Legislator Case Law & Legislation
3-05-655/1 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.655.1837 AI generated

3-05-655/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-655/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-655/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



      

    

     !!  " #$   "   %   " 

   &  

   " %  !! '!! "    (     )  #$  (  

   &  

      * +  , " 

 !   ) (   

#$   , " 

        ) * + 

 !   ) 

 - "  '        "   !   )   ( 

   &  

  +"  ' .' &/ 0 1 )   !   )  21  ") 122 ( " ) 3        !   )  ' .' &/ 0 1   

 "    ) 0 1 )    

 "       !(() " -    )4  !   ) ) 56   " ("! 

 ' & 0  ()   ( )!  4  ! "  4  

 "  -       ) 

   71   ") 5524

    - ) 

  )    

      " -    

       "  -) 

 !  )  (   

 - "  "       ( (    

 .2 /  -   + "    

    

  

    "    (       )    

 

   ( . &/ 0)  )      )-

()        "         "      ) .  15/  "            ") " 

   )      .%&/ 0 5 )  ( &) !(() !  " " ! !  

%& 0 1 )     ()   (  !  ()  )  ) () -!(()    "  )  !("    "  )     )  "    !   !   !  )   

 ) -   "  &  

  ()  !   ) 

  "   -   !     )   "  (  -    

 (  !     $  (      )   )     -    

"  !  ,        )

!   ) ( 

   (    

8) !( "  ) " 1  

( 0  " ) 9   () !(( ) ()  ()!    ! !        ()    ()   ( " "  " (  ()!   " ! !   !(( ) ( )  " ()  

+"   



, " 

 !  + ) + 71   2 :9 ! "   ;   ( )   <   !   !  5 " !   !  22 " )  -  

 "  '  !)--! , " 

   = 

  .2/ !("  .27/  . !   " !((     .2   ! / 8 !   --!    )   ( "   !   "

* + ) !   )  , " 

  1  ) 52  ))3 /    4 /   ( " /        ! 5   

 & 0 5 )   !   ) (" 

  (  &  

  #   ")   , " 

 !   ) ( &  

  

    !   ) ("   ")  &      !   ))  -!   )  !  

   ( 21  ") 122 )  " )  ) 3 / !   ) 56   " ! 

4 / -"   )  4 / "   !4 1/         -    ) 

 "   ) "      !(()  ()    " ' & 0 1 . 

 "    )/

 ) 0 1 )  .     !((/ &  

  ' & 0 1 )   

  "  (  

  !   (      +

 & 0 5 )   !   ) (   (     & 0 5 ) 1 = : (     (    () (  !   ))  !   ) (  !   )    !  "   ;           .  &/ 0 5 ) 1    "           <

 9

   " "( ) !   ) (     ()     , " 

    

   11   1 :%" ) " !  )     "!   ;   ( ) <   ! 5  " " ) !  ) &   0 1 )  !       !-    " (  +(  ! )  + ) +    ) ) !   !   ) (  ") !   (

: -    <   + ) + 75    .! + ) +   / %  0  )    !  )   , " 

  !-     " = &  

  = ( &   0  !   " )    " ( !   )  

   ) ( "     & 0 7 )  !   )   "!  ,  "  

 !    " -    !   ) !   (   !  (    " +    + ) +  

 0  !    " )    " ( !   )   &)    "      ! 



  !   ) (  "   !    (    )     "  9         ' & 0 1 )   !  !   ) (   ! " !  

    ( 

+"     " )3

#    

      -     -        

  " "( "       8

 "    $   )         (  

  "           &    5  ) 75  

!   ) >>  :&      "  <  &   ( !       ?!   ))    

!   )  ! 

# ()   !  ,)     ) !(()) '         !(()  !   ) (     &"         ) (   ;(     )  (  !  (!!        ' & 0  )  " 0  )  

    + ) + 

     ;  ' & 0     "    &) )    ()    "    

   ) (   

  (   ! !  )    & 0 5 ) 1   (  

1  () (  !   )) +    !   ) (  !   )    !  "   &) !   ) ( 

  ( 

   !     "  !   ) ( !   ( "    &  

    !  (   + ) +  )    "     )  -    ") (  )   ()) +" ) ( )        ( (  ' & 0 1 



 "    ) : 

 (      < 

 !        " -    "     '     

 (    ) : 

 (   !        # 21  " 122 &  

  )   ! 

 ! "   "    !     (   @  

      

 . ) )!( )   "/  ! "  9  ! ) "    !

