Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-16795/10 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.05.16795.16670 AI generated

2-05-16795/10 · Viru Maakohus Rakvere kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-16795/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

1    

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-16795/10 · Viru Maakohus Rakvere kohtumaja: 1    

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

1    

K O H T U O T S U S             

                        

 

 

 

     

   

   

       !"  #   $ #

%  #     #     #     #    !&'&(")*'+#   !&*(),'-  # 

 # 

 # 

 #   . /+0  -  #

    #   

/ 1#

 2/                                  / /      / /      / /      / /  /  /  /  /  /  /  /  / 3456. /+0  $ /(*!(*$

   7&!$((!7  -$  /       0   / # + /8888$9  1: #.$  ;  !!$((7'  -  56+ /8888$ 8888$ 8888-$  /   /   0+ /#

/ 1  <=   /$= $  ((!7-                                  (% 7 !"      /     /     /     /    /         /              6 

 

 

 

. /+0  -   . /+0  -   . /+0  -   . /+0  -     #

  #

  #

  #

    #   

/ 1#

 2/    #   

/ 1#

 2/    #   

/ 1#

 2/    #   

/ 1#

 2/ 

#  

#  

#  

#   /  /  /  / 







    3  

   ; 3  

   ; 3  

   ; 3  

   ;&  

  * * !'     $      

  * * !'     $      

  * * !'     $      

  * * !'     $                

    2 

    2 

    2 

    2         /

/

/

/   10    /    10    /    10    /    10    /    #     #     #     #         ;                    ((%'%"$     ;                    ((%'%"$     ;                    ((%'%"$     ;                    ((%'%"$ 

   )%7)6)(6'7$ '),(7" 2

    

1  0 /    ('%  

   )%7)6)(6'7$ '),(7" 2

    

1  0 /    ('%  

   )%7)6)(6'7$ '),(7" 2

    

1  0 /    ('%  

   )%7)6)(6'7$ '),(7" 2

    

1  0 /    ('%  !$$$$  

$  

$  

$  

$ 8888 888 888 888$    

        $    

        $    

        $    

        8888 8888 8888 8888 1/0     '$)   1/0     '$)   1/0     '$)   1/0     '$)  ! !! ! $ 1

/  $ 1

/  $ 1

/  $ 1

/                   2    2    2    2          







                   

   1

      

   1

      

   1

      

   1

   

  

  

  

   ; ; ; ;&  

 = >   

 = >   

 = >   

 = >        3  3  3  3 







                                 0    2   

/  0      0    2   

/  0      0    2   

/  0      0    2   

/  0                                     0#   0#   0#   0#  $ #     $ #     $ #     $ #    

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

 0# #

0#

0# #

0#

0# #

0#

0# #

0#

   0   #    

     $ 0 

 /  0       0   #    

     $ 0 

 /  0       0   #    

     $ 0 

 /  0       0   #    

     $ 0 

 /  0       

   

   

   



 $ 

2    /           

 $ 

2    /           

 $ 

2    /           

 $ 

2    /           +  ?77! "$?" )- +  ?77! "$?" )- +  ?77! "$?" )- +  ?77! "$?" )-           /   /   /   /   2    2    2    2      

2    ;   (7  !'    

#   0  3  

         2  /    1/ (( 7 !'       

     0   /    #     

  /   

# 20

/ 3  

/#

     (*!  ('  $     $               $  ( (! !7     



1 @ A #   /*""!  (   !7 ( !'   

 #   /*'))  '     /#   /     / /   

$     #      

 0 /     

/ 

 #  / / #2

/  3      $         0 /   #    2



/   

/ 1#

  =  ? !%   !    

       #    /      #2        0         

    #2       2

      /     . @ A     ! ( !7     . ; A B$  0   

 #      ;    (! ' !'      . ; A B 0      /    /$  0 

 /  /

 0 /      

 . ; A B         $      

 #  / $  

$   /  0       / /  / #

# /     # 

 $ 2

  2     (*!  (' / 1#

     2 

   

