Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-5687/6 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.5687.16547 AI generated

2-06-5687/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-5687/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-5687/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 

   

            !"#$%    &'()%*#+%    )),( $        -./-- %( (           /" %$0$#1 +/ $ 1 ) .. 1$%  ,% 1$ !$ $ */$$%,*+"%+21/$./ )3%,            "/" %$0$#1  4*#$"$ 1 )..         

/("!/*. ) $!%    -/(+%!,,-  -'!" .3/$ $ 1 ) .. !$ ..  /" %$0$#1 *%*  *#!. $%+$ *%%,  /$ *2.. ),1// *(##)/-        - 5'$$+ ". ) $!%*%!%,*#$"*),- - #$"6 7$%.(///! *#+$%*%!%,#. ) $!%,#*%. )$/, *'$$ $#/. $./ *%!%,-       

#$" 13/7 /$, $ !"#$%  6 !  *"4 *%/ $ . $  1% $%4 ./ #!/ $ !"#$%  $  ./  !% *4 #!/ $/)/$%, .3"%1$ 63+"% $- " 13/7 /$, 3!$%.$ .3"%1 63+"%  #! .#!%$4*%/+/1$.$"'$./ 6%+%!#!/*#$"! 13/$ . /),"! $#/. $$%,*'$$ .%%! 1///!*%///*!/*%!$!!*/("1$%2! ),./ -

"13/7 /$,$ !"#$% *'$$ $#/. $./ $!$  86' 1"##*%!#$% $ /)%,*#+$%! - 3%, ,*"! #)'$ $$%,$/1//!*#+$%. ) $!% 98 -   !" #$%#"& /$$%,+/6!%7+ "*#$"!$1'!".3/$3/%1$ !$$ */$$%,*+"%+21/$./ * *(##)/". ) $!%*%!%,-

  

/1!,% *#+ !$3/$/+ " -1 7(%(/!$ .! *%%!%1%$# :/($#6(./! ; !/ /($%$ %/1$% - !!  6(./!4 1//7/ + " !'+ ,! (%66 //*%/,4 * !! , $ *#$" #!/ $% 1 !*#+#!/"##7  " $ ,.$4 ./!! $ $/)/$%) 13/ !*#+#!/ .3"%!4 !3/ $ + "*3(1!%13/,%%$#$%./ %* 1$%+ "%$#$4./!! $%! .% ).3!*/ + "%$#*2!" 4./!! $ */$+ "! *+"% *(##)/-

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

#$" /#! *#+$%! 1$)%,>$-!-  4 >-    

#+%#!! $%$1%)%,$/1//!".$ ("!/, ! /74 $*' #! 1"13/7$ !"#$%  +/(+%!,,-  9 8 !  '$ $74 $ *#+% 13/7 + " $#$!% ! 13/ #.! !$% ! +/ $ !"#$%  (+%!,, +/1!,%  .'(/$%, " "#!%,  3/%!/*%!$ 63+" ),$%, %!$% 4*%/*#$"4* !! ! *#+%#).''()%,1$./ $'+$"4 /#! $'+$  !$1$)%,4 / /*%/+/$#/. $$/*#$"! *'$$ 1'!/(///13/*%/ $#/. $$/*'$$ 1!/*%!$- !"%+%! !# $* + " /$$%,;*$/!/ ,1'/$ ,*#$"6##!$#.*13 $%*-  "13/7)/. $$%,$#$!%  /$,*+/1!,%  98! - !"#$%  13/798!3/*  )/. $$%,"%+%!$ +*#+$%/$%)/$6/,.$ 98! - 

#$"! 1'!"$*#+%+/1!,% " !! ! !/$%,.$ ("!/,- ---4*#+%$,  *#$"$ +/!  */("!/*%!$ 1$. 8 6' 1 "##*%! +/ *'$$ ./ $ !$  >$-!  >-

#$"!  #) . ) $!%,#*%. ),/, 6#$/%$%  6##!$ *'$$  $#/. $$%, ,/),./ *  - ->$-!- >- #$" /#! *#+$%! $'+$  !$1$)%,-5'( !/*%!$$%! 7!% ,+ " +/ /$$%, ;*$/!/ , 1'/$ , *#$" 6##!$ #.*13 $%*-  #$"!  #) $ $$%, +/!  1$.$"'$./ $"'( , $-

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