Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-13747/2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.05.13747.9790 AI generated

2-05-13747/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-13747/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-13747/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja:   *  !"*1  +)- 3"4 2&,&%-% )-,** )!& !",#+-"! %++%2, &&&,%+)-"(",-" "*-&%-568 ,!  ,! #8,! %-&2*)!&+(2&!-,&%-,32)#"(*-* %+#%--&%+)-&-(!&,"%+,,#(*"",&%-*"*(*"*,*%+)-%-"! %-&*%+)-&-(!&,""&&,-(-*#&"&,-&"32)#-"%+)-,""&"(-*-&"&+," %+#%+)-,")"!",(-*",#-)-,,+"4%+)-)!"#"&-*<%&,&"*&"*%+# 3++, +%2"-%  8   ,!  ,+","-* !",#+-" "!"& ,&&* #+,-&* (-#"&"&("  ,  8  ,!  2&4 %&#",* + !",#+-" ,# # =2)#"(* + !&%"7%("2&!-,&%32)#"(*-  !&+(2&!-,&%-,32)#"(*-*8 *"!    9   ,8  ,! -,"4%+)-&"*&(2-""%+)",&&&,#%&(*,%-*)#% , ,"3&(!- 2& "*-" ""," (&(!  8  %+)", "& +," ,-4-* 7)"3++,(" %"",*-&("%+)-&"&&"8"4"%-&2,!(&%"&&*%+)-&2&"&&* "*(2-""%+)",+(%+)--*)7&%""*&+&,"",,"!"%&-*%)#-"*-" 8 9 ,! #!&%+)-&"&&2&*%","*-","2&,"3&(!-,"!*&&&"! 8 9 ,! %+)",&&&"%,+"%""*-"2&,"3&(!-!%&(*,%-*)-

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

 

   

  !"#$! 

  !     % ! $ &    ' () !$ $ $$*$ $ !+,-+-./0!  *1  11 11 !"# $ %& '&(( )!"# "&(*# +,&%&# ,-",,#+(-*+.&%+#/","(."(&%+  ! !&"(",- # $ !"#$ 

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

&&&,&(

  5 2,- 2#- 32)#-" +,"+,- %-& )!&,"  #&" 3-)-, +,& )!& %+#," 2& " "&(*#," +&"-* %" --, &&&, %-& &&%,&%-, ,,%&#-7,"(*&"!  -& !",#+-" "+,-&++( ")& "% ,#(*"",&%-*"*(*"*2&4%#"&*1 3" #++%-, %+)-+-" "+,-&++(& &,-&" ,#(*"",&%-*"*(*"* -& !",#+- ")& "","(",-" ""2- " %+#"&(-*)"!",%&#,&%-,%+)-,"-,"4 %#," ,&* %2&% # "",&&" ,23-,"&&&"%#,&%8 9(2-""," %&#,&%-#"&&",-%"%-#+(& 4 &&!&,2&-," 3++,", )!&)&((, -#+( -   %++(& -,"4 -* )(*-&(&""&-& 5"!&&%++* 

6 3(!%+(+," (3(! ( 

9 9 2& 3(!%+(+," : :"& $)&3(! (



99 1 5&&"(-4"

1 ",!&-; %# "&&" %-#+( &&&,# ( 

6 # "&*%+)-,"",,"%+)%"%+,*-"-#+(& "&+,"#"&*%-&)!&,"#&"3-)-, +,& )!& %+#," 2& " "&(*#," +&"-* %" --,&&&,%-&&&%,&%-,,,%&#-7,"(*&"!  !",#+- #2--4 %-& ",," 3"," "& "& %# 2&%-&%##"%",4&  +)-+-" ,&%-, "% "!"&" 3" +( 



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

&&&,&(

 

&,," 2,!(&% +( %+)--* - %""*&+&," %+)-&" &"&&" 2& &"(2-""%+)" &&" "&& &&"! &&&&" %+, ,  8 

 ,!  (2-""%+)", "+-* &&(" ,23"4 %+)-&" +# +( #(-* & ,"3&(!-,&"* %+)--"* +4&&,","<+(&&*","""(-"""-&"+""!-,"4%+#,)!"#%-%2,!("- - 1 %++(&#&&& 1 %++(&%+%%-   %++(&,#2&  &&&,%+)-"(",-" "*-&%- # &""(",-" "*-&%- %"(*&" "*-" 5 #  %6 8  %+)", %+),*%" "((" %"+," "*-" #2--& ,--* "(",-" 3-)-, "(",-%-,-*" #+&"," # ("(*" %&(*,%&"," "(& %")&(-* &&&,%+)-"(",-""*-&%-"-""!%--,-4%-(&  

%")&(-*8  ,! # ,! ,-",%+#,,#2&&","#,&%#32)#"(*-*%+)-%-,->)!&,*-", --* &&!&,2& -

 %++(& 2&!-4&%-,-* -  1 %++(& (&(! ,#(*" ",&%-*"*(*"*"*",*&%-,-*-

%++(&)!"#%-%  +)-""4+-""",++*--,"(",##-)&(*-*"8 *"  ,! ,!      4+ +)-(&%