3-06-272/4 ECLI:EE:TLRK:2006:3.06.272.9057 AI generated

3-06-272/4 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohtu halduskolleegium

Case Number 3-06-272/4

Court / Authority Tallinna Ringkonnakohtu halduskolleegium

Jurisdiction

Estonia (EE)

Decision Date 2006-03-10

Outcome Kohtumäärus

Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

! 0 @ 4 ,! @ @ @ 0@ -- (! - ++- 5 + 3# + , 0 - !! 0 * + - -- !! @ 0-

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-272/4 · Tallinna Ringkonnakohtu halduskolleegium: ! 0 @ 4 ,! @ @ @ 0@ -- (! - ++- 5 + 3# + , 0 - !! 0 * + - -- !! @ 0-

Full text

!"# $%#%"&" ' (

"& "# "%#)"$$*+ , - . ( "# !! - $%#%"&"

'!! ( ( ' - -- /

!

' ! "#$ %&&' ()&')%*% +, # -++.+ -

!!0 !! ( - 1,2"" 34 +!+-!+ / 0#

! - 0

5/ 61 ("$$*4 %0# %&&1

1(' 0

- 0',8 %/9 -:; <

= >8 9

; + 0

' ; ; 10 4? 0 0

' 0

,8 %/9 - : ; <

0

= >8 9

; + 0

'0

; ;

$%#%"&" "1&4

0

10 " 4 !

0

$ - 0

,2*3 "0

- - - - -

@ -0

A'0

3.".*.

+ %*# %&&' %)&'2&%0((3 - '

- +

" -( "3 !

3$# ' 0

* /* ' 0

/*- %#' $ ( "# , - 0

"& "# + - ( ! - - ( 0

- 0

- - 1/B4 !-

( @ - A ( ! - 0

@ - % '

-

+ - - 0@ @ -

- 7 - 7 @ 0 -

- - 0- 4 0 0-

0

- @ 0@ --C 4

0

0! 0(! / ! - ' 0

- ! @ 0 @- - @ ( , 0 @

( -- - -- @ -(

( @ - @- 0@ @ @ ? "4

! ' 0

@

-

( ( -

A

-0! @ + ;(-

- 7

- -0 - (

@ -!!? $4 0

@

- ( @ 1 @ @ (-4

- - -? *4

-

-

, 2 " "

- !- 0@ @ (

-

,2#* @

$

- - @ (0

0 ? 34 ( - @ !

( @

0

( - @

- @ 0- - -

(+ ; D : E 9 ; + - 7 7 - B (# "#$ %&&' 1 0 *4 ! @ - 0@ --C 4 ( @00 - ( 0

- !! @ @ 0 + @- - ! -! -

( - - @-- @ - ( ! -

-@ ? "4

! -

0

# "3 0

!0! ("3 /B 0 - 0

$%#%"&" $1&4 @ F 0! 0

!0! 0

@ @00. "#? $4,!(+ 0

- @/B% ! --! ! 0

0

0 !( , 0

@ ! @ 0

F 0! !0! ( 0

@ ! @0( , 2 . " !( 0

@0 - /

@0(0!+ -( @ 0

@00 0

@ ! @00 0 @ ! 0

@ 0@ 1, 2 . " 0 34

- - + - 0

@ @ ! GG-. "#? *4 , 2 * @

- " !- + - - 0

@ ! 0 @ $ !( - 0

@ !0

- - @ 0

0 0

@ 0 @- @ -- ;0 -

- ( @00 ( @(0 @ +

( 0

-( 0

- @0( 0

@

- !!- !0! ! 0

@ ! 0

- 0! ! GG- 0 - 0

@ ! @00 -

- -+ -,2* @

$!-

@

0

0 ? 34

! 0

0

- ( 0 - ! - ( 1 0 0

! 0 @ 4 ,! @ @ @ 0@ -- (! - ++- 5 + 3# + , 0 - !! 0 * + - -- !! @ 0-

@ 0-

0

/ - -

0 !! (0@ --C 4 0

! @00 - ( + ( @

@ ;

" -( "3

!

(0

- !

-- !

+ ( -

- - @ - 0

@ ! -! + - 0

- ( @ 0 @0 F0! (

"F "3 - "%$)3)3

- 0 0

@ - 0

@ ! , 2 . " 0

3 ( - 0

@0 0

@ !GG- - 0

@- - -0

-0

( 0 @ -? "4 - 0

@0(,2* 2. "03 0

@ !GG- - 0

(! - @ ,2& @

"!-0

- ! - !!

0 @ /! 0 0

- !!(

$%#%"&" *1&4 !( - -+ 00A@ - 0 0

- @( - - - / ! - !

