Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-5403/2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.06.5403.25713 AI generated

2-06-5403/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-5403/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-5403/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja:  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 

                      !"    " #$         %&'(& ) * )  *  !+, '                                          $-' . # /#-+" *   "+' . 0,/#-+" *       1&&& ) * (  !+"+#$       $-' . # /#-+" *   "+' . 0,/#-+" *

  ## 2+, #   3- +- # 4 *(-*  !    "# $        %&#  '%%'# (  )     *               "++# '# ,       - .# +#     /      ,              # 0#            /   ,   1      %"#%"#'%%2## "3%% 41    4  

                 # 3#             1    5%% 41 4     ,               # 2#               # &#          ''3%4       1 4  #                4!      4   &%%%%'&'4

  ''"%'+&&62%2 7      "%''%%+0&52%"" 89 8   :           '5%%%&'"+24 "3         # !                         

       # !                      *                 6#       #           %&#%&#'%%2#     * 

   #

    8        !+ +""-5- (- #6$"-"+ 0  5-(( +" # -7" #$ ## !+(-58-* ' "( * +-" !+ +""-,-#-+(" " ("+-(- 8++-+ ,-+ ,"-"+&  

 # /#-+" * '  0,/#-+" * # 7-(" ( +-"%&&& &7-("+ #"9#0#05 -$

2 #(/#-+" *' +9+ 3 # /#-+" * ) -"-( * 0 "! $-' $ '  #! $-' 9( 50 ,"-(& &&&  -"+ "  #  /#-+" *    !+(- ! $  0, /#-+" * * "+ 7-(( !+"-' -( +"-#60-"& 

    

 $ * (0"- 56!'-#0"+- ! "-(+ 58 "+ +9+ - "9#0 (8 " "+'  +::(-  ((## & 

" '8  '8 $(+ ! *-,# 0" 8, & --'8 -( 5- - #0( 0 "!+-0 (655-"0&  "+- "* + ,"-$  +-$-(-7 ! $-' & ;- - #0 ( $#-" 5 (+-"+ "+ + + $ ") 5- - #0( - "!-+- + "+ ,"+ 5- 7 ! $-'  *6, + "&  "+'  - +##- !* ( "+- * "+) - " (- #-#0- "* + ,"-"& 65-+ " , +-  ("- 7 "+ ,"+( "+-9( (50 ,"-() $(8 "9(-

6 $-, (++ ""+ + * (-+::(-& $-'  -+::+ ) (65-+ 7+8" "* #+- (  ( ""& -,+9+ - (-*--( (,- "+ #-& $-'  # -"- "+( " #;-#" # ,-+5 (+, "+ *+ -+"  #&   $-'  5 (7. < ( !+ 0  ! $-'  '  "+'  7-(= < '8++  ! $-' (- 7-((,"-( *6-+0 5- - ## #,/#-+" * =<,6"+  "+' (+*8(' -( +"( "+-9( (50 ,"- ",++-*8!-,   #$ (-( 5"-(-$ "-(+ ( +-" & && =< !"+ 0  "+' +, ", ! $-' (- 9( (50 ,"+( 5"-! (0"5! "-( (-  ' ( #( 5"- (,- "+ "- "" ,"-#,++-*8!-,

1 #$ "-(+=<,88 + ,6(-, 0( 5"-0-( , ! $-' ' -"=<'8++ ,-#-+(" (0

"+'  #0 &   

 "+' +##"+ "! $ " ("-(+& "+'  ##6" 7-(( !+ ,"-$ ' " *7, "+  #(+ 

# $ "-(+&  * 7) -+ ! $-'  #6- 1 # *8(' ,6"+,"-"+ - (- 56!'-#0 +0& 8-" (-* ( ' ( "+' +::5 (  #1 #' $ "-(+, " 7+ ! $-' (--( +"-" "-"  #&      !+"+#$(! $-' '8! $ * (0"-#60-' 0-##$ "+' ! $+##"+ "&      !") ++*#0 + ,  , +- ' (0-$ ) ( #0 8  5 (+- "-" ! 0) (- 7) -+ ! $ (7 !(0 ,"-(- !+ +""-56!'-#0"+-"+ 00 ("+-(&         !" +* "+ ") -+ ! $-'  '  "+'  7-(("0 %& '#( & & ,7  7 "  - " * 5- - #0 "8(+ 0 ##$5- * 0 7-(+ "+ ,"+*6, + "&  ;- - ## "- 0"->; <?1($                     " 6( " ;  ? 1 ($           

   

        "+ * (+; ?($      ##$"--$ *67*8+ )-+  7-( '8+ ,"- " 5- 7 5 (+-( (-,  9!#- " * "-( "&  !" (- 7) -+ #  ,6(-, 0

