Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-1510/4 AI generated

2-04-1510/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-04-1510/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

7 !"  3  2 43!!! 6   3

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-1510/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval: 7 !"  3  2 43!!! 6   3

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text











          

 

  





















  

 

! "#$!

 



 



 





%&'!(!)!*++,''-! %,'++



.. ! ! 





  

*/+0/%1%+2!3!4 */%+,15*++06











"

2(6"7!" 3

2 43!!! 6488+,&9'11-!%+:+1+'*8

44!&%::0'%0$3!'



 

   







 "

2(6

;.*&++:%





 



( 3. !



7!" 32 43!!! 6



; 3%&++%%









 4 - 

<").-00/*+- '











 





+8'!(!)!*++,''-'







*286

 





=0:, "%-=00+ "%-=00*-=000-=0,& "%-

=,:* "%'



 $7!" 32 43!!! 6

88+,&9'11 "

2(6'

3"!443!4'



$4" )! $(!3!!  "



2(6"7!" 32 43!!! 6

4!%+:+1+'*844!&%::0'%0

$3!'



  

 $7!" 32 43!!! 6

" $4:&+++'/" 3!!'



7 !"  3  2 43!!! 6   3

" $4" 3!!2

3!!'%+*:88&,+, ("

4$ %+++:089,+%%    ! 7("- $ !!  4!)! *9+++8*:,9- ! "!

3 !3)!"-! !!!!-$3! /" $46*'2!6 

!$!'





 

 



(! !)!4$)!3:+(!4 - !!(! 3 !!!!-

3! !4!>>3! !!!!!4  

!4!"!!' (! !) !)!3 

" !'!)4$3!

!33 !! !-!)!! !! ! !3" '











 !   "!  #











%' %'   "

 (!! ! )4!    !3- !  "

 

(!3  *%'+,'*++*'/+8'%+'*++*' 33 7? ! !"  3 2 43!!! 6

!"88%*&9-11"! ;

%'%'%' *%'+,'*++*' 3  "

 4! 3  %+9+*++%1,%++1 ? !

7( 7 !"  3 4! 34! ! %+++*%&*0+%9 ? !

7(0*0*&9-11! "!"



%'%'*' %*'+8'*++*'3 "

4! 3 ::08+:*,+++0 ?(

7 !"  3 4! 34! ! ::08+:*&++++ ? (  *1+

+++-++! "!"







:286

%'%':' *0'+9'*++*'3 "

4! 3 %+%980+9:, ?

7 !"  3 4! 34! ! %+++*%&*0+%9 ? ! 7(

:++++-++! "!"



%'%'0' %9'+9'*++*'3 "

7!" 3!1+

+++-++! "!"





%'%'1' +0'%+'*++*'3 "

4! 3 %+%980+9:, ?

7 !"  3 4! 34! ! %+++*%&*0+%9 ? ! 7(

%1+++-++! "!"





%'%',' +8'%+'*++*' 3  "

 4! 3  %+9+*++%1,%++1 ? !

7( 7 !"  3 4! 34! ! %+++*%&*0+%9 ? !

7( * +++-++   ! "!"   



  



   "



(3! 





 !"



#$$%&

 

 





  



')!3. !!7? !

!" 33 !291+%06'

%' *' "! !3"! ! !3 ! !3 !4  ( ! 4!  !  ! $ 3  !

! !("3 () )

 (* 

$

   +



 

$ 

 



$



 

'#  !   "

 (  7? ! !"  3

3 !3! "!3- ' !3! "! !"'  ! 3 4!3!  

"

 2(6 "!3 7?" !"  3 $ 3 ! !("3

!'



%':'7!" 3"3! !!! !3 ! !("! ! 

. ! 3 !3! *,'+8'*++*' ,++-/ '  7 !3 ! " 88+ ,&9-11

! !4"'



%'0'+,'  *++0'! "

2(64$ $"!3!2!3(3

<6=?

:9&        " % 33! 7? ! !"  3 ! ! !("!

*%'+,'*++*'-

%*'+8'*++*'-

*0'+9'*++*'-

%9'+9'*++*'-

+0'%+'*++*'



+8'%+'*++*'

. !. !4 3! " (  "3 !3 " 88+ ,&9-11  "

!3!  4!3 !3 ! !("! !4! 4!  (!4  @ ''

+,'+9'*++0'



%'1'! !("! $(!!(!4-''+,'+9'*++0'!"

