Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-04-1218/2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2005:2.04.1218.534 AI generated

2-04-1218/2 · Viru Maakohus Rakvere kohtumaja

Case Number 2-04-1218/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

  (4  (   ""   " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "         * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4 *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #   ='"(4  / ='"(4  / ='"(4  / ='"(4  /  1  "(   " "    *  

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-1218/2 · Viru Maakohus Rakvere kohtumaja:   (4  (   ""   " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "         * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4 *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #   ='"(4  / ='"(4  / ='"(4  / ='"(4  /  1  "(   " "    *  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Ärakiri

K O H T U O T S U S EESTI VABARIIGI NIMEL      

 

 

 

 

       

                                  ! 

" #  

" #  

" #  

" #   $%& 

" 

" 

" 

"  ' "  ( )*  +   , -' ' (  &. /" ( 00 " *   /    )     +  

""  (  (  

""  (  (  

""  (  (  

""  (  ( 

 ((

 ((

 ((

 (( 1 2 ' "  ( )*  + ) ( 33$4 55 4"&.

+4  ("   ( *  "(4  ( (  6 64 '( ( #0 78' )  $$.4  9/     ""  +4  ( ( "   " "   )  ( :::::+ 2 , -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  " &&

+4

 (( "   " " <  )  (  ::::::+    )  (:::::::+                                     "" 2    "" 2    "" 2    "" 2 !     (  ((

"  2

"  2

"  2

"  2 "((  "((  "((  "((                    ('"  ()*  +*  

"  /     ('"  ()*  +*  

"  /     ('"  ()*  +*  

"  /     ('"  ()*  +*  

"  /        ' "  ( )*  +  , -     ' "  ( )*  +  , -     ' "  ( )*  +  , -     ' "  ( )*  +  , -' ' (  " &  "  ' ' (  " &  "  ' ' (  " &  "  ' ' (  " &  "  /" ( /" ( /" ( /" ( 00 " *  00 " *  00 " *  00 " *   " /   " /   " /   " /      0 "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..    "  &&     "  &&     "  &&     "  && 

+ ' "  ( )*  +  

+ ' "  ( )*  +  

+ ' "  ( )*  +  

+ ' "  ( )*  +           / # "(   ")0( / # "(   ")0( / # "(   ")0( / # "(   ")0(

0 (+  

0 (+  

0 (+  

0 (+  " /    " /    " /    " /   0 "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..  "  -' ' ( ) ( 33!4  ;  ..    "  &&     "  &&     "  &&     "  && 

+  

 "(   )

+  

 "(   )

+  

 "(   )

+  

 "(   )   ""    %    ""    %    ""    %    ""    %  .7  , *  / %.&&1 * 4

 #  .7  , *  / %.&&1 * 4

 #  .7  , *  / %.&&1 * 4

 #  .7  , *  / %.&&1 * 4

 # !.+ !.+ !.+ !.+ 

 "/  !) 0 (+  

 "/  !) 0 (+  

 "/  !) 0 (+  

 "/  !) 0 (+ 

    "

( " "       "

( " "       "

( " "       "

( " "          * "  /   (* ""   #   "   * "  /   (* ""   #   "   * "  /   (* ""   #   "   * "  /   (* ""   #   " 

  (4  (   "" 

  (4  (   "" 

  (4  (   "" 

  (4  (   ""   " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "     " " "   *  "         * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4       * "  *       (   * "4 *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #  *   4*/ ((* ""   #   ='"(4  / ='"(4  / ='"(4  / ='"(4  /  1  "(   " "    *  

" 

  .&      .&   

"   &$&%& "  " *  -"   "" &./" ( 00 " * 4 ""  00      2  

  )# +4  "/  4 "*  4  *  4  4" * *( 4") &&+

"( >#? * *     #   ""  " 4  (    "  0"   ( 1    "    (  00  (    " " #/ " "("4  (    4  " 

(   "" "      ;

