Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-4473/3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.4473.14827 AI generated

2-06-4473/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-4473/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-4473/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja:  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 

    

          !"#$    %&'($)"*$   '+# %,'        -./'+ .. $''          *+' '01#$12 3)'""(+(2$,          !  3 *! /+($ +( +(,! 1" +)+'!  $  +,"+( $ +(,"'44#+3$)"*#"0$!5 +((  6 3  "#!' '0          +'! +)5(# $      !    " #$%     & '.)"", - 6-  3 --6 +((3 # 4.-    %  

'()* ( +#$*#)$$,+#)755(,    *'  +,% % "--./*"    "--./*"  0           1$ &         "   ,                 $     

         %      ,   /     /          /   %,%  %   %%,%   /       $   ,       %          $         2      %        $        ' ,$       

 %   $       34'(  

    !&51&6/76!18 ....+#)"*#$ *+' '0+1#$12 )"))$3)'""(+ ." /2*+12  63 ! 1++1+ 63 )'""(+  1& !52+#5+). ! / $0 )"*#$ # ) 5(# $)$ $,!"#$#5(# $" +#1* . 2$,  $) " 1# !" $, )"* # 2 5++, *! ! )"#! . ... ++#$5+ /+($ ,/+,+ /+( 3 5+   $  "$# *! )"#!  # #($# + . "#! )"*$#$"$##$,#($##$5. #1 # /+($  +# *! )"#!  '1, ('. 863  683   888 )"))$ $55 63 +  . +1 ,$ +#5+ +$ + "  )"#!"5)"*$#$##&+#($,. !"('1#($,1++1+# #1++5'15)#&*#/&1 !&'(1#/&1#)$(+ *+ +#5+ )$$/&1(+ .... "#! "( " ($, 1++1+#$ 6 /&1. "#! 1++1+12  *!  "( 3  )'""(+. ++1+ '1#5+  "(  $) 12#$, )$$ /+))$/&1!#/+))$/&1.++1+'1#$93 6:/&1;63 )'""(+<36)'""(+=/&1336)'""(+; 6/&1<3 )'""(+. $ (1 #  #3 # 1++1+ 7 #0 /2*+12  (+( &*#$1 # * $$ ! 52+# +))$ /2*+52###3 /+,, 7*# + + 5 #+ 0'+++ )"*#$/')#+)# +++)"*#$ #+1++  )" +$5+ *(, #+1++ ! ('.  6 3 "( *! *$1+##$, 1++1+# /2*+12  $ #$3.".$5563)'""(+. >? 8  ((012 $ ,! 2+$(2$,'* +)"*$#$#&+#5+# '+))$5+ . #1 #12 2+$,$ > ?8  "( /+( /+($/"" # #&+#5+))"*$#$ +). > ?    )"* # #$ 0 )"*$#$ #&+# 1#1 # /+($  12+ ,$ . > ?  &##03 # )"*$#$ '+))$5+( "( 12 $*## #$ (1 )"*$#$ #&+#5# !&#5+( 12+ 5+##)"*(#&+#5+(*.#&+#5+1++1+#5+(.>?    / ((012 $ ,! 2+$ )"*$#$'+))$5+)"'' (2$,)"*$#$#&+#5+#. /+($12##+)"#!)"*$#$5)#*! 1#1 #+##$,'1# '*./+($ *$#5#$) +) "(  #($# )$#5+ 7 ,#+(+5$, +(+5$,@ +  . +(+5$#/$()#+.. .)"* #)"*$#$)"#!#&+#5 /+($#3#.1#1 #/$()#+ ... #$52+ ##($#'1+,1#1 ##+(+5$#4+)'+#$,'1 ,$#)"'' . !+#)"#! '1, /+($5&'+#$,,'+ 91')7  '+'1 ,-  '5. ,'+ 5$$#$5+# + "  )"#! *!# #1+#($,. #1 # +(+5$# /$()#+ ..6. # )"*$#$)"#!+5 12+5 $ #1+#5*!#"5(+53,'+3 )"(#)## 4"(+12+#+#')1+++#+,5$$#$5+#)""$$#(,5#+#5+. (1# #$ (1 ##$ 0 $,)"#!1#1 #+(+5$#/$()#+ ..'1,($).'1#5+## 5+(1#1 #+(+5$#/$()#+ 6. .+10#($,++)+)"#!##$5+)"*$#$#. >?   . /)"* #12+012 $ ,!3)$+12 (+)"()"*$#$#'+))$($,3(2$, '* + )"*$#$ #&+#5+ 1++1+#5+ )"''  1++1+#. #1 # > ?     12+0 12 $ ,!(2$,12 (+)$ #'* +)"*$#$#&+#5+1++1+#5+)"'' 1++1+#3'1# )"*$#$+(2$#1)5$$#$5+#)$(+)"*#&+#5+(+.++1+5&&') "#)> ?-&###$,+(#'+5&&'35+   +(,$0:#3)$+ /+($+" ##(&*#$, )2'5#+(#'+5&&'./+($)2'5#+(#'+5&&'##(&*#$,+" .&*#$,> ? 6 &###$, ,+/"+#++1$ /2*+52### //++, *! (+( )"#! #+(+5$# /$()#+ 6. .)"))$1++1+5&&'3 6:/&1#&*# ##$5#$55#.+(+5$#/$()#+ 6. .)"* # "#)5)#$#$)$55 )$5+ *! .  (1# &*#$, 12 (0 )"#! *!  3 )'""(+3 5+ # '* +( /2*+)"*$#$ 5"",$#063)'""(+(+(1++1+63)'""(+.

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