Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-469/4 ECLI:EE:TLRK:2006:3.05.469.9929 AI generated

3-05-469/4 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 3-05-469/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

+,)-,.*/  +9.: 8 !" "!"  18!" #"#!        0 6 7   "  #"" ''# !2  !#2#!80"3"& #!0'0 "!82#22#"!  8"2;+((##"!&  ; +(  ( !2    2 8# "'0! !#! 82# !022#"!" #!!2"!22"  & 12" ;, $(  3 !! 82!2  3 !23"82!2";+(82!2#"& 822#"82# !";+((2!'0 '0  #! #&    8" 2 " "'0! !#!8#!"!"&"20"! $))<,8#8# !2!"0""'0!&"& 2!';(/ +(;++& 8 0   "  0 3 !! 82!2 !   !3!!82!2#" !#"!"& !##!""230#.)#!'0  "2!8#8#!#!!"#"! 82#22#"!  8#8#  ; +(  (  '"  !#  2! "'0! $)) < ! #&  "   !"   0 !"#  "'0! !#!& 8" # 0  '"  3 !!82!2#!& "#  "   8>>#" '8    ?  8 " 8  "  !  !0 '0 #& "   "8"3""&!33##!?2"  #>>"  2"&    ; +(  $ !"  '""& 8 '"" ! " '0! "" "  ! "'0! !#!!"#80828#" "!8#2"  "  !" !!   !0  ! '0 #&  '!!"#8!"& 8"''08""0"""#"&        80,!   89 ,  ' 80#"!& "#     !0 '0 ! "  " '0!20"!'0!#& "'0! # #" '0! !  "    !08"!!0'0#0& 8!80""# !!"0 2""'0!!#!#"'0!& ;+('"82!2!"2#"" '0! !#!    !#  ! !33"  "# 1#  ()  !33""!2 !"  ! '0 " !'& '  8"0 ! 2 # '"" '0! #! "'0! &  8   ""  !33  " "& ;+($2'""&## !33"! "3"!"  !2!82"! 8"8!&

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-469/4 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

            !"#" !      $%&!'#())*     +,)-,.*/   0 ,  ! 12 ! $.&)+&())- !#$+*$3!2"    "$*&$$&())-#+,%/45)-        6780      #!      067

,!12!,    !" #  $    ! %&'%%'())* +,-./0)*  '  1"2" 1  '  8 20 

 "

 " 0+)8'#'!&  $  1$#! 3"  ,  ! 12 ! # 6 7 8 ()).&   8!0# "##" '0! #! 2& # !  %4')+'())*

  %+&%  !  6," 7 ! ## '0! !! (-()))#'0!#!!$/+..#&     6 7 #" '0!" 9: ; (/    # "'0! !0 !33"" 1# ()  !33 "! " !#8"'0!&6&!#""!0 '0#0& 67'!'#!"# ;+($0 !#"""'0!!#! 08  "  !  !0 '0 #0& '  !33" 82# !0'0&  6 7  $+&).&())- " ,  !& ,  ! $%&)-&())- "'67#"!& $+     5 #& 080! '!8'2"! #9 !"; *(:&

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

''0#!0&00"!02#" #"2##"!&  ! %&'%%'())* +,-./0)*'0#"!& !";(/,$0 "'0!0!# 8" !"!!0!2!'02; .(!"& #"#!33! !" !"  !0 '  " !"  0 #" "  !  " !0 '0 0& 33 "!  ""  ''#  !33""!0'0& ;+(,$0 ""'0#"'0!"'0! !#!!"" !08" !   !0 '0 !  # !# "'0! !''#! ' !  '0 & 2 ( 0    '0 ! '! ' # ' 82# 22#"!  3#" # !33& 0!#!0'0#0 2!"# 2 ""   0 8"0 2 "'0!  !#!& 0 ' '0!"'0!!#!2!2  8"0& ;+($(!"2#"! #0#"  #   "" "" 2 ! !" 2" !! #!!##!&  9 :=

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

0 ;+($282";,$(&  9 :=

+,)-,.*/  .9.: 6 7 '   "       80 #"&  "#: ## ! 8;$#1 1 

!0" ;(/$ 2 ! # '0! !#8     2  ; +(  ( #"!& 

20!"#"'#"&0 ; +((02!#"'0!$))<,!#!  2&;+(('80!8##2$'""'0! !#! 82!2"    '0  82# 22#"! " '0 '!2$"""'0!!#!##!&! 0  !#!  &  ; +(  $  #"" 3    ###" ! 0 8  " 3 !  !0 '0 !&082;+("!&0 !#3!0'0!&  0 '"   ! 3"" "" ! !#  !  ! !''#!338"'0#''!" 822 " !#8& 8   !# #"  8" '0#''! 0!!88#"&3"!""" 8" "!!'#!''# !!0'""&8'# 82"!0"!"#!"'#!'!&  08";+(,$(#"! 8#"3  !!"8#8#0!2"#""& 

 20 !"#  "   "'0!  !#! #   2#" ! 8#0 #!& 0  8 '"" " 9     !0 '0 ! 2#"    !!!0'0!: 2##""   3   "  " 3 !0 '0 ! 9#"0;(/$: ! !'0#09#"0 ;+($:&6!!82!22#" 0 082#!022#"!#0"!"'0!! #  "    0  ! !0 '0 #  !#!  0& "'0!!#!22" !82#2!      !  ! 2 !0 '0 #0 " 0 2 &   80 ''0 #"!  8   8" " 3! &   

 #"  !  9 :=