % . !( &  + &

 +%&! & /4,( &4+$4,) -!'! &!, ,4%.(  7 6;   %,4  !(

!(2+!*''%((  !%%, !%, )







 (! #' !(!',%(!( <782=7( 2;20622

+622@ 7+!*'4/, -)), .#,

%+%& &!& 20  , &$%,  &/,, 4% !&!!( 1' ! !( $,,,/,.

882 ,&$%,3& &%(# 4, )



 &' !

 ,&' !. %!(A )686;26A)



 ! !

'!  ! .!%!( ,.,, 4 $,( ,*2   &#.  ./,* 

 !',$'!(()

 7 6;   #  *2   &'! ./,* '  ! ./, 4  ! ',

 !$'!((',.(!4#$, !(!(/,!,&! +/'%( !(

! !2 &!, & 2 & &'! % 4##$%!( . 4, #' 2 ,  #'  

. %!(2 ,, &!, ', ,4  , &  &#  .#,$,,, ./, &!,  ,4  , &# 

.,&! )!'! &',  !(>& ,,(.#, (& + 4&./ !&)

 ./,* %,4  !(  ! , ( & ',.(! 1  7 6;  3)

 ! ./,*  7 6; /,&  %,4  !( !'! ' &' !, !%,  +,(4 

1 76;3)



  .#  &'! ',.(!   , !( 4 $,( 0))))2

&'! (&  ',&,$,&! . 4+#.&!',&# 4,  A )

686;A)  %4% !(&!4% + ,! !+ &#  ,4  !((,%(4,&

0)) A )) 6A)   ,  &' ! #'   . %!() -#$,&!  !* !(

' ', ,  !( >& ,,( .#, ( &  +  4&./ !&)   %   !(

',. 4 # 4, #$( )

'!!*,!&'2 '%/,!,&! +/'%(%!(4',.(!4#$, !(

%/!(4,  76;!&!!!*',  !$'!(4,)



+!*, (4% !&!!( !4% !, .')



7 26&' ',4% !&!!(&%%*+2&&'!& !

' ,)

"2 & &'!&  ! ' ,2 '5., * , + 4!! '! &' !4% ! / !

&&,%!( .,&!( &' !.#,( &!!() ' !.#,( &!!(2 4, '5.,  & !%%, 2

&$. !('5., ,4 ##%!( ?? !./,4!!+5,., !&! 2'5.,  &

+ 4(!  4! !2%!'5.,  & !%%, &!!() '!./,*

# &!!( #,,&! ./,, + %(,&%(2&!,. +&!!(.#4/, 4,%

+ 2&&'!& ! ' ,2& 4!' ##$4, */,%./,*4/, ,&)



 .  7;, *4% %!(&'!4% !&!!( !

4% !,  .' &' ! ! ./, 4% !  /+ . 4##$!)  #$4,%

4% . &' ! '%(, ,  & &! %, &% !( 4% !&!!(  !) % !

&!!(  ! %#* &'!  2 4,,( 4% !&!!( &, 4% !,   +*

&%(4)(!&$$4##$*&'!&,%(&4% !&!!(+$+$ ,% !

4% !, .')

 (! !,%(!*4&'!,!&'2 & +*&%(4'4% !

&!!( !4$,,,4% !(&!4% ,(&#  ,4 4,&!!()







7;6 #$,./,*4% !,%%/!('%(%!(,4 4

&' ! 

4% !&!!(

$', 

&,%(&4##$4, 

'%(,

,(!.

&!!(

+$+$ ,% !!+#.&!2 &!!( !&'  ' !('%(,

/! !4, ) 5.,  . !44 &,%(& 4, .(! ,  &  4% %!(

,4  4 &' !) .(! , & 4% !&!!( %,4&,$, %,% &!!,(

/%(.((&!4%(,()

" ,  ,(&!!( /%(4,& +,,* .( &,%%, ! 2   %( &!!( % &% !(2

&!,(&'!./,*%/!(%%( /%(4, &4!!.,,,)

% !&!!(

&,%(&4##$4,

.(!

,4 *

&'!

.,,., 4 

&

4% !&!!( %,4&,$  /%(,  &#  . + %%*   .#'4 

, +#..(!&#  ,4 4,  . !.#,( , 4,&) #' ,

./,  5'4 4% !&!!( &,%(&4##$4,.(!, 4, #'  1 7

;3)% !&!!(&,%(&4##$4,4##$! ,4  &4% !, &# 

1 7;;3)







)

%($ 

&' !%,&