2/ /  !)*"*"  ''  $     #

$      0  (*!     (' /     



 02

/    2       '  !  /    !&(&")&   /$         #     02

/ #2    2  $  / 

 #2   $       #   /  #

    /   .?) (   /       /$             

/    /   $ #



# /  /      /

  ?(%) (     /$          

/    1 $ #



# / 

/   1#

         # / /  /  2

/$        0   1  

/   1#

  2/  /    0     2/  $        /      /   

   02

    1   5   0   #

   #     2/  $ 

0       11/  3    #

/$        1  #   /   /   #       02

/  1      0      



  #



  3  0   

 /    ?('" (0 (    /   10         8888$      ((%'%"$       0

    0   # 

  /   #   #22 /     $          1  

 0 /     

/ #2

/   

# /$     #

$       

 /  1#

   # 

    #2 #22 / /  

8888 #         # /     

     10       



     0#

   / # $ /

 #2      

    * * !'    /   

  

    02/ /

 /   0#  /     

    2 # # 

 

       #

       #

       #

       #

            #

    $       2     02/ 

  

2/ 

 3    # / /  #   

2     $  2

 0 $     / 

      #

      3   #

 =  ?& !%  !$  

   # 2 $ 0    ?&(%)  .?&)  ($   

# /       0     #          #

      #     5   0    #

/    0      $       #     /   #2  02  

 #         3   0  # / / 1    $  /          

3 # /

#      / /    # /

#   #2

/ /    2    # /     / $      0  # /

#   (*!     (' /  

 #      02

/      2    3   0  11 /  1    /   /   # /

#     2   02

/ 

 0   =             

$       1    2  02

/  3         /     2 

#$   /   / $    0  1  

/  1#

 2/ /   0    2/  $      /        /    

     02

   

        0 

   / 

                                  3   /  3   /  3   /  3   /   

$   

/  #

(*!  (' /  2/ $   0      #

/$   

( (! !7   !7 ( !' /0     

    #   / 

#  /   .&@ A      #

#2 //    

/  .@ A    # #2

  $      2  /     / 200 / ! ( !7 $  2

 /   !7    

   !' 0

 #

     #     / /      2 

/ .    /    # / $  /  

     

   /     # 

 0 /  $ /   0  B    /    

      #2   $   1        / /              3      $       #

# /  /   1            $ /    / #

/ 

/     #  = ?!%  ! 2   =2/   #      1  

       #/ /  1  #  $  2

  1       2   2         !7 ( !'          0# $  !' ( !' $ 



 0 

# /   2  #  2

  0      / 

2/ /        #2  # /$     2   02

  @8    0  0  20

   / / 1   @8       /  /0/ /  

 #2       0/        20

    /

   02

/      2    2/ /         $           # 02      $         

/   /  

 0 /    

 02/    #  (*!           1   0              

 !!%            /          $   1  0   0  = 

  #2 

 02/  $  1 #2  /        

/ $   0    / #2  /   /     # /$    2         / # 

/ 



/        $   2 $          /

 #2   /     /  1    $   #    1   3    $        

/         

#    /

#         #     /      $        /  1     3       ?&/ (%$(%)$ .?&/'$)$= ?&!%    0   $   $  #2        0  

/  $    #   /     #

       $     #   02

/  2     #       02

/      (*!     ('     #

#     1#

/         /      /      /      /    

$       2     02/ 

   2/ 

 . /0      / /#  # $   

/0 

# /  =      $  /  //$ . / 0

     0  2 / #2   2  #2   /  ! 20 $  

4   *' *'         #

          

/$      . / /    $    / !7    /        

    /  / #2   $ 0  0 

         / #    !7 20  / /    /    $  .         #     $   0 /#    #    #2   $   !7  0   $ . / #2    0  $ #

    (   $   #2 /

     !7    / &             ./             



/ .@ A 

#/$   #/  /



    /

 !  . /      .& @ A      0 /# 0     



/ #/

/      $      /                      / 0 /#  

 /$    2     

 

/  #   / #/      0/#  $  # 

 2/ $       .@ A      

/        2/   2      ? !%   '       2/

     

#$          / #     0  #

// # /

  2/  $   0/# / //   /$       

               $            

/$      /     $       

 #

/ $  

 2     /

/

//     .& ; A B      #2       

//    

       0       1  /    # /  5     0 

# /  

       ?&  (%    '(  = 

# /  

   0 !' 

