Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-6978/3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.6978.17824 AI generated

2-06-6978/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-6978/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-6978/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja:  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 

   

            !"#$%    &'()%*#+%    )),( $        -./-- %( (           +/--0$%01!)1%, %.. -2 *(##)/           " 3+ " /)," ! )&%( /),#(44 $/ #5%". !!/)) 3*#$"--        

/("!/*. ) $!%    -/(+%!,,-  -'!" .1/$ *#$"!$ - -   *%* 01! %..  $%+$ 6+ *, *+ **6.. ),*%% *(##)/2  )$/-        - 7'$$+ ". ) $!%*%!%,*#$"*),- - #$"8 5$%.(///! *#+$%*%!%,#. ) $!%,#*%. )$/, *'$$ $#/. $./ *%!%,-       

#$" 01/5 /$, $ !"#$%  8 !  *"3 *%/ $ . $  0% $%3 ./ #!/ $ !"#$%  $  ./  !% *3 #!/ $/)/$%, .1"%0$ 81+"% $- " 01/5 /$, 1!$%.$ .1"%0 81+"%  #! .#!%$3*%/+/0$.$"'$./ 8%+%!#!/*#$"! 01/$ . /),"! $#/. $$%,*'$$ .%%! 0///!*%///*!/*%!$!!*/("0$%6! ),./ -

"01/5 /$,$ !"#$% *'$$ $#/. $./ $!$  8' 0"##*%!#$% $ /)%,*#+$%! - 1%, ,*"! #)'$ $$%,$/0//!*#+$%. ) $!% 9 -     !" #$%#"&

  

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

3 *(##)/>8' 0? :3:*(##)/- %! ) 0!$  !! $3 $ 0//0/ 6! $5 81+/01! )/) !'+$%0!$ +  %% " .1/$!/%  81+/.1$ $ $3 8/,,  6+$!/ /!.  $/ 5(/// *#+$%8(*$/*$

///*#+$% $/0//!*#!! /%./ !+ ), $/0//!" )(- : 2  )/) $/0//!*#+$%. ) $!%   ,%$/*%

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

  :

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

#$" /#! *#+$%! 0$)%,=$-!233=-    

#+%#!! $%$0%)%,$/0//!".$ ("!/, ! /53 $*' #! 0"01/5$ !"#$%  +/(+%!,,-  9  !  '$ $53 $ *#+% 01/5 + " $#$!% ! 01/ #.! !$% ! +/ $ !"#$%  (+%!,, +/0!,%  .'(/$%, " "#!%,  1/%!/*%!$ 81+" ),$%, %!$% 3*%/*#$"3* !! ! *#+%#).''()%,0$./ $'+$"3 /#! $'+$  !$0$)%,3 / /*%/+/$#/. $$/*#$"! *'$$ 0'!/(///01/*%/ $#/. $$/*'$$ 0!/*%!$- !"%+%! !# $* + " /$$%,4*$/!/ ,0'/$ ,*#$"8##!$#.*01 $%*-  "01/5)/. $$%,$#$!%  /$,*+/0!,%  9 ! - !"#$%  01/59 !1/*  )/. $$%,"%+%!$ +*#+$%/$%)/$8/,.$ 9 !: - 

#$"! 0'!"$*#+%+/0!,% " !! ! !/$%,.$ ("!/,:-:---3*#+%$,  *#$"$ +/!  */("!/*%!$ 0$.  8' 0 "##*%! +/ *'$$ ./ $ !$  =$-! =-

#$"! #). ) $!%,#*%. ),/,8#$/%$% 8##!$*'$$ $#/. $$%, ,/),./ *$ . *## !0! 8 ( !//*. !  - -=$-!-:=- #$" /#! *#+$%! $'+$  !$0$)%,- 7'( !/*%!$ $%! 5 !% , + " +/ /$$%, 4*$/!/ , 0'/$ , *#$" 8##!$ #.*01 $%*-

#$"! #)$ $$%,+/! 0$.$"'$./ $"'( , $-

#+%%5 /%*#+! 3 $+ "#)1/%!/*%!$81+" ),)%,#.+/0!,% .'(/$%, )1%,./$"9 ! !% !*%%!%5+/$ !"#$% (+%!,./ ! -   "8!%5 /$,. ) $!%*%!%, "#$%. ) $!%#!/$ 0+ !- 

 

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