Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-03-831/2 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.03.831.24561 AI generated

2-03-831/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Paide kohtumaja

Case Number 2-03-831/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-831/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Paide kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















          











 







   !





"# "! 

 

  





$%&"$''(&") !*

   



   

!"+,-.$- "*" 

      

 



/""  ) !

"))012&)2&

"+,/"" ) !

""")*)) 

+/"" )/

 



   "3!"/"" )

")0!""

!"   



$%&"$''(&



!""24")1/

#$% &'%( )



#



 

*

*4"! +  ,,52""! ! )   3)2""6

 

 ") !  "5  )6

 )"""4"2  &



! )2*4" &



 

-"

. 

!

+

"""22!)"

5!)*"""*"

2

'$$''78%9('

 "+!": 24" ": 2$$'$7%%.('(/2""*;

$9'''%$7(96 """4"2   ,  53 ) 2"" 3)6

  " 

"  

 /*0 53 )    %' 6

  5!)*"""*" 2

'$$''78.'''%

 "+!": /2""*;$.'''89(9(6*



)   ! ) 2;!"   *"  """) - :2



$

!4*"2&*"* ")" !*;*"

 &")/! " "*)!  ! ")"/

; ) !)"*") )&



1 )2 )";3 &  : ) 4";"  %8-' 5" ! ")

2"" 3)6 """" ))"""2!)"&



1 !" *" %&&$''-& *  $#$($<$''7 :2 "*" !

3!"* " !"*""&

$

   



 "   : :" ; ")&  24"; ")

: / "*2""")*42:4!&;

")   ! ") !* 8 :2    

"**"& "  ;  "*) 2"  2 *"

2) *" ) )))/ 24";  ")  2"  "**"

$.:2 &"4 :; ")*/*" "

 " !"" "**   * "  :4!"& *" ;

) ! 2 * *" ) )   " %- "*

4;/ ": ""&



24";:"):" ;& :" ;" 

""  !7':2  ! "**"&





. 

 * "*)" *& *  *))  "3!"  &

"3!" "* *)"&==) "+,&$9&'(&$'''&==)

") " *)  "- " 2"!*;" 

& "!* ;"  "* 7'&'(&$'''& !"   .#"& *  ") " 

!/*""/2*)") " =="/**"" 2""*""

" )/ !" " *==;  *" ==" :4) & ==" " !

*"2"&:==);"*"  "3!":&+!""/

==24";*33)&1!"" ; !!32")&3!";!

*)"/ ") !"* ) &  4;  -.$- "  ! )

!32"*"&



   

"



 + , " ") 4 * 2& ") 4 2"!*2

;"  *") :2  &  ! *"   $''' " 3 ))

3!"& "3!";)!32")*3!"!32")/""!

!)!32")&



 ")!4.-$- """*)" ) *)")&

"")))4&")) *"!4*!) "

*"/ ) )")&





7

"  *)""  : "3!"&! 

"3!"* *)""  :/")) *")""

!4"*" "3!"" )) "3!"!

!3!"3 ))&*)"" /*":*2")

 *2/ !"!)):2*"2)&"3!"

" !!4*"!))& ))3!"224* 

)$''' "/:")))2! &!"3!"24/"" )"

3!"  ! 24  & 42 " 2"& "3!" "" *  !

!)*  ")!)&*"4)2)) *)")/*"

!3!""/"2)4&



 ")/+,"")3*; + 3!"

) ! "" *)& "" ) " * & ! 2" 3!" ! "2

2") "*" ) *")2*&"")) 

3 )& !  ") :"*"" """/ * *"/ 3!" )

" "3!"/ ") *& !  !" :2 "*"

%&&$''-&/ ") ;"4""))& !3!)"24)&!

2)  !"" 2) *" ) )))&  !"" "

"*)&



"2"" !* )"  56 > 87   !/ " ! ;

!"" "** )  2  *"/ ; ! !

 ""*/!"!"2)*"))

4""  :4!))&  !   ! ") ? "") 2")  :

* 24 &  ")) ") !"" & ! !)

!;&



 

!"))")")/ :;!)*!"2)/*"4) 

"-.$- "& "") 4"  ) !/*" 

.-$- "& "3!"  ) $''' "/ *" 3 " " 2")& @  

2"!*2;"  33&")2;"   

) "3!" $''' " "" !  " !& "3!"  "

* : ;) 7$'' " * *"& ! ") ! 24) "3!"

;  42/  ) "  2") )&  2 "  " 4

")&"3!") $''' ";!3)

"))!& );  )& "*33"

:":#(&$*")/":#*33":"4*"*"")*"")

4)")!&4" 4))!2)3 "*" &!); 

4" ! !  -.$- 24" -$'' 24" .-$- "&  :; * * $'''

" "3!"&



*) ""  ") ";/  4) :; !)* &  "*33 " "

)&*" 24"!24)3&")!) ") !

