Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-13850/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.05.13850.23100 AI generated

2-05-13850/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-13850/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

B -    B -   6  # (!" " 0% *3+"*+ )+04#" "#"#4 &+++3+0

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-13850/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval: B -    B -   6  # (!" " 0% *3+"*+ )+04#" "#"#4 &+++3+0

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





 













      



 !"#







$%&'#(!)#

$%&'# !)"#* 





!)"#'+(++&"#

 

  

, ##'+-,,.$%&'#









 











/("+01+''")+,,0"#2(&!!'+'3#4

  

   





 / ("+0 1+''". . #(, 53 "' .  +''.

+'4 ,,



,,."+(##(!)(!)"'4*46##4#04.

*'"#4!(#*'"(%""'"#40++7+*+(!)$8))+"&+(++'+(#.

%%"'.$%&'#,





  



   

 !"



)#44)+,



% *3+",,2,(&!!'+ 0++"#)"((4

'+(8'48((&!!'+

 /("+01+''"(#(,



#''+"4" !"#""+"0++0+"*""%+4"0(,

   

,

5%"" /("+01+''"*'"#(##4,,('4,



% *3+",,*'"#(##-,(&!!'+ /("+01+''"

(#(,







 



 

 

!" 03+7+"4" !"#6( *'"#

""*+($%&'#(!)"#26%0 !!(#"

" !"#(%"""!+*"*+",  "#7+4(3+( 

""0*+"*+36#0++*+(0 +(,



 03+76"+!!'(7#+"46%0 !!(#."

!"#6'4+(%"""!+*"*+".(#+4*+"")+ *(#+0++

(##*994#*++*"*(!)"#!"#0+(#"

""0("*+",6"+!!'(7#"#7+"4+''

+'(!''(!)"#, 7#03+4()'44(+& +(#

*'"#.(#+(7#+"!"")'4*+"+"#'+,











  !

+ !7+++4"'#4  4+!+'   3+# %&'

. 46+4+ '+*""#4 :+:.

3*+

(!" 

++"#*+6+'# 4

.

*+

#

(!)#"#"+

6((#*

(!" 

*!7++";!'++4+4

"'#+4

'+'

(!" 

(!)#"#

4#4

(#64 *!7++";!'

<"'#" " 3+"  &#&" "#* 0"0" +""#4

&0",





6+'#

'+*"#

&,

##6%0

++"#*+6+'

=, ,,===





("%)".&04#(!'"!'#*7& *##0 +(+';!&*"+!!'*(!!&+"*+(!+

(+& ) 6!!"&#&"+""#4&0",

 !'+"'#4%&(+& 4(!" 4"#4

&0""#-,(&!!'+,



+""#4&0"#"#!'(!" (#"'#4+6!!"6(#"#4(#6#<"'#+4''4"

"#*"'+'&+((#'#4+(%+"#*+6!!"0)3*+"#46+'# "

"+'+*#+,



*(+& 46+'# "

(+''+"+46!!4."(!)#"#04"%+"*6+'# "



)#"*"#(+(!0#&!";!'-(#"*+(+& # 46+4+'+*""#4

(+& 4

, !" (!)#"#4!'!""#4(+& 46"8(+,



"0"6+'# "

!'(!" (!)#""#4*(*+0++0+"*+(!&&"#*0++0+"

.>*(*+(###0"#"+*(*+0++0+""#46%0".(#+4*+""

0%)*(#+-(&!!'+,





,3#4!!0#"*+') 



!"  + &&+'#4 + !7+++4"'#4  '3#4 "#4 6+'#" "#'0

03'0# '+' + !7+++4"'#4  !!0#" '3#4 (!! (3&0'3#" 0++0+



(!" 0"#) ,*#"+0% ""+(!" 3#4!!0#"*+4,,,,



+ !!0#" )  '3#4 (!"  0"# # -. (&!!'+. *+ +'4#04

0++0+4,





 

  '3#4+ (!" " ##+"  (+& +(#" 6+'#" "#'0 '3#4 "#*+". (#+4 (#'+

(%!0 )"('+ + ! 03'+( (!)#"+" "%+"'#4  '3#" &)#4'#4 3""+

,,,,

,







,

 '3#4##&#



!" 03'7) 6+'#""#'0" %&'04#4?





63)+03'0#-.(&!!'+



0++0+4#2=.(&!!'+ &0""#4) '3#4!!0#"*+)"(+#

,



"0" 6+'# (!((#6+"#4 0++0+ ##&# !' 0++0+&0"# %&*+'? 03

63)+# %%(@0++0+""#46%04&0@.>?









