Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-15089/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.05.15089.3831 AI generated

2-05-15089/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Rapla kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-15089/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

     . "          . <:!    %.                2  1%.  !$&    *        %.   .  .  1    *      %         .     *  .   .  *    . -         ", <#!       %.   .  .           ."   < )  ! *       *    .    . .     " +    *% .

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-15089/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Rapla kohtumaja:                2  1%.  !$&    *        %.   .  .  1    *      %         .     *  .   .  *    . -         ", <#!       %.   .  .           ."   < )  ! *       *    .    . .     " +    *% .

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                      !" #"# $%     #& '&!' ()                                     *+,-  .   * .* + *+ * .*. +.  .   /.

 .*.         !!" !"# $      . +,0  .  %.  +. 1   " 

*2 +$ "&   2 +,0  .    "        +,-  .  *+2 .   %   .%          

3  %  *       % .      

 .  *   44.               

"   3" $"!)))     &%   !#"      2      *   /5'#( " '+6   **%  1    "  2   **   .        44  .

2 *+ *  ,,1    .   1 %.  "     *   

.    % .      . *   %1 ."  *  2      44           .      *   .     " "/         .  .  * 2   * %  .  +&  % "    *     *     .    %    1 .  *      . &    *  .  #!! "&" *   .      2.  .*     " * %  %  ..*

%

   % 

 .

44 * * +           

   %    %   * .*    %          .          .*    7 8 "& 9  % "  .      !" :"# '            *2   . * %  .   .*  1 " .          %#*  *2   .*   1   *       ;  * %     .     2 .    .     

.     .  *.       2       %    .*1   " *%      2   "  %  * 

.     *   1 . ." *      . * 2     .  *%.2   . *  .*   1 "  * %    .   %.   

-   . *. "   ! !            2      3" $"!)))"    22 

. 

  .  1.  .  *     2   .   . 

. <& !!=<&.  # ##!  2     .*  *  .      !" :"# #   . .  >  .  

  .  1.  .  * 3" $"!)))   .    .   . "

      !" $"# ! *2 .  .   * 1    .   .  *     *  .   .   . " .*   1            .  

.

    .  .*  " * %.."  ? < '(  !     2   * >       ."      *   %    2 

           .   . "   2      * 3" $"!)))   .  < !

      .    %    1     .    .   .

 %   .   *"    %   . 

  1     2  

2   . *  .      *       .   .

    .".*       .   .   * " <& !). -   .  *2 2  !*     2   **        . * *    2   #    .

*

7*

 442  

   *%1   442  

   *9".*     *

 442  

   *      <# !*  44 *2   **  442    2    *. %=%1   442  

   *     <#! !*   .   2   *. %   ."< ##   .    

       * 

    .       

.         2%   ."

 .       **%.  2     

7%         44   .  *. *   9" +   *% .

*          "           .  .  < #  ! 2

 7          44 *           2  1       .     *         ..        .    

.    2         .  " . 

 %   .  .*  *   .  7   

.      * %.    .  9 1     "+    *% .

 *    

     *  1

    .    < ##  .

" *  1

  2    .    **   .%   

.    7 .       9    2.    .    .    % .  7   .   

.    2  .%..>    9".       *     %                . 

.    %          . "     

               *        2     .     7<#%!9"<3#   

  .  1       2  %              2.   2    .          *     *.            *1          "<)!*     * .   . .     " +    *% .

 *        <! %32

.  "<#$#  .     *%.             

      *     "   <#3#2  & 2            !(&   *      2     .*  2   *  .*             .   * "      .    . %-

  .    %  

 2  . = %  .    . .

2 1 ..* .   ..*  .          44    2      . . %    "          . <8!%&. #&: .. %           .".           

. *    %.   . . 1   7<:!9", < #!       %.   .  .           ."    .    .  .* %..  -   . .   "+  8" ("# 3   * .*   2.    7%

   8" ("# 3 .   #:89    %   *                  " *           ( "&   "     * .* .*    8 "&   " %

   :" 8"# 8  *  !#&'"$@(!       * 

  44 * 2 .  %  .        *.  "       *   *  +          

       . .     44 *  % " %       +" .    

 *. "     * . *.     

