Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-22651/2 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.05.22651.5875 AI generated

2-05-22651/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-22651/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-22651/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







          !"#$ %&'!

 ()*'# +&#   ' ',* "        -.!/*#* -.. #* *          .0. 1%'*+" 2 & .0. ! "# 3& !* 45  '#,          4 .0. 1 26  ',4 %'*+"&$,#* *4 %*6 + "4 .0. 1       

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



  ""#, & %$#/ &4 4, %++$" 3& !* &#$ ##$#! '' "#6  #+& 6 *56 %++$" !&$ !*, " + , 6 5$$ "#$5# ' &4 / 8 '' "# 5""$ +  +5'# '' + "4 8 '' "# 5""$  +  +5'# .  $#  +$!"  4+$#, +& $" %++$" /$# * "**" .'+!5/*$ <;:. "$

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

#$'!$" (*+'' ,#  1, %, '5""#, (2 @ : $  +' / , 3& !* /$#  "$ +5',"#, / , !*. ( @  $  !,  3& !* 4, ' /$#  "$6 /$# $&#"5 $ #  %$ ,. ( @  $  4)* 4/ !,$#  +$ 3& !* +&# 3& ! 5$5 /  '#,$. ( @ < $  4)* $+"  / , + , 3& !* 45 $ !*,  . ('* @  $  4)* '#/ &$,#* 3& !* 45 " 4 !$'# +  3& +5', "6 4#&#$ # !* +' !$'# 4 "5 /  3& +5', . 4 +'  "'#, "',,6 5$$ +& $" ) +$! &  5 +$! '' "# +' %++$" 3& !*6 #!*, +' +5',"#, /$#  "$ '' &4$  +$ ",  4+$# ,6 5 !5$, , %,, !* 3& /  $&# !* . 4 +'  #+&$6 " %++$" + , "#$/ 3& !* 45 $ $#, !*,  '' 4, '' "# $$ $"6 " &4$ ##$#/  +5'#' 8 5""$ " +  '' "# " '' + "4$ 5#" 8 5""$ " +  '' "# ". )&"#!$" $"++,# " '' "#',  @ ; $  4 - $  %$#/ &4 4, %++$" 3& !* &#$ ##$#! '' "# %++$" !&$ $#, '', + , !*,  6 5$$ "#$5# ' ##$#/ &4$ 8 '' "# 5""$ " +  '' + "4$ 8 '' "# 5""$ " +  '' 4)"" +&"##$#, + "4 ',.



    #

+ "4 !"/ &   !,$ $$$ ! "# ".$. -.

 # #

+&# +$$ "#"!#'#,  4  ""#, ,+#5'"$ " "'," 4 + "4 %++$" $5'"$# +&"#$  ""#, &  !"5  !$,#  $/6 " & ##$#/ *&#$,5 $. +&# %/ !5$#  4 $&',5 " +&"# "#'" %,5".

 @ :: $  4  +& $" # + "4 !"/ +&"# "#'$ ! +&"#$  ""#, !$,# &4 '#,  6 *&#$,/ +&# &. # &  !"5' +'  ""#, +&"#$ !$,#  6 !"  !$,# "+5# . # + "4 !$,/ &  !"5  +&"#$ $5'"$#  6 $&',/ +&#  4 +&"# "#'" %,5".

#$'!$" (*+'' ,#  1, %, '5""#, (2 @ : $  +' / , 3& !* /$#  "$ +5',"#, / , !*. ( @  $  !,  3& !* 4, ' /$#  "$6 /$# $&#"5 $ #  %$ ,. ( @  $  4)* 4/ !,$#  +$ 3& !* +&# 3& ! 5$5 /  '#,$. ( @ < $  4)* $+"  / , + , 3& !* 45 $ !*,  . ('* @  $  4)* '#/ &$,#* 3& !* 45 " 4 !$'# +  3& +5', "6 4#&#$ # !* +' !$'# 4 "5 /  3& +5', . 4 +'  "'#, "',,6 5$$ +& $" ) +$! &  5 +$! '' "# +' %++$" 3& !*6 #!*, +' +5',"#, /$#  "$ ''  +$ ",  4+$# ,6 5 !5$, , %,, !* 3& /  $&# !* .

#!*, + "4 +' +&"#$  ""#, !$,#  &4 3& !* '#,  !"'#,6  "#$/ %++$" 3& !* 4,. (++$" + , "#$/ 3& !* 45 $ $#, !*,  '' 4, '' "# $$ $"6 " &4$ ##$#/  +5'#' 8 5""$ " +  '' "# " '' + "4$ 5#" 8 5""$ " +  '' "# ".

4 $/6 " +&"##$#, "#$/ ) +$!  4 4)"" + "4 ',. 4  +$  "'#, '#" ', +&"##$#, &3!"5  6 #, +&"##$#, ) +$!  4 +' &  "5 $ 3& !* 45  '#,$" " #5 $ ##$#! *$! -. *++'6 5$$ " #5  " +&# &4 ;.... 5))*#  !/ " ".$. :.

+ "4  +$ +5%++$ " ""%'#" +&"##$#, 45   "'#,6 5#" +5%++$ " +&"##$#, '#" ".$. -.

#!*, ) +$! " !$ 4 +' 5'"$# " $# ""#, ''  4   4# "#5 " ..-..6  +&$,"  5'"$# #$#, 4+"5 $ 4 '', ',$ 5))*5 $ ' &"'#, " !$+&"#5'"$#  ,# "# )" ""#" 1  4   @ 2.

#' +" # +' "&"#, &4  # '' & *&#$,"6  "#$/ + "4$" !)$4 5 " *$! ++ $  @ -: $ . 5""#, )"" +& $" *$!#6 5$$ " #5  " &4 +' !/ ""#,6 5 "/ +&# + "4$" !)$4 !*,$ $" & *&#$,"#, + . $"++,# " "#$'!$" ##$#/ + "4$" !)$45 "5 $ *"#$#,  *$! 3& !* 45   " -. *++'.

.',* " +&"#'