3'0#

++0+"#6&+!!4 6%0

++0+

-.(&!!'+

,,===,,

--A.(&!!'+



 !'&0"'#40++0++4"(!" +""#40++*&0"%)" ",,===,,



#"4)##.0%)'47) 0++0+'3#"63)+03#'+'+''3#7(!" "

0++0+""#*+"#-.(&!!'+,







 '3#4*"&+3+#+(#





33+#4#. "+0++4#"+(# 84! 4#  &)0#0)+ &3+# 4#

&('4*+ 4# B    (!)" (!)4"( '' , ##+"  3*+"#4

("0#6+'#"

"

,

##+"



"+0++4#"+(#

84!

4#



033+#4# %"""#" '+' * 6&&)0+   (!)" ("0#6+'# !"#4

 !#403+"!+*+'#".*+!'"((+'#403+")"#4'', ##+",.(!)4"(

'+()"+'#44#",



+0++(!!4(+ B A   (!)" "#7 (!)#"+4 "%+" '3#"(!) 0+++ 

(+'4(*%%&"#4 "%)" ( 0"0" 6+'# %"". *#"+ + ! +0++(!!4(+ B A2

(!)"#7"#48)6!!'(4#*+'(!)#"+"%+"*+", !" "0#"#03'0#"

"%)"(+(0+4&+*+(!'!""4# 6+'#0"#!#,

!"  (%+"#*+' 6+'#"" "#'0 03'0# *+"""#*+ !' 3+#0"'. !

0"#!#"+0++(!!4(+'+'88+'.(#'(!" !'"4+(4#4"'#""#*+

(!)#"#". (#+4 ")"+(#" !' %"'#4 (!)#"# "%+"*", +*""#4 "#*+ (!)#"# !+

;+(&+"#4 6+'#. *+ 8( (*6& '"+ (!" . (+& 4 '+' *#"+ (!" 

0% ""#4&0",3'"06&+!!4+!''3#"#4(!)#"#"%+"*+"(!" "(&+'0"

+'(!;+&*40)'4#.(#+4"#*#",

+( "!!4# !' (!" " 03'0#" +(0+4&+*+ (#"#"#4 + 6!!" (!" 

+""#43#4!!0#"*+"'+') 6!!"(!" +""#43""+,



#'(!" +!(%!0)"('+(!&&(""!*(!)#"#+"%+"'#4.!') #''+"#4

0++*0)'4+'!*3+#"(+"(699&4#*(!)"#6!!,







2 

"0" +0++(!!4(+ B  ,  0"#"7 6+'# %&+4 (!)#"#+ '3#"(!)"

*+"""%+"'#4 03'+( (&4+"!&+ "(+""#4 () # ", * 6&&)0+ "+ 3+( (!)"

*3+""(() #4*##)#((&4+"!&+6!!"")"#4(##"#+,





+0++(!!4(+ B = ,. B =     %""04 (&4+"!&+ 3+# '3#4 03'+(#

6!!"(!)#"+"%+"*+0++0+"*+)80+"*+(0++0+",



%)"#48"!!4#"  #)+'4#4+0++(!!4(+BBA,CA2C=C=CC

'+'+0++(!)"#*'"#4#"+(#BB2 -) 6#7



, 3+"(!" ",, /("+01+''"(#(0% 03'0#-.(&!!'+ 

0++0+4-.(&!!'+C



,3+"(!" ",, /("+01+''"(#(0%  /("+01+''"6!!""#"#4

(!)"#(##4.)#&+++3+0#2.(&!!'+'+' /("+01+''"6!!"

+'4  *("#4 "# 3+#7+ " -. (&!!'+ (!)"#(##4 '+*(+&+ 

(##4!(#*'4+4+"#4

,



 !" !')+04# +4%&(+& 4++(+(#"(%""'"#4,,-,,

!" +!(!)"#"%)""26%0 !!(#0"'#4, !" "!')!+""#4."(!)"#

"%)""*+""0"*+03+7(!)#)+" !"#&)#44, !)#!7B

2A#) +""#4;("++40%+"4(!" 6!!"!*(03"#(, !)#&)#47

)+" !"#)+04#*%&+"#4  !#43+#+(#"63) '4"#4#"#

"+0++(!)"#*'"#4#"+(# 

B2A#,

   !



  6#7 *3+" (!" " 0%  / ("+0 1+''" 6!!" "#"#4 (!)"#(##4.

)#&+++3+0#2,(&!!'+'+' /("+01+''"6!!"+'4 *("#4

"#3+#7+"-,(&!!'+ (!)"#(##4'+*(+&+ (##4!(#*'4+4+"#4

,

+0++(!)"#*'"# 4#"+(#  "%+"*'"# 4#"+(# &('4*+ 4#

 (

B(!)"''(%!04# 3#"#*+"#""#4*'"#

6#)#(!)4"(*'"#(##4 !"*+ ''4(+'4(*%%&*+'+()"+'#4

"+0++(!)"#*'"#4#"+(#%"""#",(###7(#'+,,,,()"+'#4

B -    B -   6  # (!" " 0% *3+"*+ )+04#" "#"#4 &+++3+0

#2,(&!!'+ (##3+#7+"-,(&!!'+,









++&"#

!)"#'+(