Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-811/1 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.811.1377 AI generated

3-05-811/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-811/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

%%" "  $   %%" + "$$" $  %%" " / 2 '  $"$ 3 "$

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-811/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja: %%" "  $   %%" + "$$" $  %%" " / 2 '  $"$ 3 "$

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





















    











  







 

  







 



  







   ! "#"$%&%%%$"'%$%

""

#(

)   $%%*%'"+" $ 

%"$"

$(%$ %"*"



 

   

 )   



 

 













,$$  "#   $ -./

'+

! 



0$"+" "*%#"%$   +" $% "#"1 % &%' $"

 $

   +"   $"  %$ $" $  $"'"%"" '" $ +" $  $" 

0$"  %$ $" $  $"'"%" +"  

   +" $% "#" "%$ %"$

$"#  $$  $"% %$$" $  ("+"  $"  %$

$" $  $"'"%"" '" $+" $  $" 





! "#! $%"&'



2 

 $ $%$"+$3%" "$ $%2 

 "4 

$*%%$ % #"3+ "$%"$"3% %5%$""%$ %%" "/

24 '%6$$"  $"$$3$  2! 



"

%$"%+"5"$%   $"' $"  

3 3 )2 $%

7%"%%" "/24 "%  $ %$  2! 8%"$ $$" 

'"3%" "$ %# " $ $ "$" *$%"%%" "/2 ""$%

&%%%"$"'%$%""" $%%*%'"+" $ %"$$ %" 







   %$ $"  $"$$"%'

 $ )  $"' 

$(%$ $%(""$"$

3 3 )2 %"$%'$"$% %$" $ 

  $  %$$ " $% %' $"   %$ $% %%" " / 24 '%

 %

"  $ %' $   

! 



"$% &%%% $"'%$%"" %$ $ "%  , 9 

)   $%%*%'"

+" $ %"$"' 

 %$ $  $!+" $ $% $%%*%'%%" "

/2' "$  )! 





4   "%$     "$% &%%% $"'%$%"" " +%% : &-!



#(

)   $%%*%'"+" $ %"$"+" " $" "#"$  ! 

- "#"%  "% '"*%' %$"$ $ 



 $ 4  "'   $%   "% '"*%' %$"$ $ 

+" $ $%&-

#(

)   $%%*%'"+" $ %"$""$%$  ! 



 $   "' *"$% "#""$"$  ! 





 ('!  "



  "% #3"$&-

#(+" +"$% %$%,9

)   $%%*%'"+" $ %"

$

" " $ "%%5 "$% %%"$ 



,$%%*%'"+" $ %"$"'%$ "$"$"'"%" "' $3$"$"%%%

""  +"" %%3 "$%$3 $" %"$  "3 *%% % "" 

+"" %% %' "$3 *%% $((+3    "'%$""%%#"3 $%%*%'"

+" $ %"  $$ "'%'$"$  %% ,$%%*%'"+" $ %"$$" "

 """+ %3%"$"%"" $ ""+ $$"  % $ %$%%" % 

 $ $" $"%" ""+ %  9% '%# $" $"%"" ""+ %" $"  %"

+" %%" "/2'$"$ #3"$ $%%*%'"+" $ %"%$ $ " 

  $" $"'  " +"    $" *$  %$ %$"

 %"$  ""$"" "/

*%'"$" *$$" "$+" #% %  $

"  % %$+* " $ 

* "$"$"#%   $% %"5 $%%" 

*%'%  



6 %$ $  $*%%%%" "/2'2%"$ $ "%"%%  %$ 

*%%$((+3  "'%$""%%#"! &-%$"+ % %+* ""

%'"%$3%%"%$" "$%%%3""%"$  $%"$  $

$ 



6$"  $%"""$" +#" " "$*%'$$   $%%*%'"

+" $ %"  %" *% "" "$" ("  ""'  "% " $*%% % *% %

$"""$" %' "  " $" $ ' '"" ""$  %$$      $"'$"

$"%" $ %  ("  $   "% " ""   $*%"%%%*%'" %%%

$%" +      $;;$ # $;;"+%' " 0< 3 % "%   5 $%%"$  

$;;$% $%$  $*%% $%%*%'" +" $ %" +(%  %"  " 

$*%"$% "  %+#""% 







  $ $"#"$%&%%%$"'%$%""

#(

)   $%%*%'"

+" $ %"$"

$(%$ %$ <$ %$ $"# "#""%$  %$ $  $%

 %" "%%" "/2 $  *%"   $  $%$ 





 ! '



,$%%*%'" +" $ %" $" $"'"%" *"$% " %%" " $"3 %"  "$

%    $ +" $ # $%%*%'"  3 % %%$   %$ $   

" "/24$"$ $%%"""$ ""$  *$$ 



0$  $%""%$3 %  # *%%  $%%   %" "  %" %%$"%3

" ' +%$"%+$" $ $ "%$ 



"$% &%%% $"'%$%"     -% $%%%%$""%%

 %$"%   $"'$" %%'% $3 % $"$ # $%" $ $ %%'%*% %' ("

