Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-06-1494/10 AI generated

3-06-1494/10 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 3-06-1494/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                          

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-1494/10 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohus:                           

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                          

      

        ! "#$$%    &'$%'()(     *  +    "  #!$,!#$$%     % "- "             . /    " --        "  "0 / " " "         "$&!$ !#$$%      * +         "    !"#  $   %      !   &'(&)(*&&+    ',&+,-./.(  0"1 "0   01 2 3## 4"  5!   $ 0$ #! 2"  -(    "   "  /      . /    " --   +   "  1   2/ 1  5!        "      +    "  #!$&!#$$%      &(# " "    1 " 4!$4!#$$% "" "67" 8 + 

  /   ". -- 92 1  -- 5! 8 1    "  "   " 1 + 

 ""    0   "    1     "  "  "  / " - "      "  1 + /0"  -    " ""!  7 1    "" " :; &#4$$$$$$ <=  (#$$$$$$$ ;   (#%$$$$$$!01 1  "   " <=   & $$$$$$$   "    " 

 ""  "   /     4 " !     " #!$,!#$$%    %" " " > '1   1  ; 1   (#%$$$$$$  /0" / "?

&'$%'()(  #2%5 ' 1  " "  1     < = 1     (#$$$$$$$     "" "     "" "    - "     0  " 1  1  " 1   /  1    ? ' 1  "     1     < = 1     & $$$$$$$   "  "      "" "     "" "    - "     0  " 1  1  "1  / 1    ? ' 1  "     1   : ; 1     &#4$$$$$$     "" "     "" "    - "     0  " 1  1  " 1   /  1    !  *(   *  "      "        "  #!$,!#$$%     % "- "     --        "  " 0 / "  " "  ! +/ " /0"  " > 5 --     "  -- +"  @    "      "" "  --    "--   --   ""/0""   +    ! +    "  0 1  " " "   +       "  "" ""/0""   

   " +  "0   "? #5"   " " 

 " !8 + 

 8 "$!$ !))4  # %  " "6

 /  /00    92

 /  /00   514)  " /

 +   " 1  2/ 1  5 + 

   "  "" "  

 /  --   --   " 1  1   1        1%,  " "   "  " 1 ""!-- / "  1    "    1   "    "  " "     / "  

 /   /00    1' %#? &5 -- / "    " +""    " 0 / "      "1     + /

"  ? (5 " +  0 "1  " / 1   1 -- +"        "       

 /   @ / 1    1  -- +"  @ /0"      / "  "  " !  +   0/    0 / " 1  " "         / 1          "!    3    1  +  1 "  #!$,!#$$%   %" /   "  /      " " -- '    0  1  0      " "  "" ! " "10 "   "!   "-- 

1  +    /"   /0  ! + /  /    " 

 /00   ! /  /  0 + 

 /   /00     " "1"   "   /0 "  /    "   ""1   "1 "  "  " /"  " 1   ""!      /    " "   "  "    /   

"  "!  '( !   &'(&)(*&&+    "    0  " " "      " !10  > 57 0  "   1+ " +   "11"

/ "? #5   " #!$&!#$$%   !$4!#$$%"   " /  "  1  " "   " --  . /          " 1  " "" - /0"  ! --     "  -- +"  ""/0"   +   ""      " 1 ""!     0"" -- +"   "! ""  + --  "  "    " 1    --    "    "  / " 1 "   "AA 1 " ! 7 1  " "   " " + -- / " / " --  ! 8 " 

  0    "  "   +   "     "0  "/0" / ?

&'$%'()(  &2%5 &5

 /   /00      1 4) " +   0 

 /   /00   "   / "  ""        " " + " 1    1   /   -"/

 "" 

    "  2

 /   2 8 53& #5   /  11"  B   -- 1/1 + "  ""  /  /   " !

 /  /00    1 4) 0""     "  /  1        --     "   " "      --    /"  " /   "" --  "" "  "   -- 1 " - /0"  "+    --    / !-- 1   / "   1' %#" 1   0""  --  C  "  "  "    "      0     "  /0   "   1   "1  

     "  "" ? (5D  --  0 / " "  " "/ "  10 "    +"11"

/  !--  " /"  1 " "  +  1  "  --     " /    1   "      /     "  1   +" """&$1/  !  +    1  --    " -  "  / " + " "  "     +   0  " " "  "  "  1     AA   1   "!  +  

 " "  "  1  "  + /

 "? 45 7  0  "       " /  / "  /  /  !   " " / 01+/ " / "--  $!$)!#$$% 1  1  " / "  " " "   

   -- " "      "   /  / !    + 1  "    

+  +   

  / " /0     -/ "   0     " 0"     

            +   / "    + / "  "   0  "        " +2 3## ,5!   4!""!" 04!"#" #!   .(    1 +  % "- "       " $&!$ !#$$%          "   " "   0  " " " !  + / "   > 57  ""   0""  -- +""!   &(#-- +"   "   +" "/0"" -   " " 1 ! E  - 1 "

1    "  /    "    "  0      "" / " "  /  /0 0  2--5! --     "  -- +"    -      +   ""   -- '  "' " '   "AA 1  ! --     -- +"  "  / "  "  "" 1 "" " / " ""      "   +  "   0 "         &(# /    " " -- +"! 7""/0"" - /0"             "    "    "       " 1 "- /0"  ? #5 +/

 "

 /  /00    "" 21'4)%4%,5 ""+ "/ 1  1   "    "   !--  "  10  + /

"  """+" " "     "    1"  !   

