Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-1123/5 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.04.1123.17318 AI generated

2-04-1123/5 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-04-1123/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtumäärus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

      

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-1123/5 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja:       

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

               

      

     !" # ! " #  $ %                                 &# '( % )" # '  &# '( % * ( % #' %  '*')+%$ ",  &# '( % * ( % #' %  '*') $%  -*'*% %*#  &% $.($ $(  )/ '  *' #  / '  *' # * ( % #' %  '*')/'*0&''  &% $.($ $(  )" (*1( *' #  " (*1( *' # * ( % #' %  '*')' #* 2  2*$ $*$ #  * ( % ) # (* (#

(  # * 0    3*'              &# '( % * ( % #' %  '*')+%$ ",  &# '( % * ( % #' %  '*') $%  -*'*% %*#  &% $.($ $(  )/ '  *' #  / '  *' # * ( % #' %  '*')/'*0&''  &% $.($ $(  )" (*1( *' #  " (*1( *' # * ( % #' %  '*')' #* 2  2*$ $*$ #  * ( % ) # (* (#

(  # * 0    3*'  4' ) %*      

    & 5 $        !   "  #    $    % &  '  '     ()     "((*     +    ,  +    %   '      $            $      %&             -          %                    .

  

   /    $   '        %    '    '  0         $   '   1     ()  "((2 3     

     -      2*$ $%  ,,  * .* '* #4 0 * $ (  ,,  *0*  ! *''*'* $ $%  ,,  $ **$'*$ ! $ $%  ,, $!  $   ! *''*'* $ $%  ,,  $ **$'*$ ! 0

 ! ' *! 4 ' * #4    *'  %, * # ''  #4  '  # ' $ ,,  *0* * $  * $,$ *.,*# ,, * ,$$*$ *$  *$ ' $*,,  *0$* 

* $ ( ., $# * 66( $,, *$* $ # $** $$ $% '*  !  " #  '  7" #  8   $

' 0 *$  (9 * $  " #  8  $'* # '(*!  ''* . ' ,, $  :  7( *$ (*  ; <9 *' #  $ $%  $*  0

  / '   *' # % $ $ ( : *' ## '  4 * $*#4 *$   &# '(*  *'$$* $ $ :*' # '* (*$*0   $* ='  *.*

%$  

. ''   $' * .* $  $*  *'$$ # $*$4$$>$66#4 *$   $

%, %*'$*    .= #, *!#4 *$ ** # '$' ( ! *$ ( !*'( %   , $ $ $ '' (  # %,,($'*$*$ :*' #* (  

(  $*(* $,*(*$* * (%$ ( $4$$$'*0$*   ' *% #

' $*4 $* # (* $*  ,, $  $ ''* * ('  * ( %  "4'*  ''  : *' #  $ $%   (( $* 

0

  / '   *' #  / *' #    (*(! $* # '  * ( %  *'$ ' #4 '( # ($ ''' :*' # $ $%  

 ,, 

% 

0' $ * $.=

$ * .* $   2 .* ( 

# * %,    : *' # ' ='  * %$   %, * . '' ' * =(  $*$ .   2'  '(* $ *$'*  # % 0:*' #66.,*# *$ 4 # ' 0 % '($ * * (* #4 '( $ ' '*(  $ $ '  " #  8   '(   #*0    $*  # '(* %  ,,  : *' # $ $% /*' #  $ $ :*' # # '  4 * $*#4 *$   " # '  $$*'** $  .*'' $  *0*:*' # $=$ " (*1( *' # !" *' #  . ' '  $ $* $= $ (   !  ''* ,, $  : *' #  $ $%  / *' #   *''* ! *$ ('  $* !  : *' # $ $% 0 # $* #4 /*' # !. '$  % 

$ * ** $* $'**  ',0 #

$  *     ?? %,$$ '  $$*$ $        $ $*'* * $  " (*1(  *' # 

 $  *0*

 $  *0*. '0"*' #    $$*$= $ ( % 

$  % * **

$* $'** ',0 #

$  *   $= $     $ ?  $% " # 8  $#*0  $ 

$   " # 8  $'**  ',0 #

$  *   " #  8   ? 

  . $*  %  # $ $(  $*  :  *' # %  " (*1( *' #   ; *' # * ( %  3*' . '0,, $ : *' # '*$ $% $*  0

  / '  *' #  

   ? * $ " (*1( *' #  $'*  % ' *   ! ''*  *'$* 4$ $  / '   *' #  ,,  *  $ $% ! # ( # 0 * ''  $ $%  " (*1(  *' #   *   '! *$ / '   *' #  $ $%  ,,  *

%$ $ * $*    $=$ * 4     $ #4 0 %$ (  :  *' #  ='( $ $* # '  * ( $ %  .

* *#4 '  / '   *' #  *  '* $=$ *   ' $ $%  4*$*'* # $ #   " (*1(  *' #  # '( 0 #  ''  *    : *' # $ $%  *( %,  $*'.4%$*')" (*1( *' # $, $( *

'*'$   ,*'*#  %    *$ $% ='* (* (!  / '  *' # @/ '  *' #  *  (  :  *' #  $ .