 .  *  .. 2 %2* . "   * .*+"%<&. !!)##3 != ?<'(=, <#!= <#$#   .  *%.  +. 1   = 2 * *  ."    !       .  .*" .    " %2* .   2  *  1

    .    .  .                   " A .         "

    ! " !"# # !!<!3         .2 .  > .    

.  . % . .      %    *     .  .  .  *.  .  %2  %1  .  .        * .  * .   * 2%   "  .   

            .  . %        2    .  "  .  .*      .   1            .      .  .  ."  *

.    .   *   "  < ##   *  1

   . 1    2 

         "  .  2 

     1               . 1



          .  "   

   * .     1

      .     .   .  .*  .1 "  "    *  .      "  *     *        %  .     .  1    3#8 "&    %2* . . * 2 . . .  .   " *   *

.  %2* . .*  .      .  .     .  .  

     .     %     .       * ."  *  %2* .    .

   %1  %     * 

 "     .  2         1

     2 .   .

    * ."+ .*  %   .    .   .

"  .   .   . <8#  .   .            .    .  *  "    %2*    

2 .   *   .* "..  %2*  .   %      .    *  1

   .   2   " 1  %   *  1

 " *  1

    .      .  " . .     * 

   .   .   .   %  1   "  * * .*    2   .         !" :"# '        * 2   . %  .    .  1      3#8 "&.  .   "   !      %2* . .*.  "  !" :"!))'  < !  !        .

        .   . .         2   2      .    .

%   .  *1   2     *    "  <8!       .

2    * &2  *     .   2   **     %  #"2      .      *   

  2 

"  <!)!     *    .

%   .*     2   **    . -11       2  -11   2  * .    "  *      *  <!)#

   * ; *

 442  

    *= %1   442  

    *=    .=

 2%% .   2 

   *"   < ##       .      

        *  1

   .      

.       2%   

. ."  .    442  

 2      *"   .       

 !" :"# '          +"

2   + ,-    .    %  .    .  1           3#8 "&    %2* . . * 2 . . .  . 

 " 1       . +  %  .*.  . 

2 . *+"   

. >      .  * 

2 . "  .  .* %  +" 1  *       .  2    1  %    ..*. 1 "  +   *2    # '':        +"         .   ,,  1         * 

%     **       % .   *   "    -  .  ;

,,  1          

%       * ** *  "          

-  ."  %  6             *2       3)!        +"   .  1   *    ,  1 * ,, 1    *   ,, 1        * " 

*2       ! (@# 8         +"      .   ,, 1    * %.1

*   *   %     **    " 

*2       !!8:@# '         +"      .   ,, 1    *  **    *   %          %      "          %  1    '"!#"# ' %   * %         +"  1&**       2 

 3" $"!))) .. **     *     *"  +    %       3'3 )#!" '"# 3       +"   %1     442    442    ! B"  +           #(" !"# 3        +" *    %.  % .   2  44%    "  .    *

    ;  1 5C       % *   *                %  .    " 

* %  *+" %   .    44%   % .   2 "       .  2 .  *2             %  1      %      *   3" $"!)))   2 

 .. **     *   ** 1&* *     %1 % "   <##*    . *  1

   . . "   . . < ##%    *  1

 %1  %  . 2        ..           ."  < ##  %    * 

  .  2    **   .%   

.         "  * +  1         %  *   1

      **   .  *         .    2 .     .      <&  ##    2 "      .  *        *   1& * *       **       *      *   .   %  2  1

 "+ .*    *   .%1 %     .  2 

 ..  

"    .  2 .              *+1   +*  %  % .   2     $ .   +"    2    

     1  5C     % * *    

         %  .   "   .  .* 44        . !("&   "   +" %  .*   . .  .* . * %2* . . . %       "  . 3" $"!)))   .  <&  ##    2       *  1

    .  .      .*." *  1

   . . 2 .. .    .    

 -1  %  2    "    *      . 1   *  .* ." 1  2   * %44.. .*.  1   /% ".       *    %               .  .  %    

     . "          . <:!    %.                2  1%.  !$&    *        %.   .  .  1    *      %         .     *  .   .  *    . -         ", <#!       %.   .  .           ."   < )  ! *       *    .    . .     " +    *% .

 *        <! %32

.  "<#$#  .     *%.             

      *     "        .   1 . .*  .   . . *  .  

      44    2     ..%    "