Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-9566/6 AI generated

2-06-9566/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-9566/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-9566/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



                           



 



! "#$"%&" 

  

   $"'"(   " ")*++ ",")+ 

    -.  $+#"/#(%")"$" 0*%1$%")     2 +.+$

  3+ " ",-$+%*     !!  ."*4  56  ."*"(*("(,)$" $'1((,)(&/ ,,$ " $'1(7  ,$*"(*("(,)$ " +$ + 0  (,)(&/ ,,$     " #$

 %&  !! $&&  $&&      '  !     (   &   )&* ($&&+ ,)-$&&+,- &&5 6'  ! ./// 5),%$+-$6

 /%&)//0&&  1 &&1          (    

 *



 

* !  &  .&  (!  &  2&     !/2& )//3&&  0&  ! 4 %- 5    $&& !   $&&    !          !! &  )-     (  !&  ( %60/5/)$+-$"$"()/%%"(6

1  !  ! !  !&   "! !

  (!$    (!! 

./  

 1     !   &   (! !!    1         !  & 

     !!       

 '!!1  !!      & 

 !  (!! !$ 783..&

 (1 

 99!!  

 !&     :*#; " 5 #;5 :"5<" ."*  *),$*  ,(&"+!  )+

  ""& + )++5$ 2 86 9)$" ),,"+#,,$"-"1##"# $

  ,,"+$),$*  +./( #,".   5$ 6   $+$(+"#,*+-$"&$-$)+$5$ 6 '0 $),,"+1##+),$*.*0 #,". "% -."* *++ (" * , ""$ *$ -."* /#(%" 5$  6  -"$+$ #"" ),,"+1##"%$1$$),$*#,*/#(%"$,3)+($"  *++$

  "% %$$" '"":)$"),,"+1##+

  # )++*%)++%)),$*),))+"##" -."*. -."*" 

 ) ,, )++ 

   ("$"%& )++ , ),$* %)+( -."*  "" 

 ) ,, *

   %0 $)++ 

 ) ,,  # #( -. ),-"$ "( ),$*$")++( +%%( $$*1++ */#0").$+$") +),$*"," $0$+(#"/#(%),-+$+$$"

  *++)++$3$,$"&-."*#"""$$ $" 



   ."* -(& #" /#(%") *)+) .)+") +%%) 0-"%$22

) ,,3%"$#,,"3, 88

) ,,$+%"),-+$++&),$*  +"$+ -,"$"*%)+$$$++3"&-."*3"$),$*#")%)% )"",$++%)+$%($"%#"&"$"%" ."$+% ""*+-+*00) #"*(+$")$%")-."*"*) 88

) ,, ++%)+1 ++ "%+%% ,;

) ,,)++.""+%%$,$"&)-."*#,*/#(%")),$*$ .)+$"$$  #"/#(%")*)")++$+$"-+)+%%22

) ,,,-."* "$+(4  ),%%+)++( ! ) ,, )++ 5-  "")$"  ;;! ) 3 "   ) 3 )/$"  ) 3 # /."(+;8) 6<



  ;  $" "$/-"(+;

) ,,)++<   +$%,$, ,"$%")) )++5%)+%+!

) 3*.$+(;)++"6<  -+ .5)$ %0.+1#"6!

) ,,)++<  )$ ,"$%"); ) ,,)++5%)+%+

) ,,3*.$+(;)++"6<  # () ,,)++5%)+%+

) *.$+(;)++"6<  $,$8

) )++5)")%"$; #0")++3 ) ,,#0"6<  ),,$,$2) )++<  ),,.",$+()++(5:,$,(*%6;) )++<  ).$+$",$%")5),,*1++).$+"(31# ("/#0"(6! ) )++<  $"$ /-)/$+"().! ) )++<  )"(")"))+ ,,  ) 5),.++%%;

) 6)++<  ),,$ &"(! ) ,,)++<  $==-)+$","$%"! ) ,,)++<  *++)+ ; ) )++<  %(30,-,,(+-"(( ) ,,)++<  -&"%"*%# $ 8 ) ,, )++ 5,"$%%)+%+ 

