Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-06-83/1 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2006:3.06.83.18593 AI generated

3-06-83/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-06-83/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                                

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-83/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                                 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                

                !   "   #

!    $        %  &          $             !      '  !  ( )   #

!  *!   +   ,    #  - (  . !     "   ,        

  

-     "    %      #

!   $          *.,/  ("+         &(   " !   !    !     !  (  

  -(           "

 0 1  !     !  (   " !      2"

 0     0          %  " !    !    !  (  ( ! " !  !     ! "#! $%"&'  3## .    $ 44$  (  5$  )    *    " " +  6&( 0  *  + 



  #

!  444$   (   &( 0   $)       $ 4"  *  +  7    !   0  #

!   & )

0) !

!   444$   (    &( 0  "   $)     )   $)  * 4+ 

     & !  &(  0    -      & &(  !  

"() 

     )      2       (    !& "   & &(* + 

      0- !

!   !    (   & &(  $7)4   !&    * $+ 

$     !&    #

!  !        *"    +) 

    (   $7)7   8 2  %- 9 * 4+  $7     0     !    ! ! 6       #

!    7 )

(    "  !  $        !  !   6  ( * + 

      0  #

!   , !   )

    ) 

$         *  +       0     !   "     #

!   $         %  &      ( &(    *  + 

     (  " ( (  ( &(          * $$$ + 

       ( !& "     .       -   !    ,   *  7+   (''!  "    &(  ( !  ,  6  *  ":,-+/

&    (     %    " ,-/ &    0)     (      !& ! )&( 0  &   (  ) ! !0

"    ,-/$ &(   0) &&( 0 !0  "      &( 0   ! 

 (  ) (    (!&         (    !  0    ( )&( 0       %     (   ""   . &(  0 

"!    %     (      (  )  (       !  !  ""  

  ,  6    /    )      (         !&  ! ) "          (    # 0 (#  44       (      ;3(!    !&&   !    "       ; *  "  + "    )  &(  0  !0 !   * + "  ) " 0   &  (    % &      !      !  . !   &( 0 % &  !)   !0!  "  )     "   ! !   !& "! !   ) 0&( 0  !&        " !   * +. " $       " &(!    !&&   !    (      "            !&&   (  % "      " (  ,        (    (      "      (  &( 0  !  !    *  +&      ! "      !  "$&( 0    ) !  !   "      ! !& )       !    !(   !   !   "   %      !" 0  ! 

0)    !& "    0   (     !      (         &(  0    !  .   (    ! )" 0

"    !    .     (      )     "   !  !      (  " 0 "              () 

   &(!    !&&       (     "    (

   0 (   )   " 0       (     (      "     ! ( ,-/ &  !  !   (       !     )     !    (    !& !&     (   !        "  !   .) !       44    "

  !  !&    44   7   &   6(   !  &(     *  ",-,+/ &       !       (  !&( 0  !      (    !& "       &( 0     (    &  !& ! "  !& 0   "   & 1-2 /7 &        6&( 0  !  &(&  &(!   !&&  !  * + (  !&"  

!   ) 0  (  !&"   ( )&( 0    % ( &( (  !&      "       %0     (        (  & 0   "    (    44$  4 (   &&( 0   #

!   !   &(!    !&&   2     7    "   !  !   ) ( % ;   !    ; !  ( !       #

!   44$   4 (   (    ;,   "     ;     2     7 !&&     $)   *    + "    $ 4)( &( 0  $ $  3(!   !&&        "   !  "         #

!      5$      "  $)  )  (  "   !    "    (  (     

 $ )$ %  " ))   &""   ( &( 0   "   !      )$   ."   !             ! 747* $+   ! 

   <"     *47 +) ( ( &( 0  )$   !  "   $ $   

   ( )  0   "  (  $ 4 ( ) 0      (           &"   )     $)     &(!    !&&      . ( &(  0  "   !     3( 0   )   (2  7    6 &""  (      "   !    (  &(  0   (   #

!  &(   !  ! ( !"      

  (      &(  0     0  "      (    & &(    !  )    ) &( 0   (  "  ' )  !   0)  "     ) 0     ! ( )  0) "    ! )  &(     )  0      ! "         &( 0  !     

   !   (      #

!  "     7  0      &  57 (        & 0 &(  (  

       0  &     (    & &(  !   "(   ) " "(0  "(0   

 "    & &(  !  )     !  ,- / 4      "    & &( !       !    0  #

!   $        %             0)    

   (       6   (  !  ,   (      %   "0        " 0  "  ) "0

  &(     &(  0     "   %!   (  !  !     "  7 .   %      !&      

  (  (   (  "   * $7+        0)       (         / 7       "&&   "& )           

0 &(   !&          ,   (    & &(  !     & &(      "         "          

) &( 0    "  (&(!   !&&     )      "   (     ( )  !     "  &(!   !&&       (  %   0 ( "&  (   * $+  

"" "''  #       "     " ( & &    ,    "         ;.     (  ;, 



     

     0 $  -  0   ,     " 8 2  %         #

!   0) ,   "     !   "  "&       &( )                 3(   "  ! )  !

