Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-7167/3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.7167.25120 AI generated

2-06-7167/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-7167/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

C,5(5"-'"&-01+ ;(&!!'-'#(#"(!"  (##*4"#"#*(## "   > ;,; ? + ; C +, --0- 2  (&!!'- --0- &0"# %& "!!*#* 0--0- &0"#&@-(#0--0-#55; (&!!'-45-*) 0%)'*82(&!!'- , %-""0'#9-'#"%-"5-"5-(15-) (%'*#(!" ,D-(!0E4( (!)#"#0"0"9-'#9#'("-;,"%-"5(1-()  (!" 0) ,+, ,, 15-"#* '#9-'#" '& ;; "#'0* '1#**4 (#- '#  - "%-* '#9-'#" "#'0-*(!)#"#-'1#"(!)",  !'(!" "(!&*#0""'#*5*"#"#- 01'0#"#5-(45-*"1'*0*)--"#* ,3, 4,,  ,, (-& *, !"  , ,  , D- !' *"#* 0--5' (-& -( ""9'( 01 "#5-( ,,,,5-(!" D(% 5-'%)"#80% "#"*"" '-'5-'*-)  (!" "%)" 01"#5-(3,,,, !" *-!("%)" () 01 "#'#*4-!(!" "%-"'#*!59-'# %&-*(!)#"#-, (&(#"(!&&"-5(!" """9'(#15-*'!"&-'#'*"%-"5-#5- (!((#99, !" *-!5-(-& *(#'-&&-'#*, F:3 %&-!'9-'9-'#9!!""%-"5-((!)#"#-(,F:(!)" "#8(!)#"#"%-"0"0"9-'#01-*#,F:3(!)""#8(!)#"# "%-""%)"9%045-!'(!)#"#"%-"5-"%)"9%0'(-'*(5%%&"#*,F: (!)" !"( 01#)"" "#'0 (!)#"# "%-"5" %"5-"  01- 5-"" '1#"(!)" "%-"5-"4)#"%-"5-0--0-"5-"(!)#"#&-((#5-(,F:94   (!)" !' 01#*  (!)#"- &-((#5- (!&& 1-# '1#* 01'-(#" (!)#"- "%-"5-"4A*9-'6 &)-(!)#"-"%-"5-0--0-"5-(!&&0--0-"'1#*, F : +2   %&-(!)#"#8 '#9-'#6(--('#'*  '*5"---(# '#   &)#55 01- '*"0   ' 4 '#   (!)#"#8 5 &)#55"-5(501-5--(- 5(!# 5(0-"*-""5, F:+2(!)""#8'#9-'#(!&&-'"&-5("(#-!'(!((#9-"#*, F: (!)"(!)#"#8(%'*#9-'#(%'* (!5'*--(#91)-01'-(  01#* 0"#"591)-01'-(#(!)#"#"%-"5-",F: ;(!)#"# &-((#5-(!&&0"#"0*91)-01'-( (%'* 01#* !-*&",

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-7167/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

         !"#    $%&'#(!)#   ''*&"        +, ##'-,, #&&          &.-''")-,, ,/,0"#01'1#*         

 &.-''"&-"&-(!!*#(!)" !)"# #&& 2+3 4(!" *,,--(#(!!*  ,/,         -& -(5'"#        !" #         $     %   &    # 



''()((((655'*(("#)"6)((655'*         ,7%"") 5'"#(##*(!" "('*, , !" " "#8 )60-"* "- 8&--- 5'"#(##*  5'"#*!(#5'"-* (%"""!-5"5-(##*,         !"  01-8 -"* " !"# 9 ( 4 (#- "5 "0#"#4 5- !- " !"# "5- #(4 !- "-'-"#* 51 #0" 91) #",   01-8 -"* 1"#5" 51 #0 91) # !5!#"4 (#- )- 0"5" %"5- 9#)# !- (!"  01- "5 -'*  "!-5""#* (%"" 5##0---(#---(-(#"(-& 0"#6'*5-,  01-8-"*" !"#(%"""!-5"5-"" 9%0 !!(#!"#"-'#*(!)"#, 1#**( !'%"""#*"-0--(!)"#5'"#: ,  %*+%,-.,+/

   -""#* )- 9#8 )  (!" "" !-*&" 0%  51-" 01'0# (!((# 2 (&!!'- (!)"#(##*,

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

  +  9#8 )  "!!*# # (!" "" 0%  51-" !-*&" )  (#( 01 (!((##552(((655'*(("#)"6)((655'* (&!!'-'-'0% 51-" (!" "") (#((!)"#(##*,    +%  !" *-!(!)"#0"'#*=",4+44++=,     !)#!"#"0#'#*"-0-- 5"& -*-84"(%!0 01-8" !"# )-&)#**,  :    %""84 " (!)# 01-8 )  "!"# 01- !5 "# )- " !"# &)#** )-0*# 5%&-"#*   !#* 1-#-(#" 91) '*"#* #"#4(#-(!" 4((!)#!'5%%&'#*0"5-"%)" 4-!"%)""0"'#*4 --(#-)-"!-5""-(!" (%""0%-&---01-(#-"!-5""-(%""0-(#", #)# !"() -""#*@("--*0%-"*(!" 9!!"!5(01"#(,

 01-8'-5""#*"!"#-"*()-0*#:  , !"# 01-8: 1-('-5""#* #)#")(!)"#-"#'-"9-*5": + ,  !" ,,-0% "(!)#)-0*# -"#*5"& -*, ,,,'-' (!)#""*)-0"5 9%0 !!(#)-"(%"""!-5"5-"", !" , /,0% "(!)#)-0*# -"#*5"& -*+,;,,,'-'(!)#""* )-0"5 9%0 !!(#)-"(%"""!-5"5-"", !" * !' 5'"#*!(#5'*-* (%"" '#* --(-(#" G ,, , ,,,  ,/, ,;,,,=",,24+=, !" *-!(!)"#"%)""0"'#*,7%&-(#""#8#* )  )- -""#* @("--* 0%-"* (!" "9!!" !5(01"#(,  !" " !' """#* )-0"5" %"5-" %&*", !)##8-#(!)4") !'1-#-(#"91) '*'#*!5)-0*#5%&-"#* '1#*5-" : #(###8)-" !"#&)#*5-, 

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

60-""0 #55 (-'*("5- 0*# -""(   5'"'#* -5 "5 (!)"#,0*#-"(5'"#(##*'-5(-&-'-'(##-*"1'*0**!(#5'*-*, $!"- -*(##*"1'*5-(9--80* (-''-"#"4"'*(##*!'('"#*4(#-* (!)#01-8'1#*''*"1'*5-"(5##0---, '"#(##* (-'*(5%%&5- 0*# "!-5"8 (!)# 0--0-"5" (!! 5'"#(##*'-5(-&  "1'*-"(%""0"9!! ''8"0%)5"-" 9%00*#(%"""!-5"5-""0"#0%-*"-"5-(,%)"-01-! 6)55'"#(##*(-'*(5%%&5-0*#-"5-"%)" ": , '"#(##* (-'*(5%%&5- 5%%&# "!-5""( 5'"#!-" (%""  :  ,   ,'*&" (!)"#'-(