Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-02-70/6 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.02.70.11135 AI generated

2-02-70/6 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-02-70/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

 0  . )"  $3&"# % : "  , %13 " %." ."!%%1 ""1"""$   " $$$ 1 "    0  !&1. % "+ ,%%1 ""1"! ."#".*1,$$$%%68('1( ## ; 1( 1   ,$$$ %% 6889(6 1( ## (; 1 ! 1 6 $$$%%6'1(##9(61$%%9'8(91$ "31) 3 8$ "    # %# . % ## (< + .%% ) ##.3&"#""$ )"! 3 5 " 14. !  )"!  9'8(9 1 11) 6( 1 34#4  ##! .$  ;$$6 " )"! &3. )# ."   = 8; $ )# ." "  "" .5 !  1"1." ""  . %%"$ ") $$6 %. #4 )1"# ,';(98 1 3 ##6888(881$ """ ")"1.5)"!% )14""%%")$$616;(11$  ,  )  "  # %# . " 11 8$6$ ! ;$$6 ".  )# .  !&)1"#" 34!" *" # %# .1" %.""%""."=' )3  &"1." #  , #" " %." "%" . 5!"$ %." "%" "." = 8 )  "  1 . "+ %" " %." "%" . 5!" "% "" ! 1"1." " ## % ) " %$ "") ") ""5 ,"+!!"% %"" #  %# ."."+".$ "+". " ""  + ! "% %" %#" " "31) 4 %%( . ## "31)&"." # "+"."&"")!++ . "")$ "+"."= ) "1"# ") ""5%" 1.+1)""."1".+%( %. "+". " ") ""$ " 1.+1)" "." = , ) 8 "  5 ! 1.% %" 1.+1) %"" " #!  "#" !%"  ! "% 1"1." 14." ##1."(34!)" """1&."$ )"!!!#" $8$999 4 %. "31)36$%)"!") ""%35 ""%.4) "31)3 "#. #"."$1&"51%". "31)31'$6""#. "3  &5&&%"3.%"$ )"!)# ." " .%"! ."1&5("!1"1.!)18;8$$ )"! " 3 #" " ).(  3 ! 1 #". ) 1" " "1") ! . "" !" 5!"#" $!".+%"(" "%.)"& ("" " "#%!&$ )"! " ! " 9$;$ !( "  . 1 .. "" 4" " . "" $ " .. #")!&5)"!!!&" 3&%" "#"$ )# ."34!"1.5)"!! +%" " #% !&% " ")( " ! ! )"! #"  4 %. "31) " 1&" "" +" ."!%"" )% )"! "#")%")#!"" 4)"".(")"!#4%  "" ) ." "%11)" " "1"# ! #""1.1.)#">)"!" """  .$ !#")"!! "#%!&%")1%" 1.+1)""."=, ) 8   "" 1%". "31) 31 6$$ # 4)" "5 34%4"( % " "  .#45##.%"&%")("&%14."#!&5 %3 " "&%$!3 #""%"3"%1" "1"1+" "(" )"! " " )1. ! "  " "%"  ( % ")  #. +#"1. !  $

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-02-70/6 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

        !"##        $%&'$(#( #%!                           !"!#$%&'(%(  )     ) )   )) )"!*"+,-")./- !*"   0 -"). /- !"1.!# ! " *" 2.1#-. /-  )    ! %"1"       %* +,                !"!#  $% &'(%(  ) )* '* ,          )      % -.( /     )    )/  * )        ,       /)     /  )-(((('-'/ ''%('$--0(0 12      %(''(($&-30(%% #4    5 2          '3(((-'%$0/ %. 2,        *      ) )  )    , )               *            ) )    )             , ) ),    ,   )*          '-* ,  '((0*  %'*((     

    )*  )     )  " 3" " 1 4) ". 3" 1"5 "  1)11 " 6 3&"# !  #" " 3" 1. " &"%"%"( . %"  !"%  #"  %77.%" "%"%""#  "#")"%"$   1 )   )# ." "  $8$999$ 4 %. "+  , ! "  

  

 0 %13 " %." . "31)(% "" 1" 