 ) ,, *.$+( ; )++"6<  #"+-"((3-/.""$ &"(!) ,,)++<  $")) ) ,,)++5-(8

) ,,*.$+(;)++"6<  ,,(#"+*)0$" 0$(!) ,,)++<  ),,),$$!) ,,)++5-(

) *.$+(;)++"6<  ( "(3$,+(3"*$() ,,)++5+%%8

) ,,3*.$+(;)++"6<  ("( 5),(+( "(3 $")#/)( 5),, "$")  # 3 ),(+") (")  # 63  0 .(3(>"%# (3./%+%),, "$+")/),(3$ )0 .(3#"+3,)(*% 6  ) ,,)++<  1#+/),(30 .(3#+(*).( * )1#"$%" ) ,,)++ 5+%%8

) ,,*.$+(;)++"<  /" ("(5$++"#++3*,#"(62!) ,,)++<  *1+( ;2) ,,)++<  $)+ -

) ,,)++  ,))+22 ) ,,)++ ."*,+(-.(+""$1"("(%")++")++ $==$+),-$%++$,5$ 6 ."*)")%")++$==$+++ +,

) ,,  ."*$,$"&%""$+)++("*0$%"),$*)(   ""$# # $" "  ;  ??  ,$*    ,% ) *)+ $+" -." $"$3 "$ $+$& -. ,"$ * , 1+ %)%#,*/#(%") 

) ,,)++$.+$+$ 



  ,$*"&3"$ #,**(+$" -+(%")")++)++/"!

) ,, ',"."&0)")+"+, ,(% ,$*"1+$+)3"$#,*$,(+")++&),,*),(+),))+82) ,,)++3 1." ,") !

 ) ,, )++  ,$* #"& /"#+$$+) ) #,* *(+"( ),%%+)++("3 # (" ,"$%"3 $" "$/-"(+""3  +$%,$, " * $)+ -"  ,$* $"")++),%%+)++("3$" "$/-"(+""3 +$%,$, ,"$%""/" 8

) ,,)++3# ".1#+/),(",$"$.$*$)+ -)#&;

) ,,  ,$*,%) *)+"$+""%" )++#.$1"(3%"$0-$+&3"$),$* )")%""$,#),,+(  ;;) ,,)++5$

3 6   ??@A



  ! ."* #"& ),$* $+0$"( "$" ++ +" , #1-*"(%$+) . #" -+( %$$" "$) ."*,%) *)+""+),-"),$*$+0("$",$1"(( 7 $ ' /.%""3  + " " ""0 )3  "$ " .$ * 7 ""$, %*$3 % $1"(()++$+#,*)$%"5$   ;6   ' A  ,-$+$+. *0 -."* ,% 1+(" *++ ("  ,-$+ #,,$ $"-$+( ),%# ,%"$$"#")+( /))-."*$.3"("3"$,,%-.#$#1-*"(+( ++$"-$()++$+"( #"",-."*-.(+"#1-*)+$,"$"+(  "$("""$,,(+$"&-."*3"$ "$"++ +",0)"%3)+; ) ,,)++   ,$*"(*,1+),%# ,%)*+-+3)+"$"++ +)++"/"$);

) ,, )++ $$; ) ,,)++#(),$*"(*.#1-*"(%$+$++ ")3,)++$+3 %-.(+"%0 .$+(","*)+(1,.)++)(*%$$"*)+( ,$*" #"-."*""$$+%$++%)+ ."*"&" %**$"%.),,"&$"%"%3)" #"& %+$ ,"% ),%%+)++(" * %++(" %* -,,(%". ",$+( )++(" $+%" ,$*"(*0("$"),-"$"++()),$*  ; ) ,,"$$)++ $+(3 )+  1$$  "" *,+3 "$ "$$ -)$)"  "$%

   *++)++$ . *,+3"$$"; +.+$$

  ,),$*  ,%""$$==),-$),,($+(  $"

   %)++$ " ,"   + #) ,+(  ++  )+  "%  % 0("$" $1"(%")"$),$*"(*),-$+"++"$1"(),$*""$$==),-$5$ !6   

