Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-9574/3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.9574.24394 AI generated

2-06-9574/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-9574/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-9574/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





          !"#

 $%&'# (!)#   &*" $+&        , ##'* ,, #&&           '-'( )* ,%)" ."# ./'.#  012 (&!!'* '/#+

          

  '-'(&*"&*(!!+ 2 #(!)" .* 12 *''

32 )  -*'#*' *'+  .!*(*&  # '.& /! 4-!"*+& (.% ( 2 $%&'# 1 32

(!" 4 3        5'"#    !"  # $% &     "'     '      &    !()*( 4'*"*" "#)" ()((655'+ '*3    +,  -&'& !#+.+!.    !/+!#(  0 +$%& "'    '       #()+#))1   '& & %    $23!!+ !% %%4,! (%!. )"( 27 -%.3, 

     ! 4% "'       #  '                %     

        &      '   5     5          5   &'& &   &&'&   5      %   '     &         

%         6     &        %        !( '%       

  &   %       37(!1

 

  "84 2592"4 :

0,,,, *"  '-'( (!)"# )* , ."# ./'.#  012 (&!!'* '/#+,

*.+# (!)" /5*"*  '-'( 4+-*+* ) 3  , 4+-*+*8 (!" 3 .) 1,1,,, ""'#" -*' 4+-*+* ""'#" -*'32 5* !* !"#+ (!"  &.+#(!'"! '&,  

01 4+-*+* &.+#(!'"!3  5* "!!+#+ "*'*5#" ./*5+ )  ") (!"  "!*5*'#*+ *'"&'"*-' )'9,'",

  .% " (!"  &.+#(!'"! (#"5*( . *(# (#" "#''#  -&!!*+2 5* :* "!*5#: (#"  *+'"*;*"&*5*'  ")*'#" "5*' *'"&'"* .)'+#, "'#" -*'# -#'("* 0,0 (!)" !"( "#&.5'"*+ (#"5*' ./&+( (*& *(# (*& , ,,,, ()"" )  (%((*&  '&,

 <0 .%*('# -*'#.!&5* (!! "*'*5#" 4+-*+* "*'*5#+3,

,,0,, ()"" )  (%((*&  '&,

 < 1 )'9,'"* (#+# /5*"#+ .%*('#-*'# )*''(*&  %&( *'"&*5%%&( 17 ",  ,,,, ()"" )  (%((*&  '&, ,< 0 "&:* (&++* ..*5%%&( #&!!- (-' -/)*&;*''"&*5*!-&"*!!'*+ (!)+". *'"&*5%%& = 7 ",

, ,,, /5**+ )   (!"  )'9,'"* .)'+# "*'*5#" (!!(/ !. (%'+#" .%*('# -*'# '&,  00 4+-*+* -*'3 #55  2 4*""*" "#)"3 "* (&!!'*2 *'"&*5%%& 17 " '*' ""5* /--"%)"  ,,,,   ('+* -*'# %& '##55 (!"  &.+#(!'"! , ,, , *'*5#" -#'("* , , (!)" -*+* '# ""5*' "!*5#5 *(#*" ''#*""5("'  (!"  (!)#"# "5 5(-%. *(#* ''#*""5( +:*"&*5*( -." &)*" .)'+*" !5!# &.+#(!'"!, (-%.( -*"* (!((# * (## , (##-%., " ,,, , "((**+ (!"  &(#+ -*'# %&" 5(" "#5* '*' (!"  "((* ./'.# "#5" -/)*! 5("  *'"&* '%!, 5"* "# (!"  -*'#" "#'." 5(" (""( ,

,,, 12 (&!!'*2 5* ./&& .%)'+"* '# -/)*! ./'.#", $%&" '*5""#+ #55 "#5*" * ! (!"  -*'# %&*+ 5(*+ &!)(5 "#'#+, '"&* "# (!"  .5"* ,,,, #' (!"  * "%*"'#+ -*'# %&*+ 5((!)#"#* '/#"(!)"2  6" )  !5 , ,,, (*&  -*'# ''"%)"" 6 -*'# -#'("*