<=? !:98 "% "*-

<     =? ! 90 

$ $"!3!- 4 !3 . 3 !3!  44! !

!$"! !3! !3! !3! =? ! %0  "!3!  4!3   7 !"

 3 (    !!3  343  %%, ,,9-:* '

!!4!"!;











 





 



 







 













 







 



 





  





















  

 

 





 !  

""#$%%





""#$%%  !  & '

'



#('

'#'#

""#$%%

 '  

%





!'"#$%%  '  &! '

'

"

$(

#"

!'"#$%%





! '

!

!'(!#$%% ! '  &$ $

'

%%

$

'!"

!'(!#$%%

$ $  

%





'(!#$%% $ $  &" $

'

%

(#'$

!$($%

'(!#$%%

" $  

(





'%(!#$%% " $  &"

'



""%"

""%"(

'%(!#$%%

"   

%





'!#!#$%% "   &'

'

(

"'"

""!

'!#!#$%%

'   







''!#$%% '   &! $ "

'

'

"'#

("!"(









































)









0286

%','7!" 32 43!!! 6! ! ! !("! $((!!(!4 @

''+,'+9'*++0' ? !"

2(6 !"3- !!3!"

44!3 ! !(". !. !4 3! !!3'



%' 8'  ! 4!  (3)    !(! 44! 4!!    

 !) ! "!"' ! 3  !!4  $) "! !3! "!"

44! !!    44!3  !3! !3  / ' %0 A -  

%,*1&-:&'



4!4!"!; !4$ "88+,&9-11B

44!(!3;+,'+9'*++0'/:%'%+'*++0'-'11(!4

44(!4;%05%++5:,1C+-+++:&:1,%,0

88+,&9-11D+-+++:&:1,%,0D11C%,*1&-:&







 

$





*' %' 

<  = :9, " % !  ) ! !("" .  3 !! !  !

4$!34- !")"4$

" "!4 !!3"'



4 

<=? !:9& "% !"!!"! ! !(3-4$) !3

$3 ! " ( ! !(" . !. !'  !3  !

4$43 ! !(". !>! 3-!3!! !!!4! 3'



*' *' 

< = :98 " % !   !) 3/ 4$ !!"!4! 3 !  

!'

<=:98 "*! !! ! !(" !(3-!! 3!-

!! ! -4 !  !3!(  -  

! 3-    (3!  "

< =? 90 !3 '

4 

*



# 

$

 +  

  

  

 



$



=? !%0 !!

<=?90 $!%!3!8

A'



!!"$)"!  !!!!!8A'



<:98 ":! !4! !)3" !3 $( ' !

 !)"3!! $((- !)!3 !"! '



*':'

<=%++! !!4$ ! !!4!

!4$!!!-!  "!"44!'



  3  "3 ! !("! $((!!  @ '' 44 

! !("!. !. !4 3! !+,'!(!) *++0'-! !. !3 !3-

 ! !  3 !3!  !!'  (   "

!3)88+,&9-11" ! !3

343%%,,,9-:*'4$ !"443!"+%'%%'*++0'

1124.!346(!4'



*'0'

<=%+% "%(%! 4$ "3-4$)4$  3

$3





1286

!(,! $3 !!!"44! 

44'



<"!4!3 $) 4$  3   !  " 44 !!

 !!!"44!!!'



 !  4!   (3)    !(! 44! 4!!       

 !) !"!"'

4 

<=%%: "%4$) !!!"

44!   4$  3 $3  4$ "  44!  4! !

!$4!!!'

4! !!

<=?90

!3     !-  ! ! 3) !! (! '

$ $"!3!-

4 !3. 3!3!44! !!$"!!3!!3!!3!

=%0!  !!4$ /$"!3!=?90 $!%!3!

38A'!!"$)"!  !"!"44!!!

44%0A'



*'1'$!33'"!$!3)$!"4 3! ! 3 !3!3!"'



3!!! 3"33!4$ $"!3!=/%++-=/%+% "%(%,-=/

%%:  " %-  =/ 90- 4$ $"!3!- 4 !3 . 3 !3!  44! !