 "(  " "    * (       (   " "   00((   " (    "2  

 )#+@   $ 400  ( 4   A  

"( >#?  @     $  4 00  (   4     A   "/         &.!  4 00  (   A  "*  @       4 00  (   A  * @   . 400  ( A @    ! 400  ( A" * *@   !.& 400  (  A") &&+@    400  (&    ' (   00         " 4 00*" (   

   // (  "

" (  "    * (

     

  ""  "

"   &. /" ( " *   "  " 0""  00 " * 4 ( # "

 "  " * " 4 # " "  /""(   -  B $ "  "  #   (   ( " "    /"    4   (

*   ""  # /""(   - B" #" "  (    " * 4 " * /"   0 "

*  

" "  - B" " / #"" " (  00 " * 4   *"    # /(  /   " 4  /" ( " * " "   /  "  "     " -  B  "   "

"( 4  0   "

 *  

"  " /" (  " * # /""(   ;

 ( 

*/ ( " "*"#  ('"

 ()*  +,-'' (  "&./" (00 " *    "( (1    (- B ( $"4"*"  " "   == == == == "    "    "    "    "  ( (  "     

    *"#     " " "(   " "( "2 + &. /"  ( *" (  00 " * 4  ""  " "     "         2  

  )# +4  "/  4 "*  4  *  4   4 " * *( 4 "  &&4 ##?   *   * & " " "  ( /  00" "  * 

  "     *"     00" 

 "  " (   $3" "4 ( 

 (

 "" *   ( / 0""" 0" 4 (00  0"  (A +   "(   ( */ ( (   *"/ "  ( 4  ""    4 "     ( ($$& $$.

"  00 

55( (3 $ "" 

  1  "( 

 4"  / ( ,   "  

#  ""  " 

#4 / "(      "" /  

  4    # " ""  "   "  *  /"   " 00 (#00(  (  

(   #00  A +   (" (0  "4 ( " 00(( 

 "   00     ( "4  "  "

 " (

"     *"# "(  (  ==='"  " ==='"  " ==='"  " ==='"  "    1   ( 1   ( 1   ( 1   (   " " #4  #  "( (("(  /(  (  1     " "  &. /" (  00 " * 4  ""   00"   "(  (   "  (   

 '"  (*  

" " -  

" " # ""  (" * ( 0"  ( 00(   ' (   4  " 

(    4"  ( " " #/ " "("7 (/ (   #4   (        *  /     (9 " "   (

(( ((       " 4   // (  " *" (     (   "     * (

         4     ""  " *       ( " / ( (   7    (  '  

   >#?>" , (  "(    &. 00 " *   "  " 00 " * 4 #   "

 "    " 4  " "#*  '

"  ( /""(  1   ( " #4  *"   (" (  (4      *" (  "     -"   " *     (4 "   ("(    

(   (  -   *"    #   (  *  "( * #/ " * (0"  1"(*"#      (4 

"   

 "  (" 

"4      ( (  ("  " # 4    00( "  ""      *" /""(      1  "(  / " ( " ( "

( - B ( $" "*4  #" "  (  " *    4 

/"  0 "

*   "" - B"  " " / #   (     00   4   

  /  "  "            /( B  " 

"(#4  0   "

 *  

"  "   (   " *  # /""(   4 

  ( " 

  / (

* 1 * # "  (4   "

 4    "

 "  (" * /"   "4"     / "

      (    

       " "  "  (  *   (  /     ("   ( (  (  00(            ( "  (" 4  ""     # /""(   1   (  *"#     ( *"   " &. /" (  00 " * 4   "(   (  (  "  " /    / # "($        (

 (

 (

 (      " " #4 " " (  ( ,-'' ( *"          (   (   #  *  

"    00((4

" " / "  "*" (      ("(  *"  (7   (  ' 4 ""  " ( ( " ( 

   4    (4  

   

"  ""       * (     "  / (   #4    ' "  (  (

 (   

00"   

