Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-1383/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.05.1383.9333 AI generated

2-05-1383/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-1383/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-1383/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja:   #     '9$"&$&''"$$  &,$"' % %6 % 2 *  46%<*2==2! *; 1 ! 1  =! 4 > ? >@&#'61$%97# A4 2!!3$ 21!!4 !6%  2%1214 2;  1  6$46$26$ =6 $ 3  ! $ 1$   =0 "-$'"$&''&$$ %1 4= % %! $'"&9#'''(#  = % 4 1   %$      =0  1   %  $  =0 &7$'9$&''&$$ 1  41% !   ! 1    B C 77 1&  21 %% ,'''$'' 6  ! 1   ! %4  %%221%4 !%416  4  6%2%4 1%! 1%1%6  = 4 =2=6%1! C9'=")"&,4  $!4 .$&'*&&6=0%!  '"&9#'''#(#  %! /$ ! 1      4 %% ! '9$"&$&''"$$6"9*$ 4  >  * > @&#'6 1$ % 97# A     !% %% !    2 =1   "( &9,-'776 4%    %=  .,"/$4 > * >@&#'61$%97# A %!!%%%  0 . %1  %=   / 4   =1 .=   "(#-#+#&/6  = '"$'"$&''"$*,"$"&$&''"$$.$,'/$ =    4   !%   2%!  = =1    21 &,+'''$''  !  !%!1 4   !4 2 22%"+'''$''.$,9* #+/$  5 32",$',$&''&$$% 4  =1.= "(#-#+#&/    2! &,&'''$''  .4  > * > @&#' 2 2  &,+'''$'' 6 %  % 2   24! =1!1%2%%,'''$*/ 24! *;.$ "'6""6&#*&+6&(6&-6*&76,,/$  ! 32% %   0    2 4  > * > @&#'6%%33 1&9'''$''.$+(*+"6+-*(#/$  0   % 21!!2!32 !%%&'+'''$''!   !% %%"&''$''.!"("''9,@/$ 2 3%  4   4%    2=1 .= "(&9,-'776 2=  "9$'-$&''"$$*,"$"&$&''"$$/ 32 1!     . =  / C 9 1" ! ,"  ! =   !6 221!1 ? 42 .$-,*-#6-967#*"-,/D $12 %%,#&($''&($',$&'',$$.!"(&''",/) $2E2 %%++7$''.!"(&''"'/)

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                 

              !  

     "#$%&''($$)%!     &*'+*",-,.&*"*",+/      0    1 1   2 !32 ! ! 14 $ 1  &"-#+($''        

     5 .1$ "'"''"(-6$  "7 "'"&# 6  ! 8*5 %6 $ ((9""+#:+"#,-"(   1    ! 1   141;  %   !2  2 2       "#$2;&''($$1    ! "    # $ %  &"  '(    )*+,-. /            0  1   2      #  $          #        %      345    5   

        5    6              77            

  #

8     

   5     0 6  

         

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

$3 E2 %%,'+($''6"-$'"$&''&$$.!"(&''""&/) $=2 %%&,9-$''"-$'"$&''&$$.!"(&''""/) $42 %%"79$'''"$'&$&''&$$.!"(&''"+/$  1!!  %%&(#'$''$ %1! 322!%%&"#("($''!   %%,-#'$''$   % 5%  

24! C##-; 24 26%1 ! =32% $  C ,-9 !    C "-  ; !   4 41 !22 !3 1 2!% %%= $ 2C#-1&=#  !41  14 !   4  2 ! 26  !   4  2 !  %  2214 !%41$ C#-1,1! 414 !!%=4!  $ % ;1!14!2&"-#+($''!2%1! =! 1   2 = !=32%$ 1! ;6  ! = ! % '9$"&$&''"$$ 1 1! =  32%=4!  12 !  %! 1$

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

  !$ < 1%  =$#$,$&$     !% ! 32%!6%=4!  ;!%4 % 4$ ! ;6  4  % %  41 6   24!    2 4  !%41 3 6  1% 2214 !%411%1!! %2$!6! 1%41= 4 2 !16   24! .$   ; ! % 1

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

1  !%$4 > * >@&#'61$%97# A

 !%%%! 2 =1"(&9,-'776 4%    %=     .$,"/$ % 4     !!%%%  0 . %1 %=

 / 4   =1 .=  "(#-#+#&/6  =  '"$'"$&''"$*,"$"&$&''"$$.$,'/$

1    412 1 33 4=4!% !  ; ! % 1! =      %    4 % 12    !  = .! / %  % 4 16 ! !  24  %% %! 1$  !    ! 1   1     .2$ 1 = /$ 1   12 %   24!%!6%32 1!$=%1   1!41 1! 322!%% $;6 %!!! ! 1    2  % =4! $ 1   32 2!%%     ! =4!  $   6  ! 1   2  1 4   3 1%  %     %  !!%1!; 1!!1141 %!% 241 %%2 %$ !%=4!46% !! 1  121!!$ !%%%!    24!  ! 1    4   24!  ! =

1    ;   .%% %! /$ 1 = ;  26   !%; 24!12242%1!!$  = %1     2  = 24% 2   1! =    32 %% $  ;6  1!      % 4 1 .41 =2%/ 4   % 4   ! = ; %%2 %$ ! ; 1!  2!%4% 2! &'+'''$'' ) ! 7("($''   ! !    ,-#'$''   6  1  &"-#+($'' $ !6    24!   ; ! % 1 % .2 !  /   ! 3% %   0% 2 %% ",-'''$''  .2$ %% $("/       !%% 2 %$ C#-1,;!2!%4%!% $  '"$'"$&''($$% !%  % C,     !4%   % =   %  !% !    %%    2%   $C('1"%4;=6 6 =2!=2! !=4!   $1! % 2!%4%! $ 2 142 C*"(1"! C*+91"1!142%2; $;6C+91& 6!%!44624;!2;  %%  % 1 $  ! 2;; !; =% 1 = %6 %  %4 213$!!%=4!%! 1  $   1% ! ;  2  C*  #,#*#+#6  '"$'"$&''($$   C* #(*(+$