Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-19232/1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2005:2.05.19232.1327 AI generated

2-05-19232/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-19232/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 *$%# %#$++"(@  ##%. -( +  .) $::$" /# (1("#$ )"*$#$ .,$*$

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-19232/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja:  *$%# %#$++"(@  ##%. -( +  .) $::$" /# (1("#$ )"*$#$ .,$*$

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





















          

 !



















"#$#%&#  















 $#'#" 



# #() #+#(*







$#  (*,- ."%$*/#0/"%#(

.)%1$#$*"#$# #"%#1*"#







"#$#%&  







 

2  3(





 

2!! "#34



 $







%&$'(()$$







$%*'%&+'(() 



 ,

-





 .

-





 $



 



-

!! "#,

/

 ,35



 .

&'$ 



%001$$

'200/

.

 

3   

4$ $$$4



  55









$



4 .

 











 

 4   

    



 -







$





5

 





-

$











 - 

 

    





 

 4



 

 

 .    







 







 

 

  



 



 - 

 

  

  %0    

 





$



65!#

7!

#7 6789



 # (+,$* 

/ 



(+,$*+$*#-8$



675%1$#$(+$)$

 ."%9$,-#)(*(.)#$#"#/+)0/"%#(( ++((*

/+)$.#*#



-"*#),-#)$#  (*#-$*$#(+,#$(+,$*$*-+(.#+#()(

 #% (+,$*+$*#-  .)%1$#$*" #$ ,  * /# (+,$ ( -.(# #-

 #$%$**"%)"*(#+*"#/# ##*")"*



."%#+#%(*"

#$$ +,(#%3 (* +$*#- + $#%$ .)%1$#$*" ) ##- #(*%# + +*"

#& #-* # - ) + +*" $.$*  &

 '+#- *  +% $# # $1$$* )& #  



%$# +$%#( ) /# $ /+ $%#(  $ ) "# 1 ,-# (**& ,-#) ##

$.#"$ , ,#"#"

 -#) ( #$*#(*( + $#% $::$*

   +

#"*") (#,$#$*" #$# %%%.. ( /# (+,$ ( /++ %%/(3

%#(+#$# #"%#,-#$%#)

( ++(

-#)$+$#&( #%

(+$)$.)%1$#$*"#$ , #"%$ ( ++(

 #%$#$$++&

,-#)$##$,-(+,$*##$%#$

-#)$+$#&,- ,*"%#(+ (+$)$(

(+,$*(** *%%

; ( ++ .)%1$%$

 -#) /++$ ($*" (+,$*(** + #+$*"

1-*& (*$%#-  ,-"*# #$%# (+,$*#3 (* ( "+(" &

(*$%#-(+,$*(*%##$*#8$

 3 375







 7

 #

+$) ."%"#&+#$,-#$*/""#,-#)/++$$+$#$*"#$ ,

 *$/1,)#"%$*$ #()$#%%$# #"1%*%$$# #$(

+

/# # ) ( /+#-  + $#% 0/"%# ## $0$   

 $# %(%#  ( ++

 *# *%%3 # )..( $# #"# , # $0$ # #- #" 0/"%#(

  + 1*

%(%0,##/###$$%%*%%3+



( ++(







 

:9 78#



+,*+#$*$**")%$# )"#--. (*"/++$##*(+,"#&3#$,-+

/1,)#"$*"-(*& ,*"%##+#$



'# #(+#"*#<6). -+#%$#+%$#*,$#1 "#"1-*#")(+,*$*#"



% #"*# < "# = -

 (+,#$ + #% (+,*$$*" 0 /"% +% #$ $



%#$$*"(+,*$*##$&/#1-*"#%$#$0/"%$

'# #(+#"*#

<=

(+,#$%1$&(+,*#%$.)#$#/##1*"##$*"#%(*(3(*

#% # $." /# 0/"%(+,*$*$

 $ /## %.. $(# ("( -(*#

#$* ,3 .,$*"# (*%%- #%  #$ #*"$) /#)"*$#$

-(*#

#$* ,1%(%%%.. +(#,$#$$*"#$& -$*#/++$)##(+

/++ (#,$#$$*" (/- %%.. 3 

+

 (.#+# )

 ( ++

  #%  #

#*" 1 /# )"*# %$*%# 1& (+,* ,*$$*" (* 1*"# #$#  *$

%$

+$)$+,-#)(*(/+#-0/"%#(.)%1$#$*"#$*%%

( ++(



3

+

-(,#($$$-8$

; 75

##))++(*+#"*")

/++$(#,$#$$*"#$#%%%.. $1**"

( ++/#(+,$( #$"#

(#,$$ %%/(

 -#) 0$*$# (+,#$ $::$& $  

 ::(+,$ .)$$*" $1#"

(+,#$ + $#% 



 (# ( (#(%# & *$+/(  +*" 

6 ( ++ 8$

 . 