4

"     "        (4   00 " *  #   "   " * " 4   "   */ (7 (*"# "(   ( <   ( <   ( <   ( < " #4       *  

"         

 "/  !  "" /*" 



 "/ 4 ""    "    #(4  /    ("    " " *  /"       /  *  

"   *  /"     ("  "   B 3 "    

 "/   .  * #"4

#



 "/ ""!  4"  "" 4    *"#/ # "(  / "(( 3   === */ ( ( "   === */ ( ( "   === */ ( ( "   === */ ( ( "   4      ( ( "

( / (

(4 *"   "    "(  *   (  

4 "

( 4      */ ((  " #  "((   " "( " -  B   "  "( 0"   " *   (

  "  

 *   " /""(  /  "(

' ""

4   / 

 /# *     

"#  / "  /   "(   "  /""(   - B$ # /   /  * " " #   /   " B (   &  ( " "    /"    4      (

*   ""  # /""(     (""     (

*   ""  - B"* " #    " * 4 " *  /"   0   "

 *  

"  " 4   *  

"  "   *   "" 

 -  

" "  .&  (""   00 " *  /"   &.

"

*  

" "  -  B  "   "     " *    /" ( 0   "

 *  

"  " 4 



"( 4    " *    /""(    

 " #

"((4  &. /" ( " *      /""(     *(# (  ( " / ((4  /"   (" "  /""(   - B" " / #* " (" " (    00 4    / " * 4 *"   # /( / 

" 4 /" (" * ""  / "  "    "   *   " "    "4   00  (" (         (  / ( (*" 

(/ (

(# "0 ( -   ( B3"* " 

( "     /" "  ( ( 

( "     "

 4"  (

 4* * (  

     &.  00 " *  /"       "   00 / "

  ""  "" " "      /       "

   

 " #  "((4        "  (    "  *" ( " ( " *  /"    "  (" (4  /" ( 00 " * 4 "" "     " # /""(  4 " *  ( "   "((     "     B$" "* ## *"/ ( /(

( /    

(      (

" */ (( / ((C      (  ( 4   (" 

   "4             ( (  (" 

" (  " " #  4       00(  "     ""       /""(    "B."/ #*" " 4 ""   4

 "*" " "  " (  */ (( "(  B . "  *   "   

 "/     #( *  "(  *  

"    /      /(   (     

 "/        " #(4

  "B " .&""#

 "/ 

 "(   "/   "  "4  "(    B 3 "  * 4  ""   "  *  

"   (  "(  /  #     

 

 "/ !  B."* "/ #*" " "4 ""   4 

 "*" " "" *"  " " (*/ (("("" (/ # 

     *"   D   "((   "  /    D   "( ("  * 4 ""     "  4 (   4 "" D(#  / # "(  /  */ (

 *  -  B .. "   "   "( " /  / "  /   0   " 4   " ( " ( " ( *  

"  /  "(  *"  (   0"  (     /  

  /  0"  (     "(  ( *"

  / " " ( 1   ("   ( *  "(     ( ( 4  ""  *" / "  4 # " (  /     *55(( "(  *

  

(- B.  "( "/ (4      *   00    /   4   "(       "   *    "  (  *   "  (  "(  7 ( "   

 *

 "( "  / # "(    / ( ( ( ( ( *( (  / # "( /     / (   

"4 

 ( (   *""   (''C #0"   (   " *(# 1 "(  ""(- B ( $4

(  (B ."4B."*4B.&"4B$4B ( &  /(

   2   %""  %        E  /                

  3 ".2 3 ".2 3 ".2 3 ".2   0 ( 

    "  "      ' = "  ( )*  +/ # "(  "/     ""   "(( '  "  ( )*  + " / # "(  "/    "  "  " /  , " -' ' ( )   ( 33!4 

( "

 (  ;  ..   " 

 (+' "  ()*  4 

 (33$4 

( "

( 55 "

 (+/ # "(   )"+  &,"  (

 '* ""   #"(("  "  / ".  ".  ".  ".