Legislator Case Law & Legislation
3-04-191/3 ECLI:EE:TLRK:2006:3.04.191.10380 AI generated

3-04-191/3 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 3-04-191/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

              

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-04-191/3 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohus:               

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

           !"#$ " !       %&'(!%))*$    +,)-,&.&   / 0  1 ((!  +)')-'%))- !   +23&")2')*'%))-! -4!5!     6!+)')+'%))7!6"+, &2-28%))-          /0" ((! 3 !, 1 6      4'(!%))*       1"/0

!!" ((!   ' '   !"# $  !  6! +)')+'%))7 !  6"  +,&2-28%))- 39" 6!  !! (!6'   "(!! !! !!  / 0 " ((!  3 ! 1 6 6!'  %#&# %  !! 3  91 !6! 1  !  !6 +)3( "! ! ! !!   !'  ' !%'$" !(# 

((!  )*+*,+-,    ). ! !    !! 3  6 ' ' !6  139"6 "1! "4&(!6!563&# "/0!6 !564)"4%3%#' /0 ! 6 ! +23% ! !!! $  ((!  "(!!*.+*/+-, ,06!' 

+,)-,&.&  %7#   "!  !  !!6 1 !(3!! 3/0!5!6! +23& 6 ! -4' 1 39" 6 6:

6!!66!6! !"!6 '!+2! ; %++9 *' 1" ((!39"6!! !    !! 9!"" ((! !<<6"' 1"! -*++!!6$ !&*&7 1" 69!6 "5 "((6 1" 61')4'&&'%))+ ! 1" ((!

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

+,)-,&.&  +7#

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

((!   ! !!6916&2)2+$7)'       $ ! 916   366   !!6 !!  ! $ 6  3!'   !  ;,! 7  &  ((!  !  6 !"  , 6 !(!     ' "!  366   6  6  66'  ; - 3 % "(  !  3! 6!!!(! $61  !(!!!6 6 ' (  "666 ((!6"6   6'   "(!! / 0  1  6!$  36  6 ! !   "(!! !!" !6 !  6 6'  ; 24 ,! % !  1$ !  91 3  916 ( 66$ 6 !!  !   !  (" 9!! "(!!'  !      96  "!    1" ! =! !6 91$ 36  !!" "3<<66663 '  34! 3!"(!! ((! 3 ! 16!' 

+,)-,&.&  -7#    6! /03 ! 1    39" 6! ! 3"(!!!! !!'  #$5 $$ "!12'$%!%  3 ! 1! 6   39"!$6!! ! ! 1 !! / 0  1  6! "(!! (!  ' 3 !  !  !6 !6 ! 1"(!!  !!  66' (  6" 6!6"!$ !139"6 " 6!5  1!     &&$7 #$ 4) &%$) #$ 4& +$) # " 4% &-$7 # 6 !6   6  (5!  1"   ?  ' 6    6  33   "966' 6!    5 $ !9 6!! "6!6 ;%++% 139"6!6 !!  9!   !!!  9 !  " !!6139"6!6  "!  "'

  9!    !  !  $ ! 96  !6   6  ! ! 1 93 !!   $    1"  !   +2 6!6 !!'   ; %++  * 6!  !6  "  !6  6!# (! !: @ 5!  !5 1 !6   6 ! ! " 6    !  ((!6 !(!"    3$ !!1  !6   6     !! 3 '   9 !6 !! "!$    39"6 !!   "(!! "   !  ! !1  !5 9   9    6 !! !!53 1$9=55 !! !! 9!"!'  9! !! 3  9  1$ !  !  !    93( $ 61 ! !! 3   ! ! 'A ( 16!6(!  !! $ !!! "!  ! 1 '   !! !! 3 9!6$6    3(6 !!!6$ 6!! "! ! !6' !9!!$ 16!5 6 !6  $! 16!6!!$  !!6! !!! "!' ! !36    !    6 19  !  !    $ 6 !!  39" 6! 1  !'

!        ; %++  * ((! 66'  1" (61$ !! !!6    ! !!69 !  " !! $36!!"6 !9!6 6!  !56    366" 1"'  6 ! "' ;%++*     (! !!6 !! " !  ! 6  !6 5  "6 ! ! (5$!! =55 !! !! 9!"! ' !9!! 6  6 !(!!$  ?  ' ' 39"6 !!   "(!!$  !! ! !5 3 1 !  6 9  ?   !! !! 6 !1' (   " 1 "( 66$ !  !6     6  1" "   9  6!  3 ! 96  3!36!!$ 6!! "! ! !6" !6$ 6 ! 39"! '  1" (61$ !  !  +2  ! ! " 6 !6 '

     (!   9!'   1"!     !6   6  !! 9 "( !6' 6!!6! ! !   !! 3 66 !  "!!5!!! "!6  !5$ "  1" !56  %*$7"6  &-$7'   66 !!   !! " '  ' ' !56    " 4& !6   6  !!! 39" 6!( !! 9! ! ! "6 !"$ ! ' '  !!  3!6!!6 659  6! !' ! !  !"! 39" 6! '?55 !! !! 9!"( !! 9!" 1"    !6 5!   !!! 39" 6!$    3  ( !! 9!! ! !'

+,)-,&.&  77# "$ ! 1"(! !( 6!!  6 $ !( 6$ !!  6!! "6 ! 1 9  "(!! " 9 1 39"6  "  6 !56  1" !6   6' 9 ! 9 !     1" (6 $ ! 6  &-$7   6 !6   ! 6! !6$ ! 1"!1!<<6 ((!   !  ' B! !<<"96 91 !6  =55 ! ! !! 9!"  6  (!   !  6 ! 6' !  !   ! !!"$ !  1" (6  !!  !   !6! !56    39" $ 366!56 " 4&  1" !6   6'  1"  !6 6 3" ! " 6 !'  !6  1$ ! ((! 6 !669 ! +)')-'%))-! +23&93( ' 6 !-4  ! 1" 9 "(!!9 !! -4!5!  !!6 1 6!'  !6  6  /03 ! 1' 

  (  39"!  ((!  3 ! 1  6 '   !!"  !$ !  ; 24  % 961 916 ( 66$ 6 !! ! ("9!!"(!!'!3!!6  $ ! 6 (    9 ! !!  9! "(!! 916 (" 9!! 3 !$    " ! ! !!$ !  1 39" 6!! !  !6  ( 6  9 ! 6! 9 "(!! (" 9!! !6$   !  39" 6!6' !  9  (" 9! !!  916  "  " 39" 6!  6  ! 1    9!!$6  " !3 !  "6"6!6!  3!91!  ! '!3 156"  ! 6  9   6 3! !6 6!  ! !'  3  6" 9!   39" 6!6 "$  !  !  9!   6 '  !   96 "!36  !3 3!661!  !6 " 91 ! ! 39" 66'   !      9!    "'

636!139"6! 6  !! 3 !  !$ ,! !    5  ' / !  !  (! !6 5  ("6  !  !  6!'  !6   9!1     !  !  $ ! (   6  "6  6   6$    !6 9!   !  "6 '   5 !  !$ ! !6   366 ! !   '"(!!916 5! !! 6! 3  !39" $ !!!"36( 91!  ! "(  "6$ 3  "!!!!916 "!!36!'         !6  !