Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-04-52/4 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2004:3.04.52.514 AI generated

3-04-52/4 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-04-52/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

   081   !   "&"       ( &       (   !       "(    ( !     ( !  "(''   *(''  ,,      ( (      &  ((''  ( &! !   ,,  (    (  "   .'( !  ( (  !"&"           (   &    "&   !      3  "     "      (!  "*(( (,,   &( (    (      #    &    "         (    ?@ $ ?@   3   #    "     (  2     )      (!  "*#    ((       =  ( (     

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-04-52/4 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:    081   !   "&"       ( &       (   !       "(    ( !     ( !  "(''   *(''  ,,      ( (      &  ((''  ( &! !   ,,  (    (  "   .'( !  ( (  !"&"           (   &    "&   !      3  "     "      (!  "*(( (,,   &( (    (      #    &    "         (    ?@ $ ?@   3   #    "     (  2     )      (!  "*#    ((       =  ( (     

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

  

       !   "#   "  "  $  "   "%&         # " '(  &     (()*  "  &   +

"   ( ! **( (''   *(

 ('' !  !  ,,  ! (  ,,  (  ( "     !   (

 "&    (

   -.   ( (

( /0 %

 1"(

   2-%'' "('' !  !     (

( #

# 2  

/0 %

 21" " #  3 

  (+0 ) 4)  *1  (''(&"  ( ("

  

   !" !  %

  "2  "& 

    ' (  " & ( $      

0 $3#15)  &   " '(   &"     "   4&     ( "   " " 4"  !#   " ""  "  3! 3   2++2(

  )  -.   "    ( '  "/ *(  !

" "(''   (   (

 (''   (    !   "      (''  (''  " (  (       (''  (''( 6''"  (   !"   &      " (   "   (    " ( 7  *

    



  (    "  !"(+,,   ('' 

    (''(      ))"*8  ,,     (    +(''

 !     0*

1") 0 

1.

   '  ! 2,,   ('' (''9  )*)*  "99 **  (  !  (   

*  ")2+*    '  (''  (  " (''   (   9  *  "99 *  8     ( ' (''  (  "  (''    

)*  00*:*1718*

 " " '  (''   ("

  & ()*

    0*;)*1"+('' )*  0+;)*1 # ((   ( ! (   !" !  ( 

"    &      (   ,,"      '  "     '     !' "         (    "   (   &    '   <  

 & (''  

    (   (  

 &(''# &   ( "

   (( ( (

   &((   3    ((

(''   4*('' !   !    (   ( ! (

 " !   "    ,,    (  ,,  (  ( "   !        &  " ( "  7   !  ( !  (     ' &         &(   !"  (   ' &(& 8      (' = " &"  ( &   +('' !  (

    (     "       ( !   " (

  (''  !   !  ,,  !8  $    ( 2 "      + &   "        (&        ! (  "&"  (           "&"   

 (     '( 8  ('' ('' !  !  (

(    ! (     3       (

     (   (   

(" (&    =    &" ( ! (( > (      (   " (   &   ( ( ?   = "&  ( (     ( ( !  "  " ( "  ("  (  &  &  "            ( 01 &"   !  (             & " "      (  (

   081   !   "&"       ( &       (   !       "(    ( !     ( !  "(''   *(''  ,,      ( (      &  ((''  ( &! !   ,,  (    (  "   .'( !  ( (  !"&"           (   &    "&   !      3  "     "      (!  "*(( (,,   &( (    (      #    &    "         (    ?@ $ ?@   3   #    "     (  2     )      (!  "*#    ((       =  ( (     

    3 "  !    &   3   (    (

  "2    (

"(*('' (!  *)4"4*3 (

  ('' (       !"   " (''  (''(  (''  4) 4)"*0 +1   !&      !("

   (''  4%

  2   (  (     <         "    ( '  " &      !   (  .  (   

 (''    ( &   !

" " (''   " &  ("

  +('' " !       (   ) 4"  * * *+  " (''  #   !   "    (         "&  @(''      (    ( (

"      #(       ( (     *&(  # " ( &"  7 2    )    !'#

# 2   ) "   "     )       (!  "*   (   !        ((  &( ((  ,,(     (      (''     "   "   @      !       "   (  (   ('' (''   (   "'        " ('' '?@.& "    (   *""    (

     A  ( ! " $3#52  !  " '( 

     (       (&       !   "  !    ,,     ( ' (''  ( 

" (''     

 (    )*   # "

   (   (

   (   "  (    !  ( # +B"+B  &(&  ("

   (  +(''0 *1

   ,,     (  " (''  (''(           (    (''  (  (       (  ,,  (     (  "  9    ( &      (  &        &   " '  

  (  ' ,,    ! 3    & !  ,,  (     (  "  (   (''   (#  ! &( " '  

  (    &( 

  3 "!   #  (         ( & (''         "    ( '  " &    A   (''   (               " (  ('' ( # 

 &(   "    (  (''  ( " (''  (''   4(''   (''   ((*+  *     4 (()  6 !       (''     !  (  "(    (    !    !   "     6 !  !"(

    "&"        # 

   (      = (   # "    "  (   ("      (     & ( ? &   ('' 22* !      (

  "2(''      %''  (''  +   &    &    (   (''    ' "

  8&(   (''  ('' (''       3 "  

 !&"      " "&      #  &  "     &    !   "  (''   (''  &                    (

  "2   (

  (

 *(''    ( !  