' #4 ' ' #  ' ' $*(  % .(*' % 

% (' '$ . $( #4 '$* $4$$! " (*1(  *' # '* $* ( '*# '$  / '   *' #   (# '$ * ( $ (* # # $ @ / '   *' #   . (*# '$ , $( " (*A( *' # $* '#$ # '$% #  ($* $$* #*$@/ '  *' #  '(0 ,*'*# ' % ' $=$ *'* $* 0* ( *$   " (*A(  *' #   %0  . * $ *  $* ( $*  $* # ' *    $    $*  $ %, *'.,  *'* $* $  ( * .* ( (  *( ! *$ :  *' #  $ $%  ='* *$*   '0 $  * 66 *'! .** *'! .$* . (  *'!  $  *'! .* # *$  *'%*+* '**''*.* 0$ $%  $*$

$*  (!.  $*  (:*' #  $! $

 :*' #    $*  # (*  $$* %$ (* $*  * '* $ :*' # # % 0$ $*$66.,*# *'$ *''4.  

: *' # , '  *,  ' =' $ : *' # #(!*$: *' # * '*#4 *' * $ *$$ $** ( * $  # '(

   &'  

! ' ( ,  # '( %  * ( % $*! % $ .($ $(  $* %  *(* * ( % $* %  $ $*$ #  * ( %  *   (! .* * $  :*#*  ' #    $$#( $   4  

$* % ' (* !'* 0!*$ # '(.4%*( $(%  '0 '(  *'*   $ # '$ # '* ($ ='( * (*7B9C'#4 0 ,, $ $ $%   '*! * #  * #4  4 4 $' * $4$$ *$# '$ *  (    $*(* $,*(*$  

( #4 * (%$ ( *'' *'%''( $ *!*$  . $($*#4 *  

'* 0!*$.4%*( $(,, $ : *' # '*$ $% !*$'* ((  $$!*$$  * (  %$ (    $*(* $,*(*$  

 %  * ( %$  :  *' # # % 0 66.,*# *'$ 4 # ' 0 % '($  &# '( %  " #  '  . '0 ,, $  $ $ ' $ $%  :  *' # '* $*  0

  / '  *' # / '  *' # ' $*(: *' # $ ( % '! '$ ''**  $ $ *( $  ' $ 0  ' !/ '  *' # $*$ ('($4*$*  *'$! *'*  $

$ .*$

'*$* 0 # *( $*  #4 ' '$ .  #  ( :  *' #  .* * $  / '  *' # 4 (*  *'$: *' # '*$

$( (*  # % '(  : *' # * ( % *   '!*$: *' # $ $% .* '* $*  0

  / '  *' #   : *' # $ $% #  (''  : *' #  0

 / '  *' #   $*  $=$ " (*1( *' #  

 ' (, / '  *' # : " (*1( *' # '* 0!*$: *' # $ $%  $'* ,, $ / '  *' #  #((!*$/ '  *' # *' (* :  *' #  %  ' $*(*    $*  $ %  

0  *( . (  

 $ $%  ='* *$*

   $, $ * : *' #  4 (* % (* %  *'!$* $' $* *  $  *'66 *'! .** *'! .$* . (  *'!  $  *'! .* # *$  *' $' *  '* .4%$ *'( ! *$ / '  *' # * ',$  $**#*$ $*$ # # (*$ '* 0!*$* '*.4%$ =0*   '( ( : *' # * $*'  '($% $ $* *' * (  '* 0!*$

#**#4$$**$/ '  *' # '% : *' #= .* *!* '= * (! '* 0  *$  4 $'  '( (  *$ * '  #4 ' %,$ $    *' " (*1(  *' #  *$$** $*( $* 0* 

 * $    $* # * $  *  '* '* ! *$  .*   $$* ,,

 / '   *' # $ :  *' #  $ $%  $'* *  '* * $ $( $4*(* (! *$ / '   *' # '* $ $ (: *' # $=$ *' 

$'* $& #**#4$$*!*$$** $ $,  # (  *$* !* .*  4 $'  " (*1( *' # 4(  =  4   % ' D $* '* 0 # ' % '   =' $ (   $0 *$$*. *  :  *' #  $=$ *'* %  $* 

0

 '*'* (  .    '* .'*'*0 # '*': *' #  =' $  * %   # *' E $   # *$  *   '* 0  *$ / '   *' #  %  " (*1(  *' #   ' $*#4 '$* (  *: *' # *  '$$*$** *'.'**'' *

% '! ''*$4$$ .* $$

! *

0$*$ ( . $($*#4 *   #

' *%   ' * 4 $* %  # (* $*$ $' *  '* .4%$ *'( ! *$ :  *' #  #

' *( %   ' (4 *(% $* # (* $*

# ($*$ $(',$(*: *' # # (*$ $'* * '** $ $($* $* ($4*(* ( #((!*$ " (*1( *' # (  ' $*(    $#4 ' '. * '*'!  ( 

'(* *#4 ' $ $%  # *'!'* 0!*$: *' # # (*%,$ $  *' *  ! '' *$ ' **$*

 %$( 4*$$! *$ $ ' '*  .* *  $  *' !  $  % '! *$ / '   *' #   :  *' # $4' $* % *''*  $,, *$** * 



(! '* 0 *$/ '  *' # 0 #  : *' # % $* =' '. (  *$ *( . (  $' $*  

 ,, 0 :  *' # '* $ $%  / '   *' #     F ! %, *' $$ 0  $ $* '4.*$  * #4  . *(  * :  *' # ' $'*0 ' $  4 (* $* $*$** * ' $ $% 4'* $   2*'.'$( '*'!+ C'%  % ((*C?'!C?'?!C??!C ? !C?'% !C '! '( 0  # '(* 

$ G '' G