 +0 "-1  "1  "    "  "   "  " /0 " "   " 1   "  1    / " "   "  / ""1  "  ""!      /   /  1  "   1  /0 "   0   "1  " ? &5 +  "0/10  +    "  +"--  1 @    "(!$%!#$$%   &'$%'%&  " "--       " /  -  "         " /  "  ! --      / " "   "       1 /  "  /

!  +0  C"

/

&'$%'()(  (2%5      /0     "  --  10 "" / "     " /  "!  " " " "" 6

 +F /0     " +  " """   ? (5  + "    /  " "/ 1        " /0   "   0"/ ""  / "! + "  / 1 "     "-- "" 0" / " // 1    +  "   / + 1    1      "    !      /"  " /0   / " " " 0  "/  "   ? 45 + "   /"  0" / 1   + /

  " + /  / ! /  /    / "         %   0  " /   / "0  "   -- 1 !/ /  1 0      " --     "  " +    0        0 / "  / 1   "     " / "" + 

!  " "      " " 1    /"  1   / 1      " " /  1   "0  "  /  1 ""? %5   "  "  +  11"

/ " "      10 "   0  "   " "   +"   / """ " /0  "    3# '"#!  5(      1 +        ""   +     " !8 ""  +  ""  " " "   "  / " "> 58 ""  "  "1    "--  " / " 1 "     / +     " --   0  "   "  " " /0    " " """! D     +   "0       &(# "  "  1   "  -- +"   "   --  " ""          /  "AA" " --    ""/!-- +" " -    """  1"  +   +"

/ 0    ""1AA"? #5 8  3 ,  & "" + 

 /     "  "    "  "    10 0""" / "              

 /0 +  " " ""   !

 /   --  "   " 0   "0      /

 "      / "  "10 0"" ? &5  +  "   1+  "" / 0 !       10     / " / -- +"  "  /0  --   0 / "  "  / 1      " "  "  /0  "  + /0    " !

 /   -- " 

  /    / 1         "  "  /   11"      ""  0  " 

 /! +  1+ +  /  "+"

/ 0 0 / 1   + /

 "? (5   / 1   " " "- "       +         "  

  ""  / 1       1+   0  "    "  "   /  "  " + "  !8

    " " 

1 "/ 1  /0   "- / " "

 /  -- "? 45 + "   / ""  / 0 " !7 0  " " "      +

   " G (#$  " " ! + "   /  "  1  "   " " /  1   1   /  1  "0  "/0" /   1  / ""     " "  " "!  +  "   

+  +       -/ "  0/ ""  / "!  +  "  " ""     +/0      0  "/  ""    "? %5  +   " " 1   "! 8 1   "    "     " #!$,!#$$%!

  / 1  /  "    + "  "  +  4!$4!#$$%--   / "   ! " +    "  +"

&'$%'()(  42%5   + / 1    ""  "/00  "       /   /"  "  +     1  "    "  /  "   +      -- 1 0    1   1    / (1/ !  +  " " ;  /   "     "  --   " " 1    " 

 / +   """ " "! "+ +"" "  "" +          ;   "  "

"   "  !  "  "   +1  /  "   ;  1      "/ "  $&!$ !#$$%   &'$%'()#!8 ""  /"   * /  

   "      + "   / "  +  " 1 " / 1   011 "!   "#6##! 47$#0 0  +(7 0  "   1+   +   "11"

/ " "

 "  3# # " "  """ "    0  "    "  "  "0""   " /0  /0  "! H      0  "     3# #"" " 1  0  "     

  10 "     / " 0  -    /  /0     

 / !  8(  +    + / "" +  " "  + / "    /      1    2--     -- +"  "  /    1  " ""  

 /   /00      1' 4) %4   %,   

 "  " """     1"   ""/ " / "0""  "" 0" 5  /   +  "   +"

/" 0 "    /0"  "     " /  "       " / 1    

 /   /00     "     "  &(# " / "  "  "            &(# /    " " -- +"! 

 0"+ " " +   "11"

/ "" "  ""/  " "   "  /0    + "  0   "0""  + "  1+ 3, '"" /0  +"0" "  !  )( D       +" "" 0 " " 

   /   /00   " /00    "  " "  /

  "" ! "      +"

/"0 "0 "

1     /   /00   "   / ""  "       "" " "  /   "!

 "   #$!#!#$$ "      &'&''4'$ 0" "  "

  

 /   "   /00    " ""  0 0  /  ""   /0 "" "1  "  1

 " " ""/0" / + "  "

1   " " "" ""  " "   /  1   "21'#I#45!   + "  /

 "

 /  /00    1'4)%4 %,  / 0     +   / "    1  "  + /

  / "     " 1  "  "" /   /!   +  "       1  " !  +  "         10    / " /-- +" " /0 --  0 / " 1  "/ " "

 "  1  " "  /0" + /0  "    0 !    "  +  "        1   + /

 "" "0 

 /  

&'$%'()(  %2%5 /00         "  /  "     / 1" /0      "     +   /0    /

  1  "   /0" 11

 / !  /(    +   11"

/ "    0  "    "  " 

 /     0  "   10"  +/ "  0  "   1 " / "0 / "/    " !  -&(   +  " +/ "" ""     " "      !     + 10 "          - / "  "  +/ " /   / 1   + /

  0 1 "    "/ "  10 "!    10 "  + / " " 1   + /

  "  "   / "   0   "    / /  /  /    " "  ""   "  "/  !   /0 +  "-- /   /  -- "/0   ""   "  "      --    0"   0  "     "0"" 0    "'--  1 " /     / 1    1    1   " " " 1    " "  " !  + /  "  "0  "     /0    1  "  "" /  "1   /    1  "  "" 1  ""     " +      "    ""  " "   /"" 10 "  " !