,, # '*' )!*" ./ 5*"""#5* (!&& (!)"# ->>&+#+,

* *"5* -%. *# * ! (!"  -*'#" "#'." ./'.#" )  "#'#+, !"  -*'#" "#'. ./'.# )   5!!+#": (!((#  012 "* (&!!'*2 5*" -/)*! !'  002  "* (&!!'*2 *'"& 0 2 "* (&!!'*  ..*+ 002 "* (&!!'*, ? @ 1   (!)" !' -*' -*'#-!!" "%*"5*( (!)#"#*(, ?@  (!)" "#: (!)#"# "%*" ."." -*'# ./* +#, ? @*+ %"".+ *+.)'+* :* -*'#" /5*5* .*, ? @  %"": *+.)'+* :* "&:* (&++*-*'# /5*5*, ? @ 0 (!)" !' #:"#+ 5(.)'+* !5  (*'+( "5*' **(*(# "#''#(!!+* ./* 5## &' ./*5# #, "." ? @ !' (!)#"# &*((#5*' ./#)"" "#'. (!)#"# "%*"5" %"5*' ./* 5*""(!)' "%*"5*'2 )# "%*"5* ..*"5*', #' (!"  * ! "#'#+ (!((#-*"#+ #55*+ (!)" ," (!"  * ! "'#+ '/#"#+ #55+ !5!# !5 &.+#(!'"!2  * ! " "%*"'#+ (!)#"#* '/#"(!) .*, "." ? @* 

-#'("*+ 2    ./*: ./#+ 2 (#* ./'*( !' (!)#"#" &*((#'#+2 >+ -*'# 62 '/#+ (!)#"# "%*"5*"  &)* (!)#"# "%*"5* ..*"5* (!&& ( ..*",

 0

"." ? @ 1  ./*: ./#+  "* '/#+ (!)#"# "%*"5*"2 (#* ./'*( &*(#: &) 5(5* (!)#"#", ? @ 0%"":2 " &*((#5*' !' .:'+".2 (#* ./'*( &*((# (!)#"#" .%%&5"# /# "/""#, !"  * ! )  *"'#+ 6)"(* "/'+*" .%%&5"# /# *'5* (!)" -*'#" "#'." 5(" "#5" %"5*,  -! -*'# &*((#5*' .:'+". '*' (!"  ."#": (!)#"# &*((#5* ",  @ 0(!)" ./*: ..*'/#+ *"+ (!! -/)*'/#+ *"2 " * '/#" ..*" 5*"" (*'+ #55'2 .*+ -&!"'+*' -/)*'/#+" (#'* -/)*'/#+ "%*"5*'*, #' )  * ! "+  !#2 5* (!"  "#: (!# ./'.#2 * ! ./*5*( *"+ (!# ..* '/#"2  -/) # "!" )  ") (!)"# !"# ..*'/#+ ! (#'* -/)*'/#+ "%*"5*'* -&!"'+*',

  !' .% '+'#+ '/#!(#"   (*& *(# 5'"#, A#)#2 (#* *5'.+  @  /*(  '*5""#+  !#+2 "!": )    )'++ " !"# '' *"#'*",

*.+# "!!+#+  !#*+ "/'+: )  )*.+# *"#+ (*& *( 5"& *+, %)"#+ "!!+#" -#: ) 8

3 .%  5/*" (!"  , " * '-'( (#( -*'#" "#'. -/)*./'.# #55  012 4'*"*" "#)" (!5+ ()((655'+ *" (!5 6)((655'+ '*3 "* (&!!'*B 3 .%  5/*" (!"  , "  '-'( (#( ..* " ,0,,, (#'* -/)*'/#+ "%*"5*'* ? @

0 %"""#+ 5%%& 4 $ *'"&=72 )"( 5%%& 27 -%.3B 03 (/*( 5'"#(##+ 4) )  -!!" "#"#+ &*/*. 2 "* (&!!'*3 %"" (!"  , ('+,

 4 " !"  * ! (!)"# "%)"" ."'#+ <",, 002 0<,

 " " !)# ! "#".#'#+ "*.  5"& *+ *:2 " (%!.   ./*: " !"# )* &)#++,

 @  %"":2 " (!)# ./*: )  "!"# ./* !5 "# )* "  !"# &)#++ )*.+# 5%&*"#+   !#+ /*#*(#" -/) '+"#+ #"#2 (#* (!" 2 ( (!)# !' 5%%&'#+ ."5* "%)" 2 * ! "%)"" ."'#+2 ** (#* )* "!*5""* (!"  (%"" .%*&* ./* (#*  "!*5""* (%"" .*(#",  #)# !"( )  *""#+ ;("**+ .%*"+ (!"  -!!" !5(./"#(,   ./*: '*5""#+ "!"# *"+ ( )*.+# 4 @   3,  !"# ./*:  @  /*( '*5""#+ #)# ") (!)"#*"#'*" -*+5" 4 @   03,