$ $  "< 5";  ,-+"&3"$"$$+(-.)+++& -+(%"","$3),-+#"&#1-*"($+("$" ++ +")3% "$&#"-+(*),$* $"+3;

) ,,)++   ',,$"-"","(+$""/"3"$"("""#,".  "&),,-."*.*, $"%/#(%"5$  3),$*) *)$+-."$

6 ',,$"-"","(+$) ""3"$),$*  #"&#,* "/#(%","%*"$#,*/#(%")$+"& ),$*$ 0* %1$ "$  (+$ " ," ) ""3 "$ "$$ $+") -)$  "$%





   ,$*  " ," "$+( ),-$+" $1"("( "" ),-$3 "$ $ ,")   #,* " /#(%")-."*"#$ --"("((+(  ',,$"-",.(+"$"++ +"/" ."*#"&#1-*"($+("$"++ +") ; ) ,,)++5 88) ,,,")#,,-.(+","$"$+(22 ) ,,"$)++$+$"$ #"")++*) ,,)$)$++%)+"",3%"-."*#")"$ -* ."$+%6 ."*",+(; ) ,,"$0)"%"$".1+  ,$*","1+;

) ,,$++ "%$"$$$+% ,$*#(#1-*"($+("$" ++ +") 

) ,,3)+(),$*"(*0*"(),-$+1+,")+$);

) ,," "$"%)%") ,-$+), (+("$$"#")+(),%# ,%)/))-."*$.   '" "),"(+"B!*0 .,"%$",%$"+-$"1 ("(1.+"(*),-+$+"(  % "(+" B ("   . ),-"$ , "% ),-+$$+( / #(% ,% "$ $  %"$$+(  ),-+$+"" $& #" 1.+ ( ,% "%$ /#(%$  '" "),"(+"B*0 .3)+"%"$0(#"/#(%),-+$+$3%1$&),-+ $"""%1+("$"%$0*"$"#""1+(""$+("%)+) '" ")B     ),-"$ %00 $)" "$ #"" )() .)+" "$+ -3 0-$+(" )+%%. "%  "$ "+($ * #" *(+$"$  $$ '" ") B "   .  , "% ),-+$$+(,%#"1.+*-+")$% ""$$+""$*+-+3)+$"""%"$0(



   #" /#(%),-+$+$ #$ , $ )$ "% #" -+("$ *,-$+$ ),-+$$+( $""$ "%$  '" ") B    . 0$"$$+( "$$ 1+(%  .),-+ , $* ;  2 !53

!3 36"(+(3"$/#(%),-+$+" ))+%". , $"."%$ ) 3 )+ "% & #"" /#(%$ "&#$  $ #"" %00 $)")().)+""$+ -30-$+(")+%%."% "$"+($* #"*(+"$ '" "),"(+"B.!*0 ..)+""$+ -/-""#"""1 , 0)"% )+ #,, & . $+" )"-$"$$+( )++#. %%00   & . $+"  ("$"%& 

   %00 +   ; 8 )"-$"$ )++#. %%00 ) $"   *+ $

  ;

) ,, "".,%$*$"$"%%%00 )

) ,,  ,$%$"" +%,$"+(

!  %+(++ %+"#"/#(%)++("),-$  + %+" C #" /#(%)++("  +$%" %"$,,()D  ""%0 .) ,  0* $==$( #")1)("$*(+$"$0-$+$/-$"%"$,,()#"/#(%)++(" +$%") /-" )++  + %+" ),-"$ " 1$++(   +$%" %"$,,() #" E)$*$" ,$%*(+)+$ $+$$ * %*(+)"$ 1%+$"$  . , $$$" * $+."& "$ #" "(" ""$ $"-$+( )++$+$"" $

;  %"$$+( ++ %+" $+"%+",0* +$$+(3"$$" "#"/#(%"/-")+++". +#  $$,82

) ,,*2 ;"+$$, 8

) ,,  "$(""+)(+"$1++ , $

 ""#,, %"$$+( +%%( )($ %0 .$$ ++ "%(  "$,,(+$ $+""$ ,   '" ") B  .! 0$"$$+( "$" %%%00    .0-"(" #" %%"$" *(+$" , $"."))+" $$$" ++ %+" $+"%+".  $+( * , ),$*1+$++($+%"$$3%"++ +,"))+;