     /    $  0         /     

    0 

# /  

/ $ 

 #

/  0

$     / 

          #2      /   /    #2/ . /

  .& @ A  #     

/    $  0/          #  /  #

/  02       

  #   #2

    $   2    02/ 

   2/ 

   

  / 

$          /    /     02  

 # /         =      

/    

# 0   /

#    # / /     $ #2/

  /#       1    / $   #   /         /   0  

    

  2

   /  ?&  " 

/ 1/     

#

   $    2

#  (       0     #

     $                    #

    /    0  /  $  

  $ 

  /   /    

     2         /   &!&(&7'& $              #

    

   

/  5   $   

 $      11/ $  / 02  / 9?(* ?(7 /    9?(7 (   #2   1#

#/ / $  1#

         

/         2   #2  / 02  2    #

#2     /   0  

     / 

   1#

/    /    2    /    '* $   0  /#

/ 1  /            

$ 02 $  

 

 

  $   $ 

    # /  # $     # /  / $          

  $     /     #  #2    0/  #  #

/

$ /        0             1 $   00 

     2 /  

$   B # 0/   #  $           /

 /$   / 0  #2 

$    $ 

    #2   /$          /$        #2  2/       2    !7 20 $ = / #= 1   0      C / 

 /   

   02/  

   02/  

   02/  

   02/ 

5   #

$   

/   1            #

     #   

/ 2/  3   # / /

/ #   /  1/   /       /  $    # /  /          #

  $ # /  /             1      

#2

 #

    

 

/      #2    #

       / #    &!&(&7'& 

$        2    1    

       /      # / 1     2/ / $         /  9    /     $ #

   /     /0   

2/      / $             11  #   1     

2/ 

   /6 (  =  ? (   !     #2    2 $  

   /   / /  #2  /  2/ /       #2   /   

 #  

    2  #2  /  #  02  = ?!% !   D  0      $   #2    2   02        #  $     /   /       #   

  B11      #2  #2   /      #2        0         

   #2     2

E       #

  # / 11 2

    #    

$                #   02

/   2       /  1     

  /     / 

2/  $   $     1       $

    . @ A  

/ #   #&

/   ((,$ (7 (( !      (*,$ !% (( ! #

/.@ A         /. /  #/ 1 /   # /         

/ #     /    

  =/    /   $          $   2/ /    1 0 . /0     0

/  3      / # /

#  .& /# /

#   / / ( (! !7    !7 ( !'   #

/ . @ A  +@  - # 

        # /      $       # 1        1          !' " !(    ! ( !7      

    2/    / #   0 $  0 $#2          

/  

/     

 2 

/ #     $    #     0 

# /  

 $  /                       #          /   02/ /  !  3       # /    

  

$  /   $          1   

/  0    02   

/  /$      ;    (7  !'       $    1     /

 200         !      2        

 20  ( (! !7            #      ('77)           77'7)      # /    $   !* ' !  02 #       / 

/ 0   (( !7    11/ 

 #   /     " (! !7 $   /     /   !  =      #    / / $     2     #    !    .& @ A  # 

       02

/ #2    2    $    / 1  /  /#2# /$   

  0    2

 0CC

 2   1        #2     #

         1  

      1       

/  



 #/

        / # 

      #

 #2 /$   

/  1    / $    /  1   

/ 

 

/      ! ( !7   .@ A   .; A B    F  / $   .& @ A $     ; A B$ 2 0/$ 2/  . /

6 +0  - 

/2       .; A B+0  -0   /  #

  

$ # / /   

   B0/    3   # / /  . ? ' 

  /          1/ /   /$       /         / 0 # /    /   #2  02  

 # /  

      

#   /

#      /   

 /     /  1       

/   2  0  

/ 

 #   /     /  2/  $     $       $ /  

 0 /    /   

#      



   1 #2  /   $ 

/     /   1  #2  /        /          #     2

$                1  0 

   /     # $    

 # 

      / / $               

      

/  1          

#    

#   $   /      

   

  2   #2  /   2/ /   #2  00 

        2     #    ! $ 0 /       /     #   /    

  1 $

/  # / =   1#2  /  0  #

# /     #2    0  2/ 

    

#2

      #

/$    / 

   .?'    ; /  #

      / $       

 #    / 

  #      /   

    /   /    /  ?     D  #   /  2   

/    0  /

    /  

    /  /        /

#      /   

 E  

#   ( ( !"  /  ?&" (2  0$        $    0  #     /           2 #

   # 

/        / 

$ # /     /  /     /    ?"( (0 (  2  0

  $      $

   0   0    #  #   /   02/ / /

  

/ 2         0 'G   / /

  #2  'G    / 

  / 

     ; /  #

      / $           / 

$ 02

              

 $  2

     / /

    /    /  .?'$= ?!%$?&/(%$(%)$   ?$   ?&/77(&77!$"! (2/       ,   ,       2  HB  0      2  6!" # 6!" # 6!" # 6!" #  !)          !)          !)          !)         HB  0