Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-23919/6 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:2.05.23919.16513 AI generated

2-05-23919/6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-05-23919/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-23919/6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

  



           !"#! $""%&'#()%&' &*!  

   !+ ,+!-.*.  

  /" "/" "'&0          (1 /" " 201 343!5!4* 6 1 % 45+-  7)0("" (1 /" "  201 -4$ * .$,! 6 1 # 8  %&' '0  %&' #07) 0(0  " " ( '00'%/9'          00"

9(#&/" "/" ":(" "280"-*"* "! !"78:0#('#

- "*!"! 3""- " 3"! $""- 35*.20 87-,"

9( #& /" "  /" "  :(  " 280" -*"* "! !"7 8:0#  *" ,"! $""  -  2#07    " " 9 # "  -*" !"! ! ""  0 ''# 90' /" "   '9(#&# -     *" ,"! $"" 

9(#&/" "&'!, 20'8##070)#0*, :9'('(&# 0##'* !! -34.$   ;:'&!!* !-445$ $:)'#!. 4!$.." 

&!* /" "0&(90"    ' '  !"#  ! $""  *-"     %&' #(0"      

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

-2,7 % >+ $*  $ #0 (0" (  &00 (  '9(#&# '"   0  - "*!"! ,""  & (  

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

,2,7 '#  0 ( 9# 0 0# 0 > -    0 (&# 0 # :  0 #0 (# ( 0#99#   0 '# 0 9"   #0 '9(#&# (00  -*"*!"! ,""09" (#&0-*"*!"! ,""0 >+*$* : ! ' &' # '0)  &'  > $3  *  '9( #&(0">+$3*90)&')## ('0)#&('9(0"

&''+34!&'">*!- '('#'&#" #0>35 *:-9)0#99" 9'(-$ 2*!A- 7" #(0 &'0!00#990 -$ :#&'!5 "9'(&' !,  "  : '&# 00 ( 0# #99 ( '9( #& (&'!, " 9' (  #   &  !*    ''   !" ,"! $"" #99 '00' % /9'   &  #99#"0):0>+$*!90 &'9(#&#(" $" -"! ,""#992 !47   / 0::  '0  &  ( & 0 8'# )&(90"