Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-531/1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.05.531.7342 AI generated

2-05-531/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-531/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-531/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

    

  !"#  

     $ !  $#  # %$# &% $$%%%%  !" #!$%$#&'(! '#$(" $#$# $$  $)#!"( $"# !"#



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

   , ;*  ,< ,=< , ; ;

($$$"($#

  031  '*!" 

($!!/*$"/(&'*("!0!" 1'"$4 

44 (.")$!/ -.(( % (&'!$'(! )55$"%$##!/&'!$'(! &('"$* )6'  $#$# '!$ '(!)$( *!&" '"$ *  ) $"( '#$("  $#$#$ &( (.$!$( 7(!$(! ,"  #)" ""$(( "&'*! &( *&&( &''( !$( #$( ") (!"!  -.( 8$##"$!( %''"! ," (!!/ !.#/$" .!$ '#$("  $#$# $(!$)$("!    )*  4 443  8$##&'*!



 44'!((0!(" '!((1!($$$"( (9 4 '"$* #)! $""*!!/""&( &(6'  $#$#$"#/&''('#$(" $#$# #$"$'"#/ 5*$(!) %$/)$(!*&'!$')#/)$(&("#(6'  $#$#')!!!!&,(! 

  44&''(!(* )!(!)#/$)$('"$!.(!!/#'!"$#$ &'%''"!) !(!)#/$(%,#/(* )&'')&(!/& -.("$##(%  (&'!$* " !)##"" $#$#$"&("#)"   



($5"")$#$!/&'!&'!$')#/$&( 

4 

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

&''#$#$#'#$(" $#$#$'"&#/#/ &"!($(""5""%$/)$(&(,('"" "'#* !22!    %" (!/ !/ $$$"'$ !()$((! !##$(!/  -.( "$##( %  (&'!$&()$($'"(#/6'  $#$# '#$(" $#$#$5*$(!##$(!/ !'#$(" $#$#$"%/.$((#/6'  $#$#%,#/"&'!$#,'" 

 

 &'*!$(!#$" %"( *  !##$(!/  -.( "$##( %  ( &'!$')#/$ 6'   $#$# "*(&(  ! '#$("  $#$#$" %/ .$( (#/ 6'   $#$#%,#/"(""&'!$')#/$#,'"   , > ;  '(! ') 



&'*!"($!!/(!((0!" 1!##$(!(*$#$#%"((!/!/ )#!"(&"/!()$((!  

  =< , ;   '*( !!#/ !'$)$& &$ "$& )! "$/ *$###/ !($$$"&'*!)#!"( (/(!$& 0(1; " !"#"!!($$$"( (($!!/!.#/$/$&5"("!!,$"$&"! ' &!$$("!

($$$"($#

  ##/ &')$( "$ ') ($(#/)( &'*("! ! *$ '#  %.* #/!/  &" ( *"/)$("  ($$$"( (($!!/!.#/$!'#!,$"$&"!!.#/)$(!"$/#/ ,)$(/( '"/<  !6'  $#$#'(!$(4 

44  -.("$##(% (&'!$ $)!!/( '"'#&'*(!(!#/4 

44 '(! )55$"%$#"("0!" 1  ! '#$("  $#$#$  6'   $#$# $" "*!!$  8$##&'*!



 44'!((0!(" '!((1)$( .(!(

 44$)!!/( '"'# &'*( !(!#/  8$##&'*!



 44 '!(( 0!(" '!((1 !($$$"( (# 4 0!" 1  !  



 !$ +/ $ &$##$(!( '(&'##  -.( "$##( %  ( &'!$')#/$ &$##$(!($(!$'( # = 3 6'   $#$# #$)" $)!!/( '"'#&'*(!(!#/&$##$(!)$('!((0!" 31  ! 4 

 6'   $#$# ($ $)!!/ ( '" '# &'*( !(!#/ ()!##$(!(>8# 3 ==0!" 1  (!"!%&'##(/(0/(%$/$:1; 3" " $"&(!"$&(/')#/!/ '#$&(/5*$(  :; " &'*("! $#!)')#/$(##$"")$(!'"#/()!$ !)%''"!$"&(!"&$#&.$%,$)$(!"')#/!/#$##*$$  %%!"$$&!!(  '*("$!* '#&'*!"%$$("! #"!!.#/#/!&'!$/(($"%   -.($#')#$&&('"$* )6'  $#$#  '*("$! -.("$##(% (&'!$')#/$('""#/$(!$&(/ '#$(" $#$# 6'  $#$#5*$(&(&###/$"(*!/".%%($/ 443(!" 8$##&'*!



 44'!((!($$$"( (# 4 '#!(!!/!'#$(" $#$#  6'  $#$#$"#/&''( 443(!(!&# $#$#",&(!$(#$( / -.( 8$##"$!((    444 !.#/$(! # = '# #,* ! '#$("  $#$# '"$ ($((&$ !!/ /(($" %   -.( "$## "!(   4=4 &#$  4 443 #$# '"$ ,"  $(!$!/ #)" (! )55$"%$# "(" '(!$( 6'   $#$#  -.( "$##( % (&'!$4 

44 '#&'!')#/!/%"6'  $#$# '#$("  $#$#$$"(*!".%%)$(!  # &'*( !(!( !6'   $#$#')#/( -.("$##(% (&'!$ %"$"(*!".%%)$(!'#$(" $#$#$($$('#(&'!6'  $#$#"*(  '#$(" $#$#$"%/$(#.$(%,$/6 $#$#"&"#/&'!  :,$)$((/( ;

 &'*("! ," (! #'! %,$)$(!##$(!( %,#/$ (!.!#/ %,$ " )%*$" ,$," (!#'!%,$)$(!##$(!(&$$($&%,$)$(.$( ("""!( '#%$$("!!.#/!/    '# %22/#/ &'*!(( !(!)&( !  -.( "$##( %  ( &'! '"$ !) (#/ ) 6  $#$# "*( #$# !   $#$#$" %/ .$( (""" &'!$" (""&(!%,(!#'!$"!(/%,$)$(!##$(!(&'6'  $#$#"&"#/&'!$"      ;  8$##&'*!= 

),,('"$* (!!/$$$".$!()$((!*$"/( ($!)$("

($$$"($#

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

333  3       )' '*!#$&