!   44$  2       (    &(  0   "     

   )     # 0 ( #      44   (      ;3(!    !&&   !    "     ;" $( (  2   ) (  $)  )   (     (     &(  0   !   !  !     & &(    ) !& 

(  !

!   (  &(  0   "   !    )$  ( ! !  

    !  "      $  $    0 4 (  44$              .    () )   &( 0 "     ) !

! 7  0      & )

) !

!  4 ( 44$    (       2      &(  0   "   $)     (  )     (       "        0     ! 2   &( 0 )  ; (    !&"   & &( ;-    ) ( ,   "        !   )  &   "(    ) " "(0 #   

! (  & 3( "    6(  !  &(     /

(  ) 

   0)  "  "         &(  0   &(  "   &   (   & 3(   "  ! ) !

!  "  &(    !   )  0      ! "       &(  0   !      1  )2   &( 0       "   $)    )   &(!   !&&     $) )    &(  )  "        )  !&   6    / 4  0   !     (    & &(  !  )   "(0 

 "   & &( ( 

&   0   & &(  !   "(% #      )     "&  3(  ) ,-/4      "    & &(  !  .    0    "(   (  ()  !     (   !&"   & &( (   ) 2  &( 0    (  "  )      !  $)   )   ) "   & &(( "(       !  

 -   )    6   "    & &(  !     )   ) 

  ( 

" %  

"& !

!   )    0    "((   -  )   2   "   & &( ,-/$  !-     (   & &(        (   (           #

!         (  (     2      

    ! (  8 2  %        ( !

!  (  

2      & &(        )        



  "   & &( #

! == 0) " ! ) 

       ! 

 ,-, /  (    ( )  "&  )   0)  

     "               &    " ! ) )     - "     #

!     )  ,-, /  (     &(  0  &(      (    &  

 "    &  !    (    !& "       *( 

   !       &   "   (    !& "       ( +        6 0!      >   !&0     )  "    &(  0   "   " ! 0 "&

        (      

    .&( 0   %%! &(   &  )     &  ! 3    !     ( 

   , )8 2  %  -  (  )    6(      )         ! 0     !   "   &         ! % (  &(!&!   > (  (  !    7      "  "  " $)  -   "

    (  & &(       $$)    "7  #

!  (  $   2    &( 0   )     "   (   ( 47 )

 !   44$     

! )     "  (   2       $ 0  $   

  "       (   (  47 *?47 + &"  (( ,   ! )  "   (   ( !     #

!   0)      (            /7& &   "    ! )       

0 &(  !&        *,/7 ($"+-   !

!      (    !& "    & &(  !   "( >& &( 

!   "( &     #

!   "  7   0        !    &    ' 

 &   ( "("        ) 

!   ) 2    (   & &(  , !    "  !    !

!      ! !&     !      7     ==%  )   (  "       %           "            )   !             0    )   (         

    

        # "  "  "  "  ( )  

(         )          !    !  !  2         !     )    " !    (      (      2!    !

!      ! !&   

 "     "     ==  !  )  

 %   &(   "&&              ( "    . 

     "  &  -(    $  )  " 

0!    " 0    !    &(   "&& (   "  

"&   0!   ) "  0        

 7 "$ %# '''  .    "   -   ! !  0            $ ) $''  .  -      0      #

!   !  )

"    ; (       !

 -!  %    2      & &(    $7)4  !&    @   "

 44 ! !&  7 44 &,-,/ &          !            (   ! &(  0  !   (   !&"     &( 0    (    &    !&  !  "   !& 0      "    & 1-2/7 &        6&( 0  !   &( &  &(!    !&&   !   * +  (   !& "   

 !   )0  (  !&"   ( )&( 0    % (   &( (  !&      "       %0     (        ( & 0   "    (    .  44      !&&( 0   ! !    (    !& "       !    (    !& "     )   

    !   !(    ,        (    (      "      (  &(  0   !  !            &       !  "   ,            !& %       ,   !& "    0   (   !      (         &(  0    !   .     (    ! )" 0

"    !   .   (     )     "   !  !      (  " 0 "           ()

 &(!   !&&     (     "     ( 

     0  (   )   " 0       (   (    "    ! ( ,-/ &  !  !    (       )  !   (   !&!&    (   !     "  !       #

! &(!   !&&        "     ) (   !&&   ( "  $)      )  ( &( 0  A )$    ( &(  0   "    $  $  *   $ 4 + .        &(!   !&&    ( $)    *47 7 +    

<"     * 4+)   $ B( &( 0  !  !       &     ! "      $    ( )!  !  $)( &( 0  

 

0)   #

! &(   !  ! "     (          )  )        &(  0  "    (&( 0  %%! )    

   !    )      (    & &()     !& 

!  * 7+     !

 "  7   0           &   (   (           & 0 &(  .  

 &       0     &     & &(  !   "()

( &( 0  !   

2    7    (   & &( )    - C ) !        ( &      $   (    !  &(  0    "    (             <  "   &(!    !&&      !     )"&  ) !  !  "      2  7      ! %  $)     ,       !    #

!   4 ( 44$      ;,   "     ;         0 (   '  )    !