) ,,)++3%"+%% +"$)$$+)-."*#,,$$,$"$+("$"++ +". 88) ,,*/"$)"(#+$  ++%)+"(+" B  . ),-"$ , $++%)+ %)*) ://" )3 )" & %)+$%"")+++$$++ ++%)+"(+"B .#2*.),-"$#"&)3)" & "$$ %)% ""$ $++%)+   "$,,(+$ $+""$ , "(+" *0 . ),-+$$+( "$"$$++%)+%)%-."**),-$+,$+".$++%)+$+%"),-+$+"#"%" ),$*" ,"(+". $+,+ $+(*/"$&),$*$0*%1$"$"$"++ + $+(+$"(+".)"-$"$$+(%%""$+ -++ +"5

) ,,6*""$1$$+" #" ),-+ -."* $"( $++%)+),-+$+"  "$%"" "$ - ++ +" %00 %" #1-*"($+)  B .),-"$,$*$1"().+.+"$""3%,"(+"0$"$$+( # ,$", %*%"+"),-+"(+"0$"$$+(), $""&)()#,,$"1+("( * $+0$"( #1-*"(( *,+( 1 "(" #++(+%"3 %+$ %++( * 1.") -"(%")$0-$(*,+( ."*""$+*)) *)+(".$+"(","$+(*  B  .  ),-"$ $1"($")  ."* , (,)+%"$"$" $1"($". $1"(+( -.(+","$"$+(.)+$"$0*%")+$"$#""+$)++$+# /.","3"""3 "")$ "" ." * $" "$" 5$ 2 ;6  ."* "( $==$+ , 

 ) ,, )++ 5$ 6  ,$*  +-.,$1.")1$$+.),$**-."*"$+")+( ""1$$"3"& ),-+3 "$ ;

 ) ,, ++ +" "$+ - 0*%1$%" ),$*$ #,*

 + /#(%)++(")$%"),*)*$$),$*),-$+$1"($+("$+")+(*  $ "+), (  "$(" ) 1%)  ,$* #""  -."* *++ " ) #,* $" /#""$(","   B2 . +"1&-."*1+("),-+%1$"$"0*$.+$+$)+/-" $ ""$ "" "$"-. ),-$+" "$%$3 )+ ),-+$$+( ) " $0$+( "" * 0$" /#(%),-+$+$ . " ""+( '" ") B  . %"$$+( *,+(   ."* , "$+($,$+""$"0*%1$%")$.$*0 ""$" 



  3, *$%),$* "% #,* /#(%") - -"("( " (+(  .(+  "$$ ),-$+"   # 

  ,$*"$"0*%1$%""$.$*0 .$+0$"("," ,-+"&3"$ #1-*"($+(,0*%1$"$$" 



  



     B 2; ),-"$ "$& ),-+ %""$+)++(" *,$+" %""$+,$" -" ),-$+,$+"  ""$+)++(" *,$+" 0"& ),-+ "$$"3 %"( %""$+)++( )"". %""$+,$"$#"&)(%  B .),-"$)&-.%""$+")++(#,,3)"")-*+),$+$"-$3"". ),$*  ,-+ "&3 "$ ),$* )( *00( -."* %""$+)++( # ,#, $,"$ -.1+(" -+($+(,"  $" 1+(" , -."* .1+"(+" 0$"$$+ ),-"$ .1+ $+%"$ &$$+( .(+"$$+%"")+++) .1+++ +"),") 



   )"-$ .1+"(+" *  B   .  +" /-") )++ ""$ 1+$$ %)"$" ),.++%%$3 ,  ;

FG 2

 ) ,,$ 2  ) ,,  ,$* " ," .1+ $+%"$ &$$+(   $+"$"."%"*+-(+&),-+""B ("$!;! !! 3! !3; ;;    '"(  ),-$+)