!$"! !3! !3! !3!  =/  %0 "! (  $ 7?   !"

 3 2 43!!! 6   ? "

 2(6  4   9+: ,%8-*1

2.!3 3!!!*1!6'



,

- .

 



/0.1

  







$'"!(  !4! !!3!



<=:98 "%!  !)3/4$!!"!4!3 ! !'

<=:98 "*! !! ! !(" !(3-!! 3!-!! !

   -   4 !   !3!(  -   !

3-    (3!  "

< =? 90 !3 '  

4 

$ $"!3!- 4 !3 . 3  !3!  44! ! !$"! !3!

!3!!3!=%0!  !4$ $"!3!=?90 $!%!3

!:+'+0'*++0'8A'

4 !"( 4 34! !

! ! !!3!! ! !+%'+1'*++0'

<=90 "%!3(!("

($!E!!(!3! ! 34!*A'



! 3 4!3!  !!) "! (3! "4 3!   !3 ! 4!!

"! ;











 





 



 







 













 







* 



 





  



*

















  

 

 





 !  

""#$%%





""#$%%  !  & '

'



#('

'#'#

""#$%%

 '  

%





!'"#$%%  '  &! '

'

"

$(

#"

!'"#$%%





! '

!

!'(!#$%% ! '  &$ $

'

%%

$

'!"

!'(!#$%%

$ $  

%





'(!#$%% $ $  &" $

'

%

(#'$

!$($%

'(!#$%%

" $  

(





'%(!#$%% " $  &"

'



""%"

""%"(

'%(!#$%%

"   

%





'!#!#$%% "   &'

'

(

"'"

""!





,286

'!#!#$%%

'   







''!#$%% '   &(  (

'

"%

"'#

!!%%!

''!#$%%









''!#$%%   " &( " "

'



"'#

'##"

''!#$%%









''!#$%%  % " &! $ "



$

"(

%""'!









































)

 





!! ! 4!! (3! !"!!" 4!3) "! 4  */%+,15*++0

!3  !! $! "  ( )   $   4  !!3

"%+:+1+-*8'





%#"!(  !4!44!



 !  4!   (3)    !(! 44! 4!!       

 !) !"!"'

4 

<=%%: "%4$) !!

!"44! 4$  3$34$ " 44!4!!

!$4!!!'

4! !!

<=?

90!3!- ! ! 3)!!(!'

$ $"!3!=?

903! !( ((!("($!E!!!/

(!3! ! 344!!!!"%'%' -

!3!4$ !(""! !!!3!'

4 !"( 4 34! !

! ! !!3!! ! !+%'+1'*++0'

<=90 "%!3(!("

($!E!!(!3! ! 34!*A'

! 3 4!3! !!) "! (3! "4 3!  !3 44! 4!! /

44!  ! %0 A - 43 9 A -     " 4) "! !!

43 ! 4!!" (!33 44! 4!! (!3 4!   +&'

4!)*++1'"!(  !444!4!"!;

 !4$ "88+,&9-11B

44!(!3;+,'+9'*++0'/+&'%%'*++1'-'0*&(!4

44(!4;95%++5:,1C+-+++*0,181:0

88+,&9-11D+-+++*0,181:0D0*&&&%::0-%0

!! 44! 4!! (3! !"!!" !3) "! 4  */%+,15*++0

!344!$!"( ) $ 4 44!3"&%::0-%0

'" "!!3 )!44!$!!'







 

!



!

''()*+#,,

#

=*:% "*! ( !E ! !343!!4

$!3-4( 4$)! !'=00+ "%! 4$)

" 4$ !!34 3!"!$3!$"!- 3)"'

 3)"88+,&9'11"!( "3$"   ! -!

4$"$"!'



 







  



  

 #

4$)4" )!!44!-!!!!4 

4" $(!)!! !'



#

4 !! !!3!!! !!3!3!!3!

2

6=:! !!! !4!3!$ 3!! !

(  3!!!  3!! !!3!3 ! !!!3





8286

4 !! !!3!'"!" $4!4)3

+0'%%'*++0''+8'%*'*++1''!"'2:%'%*'*++1!36=

,0 "%-

4=:8% "% *!3:%'%*'*++1' !  !) 4 

$" $4" 3!!:&+++'/'