   7 " 0 #*8('-#0 #0+ !-+ 7-(( !+ 0 )*67($-0 )-+ 7-('8+ ,#- #*6, +##$ 7-(! $-' '  "+' * !-(+(-7( !+ 0 &  ,-"- 0"-? ($  ! "-(+ 7-(( !+ ,"-(+ "+ + "-"  * (0"- ("-(+-, * -,

#+05- - ## #,),0"8(7"  7-( ' ( #+05- - ## #,& $-' " *(+(-7 "8(0  # /#-+" *  7-( ' ( #+05- - ## #,/#-+" * &  ; ?  ! "-(+) * #-, 0-( * 0( !")(-5* 0# 0

) ,, * #-, ' -"( 5"- -( 7&

(-55-50,"-(( !-#0 7* 0("-* #-, #60-( !"&      ; ?($ '8 $ #* #-, +-(6$"'  !"+"( 5"---"+! (+"-0 ##$* #-, +-6$"-0' 

!"+"-0( 5"-"!+-"*6 0"-0>; ?1<& #-, 0 # !"+ +09( (50 ,  ,  ( - ("+ ( "+>; ?($ <&; ? ($ ! "-(+$ #--( +" ! 9!-(-( 5"-(--*6 (( *8 "-,

5 (> @< 7 $ (+""- -!+-"+ +0 5 ($  ( ,,88 > ( +-" & && A 

#<&  ; (+- * !-( 507 * 0(" -( +"- ",,  " "& ( +" (7 *8(' ,6"+,"-(- ( +-"  & && >; ?%($<&  ; ?($ ! "-(+( !+ +0 7 " ( #6$"" 0 ( !+ +0 7 " (+9( (50 ,"+( 5"- ! (0 ,"- ' ( #( 5"- (,- "+ "- "" ,"-#) ( 5" (- "+ +0 7-( -"+-('  

!"+ +0 ( !+ +0 7 "  * (#- "-"#0 9( (50 ,"+ *6, (0 7& ; (+- * !-( 507 * 0(" "-((--( +"-",,  " "&   !" # +""- +-$-,"-( !## #0 '8 $,"-0 +6-#0-0. 7-(+##"+")  "9##+##"+"-0) 5-#" # ,-++6-#00) (+  " ## +6-#00)"-( ,"+"-0) (+6-#0)! $-' +::+ +&     $(6*"- 0"- ?  ($  5  ! "-(+ # ! $-'  * 7 "+ +0 $(6* + ","-"+ -( +"- #60,"- ! $"& " ? 1 ($  ("-( $(6*) ,((- + ","-"+ ! $-'  # * 7 "+ +0) ,6"+ 7 !" "+' (+ *8('  $+(0-""- *6 0-("-(+ ! $ !(0 +0 " $ & " ? 

! "-(+ +"*( "'  !##  *-"+ ,"-( *6-+ "- ("- " ! $ *6 , * (0"- -"+ ,"- -$&  "+ * (+"? 1($"- 0"-"++(-#-* 9( (50 ," !"+"-+8+,"-9(-5--+ * * 0("-

( # ! $!## " #6+ * +- , "-+- $",, ) 0 ,++- " -,  ! $ -"+ ,"-(- '8 $#-*  9!- "   --"+ " 0 * ",, &  "+ * (+ " ? 1 ($  $(6* " " "6(+7 +"*( "' !## "+&#+0! $!## ),", 0"+ 7  #@1@-( +"-" "

@B 1 0@)" "-"+(8!+0-"+(-7+ "0  $(6* #),((#- (7*8(' ,6"+,"-(-

"+' (+&   "+ * (+"? ($  ## 7! $,-#-+("- (05 () -((- !' " +""+-!+& , 

5 $ !* ($  ! "-(+ 5 () -((- !' " +"" +-!+) !9*+ 7 +-"-(- 5 (-(- , !($ "

!+,-#-+("-+6+++-

#0* ' ( 0 !+*8("-0 (0&"? %($  ! "-(+-"+ 7 "'  ,-#-+(-#0 !" ,-#-+(" (0- ' +"- ,-#-+(" " ("+- * !-( !+ +""-" *6 ,-#-+("+ (65-+ * " ,88 "-"& -#-+(" (0 #+0 +"*( "' " ## 7  0, /#-+" *) -((- !' " +""+-!+&   !""-($+ 7)-+"? %($  ("-(*67,-#-+(" " (#-#60  "' ( !-#0 #0-",-"- "+,-

!+(+ ,-#-+(" (0- ! ("+

#0( ",88 ,"+ ( !-#0" "" (0* 

(0-

5 5 +" # ("- ' +"- ("-(  58-*  ' "() ( +-" (0- ' +"- !+  +-!+0 ( !-#0 '6"+,"-"+& 

    !+# @ ((  @ " #$