 0  . )"  $3&"# % : "  , %13 " %." ."!%%1 ""1"""$   " $$$ 1 "    0  !&1. % "+ ,%%1 ""1"! ."#".*1,$$$%%68('1( ## ; 1( 1   ,$$$ %% 6889(6 1( ## (; 1 ! 1 6 $$$%%6'1(##9(61$%%9'8(91$ "31) 3 8$ "    # %# . % ## (< + .%% ) ##.3&"#""$ )"! 3 5 " 14. !  )"!  9'8(9 1 11) 6( 1 34#4  ##! .$  ;$$6 " )"! &3. )# ."   = 8; $ )# ." "  "" .5 !  1"1." ""  . %%"$ ") $$6 %. #4 )1"# ,';(98 1 3 ##6888(881$ """ ")"1.5)"!% )14""%%")$$616;(11$  ,  )  "  # %# . " 11 8$6$ ! ;$$6 ".  )# .  !&)1"#" 34!" *" # %# .1" %.""%""."=' )3  &"1." #  , #" " %." "%" . 5!"$ %." "%" "." = 8 )  "  1 . "+ %" " %." "%" . 5!" "% "" ! 1"1." " ## % ) " %$ "") ") ""5 ,"+!!"% %"" #  %# ."."+".$ "+". " ""  + ! "% %" %#" " "31) 4 %%( . ## "31)&"." # "+"."&"")!++ . "")$ "+"."= ) "1"# ") ""5%" 1.+1)""."1".+%( %. "+". " ") ""$ " 1.+1)" "." = , ) 8 "  5 ! 1.% %" 1.+1) %"" " #!  "#" !%"  ! "% 1"1." 14." ##1."(34!)" """1&."$ )"!!!#" $8$999 4 %. "31)36$%)"!") ""%35 ""%.4) "31)3 "#. #"."$1&"51%". "31)31'$6""#. "3  &5&&%"3.%"$ )"!)# ." " .%"! ."1&5("!1"1.!)18;8$$ )"! " 3 #" " ).(  3 ! 1 #". ) 1" " "1") ! . "" !" 5!"#" $!".+%"(" "%.)"& ("" " "#%!&$ )"! " ! " 9$;$ !( "  . 1 .. "" 4" " . "" $ " .. #")!&5)"!!!&" 3&%" "#"$ )# ."34!"1.5)"!! +%" " #% !&% " ")( " ! ! )"! #"  4 %. "31) " 1&" "" +" ."!%"" )% )"! "#")%")#!"" 4)"".(")"!#4%  "" ) ." "%11)" " "1"# ! #""1.1.)#">)"!" """  .$ !#")"!! "#%!&%")1%" 1.+1)""."=, ) 8   "" 1%". "31) 31 6$$ # 4)" "5 34%4"( % " "  .#45##.%"&%")("&%14."#!&5 %3 " "&%$!3 #""%"3"%1" "1"1+" "(" )"! " " )1. ! "  " "%"  ( % ")  #. +#"1. !  $

 

" . "1"# 3.5!&%"++$ )"! ! ! #"  $8$999 4 %. "31) 31." 6$ ! '$6  "1"5( " )"! ") ""%#. +% &5&&%""" 4)3 "#.#"."$. &5&&%""5411"%" "3 " 4)"377.%"$ )"!". %"! .11#.".(")"!" "#1.  &5&&%3..$ )# ." 1&5(" &5&&%"3.%!&%" 1)"! &1."  34%4"("! 3. #""!&" 3&%4)(1" 1"!4)" 1. "31)&".$ !3 5  .# .")%  =;9 )3 " $ )"!".)" "" )"(13.5##"#""%".$"+"."= )61&"5""##"%&&1(<##.%%3&"#(%43.5 (< " "##" "$ ! 3"5 )"! ! ! #. +%" +" ! ! #""  ." "% ! !%$

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

  ; ! "+%5"#%.#".$  )"!""1.%1)".4"1.".%14""34!"1.%"$ )# ." " .#"." # "." 14"" "$ #"" " 1&. %)" ""  . ! %%1 ""1" "" 1 1"". ".$ #"" "  " %&). 5. +"( #""( )( " ""1"))".!1"1."%%$ )"! " "1.  " ") ! " ) " ". #" " . " %%1  !  . .  "# $  !"))"! """31"4 %. "33"(.)"!"" .$  )"!!!1..14 "! %"1" "$  1. 3 " " &") 4." .%"1." ! 4"1." "%"$ 2 ". " "1.  "%1)"..%"1"")4"1.".$ 1:," "1&" "#!1! "#"."1." " 1"1." )14"" .%"$    ) 

# %"1" " ". ! &"%"1" " ". "1.%" "." ?   !

   @ = 6 "  "11" &" "# "." !4%  . %"1" " 3   ." %"1"  ." !%" " ! 1"1." 1. %&&%" " "1 "1. # %"1" "".&"$

 =; )3"  "5) .) 4#"."&"."$# 

 =; )"11)) ) 4#4 # )11$ " ")1116;(1(% ") 4#%.5;81$ )"!% )"%" 1$

 =8 )6 " )"!11.) 4#"."&"#&"%(#45 ) 4# "." &".  " #& ! %4 ") 3" " ( #"."

 ='&".$ #   =' )!' )%453 " " (" "1".( "" 3 " " "3 "#& !#! .!34!"1.. .$ 1)!&"" .% "5)"! ) .""#& !%4) 4#81$   ""5""" . "1"# !!1.."  =."'(;6'(;;(;8 )('6 )! '66 )$      !"## 1