    ( ( !  "  &" (      ( &   '   " (" (    &      " "

 ""    ( ! ! (  !"     "    '      (   ( ( "  4  " (   (  "  (   C           (  ("&"    "       "   "   " ( 7    ('' !  !  (

( "       "     %''* '(! '((   "   (!.,,     " (''' (



"    "   " "  (  (  ! '(!     #(  "    (         (  ( !   (''



 (&  (           &  (

   

     "

  " &   7  (

  -.   ( (

( /  

 (#

# 2 %

     



 (

 (   ( 

( (  (   ('' (

  2-%'' "('' !  !      (

( #

# 2 

/  (''  "(''  !  !       (''  (  (  "

 * #((

        (

 "&  (

"  "    ( ! !  (   "       "   ( **0    1   ('' "(

  2&  (   !  (''     *& 0 *)*1" (''   (    (   ( ( (

     

 

(  

  2 ( (& ((

  "(

   2'"& 

$    (2  "      &  !&(&   !    &"        (

     "   

  (''  &  

 (   ! " &      (''  (''   " (  (      (''  ('' 6    ''  !  &     " ( ( " &(  

( (  ((''  *)*9    "  (''   &  ("

      & *   (''(   ("

  "(

  ! !     '  ('' 0('' ))  *1(''("

     "     

(''  *  ( **   !  !    ,,  (    (  "   !" "       (    &  (( (  ,,   (''  ( (''(   ( "

   & !  (    ( !   (''  )  *  "     &     (    ( !   (   ! "  7  ' (

  "2 &(   #   "    ( **  (    (  (   (''  (  ((       (  ('' *)"*4 * (''(       ' (

  "2 

 < ('' ) !  !  ,,  (  ,,    "  "(''  *   (   ,,  (    "     !"    (&      ((  (''   *(

('' !  !  ,,  ! (   ,,  (  ( " ( !          "  " '(  &  &(  3$      5 )&!  &   &(  " &     &     

 &    "  '( "   &(   &(&      5  "   &  ( &( <      &   " '(  &    ! (   (&    &(   &   '( &(  & ( &   ( &(   (  "   (

    (   "     " (&(& & &     " '("   "   &(  &  %#    !   ( &  ( &(    "    #     '   &  4  .'( !  ( (  !"&"          (   &    "&   !          ( !  "+         '        '( !   (  &(" 

(   &  # 

 (&" &"   '( !   (" ( # &  !     # "  '(  &   ("

      (! !,,    (''("

(''       )"*  !"   (  !   "&"    ( &     "  ' &"   (''   *(

('' !   !  ,,  ! (  ,,  (  ( "      &      (    !'     "  ' "   " '(  &     ( &      &  "" '(  &    (" (    ( &    (    '

 !#  '(  ("

     ,,  (     (  "  (''  (''( ("

  #     (   " '  ,,   (''   ("

  &  

()*  *

*;)*D)*  "+(''  *

  +;)*D)*   # "

  )  " +.   

( (

 " ( 7

,,  7(48(4+8    ""7(4*8

   ( " ( 7(8 ((   ( " ,,7(48 ( & ( ( ' !*  7 (48 ( & ( (  *  7(48 "( 7(4 C    !  ,,    (  (!(''"  ( *   00:*:*:171 ,,  (    (  "  (''( (!  (  )*  0:::1 & ((   (  " ,,   (  "     ( (''  )   (0*7 )*1 ,,       !(

  (  

 (    

 # " & (''  )"*(  22++*   & *0;)*1  *+2   0*7)1 

 !"  '(! '  "  "&   (''    (  (

  2  (    (  !    (    !" &  (   ('' (''("

   ("

   )*  0;)*1  #(    !"       (''  )(''    "  * **+ )&  ! ,,    &   ! " ' (    (     ((2  00)*71;1   *   (     ((*+*  00)*7)17D2+8 2+;1

 )  #  

 ! '  ((( (  22++*:)*: 2:*+*D22*2*        & )*   

 ! " "(&(  )          "  (((

(    "     ((  ,,  &( (    (     #    '(    &    " "       (    (   !   ((        =  ( &(    #(   " (      # & (''(''  (      (''       ( ! (    !" "  ((  (   "  ( ( ( ( (        "     &  " &   '     "  (      (      &    "  &"  ((    (      &  (    #(  !     # &"    

"    &       &     ' (''.,,"    '  "     "   (   (''      ' 



&( 

  %#5+  !     (  "          !    (   "   ( & " '(   !    +        ( ! "      (   !&"        ((  (& " " *B)     C    ""    %#5"5+       A  !   ( ** &    (  &    (  3 "(& #  &     (   "   (()0  '(( ' ( '(( (1    3 "(& #        )0   

'1      ?   &!    !  . $     "        (   

         (          "  "