Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-04-399/2 ECLI:EE:TMK:2004:2.04.399.568 AI generated

2-04-399/2 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-04-399/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-399/2 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           

        ! "#$% &'( ")   "" *"$""+ "$"$,* % *"$%"%+-"   "+ .%/ ! "# % ""  0

)1"$23 )# /4 5!""/ % *"/  & '( " "" -

3

1 "$ 6  0 3- *# /2"*       .% "$    #  /     "$ 0% ) "% /   )37 ) 6/   ! " 2/$  3

  - 

 " "($% /$   /$/#  & '( " *"$ "  /  % ! ""   "($% "  

   ($% 66  $/ /$% % !$/ "($% " $/ 8   /"  ""   ! "# ! " "   "($% /$/ " "$"  /$ !""   $%  " " ($% 66  $//! /$$! "9 %

6$+ #  

2: %2;" ((% !%%"2: 2;332:*" "% ! 5!% " "/ !""   / "/ 5!% ! ) "$"($66   """$%8 - ""/"% ! $ ) /"  ""    2:  2;  "  0   "") 0  ! < !"= !!   ""*!% /"/  < !" = !! /6    % ) 0  "  < !"= !!2: 2;!""        ""  %      %< !"= !! " 2: 2;  %    >  %   " 2:  *! $(!%" 

 33  ""2

/!% " 6 ($%  ! "" $/   )    "" /   $/ 0   "" !   "  $ 3    "" :%"%6 ($%%" " /" 66 6/($66 % "66 ? - ""*6 /!$ "/""   :% "     @  "   A 



#  

" 2  - ((%!%/(( B"4((%!%"   / "/ 5!% ! 3 "$ "!% $ 0    ""  "/ "$  ((/ !%  $/ / 

/5%((%!% /%"!%"/("5!%!30 "$  "/   "$ 6 % !% /6 %   " "    6 "  :% "/  :"($%/   "" !% % "" ((%!%  = $ 5 4     ""% *  /6 !% $ 6$/

 )    B" 4 " ((%!%  / %  ( ($  ($%  %  -

 "!  %   "":%"/ !%!    ($%  !$ " 6 % ! % !$/  "/"$6= $54  % 

 

 "!%     "" % "   ""!%/ "($%"!"    "" ($% " %     C   -    "     :  6  %    "($% !" "% %/ /""($%/ %"% A % = $ 5 4 /$ %  "  "  :%  "/  /$ % !%!     !$ %% $ "$$6"66 ( >: 9 - %  "$  /$   " " "$ %$/"($%$/$("  >: 9 ) 0 %  "$ ! /$ % % / % "   D 6 6 (  /$  " ""%!$/"$"($%$%%/$:

9  %/$"$"%"/ "$6$,%"$  0 )"/)

 0- )"%/$$"""$"$/$% ! " $"" "  ! A"   % "$  ($% !$/  * /$ %  % $""%  "/"% ! $"""$   ""  /$   *$! "9 % "$%/ !$/ "  /$% 6 % "$  " $ , /$""$ $ $"".%/" "$  ( /" $ $%  %  /$  : 9   %  6$  /$ % "  $"""$"66 E:9 %"$% "6/$""/6 %/6 $"" .%/ " "$  "  "/  /  """#$/6/$%/ 6$)    ""1

# % "  /$ % " " 66  /6 6 " /!$ /"$%/" /

6  / $""% 2 " ((%!%   " " "/ ($%  !  " /  * "

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

!%/"/: *"$%/"$/.%/"$/" $%!%%*!%" / ""6"$%($:$% % % "$ %  $/ .%/ "  "   !%  !""   D  !"    6 !"$/"/ *%"/6 ($%/$$%"" $/$(                "$ 0  ) "%    # " 6/     #! ">  % (6/ ( 

0#6$ /$  3

  3   "    /$ '( "   

"2:/2;$ " ((% !%  

# "$"2: 2; 33 2:  *   " "% ! 5!% ! ) "$"($66   """$%8 - ""/"% ! $ ) /"  "" .%/      2:  2;  "   0    ""  3   "

  ((%!%6$ ) # ! < !" = !!   "") 0 "< !"= !! )# " 2:  2;       !""      ""%   %       < !" = !!  "        2: 2; % >  % (6/ (6$ ) )3#2:* ! 

 33  ""2

 /!%"6 ($%! ""$/ )    "" /   $/ 0   "" !   "  $ 3   "":6$

/""" !$  / 6  *"$  $%/ "$%  2  *  6"  " 

   " /  (  "  %

6 ($%%" ""66 6/ ($   66  %  "66   :% "   @ " 6 ($% 

  

 "      2  -   ((%!% )0 )#/(( B"45!% ! 3 "$ " !% $ 0    ""  "/ "$  ((/ !%  $/ /    5 % ((%!%/%!%"$"/( " .%/ 6  !"   "/ "/ ( B" 4     5!% ! 30 "$ "  "/    "$ 6 5!% 6    

  "/= $54$ ""!% )  #%""2  - ((%!%     = $ 5 4     ""% .%/6!""//6= $46$/ "  )  $ >  %  ( 6/ (   )# 6$   B" 4 " ((%!%/%(($($% %  -

 "!  %     "" :%  "/   !%!  ($%!$"6% !%!$/ "/"$ 6>  % (6/ (  0#6$= $5 4 % 

 