( (@ -- 0

, 0 @ 0 @- @ @ (@

/ 0

!(

( - @--

- 0

7 - 7

!- @

0 !!(

- ! 0(

( @ - -

- - - - -( ! -! @ ? $4 -0

! (0 - ! -( @ ! - @ 0@ - - @ -( ( - -0@ -

-0

0 ? *4 ( @ ! @ 0

-

- - 0 !

- - @

! A--

0 ( 0 @ @ - ,2& @

"-! -!

-@

; - @ - -

@ 7

- ? 34

0 ( ( -

0

0 , - - 0@ - ! ( ( !

! - ! @0

! ( @ 0 / ! - -( ( @ -@ @- 0@ @ 1#

+ $ 0 ! !! ( - ! 0@ - C 4 - @ -! -7

@

! - - -@ (00

? "4(@ (! -

!

(0

-

-0

!!0!

0 +

"$ ( "# !

." - 0

@0 , 2 . " 0 $ , 2 * @ " ,2. "0$ 0

@00 0

,2" @

-

+ 0! 0!0

@00

-

- - --# ! "# /

- 0- @ -

0 ( 0@ -- ? $4 ( !

@ -

- - ! - @ - 1 4 ! ! ? *4 (

"F "3 - "%$)3)3

- ! - ! 0

( , 2% * ! --0

! - 0

@

0

@ ! GG- -- 0

-- (

$%#%"&" 31&4 ! 0

F -( "3 !! - "% $).$)3! -- - @ -! ? 34 ! - 0

@0

@ ! GG- - - 0 0

-- , 2 *# - 0

@ *0!GG- - /

- + 0

- 0

- @ - + - 0

@ ! ,2*# ! ( ( 0 @ - @ A 0

- + -? #4,2* @

$ @ + -0

+0! 0

@ ! @00 !0

- !! ( ! - 0 0

- , 2 * @ " -@ -(0 0

- ,2* @

$ - @ - - - - - -

0 !-! - ! (@ ? '# $ - !! ( ! 0@ - C 4 - !! - - @ ? "4 !-

"& "# -

GG- - - 0

@ !

"$ ( "#

!

." - 0

5/ 6 1

( "$$*4 0

@0 ? $4

0

- @0- @ - 0

0 ! 0@ -- @

*#+), !! ( ( - 5 +67! -- "#, - ! @ - 0 0@ - 0

@ ! GG- -0

- ,2%-*2. "0

3 @00 - ! ( 0 - ! - ( 1 0 0

! 0 @ 4@ ( @ - - @00 - ( ( ! @ -

0 ( @ @ - 0 @

0 ; @ !! ( ! - ( 0 @ - - -( ( ! @

! @0 - ( (-

$%#%"&" #1&4 8#(0

--

"F "3 "%$)3)3 -

- ! C5;

0 0(

@ -0

@ ! ,2. "0%3 ( - 0

@0 0

@ ! GG- - 0

@- - - 0

- 0

( 0 @ - ; - ! -

! 0- -0

--! @00 , 2 * !( 0

@ ! F 0! - 0 $ @ ( 0 0

@ 0

--

-- ! ( ! -- 0

! - 0

@ 0

@ ! GG- --0 0

-- 6

1

0

0 4 -

- - -0

-

- - - + - -

- @0 -

F -( "3!! - "%$).$)3 @ - ! 0@ -- 0

@ ! GG-( @0(,2%*2. "0

3! - - @ -

- - - (0

GG- -

- @ - @ - @ @0 !

@ @ (

- - 0

- - !

- + -

@ + - ( 0

@00 -

! ! C 5/

@00 - - 0

@-0

( 0 @ - " F "* !

- - ( 0

% -0 + - -- ( +

- -

-"* "* !

- - -@ @

@ !

- - +

@ - 7

0

@ @00

- 6 ! ( ! -

- "%$).$)3+

" "* !

( 0

- 3 "*

!

+ - !

( 0

- "* "* !

@0 0

,2. "03 0&# ! (

( "3 - 0

@ 1F 0! 0

!0! 4 @00 . "# -0

0

@ !0

- 0 ! 0

-- 00#

!!( , 2 * 2 . " 0 3 @ - - ! -- --

!

- -

( 0

- !

+ ( +

- - 0

- !

+ - - 0 @

+

@ -7

0

@ @00 -. "# (0

@ @00 - , 2 *# @

- @ - , 2 * @

$ @ 0

@ !0

- 0

$%#%"&" &1&4 @ -( ! GG- @00 - - ! - !! ( ! - - !! + !! @ -