!)# .% " (!"  )*.+#   *"#+ 5"& *+ ,,,,2 (!)#"+ (!" " )* (*& *(#" ."5 )* 5" ,,,, <", 00<, !"  !' 5'"# +!(#5'+*+ -!"*#"# -!!" (%"" "!*5""#+ **(*(#" ,, <",, 0<, !"  * ! (!)"# "%)"" ."'#+, A%&*(#" "#: #+ )  )* *""#+ ;("**+ .%*"+ (!"  -!!" !5(./"#(, !"  !' """#+ )* ."5" %"5* " %&+",  @ 0 %"":2 " ..*'/#+ ./*: (!! -/)*'/#+ *"+ )* *"2 " "!""( ..*2 5* * ! )* *"5*  ( . *'/#".( 5##"#'#+2 .% 5/*"5*" (!)"#" 5*"" (*'+ #55'2 .*+ "%**(#" ./* !*" -&!"'+*' -/)*'/#+" (#'* -/)*'/#+ "%*"5*'*,

 

!)# #: *#(!)2 " )  !' /*#*(#" -/) '+'#+ !5 )*.+# 5%&*"#+ '/#+5*"   @  # (###: )* " !"# &)#+5*, #' )  !' *"'#+ "!"# ..* .% 5/*"5*(  @ 0 (!)"2  * - (!)# -/) '+"#( (!" " (%!. (!)"#!"# (*'+ #55 ..* 400, (&!!'*3 .% 5/*"5*", "!!+#" "#'." .%)': )* '/#"#+ #55 '*5""#+ ..* #55 ./&&  (!" " (###: .% 5/*"5* )  (#( ./'.# -/)*! ,!  002  (&!!'* '*' *'"& 0 2 (&!!'*, .* 5/*": (!)# )  '/#+ .%  5*"" (*'+ #55'2 .*+ "%**(#" -&!"'+*' -/)*'/#+" (#'* -/)*'/#+ "%*"5*'* ? @

0 %"""#+ 5%%& 4,! (%!. )"( 27 -%.3, "." "* $' "" 5"*( +''" !* #&!!- (-' -/)*&;*''"&*5*!-&"*!!'*+ (!)+". .5' *'"&*5%%& ''  , '#&* ,, 27 <", 01<,

 @  2    (!)" )*5'"# (##+ ('': -!!2 ( () #( !"# ")"*,

$!!2 ( () #( !"# ")"*2 )6.*": "* -!! 5## )# (!)"#5'"# "/""# "((*'#+ . *(#+ (!)"#.%*+ (##+, !)"#.%*+ (##+2 5* )6.*""( "#''*" 2 ( &."#+ )6.*"* 5" %%'#+ ">>"# ./* 5## -6*. *"#(# "2 )6.*""( -!! 5+ #"  5 #"#2 '# )6.*""( "#''*" (##+, !)# ./*: %"" (##+ "%**(#" ./* !*" -!!" '+* ('+2 (#* ."-!! (##+ .% 5/*"5*' -!!"2 ( () #( !"# ")"*2 !( "5 #)" %%&5*" :/*' ./* :5/*"*(,

"."  @ 0  0 *":   5'"'#+ (!)# 5'"#(##+ !"# 5'"# !*" .) (!)"#!"# ./* 5'"#" /-". 5%%&#,   %&5*' 5'". (!)"# )'+* *""( (!# '* ('"#+ 5'"#(##+ !"#, '"#(##+ !"# '%: (!)# ""2 5**+ 5'"#(##+ (* 5'"#!*"" -: ('+5,  +# (!&& 5%%&: (!)# (*'+( 5'"#(##+ -&!-!&"*!' !"# 5'"#!*" .),

"!!+# "#*'+ #: 5(!)# *#(!)2 " (!"  -: ('+5 )  5'"#(##+  "#5 &* 5'"#+!(#5'"*+ (%"""!*5"5* (##+,

 @  0 %&* ./*: 5'"#!*' '/#+   )'+'#+ *5 "5 (!)"#" 5'"#(##+ &)*" (*'+(5%%&5*" )'+* *+#. (##+ -&!-!&"*!' !"# # 0 -%. !!(#2 " (##+ !"# (!)" ")"#+ )'+* /#"#5*", 6.*"". #55 (*'+("5* .+# *""(   5'"'#+ *5 "5 (!)"#, .+# *"( 5'"#(##+ '*5(*&* '*' (##*+ "/'+.+ +!(#5'+*+, $!"*  *+(##+ "/'+5*( -: .+  (*''*"#"2 " '+ (##+ !' ('"#+2 (#*+ (!)# ./*: '/#+ ''+ "/'+5*" ( 5## .*,

&*" $+& (!)"#'*(