Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-682/10 ECLI:EE:VRK:2006:2.05.682.19594 AI generated

2-05-682/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-682/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtumäärus

Legislator summary

AI generated

            

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-682/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:             

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

            

 

       !""#$   

    

  % #% & '  ' ('' &')*++      *") " && ',' -)&'"       

 % #%'-). /&&',"   

 )''  ! "#

  $%#  &$$'##    

   &($)('*&         # &#  +     ,        +       # -# .,        #  %#% 0 1#% 232 0 24  "#% )  5"-'',' " - %-' #'  , ) ''-) '-')&'(&)"%-'#' (&- $- ('

''6 '''& %3124 7'-(- ' $-8 ) ' -'

&53 /',% )"  &#5"& " ' % ) 4- ' ',' & '

95" '',"'(''/'(:-&'''' ' %-' #'  ' 7&') *++8 ) :- & $$-''&-''-'$-')'' &53 " ',' '  & '  5") " '$-) 2'

(  -' ) 3  0 9!" 9;" ')' ' ' ' &'''/ '''/'5")"&&'- $ & -/  - '- $ %-' #'  ' 7$- ) '8''&-''-'/-'-' '" ','')'-/'&'' '/'&'-'-(- -' '''/ ' '$-' $, (<<  $ '   $-' ) ')' ''&-''-'(--&'-'--"  -#&  9"( " ' ', ' -" ' '  &''' - '$-) 5") "  -' ) 3  0 )$- 9!" 9;" ' '/ ' $' %-' #'  &) !;*5 /"'$-)$$-$-'-(--  '"& &/''''')'- =599&''$-'(<<'(--

 78   '/''(-- ::(-(-)'- $ (-(-)$' &'(--$-''" &'-'- ,' (-- & $'--/  -/ ' $   , &' &'-'- &'/  ' - ' (-- &&''''''-/' $%-'#' -"  /#'$-) > ' 4 ' 7% 2' ( +(+ $)&'8   9"(" '&/'% )''''-$'-'-/$'- $-/'&--'$" '$-) $/ '&''' -&,3 0)$-9!"9;" ' '  ' (- &'/ ' &)$'-  $'  (<< - (-- '/   &-'- ' /  (- '$-' (<< (-- '/      &" ',' ') &'-/ ' & -  ($)'-  -  :-$'- ) $'-" $$-'''-'' '&&-'-''"  )#  '-/ ' ', ' ' ($)'--" *") 9"   '( 7% 2' ( $'''8 ) %-' #'  ' $- ''( ' !  ' &) ") 9" 7" " !8" 0''( &' ' $ ( ) ') ' 9!") 9" (-'(/''')('''))3 %>.' 7""58" ''-)&' (&$' ' 7""98  $'--/ ' % )  5"-'', " - %-' #'  ''-)&' (&)/ (&-   -$-)'% ) $(&-  "3 09!" 9;"')'$'%-'#' %2' ( &)!;*5 7"";;8" &&' ' ' '  ',' '-' ' $ - 3  0''/'''95",'!" )5")&&'7""959;/;8/'3 09!"9;"&& :-'-' '" ','')',$'$'--3 09!"9;"')) (-$'$'"(--): $/'' -%)$'-' =;/*'''-(-'('''(/'''  () ) $  ''  ()  (-- )/ -  " 2,$'   ',' ') &-'/ ' &''' ' $- - - $ '"  &' '' ?''' $'''   &'-'/   - '' ) '$-)  -' '  &''''/  (-, $ -&'-'-$(&"  )#"#  '-/ ' &'''' ' $ ' ' -   9") " '-  &'' '   '   &''/ '' %-' #'  '' '''- '' ) $-' ''&' '-' ' ' '-' '"$ ' $$-(''-''' '''-' -' ::"'  $$-''--'&'''&'' ,$-'"  ' ' ',' ') $'--/ ' $ ' $$-''--' '-' ' ',' ') ) ($)'-  /  '-/ ' ' - '-('-'/'- )'&'" 

 78 ! !

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

''' ''   &&',' ''" ',' ' ' '- % )/ -'-'-. " % )  ,  99"& " 7"95;8 ) '  . B '- &&'," .'')/'% )).  '(-,)'("  =9 )&'(''-)'-$$'-, "7"9!8' '-"''. % )'(''-)"  "&#!"&""&&'% )&&', )&&-&/. '   =9&'-$-''/('- ' ',' '-  ' ' ($-  '-$' '"  7"9558-% )'(-'$ -'&);"&"" "& "" 7"95;8 % ) ' )/ ' '',/ ' .   ' ' ) '-- '- $-' )-' ' 9"   '  '('/''-, )''()&'"

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