  8  & "3!" 2" 7$'' "  ) * *)" )

!& " *"*") ) */22":!""$*/ ")

4")*"&1""!  !" "*&"3!" $''' "/"""!

"*"    *" & ;"    " !  !  " *&

1!  ) $''' " ) ! 24)  &  * *" 

! )&  *"  " "3!" ! ) ""/ "  "

*&*" ""!24)*" )&



8



 .  

")!)*" ! "2"" ) 56>88./*" !"$'''&

*" ! )" 2 ") ! ;!32"*" ! ")"" 

: " & " 4"  ! !  " 2;;  !32"*"/ "

4);/ ! ")*"*33;"&



")"3/! )2"!*2;"  !"!

"*)"  ) !" !32"& ")"3/3!",

"3!"3 ))$''' "! ""*)2"!*2 !

4& "3!" ""; !*"    ") ! 2 !

2424 "3!"&"3!"") "- ! "*"

2"!*2 ;"  4  2") ! !32"*"  *==) ) !

) *5-6&1!"" &;) !!32")&+,"4))/

! "*"""*)*33&



") ")! "3!"2!242: "3!"&"

4))/"24 "3!"&":""5'%6:$&&8

" !) "*)")* )/) "2-&

 ;"  $'''&&   2") *"/ ") "3!" "   2"

4)&"3!"4))24"*"*"*2"*"/*"")

 ! ")) 3 ")  *" " 3! 2 ")& 4* :

2)  * "3!" ))& ) ") " " 3  3*; 24

"*"!&":":(&$! "*33  ::")/

4"  "*)")* )!2)3 "*)"2) 

3)*" -&  ;" $'''&& *)  3 ") 22  :: !

") "3!"") ""*")!&-& ;"$'''&"

*24"*" :"")"*" :"")&3

*"  4" ") ! 4 :" : %& / " ;/  *33 2) 24"

"" :" :# $ " 2 4& + ,  "3!" 3 )) $''' "

2*;"$'''&/*"/ "!")* "*" &!;!)

") ""  ) *") *" "3!" ") " 2")/ 

"*)"2!") "3!"&;")/ "3!""

 ") 4":/ "   ") 2 $''' " ! 24 4

: ! "*)" 4::&  " *)" 3 )) -&  ;" $'''&&

2*;"$'''&")**" &"3!"") ! "")/

 *"   ) " ) 24)/ "" "3!" !  24"*

""2 !  ! 3)*"  !& * "    )

:4!"2")"*2 *"/ ! ! ")24"

*"&



2*"")) ! "*"! "2"!*2;" 4&

 ! 4:"     ") .-$- "   ") *)"*"

) *)")& ) ) ) *") "  *" 22  "

2 4& ! !"  4)) -.$- "/ *" ; )/ " 

:4)*)"&)" !2): ! "*" ) 562""

"" :/)!! "3!"")"")  "5'6

"")):2!:3)*&)!"2"))

"  "3!"&*2): !&)5989%6"

 3!") !  ")  *"   :/ 2") 2  4&



-

  " )  "3!"/  " " ==" &   ; 

==" 3!" , 24" * 4"&  "))  "" " *"

4)-.$- "/ ")) !)/ :4!))-.$-24"

-$'' 24".-$- "&  :""* ")4"**

!!)"!":" "3!":!)2&" 

!") !:==)*"$&"$''7&+,:""5.6-.$-

"&" "))/*"" !: *24"

*" "*) !*&4!)/!4))

:) 4"  !) )/ "  4" 242& )/  "* 4 " ""

"24"*"&



4)*""))/+,";2"!*2;"  " ! "*"

57$/(-/%$/.$6& ! ":4!" *2&

3!""2")) !4"#-.$- "57$/%$6&  

3!"2"))) "3!"$''' "59'6&4!"

:4!)) ;!)*"&  )+, !:))

* "  +5(96/""; !-.$- "2*4"

*&



 * *"  & " $''(& ; !"))  

"2*) )) /*""!) * )&

"" $''(& !") &  > ('   ! *4"; """4"2 !

2!  24)"!"!))">(8""""4"2/

*" " ! 2;)/ *4"; !  2 """) 24)" !"

!))&  " "2;)"""4"2*"&"""4"2 

; 7-' "&   ) !  """4"2   $'' "&  ;

2*4" """4"2/*"""")-' "!  

$'' "& "2"" **"  ! ") """2!)" 2 " '(&%'

"&"*)  "2;"2*" /*"";""")

4)&  " 2;) 4";" *"  9&'$&$''8& !*  $#

$($<$''7)24";"""" )& )2 )";3&:2))2 )"

4";"2)%8-' "&+, ! ); !*)

)&





"# "! 

!"