Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-22719/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.05.22719.11219 AI generated

2-05-22719/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-22719/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

  

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-22719/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval:   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

  

                   !""#$%!&   $%'! (#)(#"("$'&      +,+-+" !""#$%'! ! ..'*(' +#$%'!/"0"  

     

  1  2!3  #"&&$ 43 '!!( %"4( (3& 1 )"&'! -,+, #$$ ()*0"/5(&'/(&3#&            "430"61 2!3 #"&&$43 '!! $&'0"6(3&1    

 (0"*(#/3 3'*!&     7!%( 8!83&9:*4+;:-*4+;: *4+;:,*4+;: *4+<+;:=;&: ,<+ ;:

*4+=;:-,*4+;& 0" "#:,;#! (++-#3%'( !8&:<+;: *4+

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

  ,

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

+$%'!#!*!83)*0"/5(&'/( 3 "430"'"$'*3?#$%'!#!*!830'/(&'#$&'0"#" 8"0"#$&'0"'"$'*3?#$%'!#!*!830"$'"/(&'<$$*'3)"%3* )58&3*'+ "&'")"*'&()((*#$%'!/3 3'*!&3&3"8!&'(#!0"('3/3 3'*!&3&3"8!&'(#!"#3 8"/(&3&3"8!&3:, #$%"*8"'"#&3 3 3 ++-+"+ 05!&'! !8 &()((*#$%'!/3 3'*!&3 &3"8!&'(#! 05!&'!/(&' "*!&'"'!8 /3 3'*!&3 <!%!* /3 3'*!&#!*!83 0"$'"/(&3*3 0" 3 83 #( 8*"#&/"/(&3*3 &3 ( #3%'( !8 &()((*#$%'!/3 3'*!&3&3"8!&'(#!&&'3&'"'!'+  3 ++-+"+ #3%'( !8 &()((*#$%'!/3 3'*!&3&3"8!&'(#!:-*4+#$%"&3*'/5(&'"?#$%!& <$$*3 '"$'*!&3*; #33 #"&!#& $  $'&!& '3%'!8; '3(&3*' <$$*3*' &33 <$$*3 #"&!#& )*0" )"0"*(#!8 0" <5%03 8"'!8 #$%'!#!*!8+ (/3'"'!8 &3"8!&3 :   *4+  #$%"&3*' '!*3? )*0" /5(&'" #" "&0" *?()""'"/(&#!*!83 "<$&'(#!*!80"#!'&3'3#''3'$(/3'"/(&3#!*!8 :<+ + "430"$ #$%'!#!*! "'"&! !8%"4(")"*8!&33&('"/(&3*((4(*5()!&!//"&,+#$$ (+ 3&'("?"((#$ #" 8 !8#3&$*3)"%"4(/3 3'*3/(&3*"&0"*?()""'"/(&3#!*!83 "-+,#$$ (+ !!83#$%'!#!*!83#$%'"#$%'!*3'53 83(83&('"'!83($*3+

 



$%!&$ &3(&!#$%"*;3'#!()58#$&'0"$ )(()('" !83&('"'!8")3'3'"&!/(&34"$%#3/#!(""&'" 34" $* !8 &!!'3*( 3 )5*" '"&!/(&3#& #$%'!)*(&' #$/<$/(&&*"%3 8!&' '343/"; <$* !8 %"430"* )5*"&!//" )*0" 5!8/(&3#& #$%'!&&3 <@@8!/(&3*3 "*'3 "'(()(+ 3*'$$8! "*!&3* <3"? #$%!& <5%03 8"'!#&#$%'!#!*!)*0"/5(&'/(&'#$&'0"*'+ $%'! (#E"#((E

 9   )(#"("$'&  $%'! (#