Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
2-05-21141/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.05.21141.19967 Kohtuotsus AI generated

2-05-21141/1 · 2-05-21141/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-21141/1
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Summary

AI generated

                                    !! " " " !#  $" % "!" !   &' (&  #))! *  ' %  "!"       + * * *!% , '" "- " !  * ! "%   !" ...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 2-05-21141/1

     

                              !! " " " !#  $" % "!" !   &' (&  #))! *  ' % 

"!"       + * * *!% , '" "- " !  * ! "%   !" "& , " !! !!  "% .+ % .*!  " %  *   &  &' !(&  * !     "  /  "012342!&45126(!&423!&42 !&7&% (4*! '""!""  %  "'""!""   " " "2842( !& "*8&&& 4288(42834242 (8(8842((!& "*&&(   .  / + * * *!% , '" "- " ! * ! "%   !" " & , ""! ! ! '  & ! 5!% ', +$! %   !  !" , -!"'' 8  !'     & ! ! " 7" !" *,- "  7"!!  "-"  !!  #  !" 8 7"*  % ! ! "" 7"!!  !" "'" '"4  '"!%"' *" '99 '"!

" * ! !"  * ""'"& "-*, "! "   % ! '""!"4

 "-"" !" "!!"! " ' !&    !!

     * ! "  "! "!   "%   &  %! "! 5    4  4  '   :- &  %  % " -   :4 ' "   "%   *! %   *,! ! ''   )" !  "'"!"% '!!")  !- "% !"% ""5      "  '  !"5;!"& "  &< "!5    < ! "% ) "!"+$!"4 " '))  " &(&&  % $!"&="  " ')) )!" "%  % !""!"!4" ')) "  "  %   : "!!"    " ')) &  ' " !" "  %     "  '))!"7& 0 *"" *,"4 "  : %    '  ' %  "!  4 !  "%  ,  :'))'   &% "  &   "% !"4"" * " : "" '    &  "%  ,!' 

!"77"  : '))   "    < '   & $ &3&3&&   "%  - "!"> ,"" 4""'  :" 4    7    %   "!" " * '7 %   -  "" 7   &  "%  ,  % ! ' *! " !,7" ' %   : * -  '4   %  "  " " 4 ', ?&3&&  "   "%  * ! " +" !"7 ">"  !" '""!" !  '" &    "%  " !"   7!" ' *    4 *   %   ""!"*  -"!

 "%  % % "% 7 ! % *,' !  "% ! :!"*  %  "  &  "% 7 !-""!   % ! "! ""* :,* '"!' *!!"  % " "*  " 0% ," "2!& !"!4 % * ! "*!% , %  ""!    !* ! "  '"4*!% ',  % ! :' *!!"  '"""  @ : " '")) 8  4""  7"* 4 %      : ! "3&3&&  8&& 

7"* 4&& ""& ' 7 !- "%  % !"'   *!% ',  !   !,*&   * ! "!"  !     '"   % ! " ," '" .  "  5     < &(&& &  !"'))!"740!% 00! ,"   )" !  ! '' '",!"   4 * ! +"!"&   "  4""  % 7 !-"!!""! " ! '   % 7,%"!4" "% "!"*  ! !" :- '  " 7!  '))!"7 ""'"4  " 5    <'  4"" 7 - "% !,!  !7 "" "*, ,"" " '"  "!!" '))!"7 !"!& ))  *  * ! &(&   !"!" '))!"7!" !   %  

!"7" !4 "  "  ')) "

  : & ))!"7 ""'"  !   !  %     " '   "     (6    " '  &  " '  " " 2   "! 

 " '    "  " ! 4 '!!"   )"   ',"!"   '  4 '!!" % " " !  !-& '  " !" "  "!)"  "  " ! !  "!"8& '  &"" 4 % !" -4"7 * % *  '))!"7 " !   A- !"&  "%  7 ""  "

  !!" 7  '))!"7 ,!''& B : ""    7," , "!%   " '   ' * "!"! !"!



!"77"!4 '!!" %     "  :-  5  %   + !""* ! % !4 "  :" '"!  5&% &+7 7  !"!" ! &C 4" *" 0!" !% 0!"0!  &+;7!4""""'  :' 

4*   :%-  5    < *   '   & %  !" -4 "  "%   - "'  , %   4    : - *""!  "% !"

