Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-6965/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.6965.22766 AI generated

2-06-6965/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-06-6965/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtumäärus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-6965/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

                    !"#""$$! 

          %&&&&! ''!$"!&!() ! *$*"+  

    

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

  

&& 2"8 && 2"8 && 2"8 && 2"8 &&6 2"8 &&6 2"8 &%&6 2"8 & &6 2"8 &&6 2"8 &&6 2"8 &6&6 %2%"8 0 6%2%"8 

&  !)! 7( *-9")- *+ ( *+!!*- *$!:"+99,* !"#*$+ #*$* (7*6% 5;+*- & (" *$(-"7 !) *$-"! * !"("(7" < % 666= & !(!#+!"*+#+!$+7 !)8 & .$*+!!$*#+!$!* $*#-(.(" """!(" !)!+! "#""$ ) (**!$ * $/.*!(" !# !#$!! "#""$!(**!$ * *+ !"4 %$-$*)8 6& .$*+""!#+2*!!*+$"+2*!!$**#$!! "#""$!(**!$ * *+ !"4 % !*" -*)* !".>>++! *-"- ( !)# !#"+$ *  ($$ *$ ( -"* *(*'$*8 5& * $*#$*..*"(" *$-*)$/"- # !#$!!"!*(**!$ * *+ !" 4$-.$*.>>!-(/* !)# !!"!(" *$*& :/.*!+(**!$ ,-" # !&%" (" * &         3!!(**!$ $+ !)+& 1$) (/" !  ?$! ,* !" 17""-"    ""-"!$+* * !$ @  ) $7"#!(" * $+ ((  &" *$"'((*+#"" ") '((*+ *!" 2+*  !)$*!!) ) $7"#!(" * $+* #7!!$"  ! (" *  ""-"!$+* * + ("" !"(" !  % 56,A,* !"B" .- 2#""!*(7*5  .*##!* !$*+" )/ !(" * !& - !+:"+99,* !""$* C6% 56;+*- .*$*( *)/ !(" !.$ -*) .$! (**!$ *  ! !+ ""-"$/"# ! && ((  & ' +  '((*+ #""  "&   !""-"$/"#!- !(" !.+!#   !"!(" * !!* (!."+(" *  *$* $*#"22! .*#) $* $*#( *)/ !(" * !&           *.*$*#/"7(.(" """!(" !)(**!$ *$/.*!(" !.+!#   * "!+% .*# ) $ *$$* !!* (" * ! ( *7 * $$" "-!$*  ! +& (.(" " ""!(" * ) (**!$ * $/.*!(" * ! !*!+ $*+" *+ "*7(" *$

  %

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

 



 4$-&.& *$!!- !! *.$(**!$ * ! !+""-"$/"# !2".$*+ /$("#+ (.(" "&-*)! +&%&&&-"$!""-"$/"# (( &"2("$$* !.$ ((  & " !$*7 -*)$* !- !+&  /$    4  $-& !*"7 -*)$ /+*/"- * $*#( *-(!+""-"$/"# !- !(" *$*$!* ( *)/ !(" * !2 ("$$* !!$**#$!$7( ""-"$/"#!- !(" *  !"!(" *$*. ! *$$*)/ !(" !& !"C$$""C

 DE,   #""$$!  !"