 ) )  .

  / &    )     (

) 

    !"    )     

'(!  "  (   "   

 !   ) (      " ()     ( !   )  (  & 0 5 )      &  

  ( &  

    "  !   )  ( 

   (    (   7  + ) +   

    !  "     " (  3

1 ) * + #$  "      ) 52 -  -  , " 

 !   )  

 - "   "    " '          !) 5   !   ) (  &  

 ) &  

     & 0 5 )  !   !   ) ("  &      " 5

 & 0 5 )  !  " )   !   ) (     -!   )  !  ) !   )  ) ) )      "       . *  1   52 ( /

9

   " "( ) !   ) (     ()     , " 

    

   11   1 :%" ) " !  )     "!   ;   ( ) <   ! 5  " " ) !  ) &   0 1 )  !       !-    " &  

  (  +(  ! )  + ) +    ) ) !   !   ) (  ") !   (



&  

   (    21  ")

122 &    &  

   -   " -      " &  

     "  + ) + 75  )  &(    

  21  (   ' & 0 1 )      "  "    (  21    &  

   "   

   !   ) (   "  ' & 0 1 )  !       (       "  !   )  !("   "       ( 

  (   "      (   )  ' & 0 1 " 1 )  ' & 0 1   

 "    )  

 (        )   " (" !   

 (   !         )    " " !  )  ' & 0 1 )  " ) 

 "    (    (      

 (      )    "@ ( " 

" !    "  ( )  )  ""     @ "   (  !("    " !   )   ) 56   " ("! 

 ' & 0  ()   ( )!   "  !  )  -"   )  & (  (  ()      , " 

 !   )   ) 

    "      !   ))      "    "  )     (    - !   )   !    " )  !   ) (    ! #) !   ) (  

 !   )  " 

 )     ) @  !   )  ) "     )      !   ) ! "  )  !   )    ) " (      )  ) ) !   )  ( (( ( !   )   (!!  )  !   ) "   (   !  !   )   " "(  ,

 8 )

 5   75  ( >   )   

)  )  "         ) (  " () 

   &  

    (   "      ( ()!        )  '       .  !    ! 

  @  51/  !  "  (   " ;   ( )  " !  ))  -   -- -   ; " !  ))  -    ! ) -       " (  . 

   11   1 0 1 )  ! 4 + ) +  

 0 / +" (  

   "      ;   ( )  

2  .     " ) 

   71   ") 552/  ) 

 "    ) "      !(() 8

 "     "  ' & 0 1 " )

) 

 (          "@ ( " 

" !    "  ( )  )  ""    %  + ) +    0           !)--! " 

  " ! %     )   -"   "!  () (    " ( )  -        " > ! !

 "  , " 

  ;       &  

  !("    !   ) ( ) (  

   (    ) 9 , "    

     "   " ))  (    )     )   

   "     -  - "      )   )  "  -)

 "  )     @    () !  !( "  "  !  & 0  (          ()      )      -       ) , " 

   !   ))    )   (   )   8

 "   )  ) ')   ( ;      )  -   ; -     ' & 0 1 &        .0 / "   (   )   + ) +  

     '     " ;  ()  (  )  ' & 0 1 )      "    0    )  -    

    ! !     )   

   (     

 "    )         

   !    "    

   ;    ."  !    /    + ) + 71   2 :9 ! "   ;   ( )   <  !  9 ! $  ;()    19%$ :' !  )   "   <   2 (       : "      !)--! A (           (  "))   )" )) 

 ( "      -     (" !(")< -        !)--! ) 

( 

    "  "   '       !) (    

  "       (" !(" -  

#    , " 

 "    '          "  !     ()!   !   8

    @  8

 "    "  )   "  )     )  (  -!   ))

5 

   ( "          

   

      (      & 

" (    &  

   (    !   )  )  (   "      !       " !    @         (   (   (    "  

  "  (  "   ) (   

  !            !   )  " " (") ;  

   "     

    " "    ;   ) 9    -         ")   (        " !          %      (  

  ) ;    (  

      !  

     ) ) !    + ) + 71   2 :9 ! "   ;   ( )   <  ! 

; "    &  

  ()   (  !  ()  )  ) () -!(()    "  )  !("   ,     " )  ()!   " ! !   !(( " )   "  !"( 

 %& 0  )   

  !  "   &(  "     -   

9  " "   %& 0 2 )  ! 2 

 

 B  #$    "     " (

# (  !  ,

 8 )

  !  "   )  

    !         "  !  "

 !!