Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-15079/3 AI generated

2-06-15079/3 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-15079/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-15079/3 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja: / 9( 7=;     #$ .! %55+  ,  +-! 4$  ('+  (+( -('4+!!- 5*(+ %55!- ($-++& . / &-! (   &( & ('44  -+!+%6( 0&!+ (-  $5(& +(!-" +! '( !++(+ #$ ( 6-($+-!++$+ ++$ ('44+   0&!+ (- + (+ !- !$!- *!+ +!$! (+4! 0&!+ (- + (+ !- !$!- $%+  ! &( *+ !+ !%%!  (- !- -%+!+! !(++6" +! '(( %!+(+ $ 4-6 '(( 4-$- (+- '-+'+-    ++$ ('44+-  ( !++$ !% +-4--+(" !++(+! $+-!++$+

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





      

      

    !  " #$" #$ !%&                 

      '() * +! ,($-++%+(, '( +-( +-&) ($-++& . / '( +-& $(& (+() 0 1 0&!+ (-)         2   

   3%    

    

  .'4+!- * +! ,($-++%+(, 4!%++!( +%+ !'!! 4!! $5(& (!%!   0$(-- !+-+ 4!%++!(+ ('4+!%+ ! $5(&-+ 0%+!(- +--+-   6!- &!+ (-  (- !!+!

7  55! * +! ,($-++%+(, -%+!-+ -& . /

!    

5+(+$ %55+ 4+(+ $'6 +!- %55+6+  !(+  ! -  45+$ &( %55+6+ +!&(+ 5!!+!%+!%+! (!+



 !  &   %55+  (!!- * +! ,($-++%+(, !+ 4!%++!( & &!+ 4!(-  %+!!- 



 

8!!- 4!$(-+ +(! !$!! * 0 ,($-++%+(,  ! ++! %&-!++$+ $'!!+(" +! + (+ +!!+$'!+ - %+- !(- ++ +((+ + (+ +!!+$'!+ !+!-   %&-!++$!  * 0 ,($-++%+(, + % !(((-"  ++ %+&'+! + (+ !(+ %+-+ &5 +     ( * 0 ,($-++%+(, +-!+- $'(+$+-  &

((%+! ++    ! $ *( 0 ,($-++%+(, + (+ ++ 4(6 * ($-++& (!- $5(& * 0 ,($-++%+(, 4!

 

   

0&!+ 4!(- -+ +(! + (+ $'( ($-++&( 5(- '( %!4-%-%+!! 9+% -%+!-+ +-+ 5!+!!- !5!+  5+(+$ +!+ %::--;" ++!'!! +!!+-+  !+!- $'((! -- *!+(+ -%+!+(+ & (%-!+(! !+(! !- <%!(+





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

0&!+ (- !- <%! +(! $-   0&!+ (- !+- -(  ++-!)  & ((%+!" 2    + %$'(- 7  9  > 4'$'( &   > !+$'(;" %$'(- $5++- ++ '-+ +%+ +!+ $'((-&!+  -%+- 4-$-  (+ %- $'((-&-"  ++ !++$+ ('44+%+   ( (+ +!!$!+ '+!+  $'%( +!- +%+ $!$5-+ $!$(! ?  @  5!+!!(+ '(( ($- $'(- *(+!$- 5* $-" +- %% 7 

0&!+ (-  $5(& +(!- $'(-+ (+%(" +(!- $5(&" +! 4-$- (+- $+--" 4-6 %( !++$ &  $'%( !++$+ (!%+ ++!'!! + (+ $'%( !! ' $'( 0&!+ (- +(" +!  $'( %4!(  +!$+"  4-6 +(+ $&- !+!- $'( 4!+- !$!%+ !5+-$! <!(

'(( 4-6 $" %((+ +(++%+( (+ $'%( !- $'(-  !! 4!%++!(+ (- '(( 4-6 +((+ +$55!+ $" %((+ (+ $'%( !++- %!" +! !- $'(+$+- % ++-!-+(+ & !! %++!(+ (-