"!%   "":%" ""!%/ ":6$"($%!" "%%//""($%/   *"$"/"$%!"" /$%%/6 /" $%/$/C$%%"$%/A 6 ($% !"66 "  %$%.%/  0   ""/(/66   "" $%/  <!" = !! % $%/  :% $%/   6$    /      .%/ " % $/  "$ )  ""#/$%66   3   ""# $ "

-    "" *"/ $%/ "" $/   66 *"$"  



 "2:/2;$" ((%!%/

 3    /   < !" = !! $  " ((%!%%/6 /$%/$/ -   ""

  

    /   B" 4 $  " ((%!% / /%!% $%/"/  "! $0   "" *"$" 2  - %/6 /$%/$//66 ((%$"0   "" .%/ " %    "   !%     !%  !""  *"$   "/ / "$%"/$/6/"$%/!"!% !%!""  .%  " $%/ % /"  "/  $/ !$/ !%$%// /$# /*"$ 6%"/6"2:/2; $" ((%!%  3 /< !" = !!$" ((%!%/   / = $ 5 4  $    "" !%   / C! B* )3 7 - 0) 0#!  6$  !% " '( "  / /6 !% C ! "  '( "    $ %   " "/ %  *"$ !"'( "$%   !" $%/ %%   :%   !"" " !%'( """('( " " /  

/B"4$  " ((%!% / /%!% % " "   !%% *"/ " %   "  /  "" "" /  *"/"%%6 ($%" /$ D  "/ / "$%  "/      /$ ($% " 6/   "  /  "" "#  /*""//$% #"/ 

!%:.%/"/6%" "/((%$/!$/ !%*"$$%/"$%6 ($%/$" %"($%/$">:9  % /$(> ($%/$%% :   >: 9 ) 0 %   "$  /$ " "$ %/%" ,%"$"%" 0 3 ) " )  3 ) "  "$  >: 9 ) 0 %  " "$""%"($%/$$:"$   "/ % " 6 ($% % /$   "  2: *   " /     !$   !$/ "  $/% .%/ " " $/  "  $%% *"/2:/2;$" ((%!%% /< !"= !!$" ((%!%"    "$   "/ " /$  "$ "$ 6 "  $% % " 6 :

 "$%"/$/$!$/"!  $%  !% %  $/ " -    "" "//6 $  :""/  

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

$:93"$ %/ "$6($%/  %"% %  " % / "$  %%*"/"$/%"%   !"" $ $/   "$  %  $ ! %"  %  (" / $$ %  E:,:#9   /6$"  -

"$ 6"/$>:9-%   -

 $ ""#6/$!$ /   / " "$ 6 /6% "($%  " (($/" *"$>:9-% "/  $%/  6/    

    /   B" 4 $  " ((%!% / /%!% %

 -  $/     $%/ /6 !% /6 %  " 0   "" .%/ " "   %  $ : 9   %   66  /$D6"/$ :9 %   $  : 9 0  6  "   /$ % /!$/%.%/"""$"/$$% /%$/")   ""!$/$%// *"$6%/6"/"2:* % " $% / !$/ % $%/ $/ -    "" *"$ "("$(2  -   %/6 /  $/ 0    ""  $%/  / : "$    $%%  $/ " $% $"/""/!""$%%" " ! "  6   /$%  !$/ $%/ /  .%/""$ 0 """%.%/ !""  "$    ' ( "" G    

  -0)

7  .%/  "$  $%/  / ! "$   45!""   !"" "  ' ( "" G /   *"/""$!""! *"/  "$  !  )   ""   "$

)  66 " !  %  ""/ "/ %    "" :% " "/  "$   "" *"/ $%/%!!$/  : 9  0  %  " 6   "$ $% $ "  "$$%/  $ %/"/   "%  $% $ /6 : 9  0 %  !  " 6  !""   " $  "$  !"" 6/ / / !$//!"""%$%$%!$  3 @ $% $ " $%/ : 90 %  "$ /6 % 6/"/%!$/ ,%"$"%"" "$ 

" )  )   -   " / ) 

#    "   ! "$ $  "$   ! "$  A"" FF( / $ %  " /"  "   " %%"/" /.%//  / " ! "$   "$  "   " / '!"",%"$$6$6 ($%/$ (""$! "":  /""($/$6/ //6   6/  : ! "$    $    % $%/  / !"" 6 %   * "$ $% $ " " )0 @  ! "$ !$/ "/ $%/ %   6/  $% $ "%! "!" ""%") 3 ""  0; )0# *"$"$% $/60@!$%/ "/$(""$"3-0 "" ; 0#*"$

    /66 "/ $%/  "$  6/    "" ) 3 3-0#  :90%6 %$%/" "$"/6/ % $% $"%.%/"" /%  "$ -   66    )#  % :"$%" $%"/,5:5  ""66 "$6/ % %0  ""  C""//$:9 0 %0%!0%

 ) "$         .% $" 6/   & '( "   ! "#  $/  0   (/"$# ""/"$   $ $(# "" 6/   & '( " % 0  (  $#  "" %    / "      3 )

) $!% 

 ) 0) .!%   #  *"$" !   !""   ,%""$  "$    !6 /""   "$" % "    !6/""!6 "$  /!""