Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-6942/3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.6942.17823 AI generated

2-06-6942/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-6942/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

       

Legislator headnote

AI generated
2-06-6942/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja:         «         !"#    $%&'#(!)#   ''*&"        +,-++ #&&          )-++."#./'/#*#,,0+(&!!'-         »

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

         !"#    $%&'#(!)#   ''*&"        +,-++ #&&          )-++."#./'/#*#,,0+(&!!'-         

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

    -""#*)-6#3) ,/-"(!" ") (#(.% ./#,,0+(&!!'- -"*,'"#(##* !"#,'"#!-".)+

-.*# (!)" )  '-' (!"  /,--* 811 --"#,-6-'# 6-' 1 ,- # !#" )  (!"  ""'#" -  + "." 6-'# -" )  (!" &.*'&+9198::9:19:09(!((##,,01:0 4("#)"((*(((4,,'*.--(&!!'- -"(4,,'*.--'"- (&!!'- - +

-.*#-",--#-!(!" (!)#"#""%-"'#*+

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

 ./-3'-,""#*"!"#-"*()-.*# 7: + !"# ./-37:/-('-,""#* #)#")(!)"#-"#'-"6-*," 7:9 +  !" .% "(!)#)-.*# -"#*,"& -*9+9+++1(!)#"* (!" " )- (-& -(#" .",  6%. !!(# )- (%"",-" " ="+ 0:=+ !" !','"#*!(#,'"6!"-#"#6!!"(%"""!-,""#*--(-(#":++="++ 8=+ !" -!(!)"#"%)""."'#*+5%&-(#""#3#*) )--""#* 2("--*.%-"* (!" 6!!" !,(./"#(+ !" !'"""#*)-."," %",- " %&*"+ !)##3-#(!)1") !'/-#-(#"6/) '*'#*!,)-.*#,%&-"#* '/#*,-" 7:#(###3)-" !"#&)#*,-+ 

 6#3-"*,'"#(##* !"#,'"#!-".)+ 

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

4.-"". #,, (-'*(",- .*# -""(   ,'"'#* -, ", (!)"#+.*#-"(,'"#(##*'-,(-&-'-'(##-*"/'*.**!(#,'*-*+ $!"- -*(##*"/'*,-(6--3.* (-''-"#"1"'*(##*!'('"#*1(#-* (!)#./-3'/#*''*"/'*,-"(,##.---+ '"#(##* (-'*(,%%&,- .*# "!-,"3 (!)# .--.-"," (!! ,'"#(##*'-,(-&  "/'*-"(%""."6!! ''3".%),"-" 6%..*#(%"""!-,",-""."#.%-*"-",-(+%)"-./-! 4),,'"#(##*(-'*(,%%&,-.*#-",-"%)" " 7: + '"#(##* (-'*(,%%&,- ,%%&# "!-,""( ,'"#!-" (%""  7 :: +    +'*&" (!)"#'-(