Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-20990/3 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:2.05.20990.7183 AI generated

2-05-20990/3 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-05-20990/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-20990/3 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

       !   ! "       #$%"  #&&'%%(!)*+(  ,#  

   #-&.-#&//&0)" #-1,&-&.2  

 

3 445$'#1+./ !!6          *74

3 0  !!6,&158$.&+!(5&

3 ()!62+6*6!  ! !*7 4   0  !!6 ,&5#&88,+ ! )3 ()!62+6* (!         

3*)!9!9

3 5$'#10!)9))6 69))62 !!*./"*#'1&0 69))62 !!!% !!")3)% ( ! 5&%,,%#&&.%% )33  !66  ) " ! 4    66 !!6 ).'$$1+1. !!96!%:3)  ) " 4    66  !!6  )  5$'#1+./  !!!!3)% !!      ! ( !)*  6 #$%&#%#&&'%%,.%&&%        " 6 !!"   !! 5& 3 *!!+  ! 6 3!))+ 6 ) *)    );;6) ) ) !!)%"666 *)+ "!6)%     !     * ! 6  % #5<,,-, 0#5%,,%#&&1%%2+ #/<, 0#/%,,%#&&1%%2 * 5&<, 05&%,,%#&&1%%266!*9"-96-6)3 6!  !* !  "  6% 6 ! ! * !* 9 66 8&+1' )5 96 !)) .'/'+..  !!% )6 6

#012  ! * 3*6 5&%,,%#&&1%% !*    % 55& 0)3* ,&%,#%#&&1%%2+)!*!65.8&+.& !!%!!*  % 55&,#,,'+&. !!% *! %&#<,0&#%,#%#&&1%%266!*9"-96- )3 6!!*!"6%!! * !* 9 66 ,8+/1 )5 96 !)) ,51&+/.  !!% )6   ! * 3*6 &5%,#%#&&1%% !*    % 55$ 0)3* ,5%,#%#&&1%%2+ ) !* ! *36 3  )%  ! !*  %55$,51&+/. !!% *!6 %&'<,0&'%,#%#&&1%%2+&/<,0&/%,#%#&&1%%2+,&<,0,&%,#%#&&1%%2* ,5<, 0,5%,#%#&&1%%2  66 !* 9 " - 96 - 6 )3 6 !!*!"6%6!!*!* 966,&#+5)596!))$#1#+8. !!%)66  ! * 3*6 ,5%,#%#&&1%% !*    % 51. 0)3* #5%,#%#&&1%%2+)!*!*363)%!!*   %51.$#1#+8. !!% *!6 %,1<,0,1%,#%#&&1%%2+,.<,0,.%,#%#&&1%%2*,'<,0,'%,#%#&&1%%2 66!*9"-96-6)3 6!!*!  "  6% 6 ! ! * !* 9 66 $5+$ )5 96 !)) .#,$+/.  !!% )6 6  ! * 3*6,$%,#%#&&1%%!*  %5.$0)3*#1%,#%#&&1%%2+)!* ! *36 3  )%  ! !*     % 5.$  .#,$+/.  !!% *!6 %#&<,#-,0#&%,#%#&&1%%2+#,<,0#,%,#%#&&1%%2+##<,0##%,#%#&&1%%2 *#$<,0#$%,#%#&&1%%266!*9"-96-6)3 6 !!*!"6%6!!*!* 9668/+11)596!))'55#+5. !!%)66  ! * 3*6 #$%,#%#&&1%% !*    % 5'. 0)3* &'%&,%#&&.%%2+)!*!*363)%!!*   %5'.'55#+5. !!% *!6 %#8<,0#8%,#%#&&1%%2+*#/<,0#/%,#%#&&1%%266!* 9"-96-6)3 6!!*!" 6% 6 ! ! * !* 9 66 18+# )5 96 !)) 51,#+'&  !!% )6 6  ! * 3*6 5,%,#%#&&1%% !*    % 5'/ 0)3* ,&%&,%#&&.%%2+ ) !* ! *36 3)%!!*  %51.,51,#+'& !!% *!6 %<,0&.%&,%#&&.%%2+&'<,0&'%&,%#&&.%%2*&'<#0&'%&,%#&&.%%2 66!*9"-96-6)3 6!!*! "6%6!!*!*966$8+.&)5 96 !)) /#'5  !!% )6 6  ! * 3*6&$%&,%#&&.%%!*  %#0)3*,$%&,%#&&.%%2+)!*! *363)%!!*  %#,/#'5 !!% !!6 ! ! * *) #5%,,%#&&1%% - &'%&,%#&&.%% )996 !* !1/,+.1)596!))58.&'+#. !!+)!*!6 95.8&+.& !!  %55&%  ! !*  66    *  !)) 51 /#.+$.  !!%

6 0 =2 > $'  , * 5  " ! 3  6!!!36+!3663) )6*+!*%

5012

= >- ,&&  ! ! )   ! 3) *3))!3)+3))% =>,&,,3" 66! )*-6,*'!"6* *+!! 6+6)!3)  !3))! %

= > #&8  , ! !" * )99 )99* 6) !* 9 !)!+ )  )99* !!  !)6 *  ) ) !)6 9) !*+ !*  !" )99* ) * !  * ) * % * ! 36 !) !6 ! - 66 6 )3 6 ! " 0962 9 !*% !* ! 36 !) !+6!*3633)6*! )!%  6 !*  ! !)  ! 6  !!6 3 !   ! * 66  * ! 6 )6+ " *  ! 3)   ) 0  &$%,,%#&&.%%2%  = > ,,5  , !"6* !3))! 6 +   !  ))  ! 3)%  )33 ! =>-/136 )33 +)6" !%

= > /1 - ,  ! )33  !!   !!   ? )! !!6 !6 )  )33     ,%* *,%*+6!36% )3*6 )6666&,%&$%#&&.%%66 )33 6)6 ! = > /1  , )6  !!   ? )! !!6 !6 )  )33   &,%&$%#&&.%% # @%  *  6 6!*#,818+$& !!3*))0&+,/@32+36 *)3,1%&#%#&&'%%3 !*)!)* "!*#'/8+81 !!3*))0 &+&#.@32%  " * !* 3* )    51 /#.+$.  !!  #'/8+81!!5$'#1+./ !!+*3!6!*6%    !*!) *01$2!6))5$'#1+./ !! ")51/#.+$. !!*0 &+&#.@32!#'/8+81  !!%  !" !     !!6!! *60-6.5+.'2+6*6)  *)+6"!* *)>1&,,%  >-  11&  , ! 36+   !* " !  ! 6 6*6+ 6"!%!*!*60 ,1%&#%#&&'%%626+" 66% >111,!"!*!*6!)3 6 9*6% 

= > #&8  , ! !" * )99 )99* 6) !* 9 !)!+ )  )99* !!  !)6 *  ) ) !)6 9) !*+ !*  !" )99* ) * ! *)*%

1012

6$',*5"!3 6  ! ! ! 36+   ! 366 3) )6*+!*%

= >- ,&&  ! ! )   ! 3) *3))!3)+3))%

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