$*#$#$#(+,#$($&$#  (0("/+#-8$

63

5

 #$"#

$#  (*& *$+/- *$3$*#&$#%/# #(%#(+,$(#$*#(*$

6;



( ++

> #%'# #1*"1#"(+,#$)&1/##  8$

5

'1,(++

$1#"(+,#$1/&=

(1/#* ."%$# (#/1,)*$#(+"*1//#8$

=5



'# #(+#"*#<=

(+,#$1&(+,*).$$#$#.)%1$%$1## *$

.,#""  #"*# %#$$*" %%.. 3 (* #%3 (##$ #$$ 1*$(#3 +

$::1%#$* 1 /# + / #$*#( 1 %#" %" (+,$* /++$ %1)*(

$*$$*" /1,)*#"

 +$) 

 ."% + /0 $::(+,$ )  $$ (+,$*# #$$*"

/-$1#"#+(+$)(#(%##$*#(#$+/-7( ++(8$

;5

+$)

+0/"%###0((0%#$*#/

* #$"3#$(+$)+(++

$#%#"-0#/""(+%%#$8$#%#)(($53$*#&$#%#$*#(*"

 #$"# - 0/##$ (+,$

7 ( ++

    +$%$## *% + $#*" 





%*" %*# /# 0/"%(**"# (+,$

 * %*# ?!/# 0/"%(**"#

 *$%# %#$++"(@  ##%. -( +  .) $::$" /# (1("#$ )"*$#$ .,$*$

0,$#%#$++"(/#0/"%(**"# *$%#(0,#(

* %*#(+,#$#1$*

 *$%# %#$++"( /#($)$# +$%)"*(*$ $*$$ ) %)"*(#$

1%*$#$

-+$$$#)$*-#&#$/# #"# ##$$#,$*"(**$*$##$

 

 %#$$*" %*# $*#%*# + .)  *$$*"3 #$ $# # /# 0/"%#

0,#(*#- */ =$$+

7;

( ++);

#*$$+



( ++

##-+'(<=

-.$#$$*"#$#%%%.. 8(.#+#)

( ++5

-.,#"#/#%%#$#)"*$#+$#-#((*#$$$# %*#$*#%*#-



%$*#& #$"3#$A00#(3(#&(+,$*+$*#*#'(<=

*##$$3

%(&#$#$**%(*#"*#<

-

/;)

6-

(+,#$$**%(*

#$++"**#

+-(+,*+%,#"6







(+,$*)



; **"#*(+,#3#$

'( < =

 -  .$#$$*" #$#  *3 %#( + /++ & - $*# (#,$#$$*"

(/- %.. $3 # +# 0#%%..    )  #$& /# ,*" " 0/"%$

/*$*#(3(*#%"#",*

%#$$*" -(+,$*,#"%. -$(#

(#"3#$+++%*(3#$#%$#,*#*(+ +/##*(+,$0,##%) #8'(

<

!/#-(++##%-/.##,++/#($%#+ #%(*/#$

,*##%



+,*#&3#$ #$"###$++"*$3,-#))(+$)#$*#(*"3#"#0/##$"-

( ,-#) ) # # /# $# ((* #*"$ + /1,)#"$*"  #""  #%

(+,$*+$*#-(+$)$.)%1$#$*"#$# *$ B$( ++$(

=( ++

(3+

 ,*"",-+#$

+$)/++$(+,$*##$$*"$1#"$#$#.,$*3#$$#%

0/"%#+#$##/+*$*(#$#.)%1$%#

=

( ++ *#*%%

 #$ .,#% ("*$$*(3 (* ,-#) ) # # /

 -#) /++$ (+,$*# #$$*"

C.  (+,$* (+,$*$.$*  $#$#$ .,$*&3 #$   ."% # +# +% (+,*$*$ /+#-

0/"%#(+ (*$$.$*"(*$#%##&#$#%(%#1-#*3%# *



6



#*-+7



( ++8$

=5

$*%%

=( ++(*&(+$)$

.)%1$%## $# ,-"*# (+,$*# #$%# /.#$

  +,$* ($#"  /++

(+((*#//###&1#$*"



 <=)=

*#/++##3(##(*($#,$+$*3%1$&(+,*$##$/++#$.)

)(*")/1,)#"$*"(**"

-#)+$+$#*"1-*&(**"#.)%1$%$

+,*

/#&#"(**"/1,)#"$*$#(



  < = -

 *# (*( (+$)$.)%1$%## -$**"## -1

  #$"#

- (+$)   ."%  %$# #$ +*(+ " B #$*#(*  *$ ) #"3 #$ $#%

0/"%# + (( #$ $ /#& (+,* /1,)#"$*( &$"   ."%

-1*$*%#$ -$**"##











$*#$#-#%#)*,"*&(+,*( < "#$  







'#" 

(+,$*(