Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-538/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.04.538.10154 AI generated

2-04-538/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Paide kohtumaja

Case Number 2-04-538/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                              !     

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-538/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Paide kohtumaja:                               !     

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                              !     

  "#$%"##&$!         "'#(')*+                              ,-! ,!-  !!!%  -      !  .  !-   !!  !  

  

 */$."##&$!     "#$%# &   

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

  012(*030,9...0...5.!   .$ ,  9 % 1! !9 5.   1! 1,  , 91..0, 9  9. . !9 ...900.,00.$     0 ,. ... 00  .   0 10.!0$@09,91..0!09!! ! .0$ ,  .! *'"'/'()'#( .!  , .  ,,5.,...!0..!.9,,0 0....90,!91,, 00 1 .. ... !0   0 0$ ,  , ,0.,$ ,!.950%0110 ...    !..  1 0! ! 0  .15.. ! 9...,1!$ , 9% 10.  !. .% .! 1,! 2A3 B /)& ., " ., .!0 ? . . 0,, 0!!  % 9.. ,. ,!  0!!  0 , ,.. .! 0.$ 0, 0! .  .  0 .%0 ! %. 10. 0!!   ... 0.    5! ,.   ! .$ 1  ,  .!! !  .. 0!!.,!.!%AB/)&.,"$ 0!0% 5!.0!.$  #&!!#%0(' ,!$!..,!9%.0!9..% 550!  .,  0!C0 0,$ 1 ?   % , 0. .! .0!. 0..  , . ! 0!C01,!%,,.9 ..,!0!... ,0$...%,!0.! .. ! 91!$ ,.  !9 .. . 0 . .., !...05.$50.,99!0,.!.. !    !.. 05 1   91..0   .  .! !!$!..055..1,91..05!!$ ,.  .. . !9  !... 05.  .. ! 91..0.$ 1..0!0...!9,5.1%!0% /( $ . !.. 9. ,.  5, .. 91..DD0 0.., 91..0!0$ ,1!.!0%.!5, 9%.0011!!91..0!0!$ %,1! .%9..0!0..,!$ ,01 9010,..,.%9091..0.0!$ , 90..!91..0!0!!$ !,! .0.!..9.$9!010,... ..$ ,%!9091..0.! %,!$  %%!#!%(!#&!$%(&!&0"$(%#( /$!....,2,/):7730, 2,":&&30$!....,0! 0 ,0, 0!C0 ,  , 1,, 0 0,$ 0!.!1!!.1!,2.)&7'+//3$  ! 0 . % ,   5 ' */(#"-##"-##)&  */(#"-##"-##)7$ ! B " 9 7 .  5   5 ,! 05$ , % ,   .!  05 2.53$  .5! ! . 9. 0! 25 9.!  .. !! '0 !.5.. 0, 9,  !. 9-66EEE$00$ 6!F$ 99G., !H /I9, ! H)I0J!H&(3$ , 1 .   . ! 5,  */(#"-##"-##)7$ , . !. 1.0% ! ,  5   5 */(#"-##"-##)&$ ,.%0..9!%...91..0!0,!9... 05. 2, 01 ;<3 0 .. 05 .0.. .! . ? 91..0.$  

  "$                                          ! "         

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

  !.000.!!00 ,91..0.$1..0.90 %,,0!.! 2./#:3$ 

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

 

 % ! 1!   .%9 . 5.   1% !  0 !  0 .,% 5.  91..0 23$ 0 .% .!! .%9.    .0 !  50$ .. 1! !.0,!.!.!0,!.!!.$

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