Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-21711/10 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:2.05.21711.21020 AI generated

2-05-21711/10 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-05-21711/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

             

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-21711/10 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas:              

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

                !"#$ %""&'()#*&'( '!$  

   $+ ,+$!-!!./$+0!0+ ,1  

    ""(,  '/          # 2 

 ./)  &)/1*/#"" #2 ""./34,, % 5%,$ 637 8(/&'()/1*/#(//(&9:(   

    $4")$ %""    !"//" $" :#)' ""4  .)7))/1/(#  "  / # / /) ( ! $ 44 %; %    <8   #') #:(    $,"8:( %    )" & :(  " " (:#)'/ )/ :)//)5 "  4" :#)' ""'(! , .7(7))/1/"

'( / /)) (   ! $$ 40-;% !!    <8  (' $$! $4--5% % 8 .() $; -$%;;1   #') #:( $,"8:(!, )"  0" :# )' " "  '  %%% ./ 7))/ 1  $,  /"

'/ /))(! $$ 405 !- <8 .()$5 0;5-01#')#:($,"8:( ! )*#())#::%%*$,"  ," ""/'!%%%*$,#: /" 

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

4.%1  !# !     4"&'( ," 0"$ $"".$51 ""77//?! -! #:*) %"!$"$ !""7( " "

((7())/.(('/!,"!$"!;;5"" #'/ !" !"$ !""1  ?+ $  !  8 $ # ?+ 4  "    (:( #:#  ' /  7(*   ?+ ,  ! 8 ! (  ==(')(#7()" &) 0" -"$ $""-.-+51 " "(:( 8'#/#==(')')#::/))( 7(/ 7/ )) !!-  " &7( ==(') ' ) #::/  ) )/   / 7(/  !!" 4"$ $""  4!" 4"$ $""5!$* !" 0"$ $""))!!!0"#(:  !" $"$ 0"")/7(!,-4* !" 4"$ 0""!% $ # !" 0"$ 0""!,$0"==(')/#8/.  ,-+%41 '/(/ #  #    ) (// /*  " " ) () ==(') ( # (:# 8'#/ # '"   &) %" !"$ %"'/.$ 1##(//)/* #()  $!" %"$ $""  !$" ,"$ ,""  " " 7( (:# )/ ,   "  ()/  (  7(  )) / ? $,  !  :( # ( ( / . ( ('/ !-"!$"$ 4""* #'/ !" $"$ 0""1?4!!:8:)//7()) 7(#''/#7()/#(( 7()/))7"  0" ::#/#):(//*#8 (  7(  )) / # ( / :  7/ /) )/ //"  #   # / " )  '( / #"  # 7() 7/ /  #  /2:(#(''/# !" -"$ $""(/"B 7#/##'):#* B :( # /)  " B  ?+  $$  !  :/*  (''/ # '( )  : / #*  #8'#/('7/)8/)('/8:!"#$ $" #  # /   :( ) 8/ %"!$"$ !""* (/#/)(/:/"  ,"?+005!:/*'(#/8 #7()*#)77/('(#)(( /" # ) (   /  #:) #/ 7)3#/'(:)#77*# )8'###'(:)#/ #("'/*#(:()8)77/" #   (/ *   #:#   " " ==(') ( #* ) 7(  ,    "  ? 0%   :*  *   7(/   8 / #*  '/' .1   ( (:#)/7(*/:/"( 7())/?$,!(/?4!!:#

0.%1 '/'7((:#)/))":(#(/ '#)(//*#7( 8'#/(:#)/*#'#,  (:#)')'/"  %"((:/?0%$$/)*)   ('  / # 7()  (://* '( ) (" &)   !" 0"$ ,"":(.$%1 "5  A+ ==(')" &)&'($-"!$"$ ,""'/. $41:( /8!-!0"# ""'/)7)/)//., 1*8/ ") ):)(:: (" :#('/  "" / . +/ $0+$,1 :*  "" $ ,"" # (     (* $%" ,"$ ,""  ) /(88))(#'" (/#(/ #  8 * 8:( ) (#/*  ('  / *  # (  /  7 "  #  7  ==(')* / ( /(/(:':*('/==/"8 #)==(')8"  ? 0%$  $ )'   (' 7(( #  (://*  #)(')(')7()/# :  ('  # :  7()  #  # ) 8 )/ (/ ::)  )#/ /" (/ # '/  # # ( /*  )*  #   : ) (') # :  7()"  # 7() ) 8  # ::)  /*   (' (:/  )8" '8(')?0%$$(://#/ #7()(:#)'())#)'#(:#4  "  -"#/(')(:#)'())/"?00,! ('8/):::)(#(' :8:(" :( # ( +   /* ) #/ (' :)#/"7/()/?+$0 !*) ('#/):)8//('#/8 (/#)/#/(":(#(:) / ? 0,  ('  (' (/  ) :) #/*  ) #:)  ('  '" #  (/ '/#(/#)/#/*)('8/#)#/ /"  (  (')   ?+ 0, :/ /   //   ?  00,  !  :/  )"   8  (/*#)#//")/// 8==(')88/(/#8/):)(::(*(:':* :)8=='#8"#/# )==*   )/ '/) (')/ ) 8/(/"    8 8/) (')/   ) 8/* ) /8/  :)   " ' 8   ):: #    :) " #   8 ):: )  $  "  (#(')/)"#8!-!0"

 8/ / ? 0-  4  :) /  :)(/('8//, 88* /8::#(:), 8(8)::" 

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

'((+0-$'(")# / '(/$//)::/,   8)'($! ":(#'( 8 !-,  "  8 (') // # /) )::* / ) ( '(   !-,  "   /  %  A *  # '( (:# )'  ! ,   .!-,  E *%1"   # )(//'()*8):: '()!, )"  &   )  # /  ' " ( 

$;" 4"$ %"")::.0;1#/7()'  # /   ,  A  ('/ )   #')" (   $%" ,"$ %"" ):: .  %-1   ' /#$44$*, " (//)#:/?%!!8!#$ '! .$  E * ,1#:/" B?$-!8! (7#::/'8#7()#/

 $;" 4"$ %"" ):: )::/  # "   !  A+ 7()   #  '  7(/  !44$*,  

%.%1 *  ,  A+ 7() (  #  '  (:#)'%%%*$,"<#::/'%%%*$,#::) /"#8)::)! " #8)'(#/#*8!  )8'#/"   8(// /) / // /) :(  8/(:#)):#87/,"8:(#8 /$ "8:(*8 "")):#):: $,"8:("