!*  ""'" & " * "

!" 6&&(&  "   * * "" !" 

% 4 "

 '  "" !"!  5     < * "  " '  " " ! " %  " " % " !*  '   )!   * " ' " "'  "   

 ' "8&3&& %  "% " ! '  "!  &% !" -4 " :- !""'' ) !!"  "!!"'  " '!%!

!  "% !"&""!" !" -'   !7  "* !"""!" ! ) " "," !"!& "% "!""  '" ," " "!!"  4"""'!

  8 ,! ! !"! 7)   "" 4 "", 0% ," " # " " " 2  !""* !  "!   7)   " ' )  !!"  &  "% ! 7 - '  

!" '   :!"&  # !% "%   * ! ""  ,""% "4% " ""!'"!",""!" !  !"  *", " :' '"''  )* '" %!4 

" !  "% ," % "- " ! * ! "*!% , '" & %  " %  % !  '  % ! ! "   * * "" % " "  ,    4!" 4" "% !7 - "'",4   A'  !!"   4   "!%   '  " ""!% '""!  "% "

!& "!" %  " "% 7! :' '")* '","&% 7 !- %     ! '    *!%  ',   "% !  !  *  * !  ! " '"  % !"&  !!!!# !!$%!!$ ! # !!!!$!! !" -4" "!",! !7,%"  "  * ! "   % ! "!"   ," " !"-% "! " ! '  & 0%   ' *!% *,"" !"  *  '4" 45    < * 

 "    < "' " '     8&3&&   ' * ! " !"! "   &&& +4 "&(&&  !!  =7!,"  '))!"7 !&? 3 *,,      " '  $!"& 45    < * "7! ""'   " !" "! ' 4 '!!" )!"%   " " '  "   = 4 + D %  = &  "% +"!" "!"* ! % !" !"!  * "')"5    <"! ' * 

 " '  & = "  * ! - "! 5     < !  "! '!" -" 

)" ! & "% 7!"    '" " 0!% 00! ,"    % "&0% &)!" !,"  4" )" ! ! '' % "!!" "'"!" "   "%   *! ??8&   :-  & = "  " 4 "  :-  !"  7)      % !""!  !"!& "!" "% "   )"' ," ","" '"*'  4'," 4" "%  %   "" 5     < ' ) !" ,! ! !"! *, !"   !"  ""!" !%"'

!- =" """   & 0% ," " " " "2!&  "!' ," *,"!   7)   " *, "!!"   % "" 4 '  '   7)*  )" "4 % ," " 2(  "! ' )  !!"  &  ," *, "!   7)    '   "> ' !" " " %  "!!" !""* " ,  " !"! )!"  * ""*,"!!" "  ! "01# 28" 4&&" - ' )  !!"    7" !"  %   ' "  '  " *,-

 7 ""!" !   '&01# 2!&!""* !*,-" %  )!! "  '  '   " *,! ," "2  "   , " ,!  !"  "  !" )* '" 4   ' ," *, "!   "" " % ! "  *,! ," "2"  ,""!"& "",  !" -4 " 0% ," " # " " " 2 !&!""* !  5     < * !"' ) !",!  !" 7)   :-  "!!"' ) !!"    %  !*  "!!"  5     <  % ! *  "! ' "!%   " '   '  "4 && %    '  "& B :-  "  '" '- '  " * "! 

!"7     !"!0126"  *!& 5  , "" '"!! - "% !012 "3% 3"   % ! "4&& '  ," ," '" & ="!   % ! "   ,"  4 " %   

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

 * ! # &*"'- 8& "*! %  888# 84848(3 % 8&' (& "*! %  &8(#(44( &  !& *! '""!""  % "'""!""   " '"" "%   #   2 8  "! "" "!"*  " " %,' !   '""!" 7!

 ! " '""! ! " %  '"!" %  " "  ! ' '"!" " "  *! '""!""  " &""  !- &&(&  "  2 ( !  !"! 7!"!4 "!!" %   " "" 7!"  4 &&   "% ! % 

  *!% ','"!" * % !  %  7,%"    ! *  * ! %  7! "  

 ! " '"  % !" @ !"  , -!" ''  8 &  "%   !  % "' "   &      !!     

 ,".& !! E E