Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-13958/2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.05.13958.7633 AI generated

2-05-13958/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-13958/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-13958/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

 

   

   !"#$!



  !     % ! $ &    '  (!$  $ $)$ *+,-./0 !   $ $  *+,-./0 ! .!!!012/.34! )(  (( (( !"# $ %& '&(( )!"# "&(*# &+" ,"( - ./+&(/" 0(%1 !"(//2 %1# 3"(&1(*"(%1  ! !&"("+/ # $ !"#$



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

&&&+&(

   - 1+& &(!&/* 5#/ 65)#/" # 5&7 "&* 5+/ 5#/ 65)#/" 1+"1+/ %/& )!&+"  #&" 6/)/+ 1+& )!& %1#+" 5& " "&(*#+" 1&"/* %" //+ &&&+ %/& &&%+&%/+ ++%&#/8+"(*&"!  /& !"+#1/" "1+/&11( ")& "% +#(*""+&%/*"*(*"*5&7%#"&* 6" #11%/+ %1)/1/" "1+/&11(& &+/&" +#(*""+&%/*"*(*"* /& !"+#1/ ")& ""+"("+/" ""5/ " %1#"&(/*)"!"+%&#+&%/+%1)/+"/+"7 %#+" +&* %5&% # ""+&&" +56/+"&&&"%#+&%9 :(5/""+" %&#+&%/#"&&"+/%"%/#1(& 7 &&!&+5&/+" 611+"+ )!&)&((+ /#1( /   %11(& /+"7 /* )(*/&(&""&/& -"!&&%11*

42 6(!%1(1+" (6(! ( 

 : 5& 6(!%1(1+" , ,"& $)&6(! (



:4  -&&"(/7"

4:: "+!&/; %# "&&" %/#1( &&&+# ( 

 2 # "&*%1)/+""++"%1)%"%1+*/"/#1(& "&1+"#"&*%/&)!&+"#&"6/)/+ 1+& )!& %1#+" 5& " "&(*#+" 1&"/* %" //+&&&+%/&&&%+&%/+++%&#/8+"(*&"!  !"+#1/ #5//7 %/& "++" 6"+" "& "& %# 5&%/&%##"%"+7&  1)/1/" +&%/+ "% "!"&" 6" 1(





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

&&&+&(

  

- &++" 5+!(&% 1( %1)//* / %""*&1&+" %1)/&" &"&&" 5& &"(5/""%1)" &&" "&& &&"! &&&&" %1+ +  9 

 +!  (5/""%1)"+ "1/* &&(" +56"7 %1)/&" 1# 1( #(/* & +"6&(!/+&"* %1)//"* 17&&+"+"<1(&&*"+"""(/"""/&"1""!/+"7%1#+)!"#%/%5+!("/ / 4: %11(&#&&& 4: %11(&%1%%/  : %11(&+#5&  &&&+%1)/"("+/" "*/&%/ # &""("+/" "*/&%/ %"(*&" "*/" - #  %2 9  %1)"+ %1)+*%" "((" %"1+" "*/" #5//& +//* "("+/" 6/)/+ "("+/%/+/*" #1&"+" # ("(*" %&(*+%&"+" "(& %")&(/* &&&+%1)/"("+/""*/&%/"/""!%//+/7%/(&  

%")&(/*9  +! # +! +/"+%1#++#5&&"+"#+&%#65)#"(*/*%1)/%/+/>)!&+*/"+ //* &&!&+5& / :  %11(& 5&!/7&%/+/* /  4  %11(& (&(! +#(*" "+&%/*"*(*"*"*"+*&%/+/*/

%11(&)!"#%/%  1)/""71/"""+11*//+"("+##/)&(*/*"9 *": : +! ::::::+!      71 1)/(&%