Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-23178/1 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:2.05.23178.1852 AI generated

2-05-23178/1 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-05-23178/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

      

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-23178/1 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas:       

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

      

 !"   

#!"$ %"   &'(! )(         *+"#,*-./            +0+$   1#* $ 2 ,3 "$* (++3 ((/( 4%(2( '#(+1(($"$ 2553 "$* -./ &$ +2 -./ /2 #+ 64 /!" ,,3$# +(+."2       *+"#,*      )&.(!2( '#(+"!( +0+$$"$,,1$$$7&&+2$""!"%! $ &2 $""$7&&+2 7$4  $# +(   +!( /.+/" +(+  1$$ !"%! 7$24$# +($ %!"$""$!!$* 

"++(!2! !"!!(!/((/(!&!!)(2!/$*  !" !%$ /($"! !!/$ #!" $ %!" -./ $ %!"& $+!( $"2" 6**,*$**  - 2/.(/2(!2$ #!"$ %!"! !"$)!!! (&!&(!!5 0)/  $"* "( ! !" !"' $)!! ! (&!2 /)0  !( '#(($( /.( /($"!!/$!&(3/.('$ (!2 !"$)!!! (&!&(! !  0)/  $"*         

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

!(!)(!+"20(+"!+."!$ %!3&(!.!!"%!!5***$ !  )#&$"$#2( $"!&( 0(+" 77!&(!*  .0! +!"2 0(+" 5**** 

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

!/!"/)(!(2%((!+"2( *

  154

%"!(***$ !%(/2"$ (2+(+$ %"!!2$ %!" $(#($"!/!&%(&!5**,*1!4*

!"$+ +%(/2"(2$)!!+"21!43$"(2$ !(  !+"2$ %!"$(#($$"/!"!*

%" + $ !! % (!+"23 ! $(#($" /!" +2&! )!&( /.(  0""2"($$" $ ## +$ %!".("%(! !"#%"221!4*      

 ; 5   $ %! /.(' $ %" % ! !" /.( & !" %( ! !"#%"22%(/2"&)#(!"2 "2.("($"!0.%+2!"2 "!"3 $"( $ !3 $ $ %" + &))#+"2 /!&( !)%!3 (  !)%!! /!+"23 (( $"( %( ! (&!!( $ ! $)!! /)(#((( /.( $"(  ! (&!!( $)!! /($"!*"%" !$%(!!"2<$!((2/)(!2$ !0 ! &$/.!"$* 

%" ('3 ! %( !"' #%"22 ! !"  ;2 6    5   "3!$ !3$$ %" +&))#+"2/!&(!)%!3( !)%!!/!+"2  $ %" + !2 % (!+"2 ! !" !&( /.(&($$"! +(+ %( + %(/2"&)#(!"2"!" "2.("($"!0.%+2!"2* 

;555$ %!/.('$(#2/ )!!/)! !"!3/)#/!"2 "%"3$"( +"!223! !"$"""'!"++"!&(!)(!&($/)0 !( '#(($(*-.%+2/ &)#(!$7$+.("($0.%+2"* 

"+$ %!"!2 /!($"""+!"2 !"!"++"!&(!)(!&($/)0  !('#(($(30)#!&)#('$ %"7$+.("($"0.%+2"*  !/!=..("2"3!(/((2"!($"72 2"#%/"/%(#.(" 2" #$+2&( 2"=; $ %2!$++*""(!*  .&(!"2 $!/"0(+"! ! * ""(! *  !(/((2"!($" 72  2"  /..("2")!!!"!*  $"""/2 $) / !(/(( $ %2&( /..("2" 120(2( >4 )!!2*  >;,)!!'3!$ %"!"!"'!)(!/!/!0(+"/.(2"* > ;    02   , )!!/23 ! $"( /.+($ + $ %"!"! #($$"+"23 /.(' /."2+."2$ %"!"!)(!&(!#%($ %"!"!)(!&(/((/(!&($ ##$ /((/(!*

"+ $ ! (  !)(!+"2 & 0(+"!! !"+/(2 $ %"!"( %   !"+"2 $ $$"0(!"2"&&(2$ %!3((( !!)(!+"2 &$ %"!"(+."!$ %/(((* >; )!!'3!$"(/.+($#($"'#%&$&($ %"!"!3/.('/."2 +."2!)(!&(!* >;$ %!/.('/."2+."2/.+($"!#%($ %"!"!)(!&( /((/(!&($ ##/((/(!"(+!#(1/((/(!4* >;6)!!'3!$"(0(+"0 /.('/!/!2"/.(0(+"0(+" 7 ?23 /'!' 77!&(+ &.&2 0(+"0 2 ++2 0(+"(! $ %"!"!

  5154 !)(!&(!@ 0(+"! $"+(  77!&(+( !$$(+"2 .("2  $ %"!"2 ))/2 $%!(&*  +%(.("($"!0.%+2!"2%(/2"&)#(!"2 "2* 

(/(($ %!"&+!" 2"!($"  !)(!&+!" 2"!($" #$+2&( 2" ;  )!!'3 ! ++ $) / 2" ."!"&(! "!!"2 &+!" 0"%" $ %2!$ &+!"$""2  !&(  ++2 $(+2$&))#&( +( $%!(+"2 !(/(($ %!"&+!"2"!($")!!!"!* $"+(**,*$%!(+"2!(/(($ %!"&+!"2"!($";25 0, +(+#(((.(/"2"1$"+(**,*$%!(+"2#2$!( +4;( "!"'$ !!/)&.(!$# +(%$"$!"!"2#(((.(/"$!!$* 

 ; 5,    0  $ %! !"++(!' $ %" & !" !!(! /((/(!&! !)(2!/$! !"*     &'(! )(

%!"+($