 '( %&-!++$  ('44+-" + (+ $'%( !+% %&-( ( &5 4+%+" % $'%(- (56 %&-!++$+ +-+ (- $'((-&!+ '-+- A!+- %'!!+ +(! &!6 %+&'+! +-! (-"  '( + - !5!++(! % ! !5! !+ ++(!-!  4!(- +(" +! '(  4++( +!+( ("  ! + - % ! '+++(! !5!  '(( 4-$-  +(+- $'%(+- % !!+ !5!%+ ++  '( &!+( (-( (+$!+ -%+!+ +(! %+&'+! A!$(-+ +!%+ $'( !!6 % 4*$! %+&'+!! '( 4(! 4!$(-+ +!%+( ++(-!+ $'( 4*$! %+&'+!!

0&!+ (- + (+ !- $5(& +(!- !+-" %((+-+ !$'!%+ (+ $'%( '( $%+- !+- !%- %6+  !! ! '( !+!+  '+!+ +!%+ (  $'%( +!- +%+ $!$5-+ 0&!+ (-  +(" +! 4-$- $'%(+- $ !'-%+ 4!$+

0&!+ (- + (+ !$!- 4!%++!(+ ($-++& !++$+ + &!%$+ !+- B!+ (%+!+ !+ + (+ &(+ 4 !'!! $'%( +!- '-%"  '+!+ +!%+ +  %::-- 0+! +!!++-+!  +!- ($-++&(+



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

8(+ ( 4'&( $'6 :+(-" +! '( %++- + (- 4'&!- +- &!%$+- $' !+ !!+ !+- 0&!+ (- + (+ !- 4!%++!(+ 5 !$!- $ !$'!%+ (+- & !'-%+ $'%(

++ 5* ('44+%+ !(+6 -%+-- - (+ (++$(! D @ 7 (!  &55 5* -%+!!  ! $!!$(+ (+ $'( ($-++&(+ . /

0&!+ 4!(- 4(6 ('4+!- $'( 4!%++!( (% 4!! $5(& (!%! +%+ !'!!" $(-- !+-+ 4!%++!(+ ('4+!%+ ! $5(&-+ 0%+!(- +--+-" %55! $'( (+%(+$!+ -%+!-+ -& . / " %'! $5(& &!+ (- ! & *$!  $6!- &!+ 4!(- (- !!+!

 

A!+-+ @  (  +(!  $'( %+&'+!"  ! + - (-- $'((-& '-+- & ++ !%! + (+ $'( %&-(! (! !(++$(! &!+ A!+-+ @  (  &5  &-(+! ! $'( %+&'+!  "  $'( $ + ! !+% ! & +((+ +- + (+ $'( %&-(! (! !(++$(! &!+

!  (+-- !$!%!" +! $'( + - (-- $'((-& '-+-" $'( $ + ! !+% ! & ++ !%! & +((+ +- + (+ $'( %&-(! (! !(++$(! &!+

A!+-+ @  (  &5 ('4+!6  %55+ 4!%++!(+ 4!! $5(& (!%! +%+ !'!!" $!%! $'( %+&'+!+(+"  $'(( + &5! $ 4!%++!(+ (-+ !!+ & 4-6 $ !'-%+ $'%(

$!!- " +! $'(( + (+ $ 4!%++!(+ (-+ !!+" %! 4-6 $ !$'!%+ & !'-%+ $'%(

++ (+6 " +! ++(!-- 4'&!+( !(+6 * +! ,($-++%+(, 4!%++!( ('4+!- (% 4!! $5(& (!%! +%+ !'!!

A!+-+ @  (  +(! $6!6  (- 4!%++!(+ ('4+!%+("  +-+! + !(++ !+!   ('4+!6 4!%++!(+"   4'&+-!-  &!+ (- $6!- !+% !!+!



 (+6" +! * #$ 8(% ,($-++%+(, (+%(+$!+ -%+!-+ -& !(+6 %55! . /

0&!+ 4!(- 4(! !(+ +!!- !!(+ &!+ (- ! & (-+ $5(&%%+ (+-6  +(- %55+

 !++6 %55+ (5!-+ ++(!-! & &--+ 4!+-+ @-+!  ( " " " " 

4 "  (

!