Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
2-05-14658/2 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:2.05.14658.6821 Kohtuotsus AI generated

2-05-14658/2 · 2-05-14658/2 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-05-14658/2
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Summary

AI generated

              !"   #!"$ %"   &'(! )(        *+,'#"#+-.,           /01$# !(2/#(!#($ 3*45"$ ...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 2-05-14658/2

     

      

 !"  

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

  /2         !" !%$ ,($"! !!,$ #!" $ %!" -., $ %!"& $1!( $"3" *+++$*++  ,.('! !"0(!30!( 1$'" #!"(1$ 11$ %!"* 0), $"5! !"013($)!!! (&!&(!5$"(3&(!!%(&$"(,(($"" &;;3"&((&!&$ %!" !",($"!!!,$!&(!+0!( 1$'" ,.(3$ %133 $(#($" &1!"5 $"( $'" ( ! !!  %13&(! (!"1(+

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

  */2 ,."3!#1,.(&"3 &1."#%"3!"3,)%&! (!$( ,##,!+  -  (3 1 .%&"  !(  1$$0#! 7" "%!" (($&!$5 $"""#1(!+  ($(:%$"%!"(($&$/"%!$21(1+ .%&"($,(3#($+((,.1($$"($ 1$$0#! 7!(31<!3"! &::(+ 

"1&)#(!"3,.3!"&(!3($"!$%"!!(&$."!"$&""!"1"3(  ,."3! %",  113!  "3! ( !3($ $ ,.1($" )%($ 131 

1$$0#! 7 &3"($(13!+ +.%&"$"3"50)#! 1."'01$# !(%3"#%(1311!"3!%(1"!$%!!"$!"11(!&(!1(1$ !! * $# 1(,)&.(!&(!01$# !(,#+     

1$$0#! 7 1%(,3"$)!!1"3+4++/!25$"(3,((&1(  $ %!"&))#!"3!)%!$!1"3$(#($$",!"!+ &"!(( $ !(13(&"1"3(!"1(+       

1$$0#! 7 (13 (  $ %!"(!"1( (&"1"35 $"(( $ ! 1 +++  $ %!"$"!$)!!1"31(1$ %" 11(3% (!1"35!(!"1(&(!!(&"&($ ## ,.('$ %"!%113$%"$! !"+ 

=*$ %!5$"(%! !'$ %!"(!"1((&"&!))1"3$ !,!" ! !"!&(!5!'$ %"%$"$! !"!(1(&"5!%( 1 %(,3"&)#(!"3"!" "3.("($"!0.%13!"3+"%" !$ % (!!"3 <$!((3 ,)(!3 $ ! 0 ! &$,.!"$+ "( %( (  .("($"! 0.%13!"35!'$ %" !"5&()!'%(#%"3&!+ -  3!$  = *   $ %! $ ! &$,.!!"5 $"1( ,((&1 ( ,(3"! <$!((  " $ %! (!!"3 ,)(3! .1(!  ,(3"!&( !% ( (&1$0 &""3!,3"!!+ 

%" ('5 ! %( !"' #%"33 % 1."3 ! !"  = *   "5 ! $ ! (  (&"1"3 $ %!"(!"1(  !3 1 % (!!"35 ! $ %!"(!"1(! 0""3"&($ ##,.('$ %"!%!&$%"$! !"1(1%( 1%(,3" &)#(!"3"!" "3.("($"!0.%13!"3+ 

=$ %!,.('$(#3, )!!,)! !"!5,)#,!"3 "%"5$"( 1"!335! !"$"""'!"11"!&(!)(!&($,)0 !( '#(($(+-.%13, &)#(!$:$1.("($0.%13"+ 

"1$ %!"!3 ,!($"""1!"3 !"!"11"!&(!)(!&($,)0  !('#(($(50)#!&)#('$ %":$1.("($"0.%13"+

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

  /2

 =     0  $ %! !"11(!' $ %" & !" !!(! ,((,(!&! !)(3!,$! !"+ 

(,(($ %!"&1!" 3"!($"  !)(!&1!" 3"!($" #$13&( 3" = * )!!'5 ! 11 $) , 3" ."!"&(! "!!"3 &1!" 0"%" $ %3!$ &1!"$""3  !&(  113 $(13$&))#&( 1( $%!(1"3 !(,(($ %!"&1!"3"!($")!!!"!+

"1 &1!"! 1 "!!"3 $) ,  + 5 (( !"' &1!"$""3  !&(  113 $(13$&))#&( $ %33 $"1( +++  $%!(1"3 !(,(($ %!"&1!"3"!($"/ 2)!!(3+ 

"1(+++$%!(1"3 =)!!5!#(((.(,"5&(!"&(!% 1,'!!"35&.(!'$ %"$ !!,)#(((!""3,.#3(!%(#%"3!"3 + !,! =34 0/$"1(+++$%!(1"3#3$!( 12 1(1#(((.(,"3"=*4*/$"1(+++$%!(1"3#3$!( 120(3( %%((!&(!"&*/*@2$# 1(#(((.(,"+  -.,$ %!"+4++&))#",'!!(%*$# 1(""#"#(((.(," !"&(!1((%((!&($"($%(#%"3&!)!&(+ 

"1$ %"#%"3'%(!)(($"!5!.!!"!"'$ !! =" /$"1(+++$%!(1"3#3$!( 12#((($"$,)&.(!#(((.(,*$# 1( "!"+      &'(! )( $ %!"1($