 "  &(  0     "  "     (     &("  )     )   !  *  +&  0 "  %       !    (   "      &("       )     !  !   "   <  "  &(!   !&&    !     $ 0  $     , !    (    .!&    #

!    "    (  "      " - " 

     * 4 "

  $ +    0       !&       445 $ *  $ +)  !&0 !  !  )  

   ( ! (      !  "%%   )  ( !  !    "   ( . (  )    "  !   )     "       & &(  (     ,     )   #

!   $  0            !  &(    (    

(  & )        

6      0 &( .    &(    ! ,-/  ( )/  ()/4 ()

  0 &( # ,-/  &     )       0   () 

  &( &  

     (   !& "  )

 !&&  " 4$  # ,-/4

& !  &)   744     ,/$ &      0)    &(!      (  !       ,     )    0        !     ! !( )    (   (      !  2            (     (  &("   )   &(!   !&&      (          )          &(  0    "        3(!     (   &  (   !&       ,-/ &    ! (  !   (  

   (   ,-/ & "  (   ! !&" 

   )

    ! !  ! ,-/ $' )  "  

 4   )  &(!     !    0 &  ( =    !     %   =     !  * (     

  !& +)      6  (    !&     &(  )  ( !  (   (      3(!     ( ! (    &(!            &( (      &("      !   ,    !  )      !     "   #

!   $  0     

 %    &(   "&     (*!%##  .  !      & 0 &( "  % 

)   !         &   !  &( (  .   0)     #

!   $            & *  +&("  )0"       . (0)   &(  ( !  : 0(     %        &(!       "       &("       )  0    (   % "==   (   #

!        &("  %  #        )!   0 44$     6 &(  0   (           * (    !+   $ 4"    ,==%      (   () )  *!& +   $     %"     

  ! &( 0    & &( - 9 *  +, !   ,     ! ) )     %"      "(

 ( )!   !  ! "  * )7+  0    )     

)       !&   "     :  0 &( "    )      "    (   !&"   & &(  !  !  !    (    %  !&   & &(    % (     

  &("        !      ,     !&  "        ,   ! !   6  *,-+/ ) ( 0   (    !&       (   >   (   ,- / ( "   )&( 0  &   (  )! !!  

 "  .  !  ! ( "  *# !  )   +      $44  !  !&    6(   !   &(        *     !  !&       6(   !   &(       ( + /  &  ) 

        (   ! &(  0   !      (    !& "       &(    (    &  0    !&  !  "   !&

0      "    &    !   !  !    # 0 (   6    *1-2+/7 &  )

      6 &(  0   !    &( &  &(!    !&&   !   * +  (  !&"  

!   )0  (  !&"  ) !   !   )   !  )  !       &(      (   !& "       

   (  "     )  &( 

  0      "       !&      "       %0   (       ( & 0 "    (     0"     ,      ( &   >&   0   ,    !  (  *  7+ 

  )  " !  "         (  6       .!&   0    ) "     &("  ( )

    !&  !  "     :         !   (    #     (        "     "   " 0 "    "&   &( )  0)  (   

  ( )

( "       %  * 47)("

)  +'(   0    &("       &(   "&& (   ! )          &(!   !   ) 0    &(      6 !   ! !  &(  "&& !    3(   &("   "&&   2!      ) !   &   &(   &("   %   0    "            !   !   !     (  )  !&!&%          "" (    #    -(      $ )

"  " !    !   "  0!   &(  "&& )   "         (  *  +    *  +   !   !  -(      ) 

     )   ! !      " 0  !   !         &(   "&&  *("

) +        & !&  (      ) &("  !&0        ( "     

    !&0 *0 + !      %%( "(  &  (  D    ( )        0  )    &( "&& )

(  " 0  !            !    *" $+ ,          -( 7         ) 

    )  % )        

 !)           

    &("  "&& *"+           / 7 (                  )                 !  )    (   !      !&    !    

    !      0%  ! !         .  !             )       !          D  %      ( 

)  &(!    !&&   !    (         ((      )  !

 !&

 !     (    0          (    #  !    

 0    ""      !   ! !     .  !           (    *( "

)    +     

      "==   ( (   

  #

! ! &("           "   !    "     ! !& )     0

   

  $    *   $+)            (    $        ,    %        )     0     !         !  ! !    " !   ,     (     ( ,   0  $   (   (!  *("

) )   + (   "    !

!      .( "     

   &      ==  !       )"   #

!    ! !   !     0    !  %    " 

         )  *&(!   +    (    00 & !   "      !     (   &"

 &     !   "   "  !   *" +   !   !  6    !   !          "   

      #   "    !& &(!     !  !    2   !    ) !  (    ! !&"     !  "   $)        $7)7       !     

         "&   ) "      0&("   (&(!     0(           %    0   !  !   (  , !   "   (  !&  *  $7+

   ( !       ) (  !             !&       !     ( !        &   .  %  .,/4 (  0) "

)

    )&   !     "      .  !         "       %!             .