+*%(" "" "' "$$"$ $" $%'%$" $%%*%'"+" $ %"*%

"$"$$%$ %" 



6$"  $"$$"$"$%  #%%$"""$ 3"$$" *$%"" $ $ "

 $   "% &-" $%%*%'" +" $ %" %$ %"  ,$%%*%'"

+" $ %"$"$"'"%""%"&-" $ "%"$%%  %"*%'$ 

&-"% $$   $%%*%'"+" $ %"*%"" %""$"(" ,$%%""

+%   $ " " #$"$3  $  ' +#  ."" $" #3 "$

"    #  3%%"%%" $  " $$ %%" $""%'

" "$  % $% ' %(%""$%""%%*"$""3"$   $

'% $%%*%'" +" $ %" "$  $" %%*%'%%$" $%"+ "%"' 

% +" $ %""$%$$"%%"5 $%' 3 %$"""$"$"$ *$

 %$ %$"' 3%$*$$  3% "" $%%*%'"+" $ %$$"""$"

% $ "3%%(( -%%%"%"%'%+* "%%"((% $" "% %$ $ 

$"""$"3"%"*% % $"  $%%*%'$+" $  



%%" "/2%"$ $ #%*$""%%"   +$%$ (% 

 % ""% %' "% " $ "% "# ++$% " +%   ,$%%*%'"

+" $ %""' $%++$% " +*%" "' *  $ $""$$

+ # $$  $$  "#"   $ 





)*!%##



6$"""$" " $%3  %$" $%  %%" " $%" " "

*$%" '"$  $"     $%%*%'" +" $ %$ "  "% $%3  %

 "  $ " $%%*%'" *$%$%  %$" 



.    %%" " /  '  $"$ $3 "$ %% $"3 "" $%%*%' 

+" $ $ (" %  "$"%$("  ""   $    $#%$ "$%

%%" "/2 "3"$%#$"'%$ $%%*%'"+" $ %"$$ "' .  

" "  +  ' % *%"   "$$%# $%%*%'" $ $ %" ""  3 %

"$%""  $  $#%$ 





   $" +" $ $% $%%*%' 

)   $%%*%'" +" $ %" $"'  



 %$ $  $!" $ $% $%%*%'"+" $ %"

""  $#%$ """$   .""'  %$ $  $%

'%$ $%%*%'"+" $ %"$$ "'"$% 



  %"$"' " $ $%%*%'"+" $ %"$"%$ %" "" "

%%$"' %%" "/2*%"""% *$ 3"$ $%%*%'"+" $ %"$

%$ $% 

)   %' $ $

  $  )   $"$ #%

$""$"

+"

  $%%*%'"

 $ %"$

%'

$$

*$

2 )  $   

! .""' %$  $$  $%%*%'"+" $ %"$""

+"    $" *$  %$ %$"$  "" $" "% " "%$ 

,$%%*%'" +" $ %" $  $  +*%%"     %%" " / 2 '" 2  %

"" "%" $ %%%'3%%"%+'%""""  $%$(%$ %$  

$  ""$"" "/% ) "$"%$%$ $   $%"$"$3%" "%

 * $  (%"%%$$$ %$ 



6 $$ '  $"# *$  ""3 "$ "$% &%%% $"'%$%"" %%$

 $% "%  %' $%%*%' $% +" $   "" $$ 3 % %

%%" "  $   %%" + "$$" $  %%" " / 2 '  $"$ 3 "$

   " " / 24 '%  %5%$""%$   $"   *$  %$ %$"' 

 "# $%%*%'" +" $ %" "   ."%" "' $% "% ""  " 

  $%' +* %$%""%%$3+%'"$"#$ 5 "$"$*"$"$ 



% +$# %%" " / 2 $"$" %"$  "  $ +*%" "'  %'   

$ $$""   $  $%"6$ "#3$  !3%%&%%'%   2 

 "%22%"$ $(%$ # %  "%3"$%%" "/2

*%" 3 2  ) "%  +*%" " $ "  .  '"" "% " $%  

 

   "%  2  .""'  "% " $""  " +($%$ %" +* $ 

-""     ($ %   $ %' %%" " +  '  2 

 '%%"$"$ 



   $*$ $  (%"   " $   $% % $  "$%%% %$$"' 

."" ""%"$ $'  "%$   $$  "$% &%%% $"'%$%"" 4  2 

%   22

3 %"'   $ "%" $"" &- #(" $;;$ $"" *%'

%$   $*%% % $%%*%'" +" $ %" $"% 

 #(  $

%"$ $ *%' %%"" $;;$ "  "" "$"    , 93 " $     +$

 %$ $  $% $  )2! 



-*$$" $"#   "% "3 "$  %$ $   $% $(%$ %" "% " $

%' "#$"# $$    $ 









-$%